Swansea 2-3 Saints - Match Thread

[macca155]

Did the job, made hard work of it after going down to 10 but regained control of the game eventually.

I wouldn't write Valery off just yet, he was playing well up to that point. Yes silly to lay hands on but he'll learn...... somewhere else I suspect.

Two similar sendings off, they need to work on that.

Edited 8 January, 2022 by macca155

[Matthew Le God]

3 minutes ago, SaintTex said:

cant KWP play Tuesday?

The suspension for 5 yellow cards means Walker-Peters is suspended only for Premier League games, not FA Cup games. He missed today because he has Covid, not through suspension. He is suspended vs Brentford on Tuesday.

Edited 8 January, 2022 by Matthew Le God

[Golac's Cunning Stunts]

21 minutes ago, Matthew Le God said:

A hand brushing a shoulder is not a foul. There was barely any contact, let one enough to put off balance a grown man and make him fall over whilst running.

You obviously don't watch much football then is all i can say. Those are given all the time. Where have you been for the last 10 years?

[Matthew Le God]

1 minute ago, Golac's Cunning Stunts said:

You obviously don't watch much football then is all i can say. Those are given all the time. Where have you been for the last 10 years?

You didn't see what happened today then. Pulling on the shoulder or arm is a foul, today's incident was not a pull. His hand brushed his shoulder with no force. 

[eurosaint]

21 minutes ago, Matthew Le God said:

A hand brushing a shoulder is not a foul. There was barely any contact, let one enough to put off balance a grown man and make him fall over whilst running.

I agree with you here, no way was there enough to cause Obafemi to go down like that, he played for it !

If any slight contact is always to be given then why did we not get a penalty when Long was touched with two hands on his back in the box ??

[Turkish]

3 minutes ago, Golac's Cunning Stunts said:

You obviously don't watch much football then is all i can say. Those are given all the time. Where have you been for the last 10 years?

Playing on his computer 

[The Kraken]

2 minutes ago, Golac's Cunning Stunts said:

You obviously don't watch much football then is all i can say. Those are given all the time. Where have you been for the last 10 years?

Correct. It’s the softest of fouls but everyone knows if you put your hands up like that as the last man you’re just putting yourself hugely at risk. Especially when the ball had already almost gone through to the keeper. The whole move was just brain dead defending from him.

[TWar]

18 minutes ago, Dman said:

So does Ralph. Once again another really poor performance when going down to 10 men. Swansea we’re shockingly bad and we sat back and tried to cling on to a 1-0 win. 
 

Thankfully, we pulled out finger out and showed a bit of fight when we went 2-1 behind. 

Ralph didn't make two stupid tackles and get sent off you mug. Stop with your ridiculous crusade. Ralphs subbing of Diallo and Long changed the game and his decision to put jwp at RB was great one. He deserves a tonne of credit. 10 men is always hard but we dug in and won.

[Dellman]

1 hour ago, Baird of the land said:

Their second goal seemed thankfully to change the mindset of Saints.

Shane gets a lot of stick on here but he makes things happen in a way AA and Broja don't. He was the match winner tonight, give him credit

[suewhistle]

3 hours ago, Lord Duckhunter said:

There’s an annoying bird though. 

Are you gay, Lord D? Not an issue for me, obviously, but I used to crew on a yacht with a gay guy like you. Not his boat fortunately, but he had the same knee jerk reaction to any female he came across in any situation.

As for the game, some resilience from Saints. Valery really should know better even if the second foul and booking was a soft one. Stuart Armstrong still not 100% fit, Shane Long still showing he has value for the team, Romeu a bit slack with his passing occasionally  and as ever we really should finish our chances.

As somebody who was there when Hughie Fisher scored I'm happy to ride our luck  and hope for a home match next round. Who do people want?

 

 

[Lord Duckhunter]

All that matters in the cup is winning. 
 

Solid professional performance, class told in the end. 
 

As or Swansea, they’re everything that’s wrong with modern football and managers. Fucking tippy tappy mincing football. Why does nearly every manager think they’re Pep. Some of their passing out from the back was wonderful, but once they got out they passed it so slow and negative that it was all for nothing. No width, no urgency, pass pass pass. Fucking get it in the mixer. 

[trousers]

3 minutes ago, suewhistle said:

Are you gay, Lord D?

He makes me moist in the undercarriage region, if that counts?

#legend

Edited 8 January, 2022 by trousers

[S-Clarke]

Hard to read a great deal into the game, at about 20 mins it was a doddle. It was going to be an utter stroll.

