Archers Road Stand Posted 18 April, 2023 Posted 18 April, 2023 8 hours ago, Saint NL said: a new contender has appeared. He's awful but still better than the League One standard keeper we have. Depressing as fuck. 1
Nordic Saint Posted 18 April, 2023 Posted 18 April, 2023 8 hours ago, Saint NL said: a new contender has appeared. Yes, he's the second youngest after Bazunu. He's only just turned 23. Top flight goalkeepers are usually in their late 20s and early 30s because that's when they reach their peak. People who run successful Premier League clubs are aware of facts like this. 3
rallyboy Posted 18 April, 2023 Posted 18 April, 2023 Meslier is in much worse form than Bazunu - that nearpost goal that handed Everton three points was ridiculous, and could well be a pivotal mistake in their season.
Galway saint Posted 20 April, 2023 Posted 20 April, 2023 He doesn’t make many absolute howlers and maybe that’s why he is still picked. It’s more conceding goals like the first against palace, the one against WHU and the one against Leeds where you’d expect a decent keeper to do a lot better. Seems really odd we have persisted all season and had we had an alternative we would be at least a few points better off and still in the mix. I hope we don’t persist next season with this as it been a major reason for our demise and the goals aren’t any smaller in the championship
S-Clarke Posted 21 April, 2023 Posted 21 April, 2023 He didn't get that shot away at all, pushed it straight back into the danger zone. No surprise he'd fluff it during the moments we needed a capable GK. 2
Galway saint Posted 21 April, 2023 Posted 21 April, 2023 1 minute ago, S-Clarke said: He didn't get that shot away at all, pushed it straight back into the danger zone. No surprise he'd fluff it during the moments we needed a capable GK. Same dynamic as the first goal against palace. He is a very big reason we are going down and yet he still plays each game. 2
Archers Road Stand Posted 21 April, 2023 Posted 21 April, 2023 Genuinely shouldn't be anywhere near our starting lineup next year in the Championship. Woeful.
MAY-Z Posted 21 April, 2023 Posted 21 April, 2023 2 minutes ago, Galway saint said: Same dynamic as the first goal against palace. He is a very big reason we are going down and yet he still plays each game. The single biggest individual reason we are going down. 2 1
SotonianWill Posted 21 April, 2023 Posted 21 April, 2023 6 minutes ago, S-Clarke said: He didn't get that shot away at all, pushed it straight back into the danger zone. No surprise he'd fluff it during the moments we needed a capable GK. he did it quite a lot of times this game, it’s just our defenders or arsenals own players blocked the shot to save him
Saint_clark Posted 21 April, 2023 Posted 21 April, 2023 Just now, MAY-Z said: The single biggest individual reason we are going down. I agree. I know people will say it's the lack of goalscorer but even without one of those, a half decent keeper will earn us another 10 points than we have right now. 2
Galway saint Posted 21 April, 2023 Posted 21 April, 2023 He doesn’t cope well with high balls, he doesn’t save 1 minute ago, Saint_clark said: I agree. I know people will say it's the lack of goalscorer but even without one of those, a half decent keeper will earn us another 10 points than we have right now. I don’t know about 10 but certainty 5. He doesn’t cope well with crosses and doesn’t save shots but he doesn’t make many absolute howlers so perhaps that’s why he plays but he is the worst first choice I can recall in 40 years of supporting Saints. It’s difficult to know what his level is really as he doesn’t really exhibit any particular goalkeeping attributes. He’s just a bloke in goal 1
Lord Duckhunter Posted 21 April, 2023 Posted 21 April, 2023 (edited) AM wouldn’t have saved any of those 3. I think Baz is pony, but fuck me, he did nothing wrong tonight. Edited 21 April, 2023 by Lord Duckhunter 4 1
Dman Posted 21 April, 2023 Posted 21 April, 2023 (edited) I don’t think he was massively to blame this evening, but he’s a very very poor keeper and should not be in the side for the last 6 games. Too inexperienced, too prone to errors. Everything you don’t need in a relegation scrap. Edited 21 April, 2023 by Dman 1
Lord Duckhunter Posted 21 April, 2023 Posted 21 April, 2023 5 minutes ago, Dman said: I don’t think he was massively to blame this evening, but he’s a very very poor keeper and should not be in the side for the last 6 games. Too inexperienced, too prone to errors. Everything you don’t need in a relegation scrap. That’s fair comment, but he did nothing wrong tonight.
