Jump to content

Saints 1-0 Man City... No, Seriously

Lighthouse

By Lighthouse,
in The Saints

 Share

Man of the Match  

350 members have voted

  1. 1. Man of the Match v Manchester City

    • Alex McCarthy
      97
    • Kyle Walker-Peters
      41
    • Jack Stephens
      157
    • Jan Bednarek
      11
    • Ryan Bertrand
      1
    • Oriol Romeu
      0
    • James Ward-Prowse
      5
    • Stuart Armstrong
      8
    • Nathan Redmond
      0
    • Che Adams
      13
    • Danny Ings
      10
    • Shane Long
      0

This poll is closed to new votes

  • Please sign in or register to vote in this poll.
  • Poll closed on 08/07/20 at 19:00

Recommended Posts

benjii

benjii

Posted
Posted

Great performance. Shows how managers are on a hiding to nothing though. If we set up like that in the second half and conceded two, which we easily could have, this place would be full of people saying we were too negative and one goal was never enough etc... 

But anyway, fair play to the team for pulling that grit and effort off after we hit the 40 points. 

JWP, Armstrong, Ings and Redmond are really well suited to Ralph’s tactics. If we can add some competition at the back (really we need a RB, LB - unless Vokins is good enough - and CB) and a bit more quality in centre mid we’ve got a decent squad. 

It’s a shame we had such a shite start to the season as this is a “Europe opportunity” year with the Man City ban and Arse and Spurs not being great.

Link to comment
Share on other sites
John D

John D

Posted
Posted
1 hour ago, hypochondriac said:

Think you need to have attended the majority of games over the last two seasons. There's been a load of games where we looked like we had just given up and were going through the motions. Let's not let an amazing result airbrush history, fans were getting absolutely fed up for a reason. 

I disagree.  Whilst home form has been abysmal the performances away from home clearly showed that the players had the ability and the desire.  The challenge was how to translate that into home performances rather than a question mark over their attitude 

  • Like 2
Link to comment
Share on other sites
JRM

JRM

Posted
Posted

Brilliant result and an amazing game, it suited us to play like the away team, we'll have to find a new way of playing when we host Brighton and Sheffield United. 

Despite 3 wins in 4 since the restart we've not really made any progress climbing the table just going up one place above Palace, still in touching distance of the top half, would be good to aim for that. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites
hypochondriac

hypochondriac

Posted
Posted
8 minutes ago, John D said:

I disagree.  Whilst home form has been abysmal the performances away from home clearly showed that the players had the ability and the desire.  The challenge was how to translate that into home performances rather than a question mark over their attitude 

I don't agree. Load sof home performances that were awful and looked like training games. Admittedly some of them were under previous managers but it was the same group of players. Thankfully Ralph seems to have been able to get through to some of them and the system we now have is paying dividends. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites
Wurzel

Wurzel

Posted
Posted

BBC 1 on a Sunday night - usually CountryFile and Antiquers RoadShow.  Can't be many in the country who didn't find last night's viewing a tad more exciting 🤣

I was so engrossed it was only when we got past the 80 minute mark I remembered I'd placed my first football bet this year, only a £5 on us to win @ 8/1 but it made those last 10/15 minutes even more tense.

Liking that we have Everton and Man Utd next, we can play the same type of game against those 2. Then adapt our game again for Brighton, B'mouth and Sheff Utd who will all play a different sort of game against us.

Probably a game or two too far, or relying on a couple of "collapses" above us, but definitely looking at the table with one eye on Europe now

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites
lickierambert

lickierambert

Posted
Posted
1 hour ago, benjii said:

Great performance. Shows how managers are on a hiding to nothing though. If we set up like that in the second half and conceded two, which we easily could have, this place would be full of people saying we were too negative and one goal was never enough etc... 

But anyway, fair play to the team for pulling that grit and effort off after we hit the 40 points. 

JWP, Armstrong, Ings and Redmond are really well suited to Ralph’s tactics. If we can add some competition at the back (really we need a RB, LB - unless Vokins is good enough - and CB) and a bit more quality in centre mid we’ve got a decent squad. 

