Lee On Solent Saint Posted 16 September, 2024 Posted 16 September, 2024 36 minutes ago, gio1saints said: Fecking well is. Captain Hack is our leader! He's not a leader in any way shape or form.
Bad Wolf Posted 16 September, 2024 Posted 16 September, 2024 Personally I thought he did okay on Saturday up till the red card. Better than Bednarek anyway. 1 1
Oh no Mick Mills Posted 16 September, 2024 Posted 16 September, 2024 THB mistake cost us the Forest game and the first Brentford goal and I'm worried he'll not be an upgrade on Stephens as he's looked out of his depth so far this season. Hopefully he'll settle down with a run of games. Last season Stephens started in 4 of our 11 defeats. He didn't start the two 5 goal thrashings or the 4 goal home defeat by Leicester either. Average player with flaws.. Basically the same as our other defenders just vilified more than the others for some reason. 1
danjosaint Posted 16 September, 2024 Posted 16 September, 2024 Play thb and abk in a 4 and ur see a different thb 1
Lee On Solent Saint Posted 16 September, 2024 Posted 16 September, 2024 1 minute ago, Oh no Mick Mills said: THB mistake cost us the Forest game and the first Brentford goal and I'm worried he'll not be an upgrade on Stephens as he's looked out of his depth so far this season. Hopefully he'll settle down with a run of games. Last season Stephens started in 4 of our 11 defeats. He didn't start the two 5 goal thrashings or the 4 goal home defeat by Leicester either. Average player with flaws.. Basically the same as our other defenders just vilified more than the others for some reason. Not quite sure vilified is quite the right word. I've no doubt he cares for the club, but at the end of the day, he's just not good enough. We as fans have seen this and have known this for about the last five years or so. Yet Martin does not, a supposed professional football manager. 3
kitch Posted 16 September, 2024 Posted 16 September, 2024 I like Jack Stephens, seems a good guy. Great character. Lower/mid-level Champsionship centre-back. Shouldn't be anywhere near a Premier League starting 11. Russell has hung his coat on the wrong door, but because he's also a good bloke (on the face of it), he doesn't want to take it off again. That's no good, he needs to be ruthless. 4
Turkish Posted 16 September, 2024 Posted 16 September, 2024 1 hour ago, SWLondon Saint said: Think that's a bit unfair on Yoshi, who while not on VVD / Fonte level was a 'lower-middle' class Premier league defender IMO. Also that season Fonte did seem to be increasingly and alarmingly error prone if I remember correctly. I feel Stephens has this uncanny knack of making whoever he's playing with look crap! It's something to do with the way he loses attention and drifts away from whoever he's meant to be marking and then the other CB is left desperately trying to cover... Nah Yoshida was a cracking fella, very popular, you cannot fault his commitment or effort but he would have struggled to get into any other premier league team then or now. He was at best a squad player for a relegation fighting team. 4
gio1saints Posted 16 September, 2024 Posted 16 September, 2024 1 hour ago, Lee On Solent Saint said: He's not a leader in any way shape or form. Oh yes he is. 1
Lee On Solent Saint Posted 16 September, 2024 Posted 16 September, 2024 50 minutes ago, gio1saints said: Oh yes he is. Fair enough if you think that. No drama. He got the job just because he was the longest serving player at the club. He's no more a captain than JWP was.
Football Special Posted 16 September, 2024 Posted 16 September, 2024 1 hour ago, Lee On Solent Saint said: Fair enough if you think that. No drama. He got the job just because he was the longest serving player at the club. He's no more a captain than JWP was. He's a completely different character to JWP , personality wise Stephens is more of an old-school captain
Lee On Solent Saint Posted 16 September, 2024 Posted 16 September, 2024 1 minute ago, Football Special said: He's a completely different character to JWP , personality wise Stephens is more of an old-school captain Like Roy Keane you mean? Or Jimmy Case? Either which are as far removed from Stephens as you can possibly get. 1
Whitey Grandad Posted 16 September, 2024 Posted 16 September, 2024 4 hours ago, SWLondon Saint said: Think that's a bit unfair on Yoshi, who while not on VVD / Fonte level was a 'lower-middle' class Premier league defender IMO. Also that season Fonte did seem to be increasingly and alarmingly error prone if I remember correctly. I feel Stephens has this uncanny knack of making whoever he's playing with look crap! It's something to do with the way he loses attention and drifts away from whoever he's meant to be marking and then the other CB is left desperately trying to cover... That’s what I meant by undisciplined. I never expected him to go and try to break the legs of an opposing winger.