Saint Garrett Posted 21 April, 2023 Posted 21 April, 2023 Thought he was decent tonight until the key moment when he palms the ball straight back into the danger area. He’s not good enough yet, despite him showing a lot of positives this season. Criminal he’s had the whole season as first choice IMO,
Saint Matty 76 Posted 21 April, 2023 Posted 21 April, 2023 Ruins us. The worst signing since we came back up. 1
Whitey Grandad Posted 21 April, 2023 Posted 21 April, 2023 13 minutes ago, Lord Duckhunter said: AM wouldn’t have saved any of those 3. I think Baz is pony, but fuck me, he did nothing wrong tonight. 6 minutes ago, Lord Duckhunter said: That’s fair comment, but he did nothing wrong tonight. Well said Lord Ducky. We often have our disagreements but tonight we agree.
beatlesaint Posted 21 April, 2023 Posted 21 April, 2023 22 minutes ago, Saint Matty 76 said: Ruins us. The worst signing since we came back up. He really isn’t. 1
Archers Road Stand Posted 21 April, 2023 Posted 21 April, 2023 33 minutes ago, Dman said: I don’t think he was massively to blame this evening, but he’s a very very poor keeper and should not be in the side for the last 32 games. Too inexperienced, too prone to errors. Everything you don’t need in a relegation scrap. Fixed it for you. Fact is, he's proven at a league one level. He is nowhere near good enough for where we wanted to be or where we are heading. He's cost us numerous points this season and some clueless cunt decided he was worth £10m.
Wiggles31 Posted 21 April, 2023 Posted 21 April, 2023 27 minutes ago, Saint Matty 76 said: Ruins us. The worst signing since we came back up. I offer you Diallo.
Turkish Posted 21 April, 2023 Posted 21 April, 2023 36 minutes ago, Dman said: I don’t think he was massively to blame this evening, but he’s a very very poor keeper and should not be in the side for the last 6 games. Too inexperienced, too prone to errors. Everything you don’t need in a relegation scrap. Remember this is the club strategy league postion doesn’t matter it’s about giving young players a pathway
Saint Matty 76 Posted 21 April, 2023 Posted 21 April, 2023 1 minute ago, Wiggles31 said: I offer you Diallo. Not a good player by any means, but less detrimental purely due to how often he's on the pitch. Could name 5-10 other awful signings, but at the position he's in, Bazunu is worse than any.
Turkish Posted 21 April, 2023 Posted 21 April, 2023 3 minutes ago, Wiggles31 said: I offer you Diallo. When he joined it looked like there was a player in there, had something for sure. He hardly played for over two seasons now getting bit here and there. He’s been terrible for a while now and needs to be sold for everyone’s own good, I just don’t think he’s played enough to ever make an impact. 3
Zorba Posted 22 April, 2023 Posted 22 April, 2023 I don’t mind Baz. I think he does alright. He makes less mistakes than Forster and McCarthy before him and at least he comes off his line unlike his predecessors. Sure we’d all love another Shilts or Niemi but why would a decent keeper come to us in our current state? Our whole team has been in decline for years. Think he gets far more stick than he deserves. 2 1
S-Clarke Posted 22 April, 2023 Posted 22 April, 2023 (edited) 1 minute ago, Zorba said: I don’t mind Baz. I think he does alright. He makes less mistakes than Forster and McCarthy before him and at least he comes off his line unlike his predecessors. Sure we’d all love another Shilts or Niemi but why would a decent keeper come to us in our current state? Our whole team has been in decline for years. Think he gets far more stick than he deserves. The stats don't give him much movement for praise to be honest, statistically currently the worst keeper in any of Europe's top leagues - and not just by a small margin either, quite comfortably bad. He may have had some talent when he came here but I think we've finished him off. Edited 22 April, 2023 by S-Clarke 1
Zorba Posted 22 April, 2023 Posted 22 April, 2023 Just now, S-Clarke said: The stats don't give him much to hide from tbh, worst keeper in any of Europe's top leagues - and not just by a small margin either, quite comfortably bad. He may have had some talent when he came here but I think we've finished him off. To be fair, when your team plays most of the game in their own half, lose the ball when trying to play out and are generally inferior to their opposition, it’s not going to make your stats look good is it? I know he’s not great but I don’t think he’s solely to blame for our predicament. 1
Saint Shady Posted 22 April, 2023 Posted 22 April, 2023 3 hours ago, Archers Road Stand said: Genuinely shouldn't be anywhere near our starting lineup next year in the Championship. Woeful. The fact that he’s not lost his place to McCarthy when he became available makes me think he probably will be unfortunately.
HKsaint Posted 22 April, 2023 Posted 22 April, 2023 We will probably go down solely for keeping him as our goalie.
Lighthouse Posted 22 April, 2023 Posted 22 April, 2023 The time to be blaming the keeper is when you look generally solid and his howlers are the difference between a clean sheet and losing by a couple. When defenders like Fonte, Lovren and Toby are keeping the danger 25 yards away but low shots at the near post keep sneaking in, then I’d start looking at the keeper (no names mentioned). I don’t really see that with Baz. He could be doing better with some of the shots but TBH he faces so many from inside the area, a couple are inevitably going to get the better of him. The Leeds goal is a perfect example, many people pointing out that he could have done better but how many defenders f**ked up for their LB to be having a free shot, 8 yards out with Bednarek ducking out of its way at the last second?