It’s a shame we had such a shite start to the season as this is a “Europe opportunity” year with the Man City ban and Arse and Spurs not being great.

Turns out we only needed to be mildly competent in the Autumn to be in the European shakeup. 

Might not be the worst season to miss it though. Not sure we’ll have fans allowed to travel by the time the group stages come around, which is half the fun. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites
Shroppie

Shroppie

Posted
Posted
2 minutes ago, lickierambert said:

Turns out we only needed to be mildly competent in the Autumn to be in the European shakeup. 

Might not be the worst season to miss it though. Not sure we’ll have fans allowed to travel by the time the group stages come around, which is half the fun. 

My thoughts too. This squad is beginning to come together well. They're playing for each other with commitment, doing what Ralph wants and looking better every game.

Rather than putting the squad under the pressure of coping with Europa, especially as I doubt fans will be able to travel/go to games, I'd rather see us have a solid top eight or better season and get into Europe when we're ready.

Link to comment
Share on other sites
Lighthouse

Lighthouse

Posted
  • Author
Posted
1 hour ago, benjii said:

Great performance. Shows how managers are on a hiding to nothing though. If we set up like that in the second half and conceded two, which we easily could have, this place would be full of people saying we were too negative and one goal was never enough etc... 

I don't think so, not against Man City. The problem is that this has so often been the case against much, much worse teams at St Mary's. Even a team as sh*t as Villa could have equalised in injury time, after all the missed chances and only having a 1-0 lead and we were desperately hanging on for the last 20 mins against Norwich.

Link to comment
Share on other sites
sadoldgit

sadoldgit

Posted
Posted
1 hour ago, John D said:

I disagree.  Whilst home form has been abysmal the performances away from home clearly showed that the players had the ability and the desire.  The challenge was how to translate that into home performances rather than a question mark over their attitude 

Playing on the counter suits our players/style. We struggle when teams sit back and we have to break them down and we have conceded so many ourselves on the counter. This explains our very poor home form and Ralph needs to find a way of dealing with that at home because not every team is going to come at us like City did at St.Marys.

I thought we looked good on the break in the first half and the game suited us as City looked like the home side. The second half was pretty much all one way traffic and I wouldn’t want to watch that every week, but fair play. It was an heroic effort and a very hard won 3 points.

Hopefully now that Adams has broken his duck more goals will follow. If it hasn’t taken too much out of him I would start him again against Everton.

KWP has grown in confidence and looks like there is more to come. 

There is still lots of work to be done as the Arsenal match showed but you can’t turn your nose up at 3 wins out of 4 and things are looking better for next season.

 

 

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites
DT

DT

Posted
Posted

Fantastic result and performance showing real team spirit and togetherness. This is the team I'd like to see. No Valery (not good enough/liability), Hojberg (mind elsewhere), or Obafemi (so overrated), and they gelled nicely. CBs magnificent. Please sign Walker Phillips, Ings workrate extraordinary, Che - so happy he's silencing the naysayers, Ward Prowse a huge influence, Redders the only one I thought was a bit wasteful, Armstrong so key with his energy, McCarthy some incredible stops (heart still in mouth when he has it at his feet tho!)

All in all, a superb performance that made me very proud to be a Saints fan. Well done Ralph (though maybe use a few subs as tactical game-slow-downs, mate) and all the team. Onwards and upwards...

Link to comment
Share on other sites
DT

DT

Posted
Posted

PS wonder if we had held on if the crowd had been there, transmitting their apprehension to the players? Will never know, but maybe the players preferred it without them yesterday

Link to comment
Share on other sites
SNSUN

SNSUN

Posted
Posted
2 hours ago, Wes Tender said:

Why shouldn't we get a result at the other Manchester club? Are they better than City?

Presently they are in better form, in fact they are top of the form table, and still have something to play for, and will most likely put out their best team, so yes currently. Their front 3 and Fernandes have clicked and look awesome and will be real challengers next season. We played City at the right time, a lot of their posters on Bluemoon say it was a dead rubber and they were looking forward to other competitions. No taking the shine of a wonderful defensive performance from us though against City, and we will be tough opposition for United and could get something, but they will be a different proposition than City.

