AlexLaw76 Posted 10 November, 2024 Posted 10 November, 2024 (edited) Simple question. He ain’t changing, he is wedded to this system but to some, a nice guy. should he be moved on from the club? Edited 10 November, 2024 by AlexLaw76
saintant Posted 10 November, 2024 Posted 10 November, 2024 3 minutes ago, AlexLaw76 said: Simple question. He ain’t changing, he is wedded to this system but to some, a nice guy. should he be moved on from the club? Simple answer. Yes.
tdmickey3 Posted 10 November, 2024 Posted 10 November, 2024 Yes, should have been sacked months ago 6
FarehamSaintJames Posted 10 November, 2024 Posted 10 November, 2024 Should do, doesn’t mean he will. Early indications suggest his job is safe.
CB Fry Posted 10 November, 2024 Posted 10 November, 2024 Of course he should go but he's not going to. The "chopping and changing managers never ever works" brigade on here are going to get their dream. We won't chop and change so lets see how fantastically successful that will be. 4
sisi1992 Posted 10 November, 2024 Posted 10 November, 2024 (edited) Yes. Hes had his chance. I and probably the majority of the fan base have run out of patience with him now. He should of been sacked after the Leicester game imo. Edited 11 November, 2024 by sisi1992 1
Football Special Posted 10 November, 2024 Posted 10 November, 2024 The board don't back themselves to be able to appoint a good replacement so are going to stick with Martin as he got us promotion , saves them having to persuade someone else to take the job.
Football Special Posted 10 November, 2024 Posted 10 November, 2024 3 minutes ago, sisi1992 said: Yes. Hes had his chance. I and probably the majoirty of the fan base have run out of patience with him now. He should of been sacked after the Leicester game imo. Agree. Been enough games to prove his style of football in never going to work at this level 1
BotleySaint Posted 10 November, 2024 Posted 10 November, 2024 He has shown no adaptability or willingness to change despite his way not working. We need someone with more than one idea. I'd go for Moyes if he wanted it. 1
The Kraken Posted 10 November, 2024 Posted 10 November, 2024 This could be the most conclusive poll ever. 1
lhammondo Posted 10 November, 2024 Posted 10 November, 2024 He should go if there's a better option available; Moyes or Potter would be very good, but zero chance they'll come here with the squad the'd have to work with. If he goes, expect an equally underwhelming appointment as when he arrived (yes, i've officially lost all hope)
Mr X Posted 10 November, 2024 Posted 10 November, 2024 2 minutes ago, The Kraken said: This could be the most conclusive poll ever. He still has support from a few on here mostly as they don't trust SR to appoint a suitable replacement
bangkoksaint Posted 10 November, 2024 Posted 10 November, 2024 I’m waiting for some nutter to vote ‘no’ 😂
Harry_SFC Posted 10 November, 2024 Posted 10 November, 2024 1 minute ago, Mr X said: He still has support from a few on here mostly as they don't trust SR to appoint a suitable replacement I don't trust them either, doesn't mean I back Martin. I'd have anyone in charge over him at the moment. 1
Give it to Ron Posted 10 November, 2024 Posted 10 November, 2024 1 minute ago, Mr X said: He still has support from a few on here mostly as they don't trust SR to appoint a suitable replacement He doesn’t have my support and I wouldn’t trust SR to organise a piss up in a brewery 3
Mr X Posted 10 November, 2024 Posted 10 November, 2024 1 minute ago, Harry_SFC said: I don't trust them either, doesn't mean I back Martin. I'd have anyone in charge over him at the moment. Agreed the man has to go he hasn't been given great tools to work with striker wise for sure but at the end of the day he should be getting a better tune out of them and he dam well could if he wasn't so stubborn and we should have more than four points that's abysmal. He does himself no favours with a complete inability to see the faults in his own philosophy and get defensive and stupid to anyone that dare criticise 1
Football Special Posted 10 November, 2024 Posted 10 November, 2024 8 minutes ago, bangkoksaint said: I’m waiting for some nutter to vote ‘no’ 😂 I've not voted no but would say our problems run deeper than the manager 3 1
die Mannyschaft Posted 10 November, 2024 Posted 10 November, 2024 Realistically he is not going to go as, a) there isn't anyone we can afford Potter, Moyes far to expensive, b) new manager won't play possession football and our players would tgen need to change style, c) we won't by any players in Jan window. The owners will want some dosh from investment and prem money provides that. December is too late for new manager and if we don't get 6-8 points soon we won't get out botyon 3 anyway.
The very right reverend Posted 10 November, 2024 Posted 10 November, 2024 I didn't want him at the start of the season, we were lucky to get promoted under him last season, that was the 3rd best squad in the championship and we made it incredibly hard for ourselves and that was down to him and his ego. Why do we employ such useless egotistical charlatans, this means to me or shows we've a problem at the club that runs far far deeper than this chancer. I'd take Ian Branfoot over this total and utter clown. 2
tdmickey3 Posted 10 November, 2024 Posted 10 November, 2024 (edited) 2 hours ago, bangkoksaint said: I’m waiting for some nutter to vote ‘no’ 😂 5 have so far🤷♂️ now 9…… Gio Martin has lots of log ins I guess Edited 10 November, 2024 by tdmickey3 1
Disco Stu Posted 10 November, 2024 Posted 10 November, 2024 No fence sitting this time from the "give it 10 games" brigade please.