Guided Missile Posted 22 April, 2023 Posted 22 April, 2023 I think everyone needs to compare this young keeper to the one at the other end of the pitch last night, who was playing for a top of the table side. Personally, I think we had the better keeper. All goals are down to a goalkeeper failing to keep the ball from crossing the line, but defending when you're without the ball is every players responsibility. I think he'll be a long term asset to the team. 2
Baird of the land Posted 22 April, 2023 Posted 22 April, 2023 Yesterday I don’t think there was any blame for the goals on him. outside of those moments I thought the same faults were there that have plagued him all season.
Galway saint Posted 22 April, 2023 Posted 22 April, 2023 10 minutes ago, Guided Missile said: I think everyone needs to compare this young keeper to the one at the other end of the pitch last night, who was playing for a top of the table side. Personally, I think we had the better keeper. All goals are down to a goalkeeper failing to keep the ball from crossing the line, but defending when you're without the ball is every players responsibility. I think he'll be a long term asset to the team. I don’t see how you can say that and god forbid he’s still our number one next season. He’s the worst keeper in Europe by some distance when it’s comes to shot stopping. It’s not even close. I agree he doesn’t make many absolute howlers but he doesn’t make great saves. He doesn’t deal with crosses well, he flaps and is often found out of position meaning he concedes soft goals. He’s a nothing keeper just a bloke in goal. Objectively in a season of self inflicted disasters then his playing the entire season as our number one is right up there. You put Forster in goal and we would have had several points more.
Norm Posted 22 April, 2023 Posted 22 April, 2023 I really don’t want to criticise young Baz but he has had a poor season. I get he needed to play to get experience but I’m shocked he has remained number one all season. Totally understand the comment about him getting little protection from poor defenders in front but he has made far too many errors imo.
eurosaint Posted 22 April, 2023 Posted 22 April, 2023 12 minutes ago, Galway saint said: I don’t see how you can say that and god forbid he’s still our number one next season. He’s the worst keeper in Europe by some distance when it’s comes to shot stopping. It’s not even close. I agree he doesn’t make many absolute howlers but he doesn’t make great saves. He doesn’t deal with crosses well, he flaps and is often found out of position meaning he concedes soft goals. He’s a nothing keeper just a bloke in goal. Objectively in a season of self inflicted disasters then his playing the entire season as our number one is right up there. You put Forster in goal and we would have had several points more. Do you watch much football these days ?? 🤨 2
Galway saint Posted 22 April, 2023 Posted 22 April, 2023 Yes quite a bit. He’s statistically the worst keeper in Europe at shot stopping. The stats were published on here some weeks ago. See below 😉
Weston Super Saint Posted 22 April, 2023 Posted 22 April, 2023 4 minutes ago, Galway saint said: Yes quite a bit. He’s statistically the worst keeper in Europe at shot stopping. The stats were published on here some weeks ago. See below 😉 Absolute horseshit! And your pointless xG bollocks chart proves nothing. It even says 'Big 5 European leagues', so claiming he's the 'worst in Europe' is disingenous at best. Unless you're telling me that Scotland is no longer in Europe and / or Scottish 'keepers are better than him? Statistics can be made to say anything you want I guess. He's faced more shots than all other teams than 6 on that chart (from what is available), suggesting that the team in front of him is absolutely dire at giving any sort of protection. And what the fuck is 'post shot xG' made up useless bollocks meant to mean?
