Jump to content

Recommended Posts

Posted
  On 27/09/2024 at 16:01, Bad Wolf said:

Ralph's atmopshere was INCREDIBLY toxic when things were going bad. Yes, he got plenty of support and love during the good bits but that's not what I meant. The vast majority wanted him gone after each 9-0, rightly or wrongly.

Jones was obviously not right but again, fans didn't help. I remember one comment on either here or social media a while ago said they they decided in the first 5 minutes of his first game in charge (a cup game) that they wernt going to support him. If that's not fans being part of the problem, I'm not sure what is. He probably wouldn't have been any of our choices but the fact is he was THE choice. The best thing to do would have been to get behind him. That 100% wasn't done. He had to go in the end but fans didn't help.

Expand  

Jones’ days here were numbered as soon as the club put a mic on him during that training session.

  • Like 1
  • Haha 1
Posted
  On 27/09/2024 at 20:27, Farmer Saint said:

The squad only has about 5 or 6 PL quality players at the very most (Ramsdale, Suga (maybe), KWP (although not playing like it this season), Downes (maybe), Fernandes (maybe) and Dibling - I reckon that puts us at either 19th or 20th in the League, and WAYYYY behind anyone who was in this League last season. 

Expand  

Yeah, its not really that difficult to grasp, is it?

To stay up we have to finish above both teams who finished above us and beat us in 4/4 games last season (one we have finished behind for st least 4 seasons) plus at least one team that has played in this league and stayed up for (at least) the last two seasons so have had now 5 windows of splashing PL cash.

Last season all of the teams who came up went straight back down.

Clearly from the above, and the fact we don't spend lots of money by PL standards, it is going to be very difficult to stay up this season, regardless of who the manager is.

We certainly should not be accepting of relegation at this stage of the season, but surely an element of realism is needed?

We were an unfortunate deflection from being out of the bottom 3 after 5 games and put in easily our best performance so far - not the time to be speed dialling someone like David Moyes who clearly wouldn't have the tools to do what those in favour of him would want.

All IMHO of course,

Morph

 

 

  • Like 2
Posted
  On 27/09/2024 at 10:20, Lee On Solent Saint said:

Surely if SR value staying up, then its going to have to be someone in the Moyes mould. Experienced, able to organise teams. Dare I say it, something like Everton have done with Dyche. We all laugh at them, but at least they have managed to stay up by grinding out results when it matters. When your squad is limited, you make the most of what you have. Pretty football goes out the window as results far outweigh the need of a performance.

Expand  

I like the way we play, and would prefer to watch, and on the flip side we do not have the personal to play up and at them style. This change would mean we would need to make big changes again in January and probably just as likely to get relegated. 

I have said we need to stick to RM if we go down or stay up. Yes we are likely to go down, but would prefer to play the style we play in the championship next season. When we got relegated the season before last we lost our identity as a club. We have back our Southampton way that we had the last time we were promoted. 

We should stick with it, grit out teeth and get on with the season and hope out of all hope we can just about do enough to stay up, or at least get takeover by someone who owns a country! 

  • Like 1
  • Haha 2
Posted
  On 27/09/2024 at 19:20, Farmer Saint said:

It's not for hope reasons, it's for entertainment reasons - the hope is the hope of fun football as we'll never do anything in the PL anyway. Hoping to stay up is such a sad indictment on an individual I think, and shows someone that has the wrong outlook on life personally. Life is about fun and making the most of it, not hoping to be 4 bottom in an underwhelming and unentertaining season. 

Tbh, it's why the NFL shits all over association football. 

Expand  

Is that the same sport where teams tank on purpose in the hopes of getting a better draft pick for the following season?

  • Like 1
Posted
  On 27/09/2024 at 21:09, Dusic said:

Yeah, its not really that difficult to grasp, is it?

To stay up we have to finish above both teams who finished above us and beat us in 4/4 games last season (one we have finished behind for st least 4 seasons) plus at least one team that has played in this league and stayed up for (at least) the last two seasons so have had now 5 windows of splashing PL cash.