Whitey Grandad Posted 16 September, 2024 Posted 16 September, 2024 4 hours ago, Bad Wolf said: Personally I thought he did okay on Saturday up till the red card. Better than Bednarek anyway. He had his usual backwards pass to no one.
Whitey Grandad Posted 16 September, 2024 Posted 16 September, 2024 3 hours ago, Oh no Mick Mills said: THB mistake cost us the Forest game and the first Brentford goal and I'm worried he'll not be an upgrade on Stephens as he's looked out of his depth so far this season. THB was sold a hospital pass by Stephens who had wandered upfield as usual. Their second goal came about because Stephens decided to surge forward and intercept a ball that was meant for Bednarek. 5
Wade Garrett Posted 17 September, 2024 Posted 17 September, 2024 He’s fucking dogshit and wouldn’t get near starting in any other Premier league side. 3
gio1saints Posted 17 September, 2024 Posted 17 September, 2024 (edited) 1 hour ago, Wade Garrett said: He’s fucking dogshit and wouldn’t get near starting in any other Premier league side. No he is not. Simply applying derisory epithets to him does not help. He may not start at any other club - opinion- but in terms of an on pitch encouraging voice he happens to be the best we have got ( fact). The season we went down and the squad that RM inherited was notable for its relative meek natured silence on pitch. JS cannot do it alone but in that regard he is way better than the other skippers I can recall we have had in last year ; AA, AM and FD ( oh and Che at Gillingham!) Getting sent off and mouthing off is not clever but the guy has fight in him wearing our shirt our crest ffs and for that alone we should be more respectful. Edited 17 September, 2024 by gio1saints 6
Smirking_Saint Posted 17 September, 2024 Posted 17 September, 2024 10 minutes ago, gio1saints said: No he is not. Simply applying derisory epithets to him does not help. He may not start at any other club - opinion- but in terms of an on pitch encouraging voice he happens to be the best we have got ( fact). The season we went down and the squad that RM inherited was notable for its relative meek natured silence on pitch. JS cannot do it alone but in that regard he is way better than the other skippers I can recall we have had in last year ; AA, AM and FD ( oh and Che at Gillingham!) Getting sent off and mouthing off is not clever but the guy has fight in him wearing our shirt our crest ffs and for that alone we should be more respectful. He can encourage from the sidelines Im really not interested in his ‘voice’ if his ability is detrimental to our performances on the pitch, I also couldn’t give a toss if he has a red n white tattooed c*ck, he’s our 4th best CB… thats all that matters It always baffles me when people fawn so hard over players, Im sure he’s a great guy, Im in no way assassinating his character, but im absolutely entitled to comment on his ability and how it affects my club 4
Whitey Grandad Posted 17 September, 2024 Posted 17 September, 2024 1 hour ago, gio1saints said: No he is not. Simply applying derisory epithets to him does not help. He may not start at any other club - opinion- but in terms of an on pitch encouraging voice he happens to be the best we have got ( fact). The season we went down and the squad that RM inherited was notable for its relative meek natured silence on pitch. JS cannot do it alone but in that regard he is way better than the other skippers I can recall we have had in last year ; AA, AM and FD ( oh and Che at Gillingham!) Getting sent off and mouthing off is not clever but the guy has fight in him wearing our shirt our crest ffs and for that alone we should be more respectful. Just before half time on Saturday I could plainly hear all the Man Utd players calling to each other. Not a peep out of our players and even less from the crowd.
Oldandtired Posted 17 September, 2024 Posted 17 September, 2024 (edited) He could be out for longer as just been charged by FA for derogatory remarks to 4th official and referee. These officials don’t like the truth… Edited 17 September, 2024 by Oldandtired
Whitey Grandad Posted 17 September, 2024 Posted 17 September, 2024 19 minutes ago, Oldandtired said: He could be out for longer as just been charged by FA for derogatory remarks to 4th official and referee. These officials don’t like the truth… In what way were the officials deficient? 1
beatlesaint Posted 17 September, 2024 Posted 17 September, 2024 1 hour ago, Oldandtired said: He could be out for longer as just been charged by FA for derogatory remarks to 4th official and referee. These officials don’t like the truth… especially on the rare occasions they get it right before VAR interjects as was the case here.