Midfield_General Posted 10 November, 2024 Posted 10 November, 2024 Cool new thread! Thank goodness there's now somewhere where thoughts on the manager can finally be shared, couldn't see any discussion of him anywhere else, especially not the 251 pages of the Russell Martin thread. 1 4 1
madge Posted 10 November, 2024 Posted 10 November, 2024 Absobloodylutely… Ipswich go to spurs and win!!! We’re so not capable of doing that. I’m so bored of this football. Crab football.. it’s like having a team full of Jim magiltons. The players surely can’t be happy playing with the shackles on. 1
bangkoksaint Posted 10 November, 2024 Posted 10 November, 2024 14 minutes ago, tdmickey3 said: 5 have so far🤷♂️ Yes…..it’s quite concerning!! 1
CanadaSaint Posted 10 November, 2024 Posted 10 November, 2024 I’ve voted Yes even though it’s just a plaintive cry if the reality is that he CAN’T be moved on because the cost would cause us to breach the Profit and Sustainability Rules, because of the understandable lack of decent candidates willing to pick up the poisoned chalice we’ve become, or because (like many on here) they fear that we’re doomed regardless of whether he stays or goes. If that’s the case our only realistic option may be to hire someone with football knowledge and a powerful-enough personality to supervise him. There are pacy, wide players in the squad who can add the fast-break dimensions we need, but Martin refuses to play them. They may be short of PL standard but the important thing is that they offer us the early out-ball and the through-the channels target we need in order to break out of our self-created quicksand and get an earlier delivery into the box. AA contributed nothing out-wide yesterday, and playing BBD out there was ludicrous. I can’t imagine that Martin’s contract gives him unfettered control over team affairs regardless of his performance. He has to report to someone, and that “someone” is also doing a really shitty job right now. 2
Sheaf Saint Posted 10 November, 2024 Posted 10 November, 2024 33 minutes ago, Midfield_General said: Cool new thread! Thank goodness there's now somewhere where thoughts on the manager can finally be shared, couldn't see any discussion of him anywhere else, especially not the 251 pages of the Russell Martin thread. In fairness, a whole new thread is the only way to conduct an up to date poll and get a current snapshot of the balance of people's thinking. 3
SaintsBarry74 Posted 10 November, 2024 Posted 10 November, 2024 1 hour ago, tdmickey3 said: Yes, should have been sacked months ago Should have been sacked years ago. 1
Weston Super Saint Posted 10 November, 2024 Posted 10 November, 2024 We can't move him on because PSR something something, no money, flat broke something something, haven't got a pot to piss in something something. We're stuck with him for the next four years.
LiberalCommunist Posted 10 November, 2024 Posted 10 November, 2024 Quote It’s not about getting relegated. It’s about his tactics doing a irredeemable harm to our (very few) promising young players. We need to start thinking about the next 18 months. We need to start thinking about the core of this team. They need organisation and consistency. Russell Martin’s dogmatic unwavering approach is harmful. And add to that it’s fucking boring to watch. Nice bloke-but I’d like a real manager in charge now. 1
Saint Gifford Posted 10 November, 2024 Posted 10 November, 2024 Chopping and changing managers helps nobody, the manager the club or the players. You have to stick with a manager that shows he can develop, help improve, even move player positions for the benefit of club and player. Need to allow the manager to change, and work different styles of play against the particular opponents that they face that week. Work with DOF to identify what would fit a fluid changing style, but with a key ethos that is the cornerstone and heart of a winning flexible team that everyone buys into. We have Russell Martin and the DIC sorry DOF do that…………………………………. 1 1
beatlesaint Posted 10 November, 2024 Posted 10 November, 2024 Out of his depth and too stubborn to adapt. It’s a shame but it is what it is !