Last season all of the teams who came up went straight back down.

Clearly from the above, and the fact we don't spend lots of money by PL standards, it is going to be very difficult to stay up this season, regardless of who the manager is.

We certainly should not be accepting of relegation at this stage of the season, but surely an element of realism is needed?

We were an unfortunate deflection from being out of the bottom 3 after 5 games and put in easily our best performance so far - not the time to be speed dialling someone like David Moyes who clearly wouldn't have the tools to do what those in favour of him would want.

All IMHO of course,

Morph

 

 

Expand  

An unfortunate deflection? We were fortunate to get anything on that shot.

Posted (edited)
  On 27/09/2024 at 21:50, SambaMaverick said:

Is that the same sport where teams tank on purpose in the hopes of getting a better draft pick for the following season?

Expand  

No, tanking is not really a thing - they may trade away players for prospects or draft picks, but funnily enough head coaches don't want to lose their jobs by tanking for the owners. 

It's also not legal, so they can lose the following season's draft picks if they do. 

Edited by Farmer Saint
Posted (edited)
  On 28/09/2024 at 05:09, CB Fry said:

What happened the season before that?

Expand  

But the relevance is in the fact that none went down last season, further allowing for increased spending and maintenance of a PL quality squad for the 17 clubs that stayed in the League without PSR being as much of an issue. You seem to continously not grasp this point - I am assuming it's wilful ignorance on your part. 

If we stayed up this season we would cut out more of the Championship/League 1 quality players in our squad and replace with PL quality ones by increasing spending on both transfers and wages. 

Edited by Farmer Saint
  • Like 1
Posted (edited)
  On 28/09/2024 at 06:16, Farmer Saint said:

But the relevance is in the fact that none went down last season, further allowing for increased spending and maintenance of a PL quality squad for the 17 clubs that stayed in the League without PSR being as much of an issue. You seem to continously not grasp this point - I am assuming it's wilful ignorance on your part. 

If we stayed up this season we would cut out more of the Championship/League 1 quality players in our squad and replace with PL quality ones by increasing spending on both transfers and wages. 

Expand  

But the season all three stayed up they would have been up against an entire league of teams with multiple years of Premier League funds.

So no, I don't get your point.

Edited by CB Fry
  • Like 3
Posted (edited)
  On 28/09/2024 at 06:27, CB Fry said:

But the season all three stayed up they would have been up against an entire league of teams with multiple years of Premier League funds.

So no, I don't get your point.

Expand  

The season we got relegated you mean? Where PSR wasn't being fully penalised so teams could come up thinking they could spend without impunity? Last season was the first one where the 3 teams that got promoted went straight back down since 1998. That's not a coincidence. 

The way for teams to stay up now is to hope that incumbent PL teams financially fuck themselves. 

Edited by Farmer Saint
Posted
  On 28/09/2024 at 07:04, Farmer Saint said:

The season we got relegated you mean? Where PSR wasn't being fully penalised so teams could come up thinking they could spend without impunity? Last season was the first one where the 3 teams that got promoted went straight back down since 1998. That's not a coincidence. 

The way for teams to stay up now is to hope that incumbent PL teams financially fuck themselves. 

Expand  

So it happened for the first time in 35 years and now it is going to happen every season forever now. Clear.

  • Haha 1
Posted
  On 28/09/2024 at 07:18, Farmer Saint said:

Yeah, cos that's what I said 🙄.

And it's 25 years, not 35.

Expand  

Sorry I read it as 1988.

You are saying that clubs stay up because other clubs fuck up, which is not the blistering hot take you think it is.

Posted
  On 28/09/2024 at 07:27, CB Fry said:

Sorry I read it as 1988.

You are saying that clubs stay up because other clubs fuck up, which is not the blistering hot take you think it is.