Oldandtired Posted 17 September, 2024 Posted 17 September, 2024 (edited) 1 hour ago, Whitey Grandad said: In what way were the officials deficient? Sorry, I forgot inadequate attempts at humour aren't allowed on here. However i'm not convinced that it would have been the same outcome if it had been the other team committing the offence. Edited 17 September, 2024 by Oldandtired
Oh no Mick Mills Posted 17 September, 2024 Posted 17 September, 2024 2 hours ago, Oldandtired said: He could be out for longer as just been charged by FA for derogatory remarks to 4th official and referee. These officials don’t like the truth… From where I was sat you could see Stephens turn back at the ref and shout "Fu** you"
Tom & Gerry Posted 17 September, 2024 Posted 17 September, 2024 He has started for another Premier league team and did very well as I recall. 1
beatlesaint Posted 17 September, 2024 Posted 17 September, 2024 7 minutes ago, Tom & Gerry said: He has started for another Premier league team and did very well as I recall. Believe me, knowing several Bournemouth fans I can assure you the words "he did very well" were rarely used. 5 2
Whitey Grandad Posted 17 September, 2024 Posted 17 September, 2024 26 minutes ago, Oh no Mick Mills said: From where I was sat you could see Stephens turn back at the ref and shout "Fu** you" Yeah, that would go down well.
Sergei Gotsmanov Posted 17 September, 2024 Posted 17 September, 2024 Jack Stephens cares about our club and I for one am pleased to have somebody like him in the dressing room. Our problem when we went down last time was because there were not characters like him about the club. 2
Lord Duckhunter Posted 17 September, 2024 Posted 17 September, 2024 25 minutes ago, beatlesaint said: Believe me, knowing several Bournemouth fans I can assure you the words "he did very well" were rarely used. The ones I speak to, & it’s a lot, say he did a decent job. 4
beatlesaint Posted 17 September, 2024 Posted 17 September, 2024 3 minutes ago, Lord Duckhunter said: The ones I speak to, & it’s a lot, say he did a decent job. LOL one man's meat I guess. The ones I know said at the time "i can see why you loaned him out"
SaintNewForest Posted 17 September, 2024 Posted 17 September, 2024 38 minutes ago, beatlesaint said: Believe me, knowing several Bournemouth fans I can assure you the words "he did very well" were rarely used. Working in bournemouth, I speak to a lot of Bournemouth fans. They all loved him, couldn't believe we loaned him out whilst we were struggling. 1
Doctoroncall Posted 17 September, 2024 Posted 17 September, 2024 20 minutes ago, SaintNewForest said: Working in bournemouth, I speak to a lot of Bournemouth fans. They all loved him, couldn't believe we loaned him out whilst we were struggling. I think that highlights the issue we have: 1 He was good enough for the support CB in lower PL side 2 Bournemouth could utilise him to the best of his abilities 3 Better players mitigate any risk of a fuck up 4 Raised his game/confidence playing with better players
Orkney Saint Posted 17 September, 2024 Posted 17 September, 2024 (edited) How much did Bournemouth offer to buy him for at the end of the loan? I can’t recall. Edited 17 September, 2024 by Orkney Saint 1 1
BarberSaint Posted 17 September, 2024 Posted 17 September, 2024 I liked the league one semi final playoff between Swindon and Sheffield United a few years back. Nice to see some old faces. The one that finished 5-5.
Wade Garrett Posted 17 September, 2024 Posted 17 September, 2024 8 hours ago, gio1saints said: No he is not. Simply applying derisory epithets to him does not help. He may not start at any other club - opinion- but in terms of an on pitch encouraging voice he happens to be the best we have got ( fact). The season we went down and the squad that RM inherited was notable for its relative meek natured silence on pitch. JS cannot do it alone but in that regard he is way better than the other skippers I can recall we have had in last year ; AA, AM and FD ( oh and Che at Gillingham!) Getting sent off and mouthing off is not clever but the guy has fight in him wearing our shirt our crest ffs and for that alone we should be more respectful. I could wax lyrical about his lack of awareness, poor marking, horrendous distribution, poor positional play and terrible decision-making, but can’t be arsed. He’s fucking dogshit. 2
Lord Duckhunter Posted 17 September, 2024 Posted 17 September, 2024 4 hours ago, SaintNewForest said: Working in bournemouth, I speak to a lot of Bournemouth fans. They all loved him, couldn't believe we loaned him out whilst we were struggling. I work in Bournemouth & live in Poole, so I meet a lot of them. Most say he did a decent job for them.
saintant Posted 17 September, 2024 Posted 17 September, 2024 1 hour ago, Lord Duckhunter said: I work in Bournemouth & live in Poole, so I meet a lot of them. Most say he did a decent job for them. That lot down there never did know much about football - but on kite surfing, cycling and orienteering their knowledge knows no bounds.