Galway saint Posted 22 April, 2023 Posted 22 April, 2023 2 minutes ago, Weston Super Saint said: Absolute horseshit! And your pointless xG bollocks chart proves nothing. It even says 'Big 5 European leagues', so claiming he's the 'worst in Europe' is disingenous at best. Unless you're telling me that Scotland is no longer in Europe and / or Scottish 'keepers are better than him? Statistics can be made to say anything you want I guess. He's faced more shots than all other teams than 6 on that chart (from what is available), suggesting that the team in front of him is absolutely dire at giving any sort of protection. And what the fuck is 'post shot xG' made up useless bollocks meant to mean? I accept there might be a keeper somewhere in Europe worse than him at shot stopping (but for the moment at least we play in the Premier League and are comparing him to other keepers in the top European leagues not the Scottish third division or the Albanian conference). That wasn’t really my point. The stats support the general proposition that he doesn’t make enough saves relative to shots faced. He might face more shots than others but if he’s a good keeper that gives him more opportunities to make saves. The stats support what we see week on week. He’s a major reason we are going down and will be a major reason we don’t come back up if we persist next season. 2
Weston Super Saint Posted 22 April, 2023 Posted 22 April, 2023 Just now, Galway saint said: I accept there might be a keeper somewhere in Europe worse than him at shot stopping (but for the moment at least we play in the Premier League and are comparing him to other keepers in the top European leagues not the Scottish third division or the Albanian conference). That wasn’t really my point. The stats support the general proposition that he doesn’t make enough saves relative to shots faced. He might face more shots than others but if he’s a good keeper that gives him more opportunities to make saves. The stats support what we see week on week. He’s a major reason we are going down and will be a major reason we don’t come back up if we persist next season. Horseshit! Your point was he is 'the worst in Europe' - take a look at your post, that's your claim! The 'stats' aren't stats either, just made up bollocks xG created by spotty teenagers for spotty teenagers using subjective 'guesswork'. 1 1
Galway saint Posted 22 April, 2023 Posted 22 April, 2023 Oknhebrh 2 minutes ago, Weston Super Saint said: Horseshit! Your point was he is 'the worst in Europe' - take a look at your post, that's your claim! The 'stats' aren't stats either, just made up bollocks xG created by spotty teenagers for spotty teenagers using subjective 'guesswork'. Ok I stand corrected; he’s only statistically the worst keeper in the European top leagues and there might be others outside the European top leagues statistically worse.
Weston Super Saint Posted 22 April, 2023 Posted 22 April, 2023 Just now, Galway saint said: Ok I stand corrected; he’s only statistically the worst keeper in the European top leagues and there might be others outside the European top leagues statistically worse. When you write it like that, not exactly an exclusive revelation is it? Our form has reached 90th out of 92 teams in English football recently. I imagine that we have been rooted to the bottom of the form table from the top 5 leagues in Europe for pretty much the whole season. Probably doesn't take a genius to figure out the the 'keeper in the worst team in Europe is going to have the worst stats. I imagine once you post the same stats for our entire defence we will be steadfastly propping up that table as well - you are getting round to that aren't you, you know for balance and perspective?
Galway saint Posted 22 April, 2023 Posted 22 April, 2023 8 minutes ago, Weston Super Saint said: When you write it like that, not exactly an exclusive revelation is it? Our form has reached 90th out of 92 teams in English football recently. I imagine that we have been rooted to the bottom of the form table from the top 5 leagues in Europe for pretty much the whole season. Probably doesn't take a genius to figure out the the 'keeper in the worst team in Europe is going to have the worst stats. I imagine once you post the same stats for our entire defence we will be steadfastly propping up that table as well - you are getting round to that aren't you, you know for balance and perspective? I don’t think you understand the statistics. They are not saying he’s the worst because he concedes the most goals he’s the worst in terms of shots saved relative to goals conceded. Take a look at Leno at Fulham. He’s faced far more shots but he’s the top of the chart. Ultimately he’s a poor keeper in a poor team but if we are looking at how we can improve then replacing bazanu seems an obvious starting point.
JRM Posted 22 April, 2023 Posted 22 April, 2023 I thought he did well calmly time wasting amidst the pressure of the Arsenal fans getting on his back
Ed Rooney Posted 22 April, 2023 Posted 22 April, 2023 1 hour ago, Galway saint said: Yes quite a bit. He’s statistically the worst keeper in Europe at shot stopping. The stats were published on here some weeks ago. See below 😉 Statistically Nathan Jones was the best manager in Europe 1
Hodgey Posted 22 April, 2023 Posted 22 April, 2023 Don’t think he was to blame yesterday but he’s not Prem standard and I don’t think he ever will be. Think he’ll be a decent Championship gk but I don’t think he’s even that yet so should be our number 2 next year and we need to buy better (and experienced)
Ed Rooney Posted 22 April, 2023 Posted 22 April, 2023 He has been very up and down all season, which I would expect from any young footballer in his debut season in one of the best leagues in world football, we have seen it with players that have come through our system, be it Tella, Reed, Targett, Smallbone, even golden boy took many seasons to start producing anywhere near consistent levels of acceptable performances. Unfortunately it seems at the moment Bazunu can’t win, even when he makes good reaction saves such as the 3rd goal last night, many think somehow he should have not only saved a shot we’ll hit at short distance, low to the ground being slightly unsighted and coming through a defenders legs, but he should have also managed to maneover the ball away through a packed penalty box… Yeah let’s focus on that and not things like the piss poor half hearted attempt by Perraud closing down Odegaard for the second goal or the piss poor defending and ease that Perraud let saka get to the by line for the first goal 1
The Cat Posted 22 April, 2023 Posted 22 April, 2023 Why are people saying stuff like Pickford, Ramsdale or Pope would have done better on certain shots or whatever? Every time we miss a shot I presume the same people say "Harry Kane would have done better there" 1
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now