Expand  

Never said it was a hot take or anything of the like, it's actually been doing the rounds for a while. PSR helps to close the PL to new teams. 

Don't know why but you seem to like to infer things into other people posts that don't exist - this is the second time in two posts this morning that you have done it. Wind your neck in. 

Posted
  On 28/09/2024 at 03:00, Whitey Grandad said:

They don't score goals in this league though.

How many times must it be repeated? Last season has no bearing on this. 

 

Expand  

but it does, we have basically the same squad who finished 4th Yes we have had additions but apart from AR we have got in basically top of the Championship quality players.

What do you expect???? We could easily have had 3 or more points had we had the rub of the green. Changing the manager is just another madness , the people dont learn its like Brexit part 2.Death by a thousand cuts

  • Like 1
  • Haha 1
Posted
  On 28/09/2024 at 08:47, OldNick said:

but it does, we have basically the same squad who finished 4th Yes we have had additions but apart from AR we have got in basically top of the Championship quality players.

What do you expect???? We could easily have had 3 or more points had we had the rub of the green. Changing the manager is just another madness , the people dont learn its like Brexit part 2.Death by a thousand cuts

Expand  

It's baffling how many people can't see this. The quality of our squad is relegation-from-PL level. That is par.

  • Like 2
Posted (edited)
  On 28/09/2024 at 07:52, Farmer Saint said:

Never said it was a hot take or anything of the like, it's actually been doing the rounds for a while. PSR helps to close the PL to new teams. 

Don't know why but you seem to like to infer things into other people posts that don't exist - this is the second time in two posts this morning that you have done it. Wind your neck in. 

Expand  

In 2023 all three promoted teams stayed up.

So an aspiration to achieve that (with an ownership that came in with explicit aims to establish us in this division) feels like something SFC should be going for as it is achievable and has been achieved, 2023 was last year.

And I am sure that as the season goes on, they will act to try and deliver that.

Edited by CB Fry
  • Like 2
Posted (edited)
  On 28/09/2024 at 03:03, Whitey Grandad said:

An unfortunate deflection? We were fortunate to get anything on that shot.

Expand  

You will hate this but it’s Saturday morning…..That Ipswich goal apparently had an XG of .04 - it most certainly was very unlucky for us to concede from there. Just like the Rothwell goal we will not see one of those again this season. 
 

Having said that I do appreciate your existentialist approach to football- it’s all about the here and now.
 

Saints history gives us something to talk about and compare to other than the very last match in the EPL though - for some of us anyway!
 

 Our saints support is not based on just the here and now or last result after all- well not for most of us! 😇
 

Edited by gio1saints
  • Like 1
  • Haha 2
Posted
  On 28/09/2024 at 09:07, CB Fry said:

In 2023 all three promoted teams stayed up.

So an aspiration to achieve that (with an ownership that came in with explicit aims to establish us in this division) feels like something SFC should be going for as it is achievable and has been achieved, 2023 was last year.

And I am sure that as the season goes on, they will act to try and deliver that.

Expand  

last season I believe was the easiest season to have stayed up in my memory. All three were dire. Had we survived one more season, we would have stayed up last season easily.

Posted
  On 28/09/2024 at 11:14, OldNick said:

last season I believe was the easiest season to have stayed up in my memory. All three were dire. Had we survived one more season, we would have stayed up last season easily.

Expand  

As opposed to this year when the bottom three are fucking legendary?

So far, 3 points between the bottom 3 from 15 games. 12 points from 30 games from the bottom 6.  Arguably, it's even easier to stay up this year, but not something we look like doing.

  • Like 1
Posted
  On 28/09/2024 at 11:20, Weston Super Saint said:

As opposed to this year when the bottom three are fucking legendary?

So far, 3 points between the bottom 3 from 15 games. 12 points from 30 games from the bottom 6.  Arguably, it's even easier to stay up this year, but not something we look like doing.

