Controversial penalty?

[eelpie]

Was it controversial? Kennedy raised his hand to intercept the ball, surely.

 

Did Dave Jones or anyone else query the refs decision? I didn't see Cardiff players protesting. I thought it was a clear-cut decision.

 

Poor BBC reporting or fair comment?

[OldNick]

I must say it was a clear cut pen for us.

Apart from that if we had the rub and not got a decision like Perrys handball Id be well upset today.

Im a great supporter of Kelvin but he called for the ball and then didnt come , which caused the confusion.

[saint_ed]

Perry's handball was a stonewall penalty....as was Kennedy's.

[Bailey]

Clear-cut in my opinion.

 

Having said that, Perry's was just as blatent and we were fortunate to get away with that, although we're due a bit of luck!

[eelpie]

So the BBC should have pointed out that not awarding a penalty for Perry's handling was controversial, but Kennedy's was deserved. Ambiguous reporting.

Thanks for clearing that up.

[krissyboy31]

Jones complained about it in his after match interview but probably in the context that the Ref saw the Kennedy incident as a penalty but the Perry one, not.