Then Valery does what Valery does, and why he'll never be a decent player. Lost count of the amount of times I've seen him done in the same way and the same position, the guy doesn't learn.

It was a weird game from that point on. We lost our midfield as JWP had to slip into RB, and we also lost our balance as we had no real right wing back presence so we lost our ability to switch it. It became a very niggly game where Swansea had a lot of the ball but to be fair they didn't really do a great deal with it, it was fairly comfortable for us in the main. Arguably, even with 10 min, we should have gone 2, 3-0 up with the chances we had (Notably Stephens).

The main take away from that game is the character, one negative put against this team for so many years, but we showed it today. We didn't play well, it was very disjointed, we had so many bad things go our way (red card, equaliser, going behind) but we still fought to win it. Got to credit us for that, and credit to Long who came on and arguably changed the game. That's the impact you need for your subs when you're down to 10 men, he stretched the game.

[Saint_Tony]

missed the game. Very confused by this threat, the usual non-stop slating of everyone during the game, then praise for a great win at the end of it

[Charlie Wayman]

Good game to watch and satisfied with the performance and the result. Good to see the website hate figures doing well. Well done Elyounoussi, Long and Forster - hope that will shut up your critics for a while. Diallo was outstanding and JWP probably just about deserved his MotM. A Armstrong has some work to do to prove he was worth the £18m or whatever it was we paid for him

Tuning in to BBC Wales was a doddle and the coverage was first class.

[Lord Duckhunter]

Just now, Charlie Wayman said:

the coverage was first class.

Dear God 🤪

[The Kraken]

1 minute ago, Charlie Wayman said:

Tuning in to BBC Wales was a doddle and the coverage was first class.

🤣

[Charlie Wayman]

5 minutes ago, Lord Duckhunter said:

All that matters in the cup is winning. 
 

Solid professional performance, class told in the end. 
 

As or Swansea, they’re everything that’s wrong with modern football and managers. Fucking tippy tappy mincing football. Why does nearly every manager think they’re Pep. Some of their passing out from the back was wonderful, but once they got out they passed it so slow and negative that it was all for nothing. No width, no urgency, pass pass pass. Fucking get it in the mixer. 

What on earth are you talking about. 

[Lord Duckhunter]

Just now, Charlie Wayman said:

What on earth are you talking about. 

Coming from a bloke who thinks the coverage was “first class” 😂

[S-Clarke]

40 minutes ago, The Kraken said:

Much rather get a first choice left back in. Not impressed with Perraud again tonight.

He's a bit of a terrier type, but there's no real quality in there is there.

Some of his attempts to provide attacking width were beyond embarrassing. That is crucial in our set up, you need to be able to provide a threat. He looks hopeless in that part of the game. Defensively a little dodgy as well, but as I said he's a bit of a terrier and isn't afraid to get into oppo faces.

[Chez]

44 minutes ago, The Kraken said:

Much rather get a first choice left back in. Not impressed with Perraud again tonight.

I thought it was just me that didn't rate him.

I am very interested to know how Small is progressing. It would be great if he is genuinely pushing for a game towards the end of the season. 

Edited 8 January, 2022 by Chez

[The Cat]

Still annoyed we couldn't go to the game because it would have been incredible to see so many Saints fans on the pitch when Shane Long scored. 

[the colonel]

11 minutes ago, suewhistle said:

Are you gay, Lord D? Not an issue for me, obviously, but I used to crew on a yacht with a gay guy like you. Not his boat fortunately, but he had the same knee jerk reaction to any female he came across in any situation.

As for the game, some resilience from Saints. Valery really should know better even if the second foul and booking was a soft one. Stuart Armstrong still not 100% fit, Shane Long still showing he has value for the team, Romeu a bit slack with his passing occasionally  and as ever we really should finish our chances.

As somebody who was there when Hughie Fisher scored I'm happy to ride our luck  and hope for a home match next round. Who do people want?

 

 

No need to for the homophobia to reply to sexist crap. 

[John Boy Saint]

55 minutes ago, Give it to Ron said:

Think we need to get another loan right back if Tino has torn meniscus that’s about 6 weeks if operated on

Should have been rested when just about everyone of us on here said he needed a rest a few weeks back.

[Charlie Wayman]

6 minutes ago, Lord Duckhunter said:

Coming from a bloke who thinks the coverage was “first class” 😂

I still don't know what you are talking about. Never mind. Some people need to find fault with everything. Time to look in the mirror old cock.