Expand  

FFS we are only a few games in. Whilst clubs may look at us like Burnley, Luton, and Sheff Utd I dont feel any of the others are as poor quality ass them. Wolves bottom! Come on last season they were dire. We are close to their standard squad wise although I think we are better than those 3

Posted
  On 28/09/2024 at 03:00, Whitey Grandad said:

They don't score goals in this league though.

How many times must it be repeated? Last season has no bearing on this. 

 

Expand  

They do though? They've scored 2 goals in his five games...Yes five in this league. Which brings me back around to the question of who do you want after the next manager doesn't do well for five games? If last season has no bearing and you're taking these five games in isolation, surely you'll be doing the same for the next manager?

  • Like 4
  • Haha 1
Posted
  On 28/09/2024 at 08:47, OldNick said:

but it does, we have basically the same squad who finished 4th Yes we have had additions but apart from AR we have got in basically top of the Championship quality players.

What do you expect???? We could easily have had 3 or more points had we had the rub of the green. Changing the manager is just another madness , the people dont learn its like Brexit part 2.Death by a thousand cuts

Expand  

I think you’ll find that every losing team could say this.

Even the top of the Championship is a long way from the bottom of the Premier League.

Posted
  On 28/09/2024 at 11:46, Bad Wolf said:

They do though? They've scored 2 goals in his five games...Yes five in this league. Which brings me back around to the question of who do you want after the next manager doesn't do well for five games? If last season has no bearing and you're taking these five games in isolation, surely you'll be doing the same for the next manager?

Expand  

I’m not taking these five in isolation. I can see that we are a defensive shambles and I see no evidence historically or otherwise that Martin can ever improve that.

  • Like 4
Posted
  On 28/09/2024 at 09:12, gio1saints said:

You will hate this but it’s Saturday morning…..That Ipswich goal apparently had an XG of .04 - it most certainly was very unlucky for us to concede from there. Just like the Rothwell goal we will not see one of those again this season. 
 

Having said that I do appreciate your existentialist approach to football- it’s all about the here and now.
 

Saints history gives us something to talk about and compare to other than the very last match in the EPL though - for some of us anyway!
 

 Our saints support is not based on just the here and now or last result after all- well not for most of us! 😇
 

Expand  

Good morning Gio,

It’s very early Saturday morning for me. An XG of 0.04 just shows how ridiculous Such statistics are. If XG were any use the actually goals and the expected goals should be a lot closer than they are. We’ve all seen the photos of our lack of cover at that corner. Was anyone surprised that they scored?

Anyway, taken overall Ipswich had many good scoring opportunities and it was no surprise that they came away from that game with a draw. You have to look at the game as a whole.

For me it’s not about the here and now at all. It’s about where we are going from here and at the moment I can only see one future for us. I have no faith or expectation that Martin knows how to defend at this level.

  • Like 5
Posted
  On 28/09/2024 at 12:58, Whitey Grandad said:

I’m not taking these five in isolation. I can see that we are a defensive shambles and I see no evidence historically or otherwise that Martin can ever improve that.

Expand  

But last season has nothing to do with it?

Or are you taking the bad bits from last season but then saying, for the good bits, that they don't count because they're "last season"

  • Like 1
Posted
  On 28/09/2024 at 13:48, Bad Wolf said:

But last season has nothing to do with it?

Or are you taking the bad bits from last season but then saying, for the good bits, that they don't count because they're "last season"

Expand  

I shouldn't  need to explain this again. 

We are playing in a different league. One in which mistakes and defensive failings will get punished clinically. One that is played at a much higher tempo. Scoring goals is not as easy as it was last season. And he's up against more experienced coaches who are more tactically aware than him. Multiple substitutions when you're one-nil up?

When I'm looking at Martin's defensive record I'm going back over his entire managerial history. His teams leak goals. We can't hold a coherent back line, we pack our own box at corners leaving no threats upfield, we allow the opposition wingers acres of space to exploit, in short we're a soft touch and other teams are picking their lips in anticipation of playing us.

Last season we got lucky. I doubt that we shall this time.

