Season so far player ratings

[Fraser Spinney]

With just over a quarter of the season remaining I had a go at rating every player who has featured in 10+ Championship games this season. KWP the best performer for me but do you agree with the other ratings?

https://www.southamptonfc.news/opinion/rating-every-southampton-players-season-so-far-as-really-gifted-ace-top-performs/

[Bad Wolf]

Agree with everything apart from Smallbone. More like a 6 IMO.

[Saint Billy]

4 minutes ago, Bad Wolf said:

Agree with everything apart from Smallbone. More like a 6 IMO.

This and I would have given Fraser an 8.

[disconnect]

Bit generous to Stephens, who I'd give a 6. Positionally lost at full back, and a noticeable drop in quality at centre back compared to Bednarek or Harwood-Bellis when played there. Smallbone 6.5/ 7 (mostly as very weak at the start of the season) and Stuart Armstrong 7.5 as he's had some great games and some not as good.  AA 8 but hasn't been great for 3/4/5 matches now unfortunately.

[richardc]

Not sure THB and Janny B should have the same score - THB playing much better than Janny B, as a rock at the back, as a leader and with his incisive forward passes

[Convict Colony]

Thought mannings score was generous and having Stu Armstrong as the same score as Adam Armstrong is definitely wrong, I'd have Stu at 7 not an 8.

[Dusic]

Shea Charles is a 6 IMO. Not trusted by the manager to do the role he was signed for.

 

[stknowle]

THB worth more than an 8 and Manning less than 6.5. I'd go 9 and 5 respectively.

[Hatch]

Smallbone and AA both rated too high by a couple of marks.