[S-Clarke]

Just now, John Boy Saint said:

Should have been rested when just about everyone of us on here said he needed a rest a few weeks back.

Can't disagree, I think we ran the poor kid into the ground to be honest. 

[ant]

7 minutes ago, Charlie Wayman said:

Tuning in to BBC Wales was a doddle and the coverage was first class.

Er... No.

Just from memory, they:

* Listed Tella at CB in the starting lineup graphic

* Claimed we regularly play 3-4-3

* Pre-red card, consistently mixed up Tella and Valery

* Didn't know Ward-Prowse has had a solid number of cameos at right back

* Didn't know whether we had any substitute full backs on the bench

And my absolute favourite - when referring to Ward-Prowse's birthplace, said there can't be many from Portsmouth that have done well for Southampton.

During a bloody FA Cup match... 🤦‍♂️

[Lord Duckhunter]

2 minutes ago, ant said:

Er... No.

Just from memory, they:

* Listed Tella at CB in the starting lineup graphic

* Claimed we regularly play 3-4-3

* Pre-red card, consistently mixed up Tella and Valery

* Didn't know Ward-Prowse has had a solid number of cameos at right back

* Didn't know whether we had any substitute full backs on the bench

And my absolute favourite - when referring to Ward-Prowse's birthplace, said there can't be many from Portsmouth that have done well for Southampton.

During a bloody FA Cup match... 🤦‍♂️

Also said we’d spent nearly all of our history in the top flight, and also had a great cup record . 

[John Boy Saint]

6 minutes ago, S-Clarke said:

Can't disagree, I think we ran the poor kid into the ground to be honest. 

I just think back to Adkins and Oxlaide-Chamberpot and Nigel’s insistence of “protecting his skeletal frame” with him still being an age where growth was still operational. 

Edited 8 January, 2022 by John Boy Saint

[S-Clarke]

1 minute ago, John Boy Saint said:

I just think back to Adkins and Oxlaide-Chamberpot and Nigel’s insistence of “protecting his skeletal frame” with him still being an age where growth was still operational. 

Nigel had a background in physio which helped his judgement in that sense, you'd hope our physio's would be a bit stronger with Ralph if there was wear and tear showing up with Tino.

[HnycS]

1 hour ago, Chez said:

I am worried about Stuart Armstrong. I know he has bee injured, but unless he is at full tilt he's a nothing player. Need him back to his best. Whats gone on there?

Covid after effects can be substantial, his game is built on stamina, seems like the combined effects of Covid and injury (meaning less fitness training) have taken a toll on his stamina.

[The Kraken]

7 minutes ago, Lord Duckhunter said:

Also said we’d spent nearly all of our history in the top flight, and also had a great cup record . 

Some of the camera work was way off too.

Overall it was extremely shoddy output. Can understand why Charlie liked it, I suppose.

[AlexLaw76]

14 minutes ago, John Boy Saint said:

Should have been rested when just about everyone of us on here said he needed a rest a few weeks back.

Totally agree 

[Teddeer]

Thought Diallo looked good today. He was very composed on the ball and got through a lot of work.

[LiberalCommunist]

On to the next round. Job done. 

[S-Clarke]

Just now, Teddeer said:

Thought Diallo looked good today. He was very composed on the ball and got through a lot of work.

Yep, that was the right sub at the right time I thought. Made a huge difference, as Armstrong was struggling.

[AlexLaw76]

Ralph saying we will probably pay for that against Brentford....

Hmm, playing it down I hope

[nta786]

10 minutes ago, Lord Duckhunter said:

Also said we’d spent nearly all of our history in the top flight, and also had a great cup record . 

Also said that we were “overtaken” this week.

[HnycS]

1 hour ago, Lighthouse said:

I don’t think there’s a saints fan alive who hates him but let’s be honest, today he did a decent job against a crap (17th) Championship side.

If a champ sides comes in for him, would he take the drop for more game time? Wwould he want it, or is he at a point in his career where he would rather bench warm and get occasional minutes, same for Walcott I guess?

[suewhistle]

23 minutes ago, the colonel said:

No need to for the homophobia to reply to sexist crap. 

Ha! I'm lesbian my dear, and if you want to see  various phobias in operation you really should look at the threads Turkish starts or comments on in The Lounge. Fortunately these days I miss most of the details if I'm logged on but see enough to know he's still at it. Seeing his 'like' for you amuses me highly.