  • Like 7
Posted
  On 28/09/2024 at 14:34, Whitey Grandad said:

I shouldn't  need to explain this again. 

We are playing in a different league. One in which mistakes and defensive failings will get punished clinically. One that is played at a much higher tempo. Scoring goals is not as easy as it was last season. And he's up against more experienced coaches who are more tactically aware than him. Multiple substitutions when you're one-nil up?

When I'm looking at Martin's defensive record I'm going back over his entire managerial history. His teams leak goals. We can't hold a coherent back line, we pack our own box at corners leaving no threats upfield, we allow the opposition wingers acres of space to exploit, in short we're a soft touch and other teams are picking their lips in anticipation of playing us.

Last season we got lucky. I doubt that we shall this time.

Expand  

I've yet to see a team have a good season without getting lucky tbh. This "got lucky" thing can be used to undermine any sporting achievement. Last season he did what was hoped of him. It was a success, whichever way you look at it. 

I'm sorry I just don't see how you can claim in one post that last season's success doesn't count for anything and then in a different post, claim that your angle is looking back at his whole career...They can't both be used.

  • Like 1
  • Haha 1
Posted
  On 28/09/2024 at 12:54, Whitey Grandad said:

I think you’ll find that every losing team could say this.

Even the top of the Championship is a long way from the bottom of the Premier League.

Expand  

Cant believe how you are panicking after being a Saints fan so long

Posted
  On 28/09/2024 at 14:34, Whitey Grandad said:

I shouldn't  need to explain this again. 

We are playing in a different league. One in which mistakes and defensive failings will get punished clinically. One that is played at a much higher tempo. Scoring goals is not as easy as it was last season. And he's up against more experienced coaches who are more tactically aware than him. Multiple substitutions when you're one-nil up?

When I'm looking at Martin's defensive record I'm going back over his entire managerial history. His teams leak goals. We can't hold a coherent back line, we pack our own box at corners leaving no threats upfield, we allow the opposition wingers acres of space to exploit, in short we're a soft touch and other teams are picking their lips in anticipation of playing us.

Last season we got lucky. I doubt that we shall this time.

Expand  

yep and aa squad of basically top championship players against teams packed with PL standard players. Christ it really bemuses how fickle the fans on here are.

You were all licking up to him in May and after 5 games you want to change the manager, How pathetic it all is. How many managers do you want this season? One every 3-5-or 8 games.

I myself was talking to Leeds fans after the play off final game saying they would have the fun season this year and we would have a miserable one. Im still hopeful we will turn it around

  • Confused 4
Posted (edited)
  On 28/09/2024 at 15:21, OldNick said:

Christ it really bemuses how fickle the fans on here are.

Expand  

I'd always assumed fickleness was a pre-requisite for anyone to become a football fan...? ;)

Edited by trousers
Posted
  On 27/09/2024 at 19:20, Farmer Saint said:

It's not for hope reasons, it's for entertainment reasons - the hope is the hope of fun football as we'll never do anything in the PL anyway. Hoping to stay up is such a sad indictment on an individual I think, and shows someone that has the wrong outlook on life personally. Life is about fun and making the most of it, not hoping to be 4 bottom in an underwhelming and unentertaining season. 

Tbh, it's why the NFL shits all over association football. 

Expand  

NFL lacks the joy of promotion and the potential peril of relegation, that isn't a good thing.

  • Like 4
Posted
  On 28/09/2024 at 13:08, Whitey Grandad said:

Good morning Gio,

It’s very early Saturday morning for me. An XG of 0.04 just shows how ridiculous Such statistics are. If XG were any use the actually goals and the expected goals should be a lot closer than they are. We’ve all seen the photos of our lack of cover at that corner. Was anyone surprised that they scored?

Anyway, taken overall Ipswich had many good scoring opportunities and it was no surprise that they came away from that game with a draw. You have to look at the game as a whole.