Smirking_Saint Posted 17 September, 2024 Posted 17 September, 2024 He played 16 out of a possible 32 and none of the run in.. they had the option to buy and didn’t Enough said 4
Miltonaggro Posted 18 September, 2024 Posted 18 September, 2024 21 hours ago, Sergei Gotsmanov said: Jack Stephens cares about our club and I for one am pleased to have somebody like him in the dressing room. Our problem when we went down last time was because there were not characters like him about the club. I am very happy with this, as long as he remains in the dressing room. 2 3
ErwinK1961 Posted 1 October, 2024 Posted 1 October, 2024 You won’t find many people upset by this (me included), but if that was the other way around there’s no way a Utd player is getting an extra two game ban. 8
Football Special Posted 1 October, 2024 Posted 1 October, 2024 23 minutes ago, ErwinK1961 said: You won’t find many people upset by this (me included), but if that was the other way around there’s no way a Utd player is getting an extra two game ban. Seems excessive, I don't recall other examples like this.
Whitey Grandad Posted 1 October, 2024 Posted 1 October, 2024 11 minutes ago, Football Special said: Seems excessive, I don't recall other examples like this. David Prutton?
AlexLaw76 Posted 1 October, 2024 Posted 1 October, 2024 Stuart Atwell: “Following a foul challenge in the 79th minute, I dismissed #SaintsFC player Jack Stephens.. After advising Mr Stephens that the Video Assistant Referee had confirmed the decision, Mr Stephens responded by calling me a "c*nt", before leaving the field of play. I considered this comment to be offensive, insulting and abusive.” Gavin Ward: “Following the sending off of Jack Stephens he left the field of play, he looked right at me and said: "You fucking little c*nt". He then went back onto the field of play, when he left to go down the tunnel this time, again he looked right at me and said "you're a c*nt". 11
Football Special Posted 1 October, 2024 Posted 1 October, 2024 2 minutes ago, AlexLaw76 said: Stuart Atwell: “Following a foul challenge in the 79th minute, I dismissed #SaintsFC player Jack Stephens.. After advising Mr Stephens that the Video Assistant Referee had confirmed the decision, Mr Stephens responded by calling me a "c*nt", before leaving the field of play. I considered this comment to be offensive, insulting and abusive.” Gavin Ward: “Following the sending off of Jack Stephens he left the field of play, he looked right at me and said: "You fucking little c*nt". He then went back onto the field of play, when he left to go down the tunnel this time, again he looked right at me and said "you're a c*nt". That's brilliant, well played Jack 👏 2
Saint NL Posted 1 October, 2024 Posted 1 October, 2024 That's one of the best things he's done in a Saints shirt tbf to him 1 3
OldNick Posted 1 October, 2024 Posted 1 October, 2024 On 17/09/2024 at 17:35, Wade Garrett said: I could wax lyrical about his lack of awareness, poor marking, horrendous distribution, poor positional play and terrible decision-making, but can’t be arsed. He’s fucking dogshit. I didnt know we had Roy Keane on here 2
saintwbu Posted 1 October, 2024 Posted 1 October, 2024 Thankfully we’ve stopped giving away soft goals and switching off defensively all the time, since he got banned. Long may that continue, as he is the reason for all that is evil in the world etc. 1
OldNick Posted 1 October, 2024 Posted 1 October, 2024 21 minutes ago, AlexLaw76 said: Stuart Atwell: “Following a foul challenge in the 79th minute, I dismissed #SaintsFC player Jack Stephens.. After advising Mr Stephens that the Video Assistant Referee had confirmed the decision, Mr Stephens responded by calling me a "c*nt", before leaving the field of play. I considered this comment to be offensive, insulting and abusive.” Gavin Ward: “Following the sending off of Jack Stephens he left the field of play, he looked right at me and said: "You fucking little c*nt". He then went back onto the field of play, when he left to go down the tunnel this time, again he looked right at me and said "you're a c*nt". I dont know how that can be brought against him, as he was clearly stating facts, the countries gone to the dogs 2
ErwinK1961 Posted 1 October, 2024 Posted 1 October, 2024 2 hours ago, AlexLaw76 said: Stuart Atwell: “Following a foul challenge in the 79th minute, I dismissed #SaintsFC player Jack Stephens.. After advising Mr Stephens that the Video Assistant Referee had confirmed the decision, Mr Stephens responded by calling me a "c*nt", before leaving the field of play. I considered this comment to be offensive, insulting and abusive.” Gavin Ward: “Following the sending off of Jack Stephens he left the field of play, he looked right at me and said: "You fucking little c*nt". He then went back onto the field of play, when he left to go down the tunnel this time, again he looked right at me and said "you're a c*nt". I stand corrected 😂 1
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now