Juneau Posted 10 November, 2024 Posted 10 November, 2024 I miss the Cortese days where we’d have the balls to sack Adkins (which was met with anger at the time) but ended up representing strong leadership which pushed the club forward with a well thought out replacement. I feel like he needs to go but we’re in a different place now… 2
Colinjb Posted 10 November, 2024 Posted 10 November, 2024 He's a single minded, stubborn fool wedded to his arrogant dogma. The easiest 'yes' i've ever clicked on. 4
Whitey Grandad Posted 10 November, 2024 Posted 10 November, 2024 6 minutes ago, Saint Gifford said: Chopping and changing managers helps nobody, the manager the club or the players. You have to stick with a manager that shows he can develop, help improve, even move player positions for the benefit of club and player. Need to allow the manager to change, and work different styles of play against the particular opponents that they face that week. Work with DOF to identify what would fit a fluid changing style, but with a key ethos that is the cornerstone and heart of a winning flexible team that everyone buys into. We have Russell Martin and the DIC sorry DOF do that…………………………………. We only need to change this once. This manager refuses to change his style. He’s been found out. 1
Gingeletiss Posted 10 November, 2024 Posted 10 November, 2024 Another way must be, that SR tells him to change his approach to the game, if he doesn’t like that, he can resign. 1
Hemp Posted 10 November, 2024 Posted 10 November, 2024 If overseeing the utter shambles we have become , combined with our achievment of being statistically the worst team across all four divisions with the most pointless and boring style of football imaginable isnt enough for him to be relieved of his duties then i dont know what is. Its a yes from me. 4
Sarisbury Saint Posted 10 November, 2024 Posted 10 November, 2024 1 hour ago, bangkoksaint said: I’m waiting for some nutter to vote ‘no’ 😂 Happy to oblige. 1
AlexLaw76 Posted 10 November, 2024 Author Posted 10 November, 2024 1 hour ago, Midfield_General said: Cool new thread! Thank goodness there's now somewhere where thoughts on the manager can finally be shared, couldn't see any discussion of him anywhere else, especially not the 251 pages of the Russell Martin thread. you are aware this is a poll??? 1
stknowle Posted 10 November, 2024 Posted 10 November, 2024 46 minutes ago, CanadaSaint said: I If that’s the case our only realistic option may be to hire someone with football knowledge and a powerful-enough personality to supervise him. There are pacy, wide players in the squad who can add the fast-break dimensions we need, but Martin refuses to play them. They may be short of PL standard but the important thing is that they offer us the early out-ball and the through-the channels target we need in order to break out of our self-created quicksand and get an earlier delivery into the box. AA contributed nothing out-wide yesterday, and playing BBD out there was ludicrous. I can’t imagine that Martin’s contract gives him unfettered control over team affairs regardless of his performance. He has to report to someone, and that “someone” is also doing a really shitty job right now. I agree with this the only hope is to get someone in with actual football knowledge and managerial ability to manage our manager. 1
saintant Posted 10 November, 2024 Posted 10 November, 2024 1 hour ago, lhammondo said: He should go if there's a better option available; Moyes or Potter would be very good, but zero chance they'll come here with the squad the'd have to work with. If he goes, expect an equally underwhelming appointment as when he arrived (yes, i've officially lost all hope) If there aren't better options available who would come here there is something seriously wrong in football. 2
Gloucester Saint Posted 10 November, 2024 Posted 10 November, 2024 It currently stands at 99-yes and 9-no. 999 - sums up where the club and SR is at. 5 minutes ago, stknowle said: I agree with this the only hope is to get someone in with actual football knowledge and managerial ability to manage our manager. Might solve the financial barrier as Russell will hate that and walk.
saintant Posted 10 November, 2024 Posted 10 November, 2024 33 minutes ago, Saint Gifford said: Chopping and changing managers helps nobody, the manager the club or the players. You have to stick with a manager that shows he can develop, help improve, even move player positions for the benefit of club and player. Need to allow the manager to change, and work different styles of play against the particular opponents that they face that week. Work with DOF to identify what would fit a fluid changing style, but with a key ethos that is the cornerstone and heart of a winning flexible team that everyone buys into. We have Russell Martin and the DIC sorry DOF do that…………………………………. Let me know when we get one and I'm sure we'll stick with him. For now we have a guy in charge hell bent on wrecking our club and pissing off most of the supporters. 1
tdmickey3 Posted 10 November, 2024 Posted 10 November, 2024 19 minutes ago, Sarisbury Saint said: Happy to oblige. Can you explain why you think this fiasco should continue?
saintant Posted 10 November, 2024 Posted 10 November, 2024 1 hour ago, die Mannyschaft said: Realistically he is not going to go as, a) there isn't anyone we can afford Potter, Moyes far to expensive, b) new manager won't play possession football and our players would tgen need to change style, c) we won't by any players in Jan window. The owners will want some dosh from investment and prem money provides that. December is too late for new manager and if we don't get 6-8 points soon we won't get out botyon 3 anyway. Yeah, they'd have to go back to playing normal football rather than having the crap coached out of them by Russell Pep Lite Fucking Martin and his bunch of lapdog assistants. I'm pretty convinced they'd find it easy and very refreshing to go out and enjoy expressing themselves free from the 'to me, to you, backwards sideways, walking football straitjacket' that Martin insists on wrapping them in.
Sarisbury Saint Posted 10 November, 2024 Posted 10 November, 2024 3 minutes ago, tdmickey3 said: Can you explain why you think this fiasco should continue? Because I can’t think of any manager that could keep us up this season wanting to come here. 1 2
Dark Munster Posted 10 November, 2024 Posted 10 November, 2024 43 minutes ago, SaintsBarry74 said: Should have been sacked years ago. I'll see your "Should have been sacked years ago" and raise you "Shouldn't have been hired in the first place"! For many of us it was clear he was an appalling choice even before he started. Look at the comments at the beginning of the Russell Martin Thread: 2
tdmickey3 Posted 10 November, 2024 Posted 10 November, 2024 Just now, Sarisbury Saint said: Because I can’t think of any manager that could keep us up this season wanting to come here. Is that a good reason then? It’s like banging you head on the wall and despite It hurting you carry on while wondering why it continues to hurt
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now