[HnycS]

1 hour ago, Vancouver Saint said:

 

Thanks for the link Convict - worked well.

Without reading threads up to this point I admit thinking WTF Ralph when he bought on Elyenoussi and Long. When we went 2-1 down I thought, how predictable...and where on earth are we going to score a goal from in this team? All credit Long for a great assist and the winning goal...

What else did we learn? Valery is not a very intelligent footballer. How stupid do you have to be to put your hands on the attacker a) when you're on a yellow and b) when he's obviously over-hit it and there's no threat? How many of us here foresaw him being sent off - and why can't Ralph see that? (In fairness, perhaps he did and realised we're out of right backs). Also Forster cannot continue to have such bad distribution or get lucky with parrying shots back to the opposition.

Anyway, happy we're into the next round.

Think your point about Valery was already pretty clear, his inability to position himself correctly when playing as a full back, and some other things have already told us as much. Yes he has some natural ability and pace, Ralph has been persistent with him, but I am guessing this might be the final straw and we will not being seeing him again, unless we find ourselves left with only 11 fit players, think most of the U23 squad will be ahead of him for future game time.

[The Kraken]

1 hour ago, Matthew Le God said:

It wasn't unprofessional... it wasn't a foul. His hand brushed Obafemi's shoulder and he fell over. It is the refs fault, not Valery.

Pulling on the shoulder or arm is a foul, today's incident was not a pull. His hand brushed his shoulder with no force and Obafemi collapsed to the floor like he'd been shot.

looks like Yan Valery thinks you’re wrong.

 

[Turkish]

5 minutes ago, suewhistle said:

Ha! I'm lesbian my dear, and if you want to see  various phobias in operation you really should look at the threads Turkish starts or comments on in The Lounge. Fortunately these days I miss most of the details if I'm logged on but see enough to know he's still at it. Seeing his 'like' for you amuses me highly.

It amuses me greatly that despite once again announcing I’m on ignore you seem to know exactly what I post and have name dropped me into a conversation that is absolutely nothing to do with me and actually was started by you being all aggressive towards another poster, yet again 

[captainchris]

1 hour ago, The Kraken said:

Much rather get a first choice left back in. Not impressed with Perraud again tonight.

Perraud is a liability how on earth did we sign this guy, that is truly worrying…

[Harry_SFC]

1 hour ago, Bob76 said:

Must admit he did not do much but do feel slightly sorry for him. Last game he gets moved to left wing with team down to ten men for a lot of the game and played very well there. This game, down to ten men he comes on at right wing, and we won.

It is hard for him to show his worth in those situations and if Long had played a decent ball he probably gets a goal.

You say that but Long and Elyounoussi came on in the forward positions and looked much more of a threat. Not sure if he's low on confidence, struggling to adapt or not actually that great. 

As we know, Che struggled in his first season but he still contributed with his hold up play and good passing. I'm just not sure what Armstrong brings to the table. 

[Roo1976]

Should have been easier ,but get in there,we march on .......................Good to see Sandcastle Arabia on top form.................good old Eddie.

[Totton Saint]

1 hour ago, Matthew Le God said:

You didn't see what happened today then. Pulling on the shoulder or arm is a foul, today's incident was not a pull. His hand brushed his shoulder with no force. 

I agree with MLG

[Totton Saint]

30 minutes ago, HnycS said:

Covid after effects can be substantial, his game is built on stamina, seems like the combined effects of Covid and injury (meaning less fitness training) have taken a toll on his stamina.

I thought Stu played well until we went down to ten men and for rest of the half

[austsaint]

46 minutes ago, S-Clarke said:

He's a bit of a terrier type, but there's no real quality in there is there.

Some of his attempts to provide attacking width were beyond embarrassing. That is crucial in our set up, you need to be able to provide a threat. He looks hopeless in that part of the game. Defensively a little dodgy as well, but as I said he's a bit of a terrier and isn't afraid to get into oppo faces.

 

47 minutes ago, Chez said:

I thought it was just me that didn't rate him.

I am very interested to know how Small is progressing. It would be great if he is genuinely pushing for a game towards the end of the season. 

I've got a feeling that when Small is fit and well he will be pushing (metaphorically) Perraud to the sidelines.

[cloggy saint]

1 minute ago, Totton Saint said:

I agree with MLG

Yep, me too, the game has completely gone to shit if the slightest contact such as today leads to a second yellow. Obafemi should be ashamed of himself going down like that.