For me it’s not about the here and now at all. It’s about where we are going from here and at the moment I can only see one future for us. I have no faith or expectation that Martin knows how to defend at this level.

Expand  

XG and statistics, in general, balance out over a long period of time, and statistically Saints are doing OK. It's all odd but it's the way it works. However, if Saints statistically deteriorate in the future, then we won't see everything balance out

The defending is down to the system. If you watched Chelsea, Brighton today the defending was awful. The difference is, they are both scoring goals 

I think there is an issue with nerves in the team. Now, if that coming from the manager then that is a massive issue. I think with the players we have, we need to stick to the system we use, but it needs to tweaked so everything is happening further forward. For me, if Russ is the issue with the nervousness and if he cannot tweak his system appropriately, then I think he needs replaced, sooner rather than later. As others have said, every manager has their level and this might be a step too far

 

 

Posted
  On 28/09/2024 at 17:06, Matthew Le God said:

NFL lacks the joy of promotion and the potential peril of relegation, that isn't a good thing.

Expand  

Twenty years ago I would agree with that. But nowadays relegation is a financial catastrophe for most teams, unless they bounce straight up, and even then it's a massive handicap with PSR as we are finding out.

  • Like 2
Posted
  On 28/09/2024 at 18:19, Dark Munster said:

Twenty years ago I would agree with that. But nowadays relegation is a financial catastrophe for most teams, unless they bounce straight up, and even then it's a massive handicap with PSR as we are finding out.

Expand  

Not sure Leeds fans would agree. Twenty years ago relegation saw them disappear. This time round they nearly bounced back immediately and I expect them to this time. 

  • Like 1
Posted
  On 28/09/2024 at 09:07, CB Fry said:

In 2023 all three promoted teams stayed up.

So an aspiration to achieve that (with an ownership that came in with explicit aims to establish us in this division) feels like something SFC should be going for as it is achievable and has been achieved, 2023 was last year.

And I am sure that as the season goes on, they will act to try and deliver that.

Expand  

Not saying aspirationally that shouldn't be what they're going for, but the PSR limitations we had due to our overspend on utter crap in 2022-23 means it's a very different landscape, and any previous small discretion that the PL would have allowed then are just not allowed now. 

Posted
  On 29/09/2024 at 06:11, Farmer Saint said:
  On 28/09/2024 at 17:06, Matthew Le God said:

NFL lacks the joy of promotion and the potential peril of relegation, that isn't a good thing.

Expand  

But it does allow a fair playing field for all teams, which is infinitely better than what we have in football. 

Expand  

The NFL has a hard salary cap... players are not bought and sold, but traded.

So all teams are under the same financial constraints,  every year.

Results in giving every team a chance to win.

Football on the other hand, is based on who has the most money and how well you manage that money. 

NFL season is much shorter, more competitive,  and more teams have legitimate chances of winning.

EPL is boring with only 2 or 3 teans that can win.

 

  • Like 3
Posted
  On 29/09/2024 at 06:32, Walter_Sobchak said:

The NFL has a hard salary cap... players are not bought and sold, but traded.

So all teams are under the same financial constraints,  every year.

Results in giving every team a chance to win.

Football on the other hand, is based on who has the most money and how well you manage that money. 

NFL season is much shorter, more competitive,  and more teams have legitimate chances of winning.

EPL is boring with only 2 or 3 teans that can win.

 

Expand  

However if we adopted an NFL approach in this country, with the same teams always in the top division, then it is likely that Saints would not be in it

Posted
  On 29/09/2024 at 07:38, Kenilworthy said:

However if we adopted an NFL approach in this country, with the same teams always in the top division, then it is likely that Saints would not be in it

Expand  

Who would make up the 20 top flight clubs then?

We've consistently been in the top dozen or so best supported clubs in England since we've been at St Mary's, probably still the case in this season's PL. Only Leeds and Sunderland can boast higher attendances outside of the top flight. Other than the elite, all the others are capable of being relegated.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...