 

Everton will be a tough proposition too but our good away form and current team spirit coupled with our superb fitness levels since the end of lockdown means we go there as equals and I’m more confident than usual of a result at Goodison.

Link to comment
Share on other sites
Nolan

Nolan

Posted
Posted

Form table means nothing. Two of Man U's games were Bournemouth and Brighton.

Man U's box was open against Bournemouth and any team with strikers who get into better areas would have scored 5 against them rather than Bournemouths two.

 

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites
Lighthouse

Lighthouse

Posted
  • Author
Posted
35 minutes ago, stevegrant said:

This is a league table comprised of matches since the November international break (i.e. post-Everton defeat).

.....

Fairly incredible how terrible Bournemouth have been in that period, even worse than Norwich :uhoh::lol:

Interestingly, that form extrapolated over 38 games gives us 63 points, which is exactly the same as Koeman in his second season here. We need 8 points from our last 5 games to maintain that form.

Link to comment
Share on other sites
simo

simo

Posted
Posted

Well I did call 1 nil on Thursday, unfortunately my money went on city to win by a margin. Well pleased for Che, defending has been our weak point at home and last night showed we can do it when we want to . Shame the season finishes is a few more games as I think we could go on a run .

Link to comment
Share on other sites
itchen

itchen

Posted
Posted

I think from Stephens' interview on Saturday,  and other snippets on the official website, that it is obvious that there is a real camaraderie in this squad and that can only be a good thing. Look how pleased Ings was to see Adams get his first goal. Ralph has built something special here and it can only contribute to how we play on the pitch. I just hope we don't disrupt this by selling the wrong person or bringing in someone who doesn't gel with the others.

Link to comment
Share on other sites
stevegrant

stevegrant

Posted
Posted
7 minutes ago, itchen said:

Another stat: only the top 5 have won more games than us.

Quite surprising that other sides in the bottom half of the table haven't cottoned onto the idea of actually trying to win games at the risk of losing some. Sounds weird, obviously, but the raw numbers make it seem so bloody obvious - one win and one loss still earns you more points than two draws.

Link to comment
Share on other sites
Fan The Flames

Fan The Flames

Posted
Posted
5 hours ago, benjii said:

Great performance. Shows how managers are on a hiding to nothing though. If we set up like that in the second half and conceded two, which we easily could have, this place would be full of people saying we were too negative and one goal was never enough etc... 

But anyway, fair play to the team for pulling that grit and effort off after we hit the 40 points. 

JWP, Armstrong, Ings and Redmond are really well suited to Ralph’s tactics. If we can add some competition at the back (really we need a RB, LB - unless Vokins is good enough - and CB) and a bit more quality in centre mid we’ve got a decent squad. 

It’s a shame we had such a shite start to the season as this is a “Europe opportunity” year with the Man City ban and Arse and Spurs not being great.

Would people have moaned if Man C has equalised, we were all waiting for it really. We beat them for effort, that and a little bit of luck (they were very wasteful) was enough to beat their superior quality this time. Also if Armstrong had taken that chance in the second half, which in my opinion he should have, then things would have worked out more nicely then they did.

Link to comment
Share on other sites
Supersubpuckett

Supersubpuckett

Posted
Posted

we were VERY lucky, I was waiting for City to score but it just wasn't going for them. For us it was a battling and committed performance from a real team the likes of which we haven't seen in years, however we need to seriously upgrade in certain positions as they were tearing us to pieces at times. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites
stevegrant

stevegrant

Posted
Posted
4 minutes ago, Supersubpuckett said:

we were VERY lucky, I was waiting for City to score but it just wasn't going for them. For us it was a battling and committed performance from a real team the likes of which we haven't seen in years, however we need to seriously upgrade in certain positions as they were tearing us to pieces at times. 

There's always an element of luck involved in a game like this, but we loaded a lot of the cards in our favour with the way we set ourselves up - with City's lineup, we knew we had the aerial advantage, so the idea was to pack the space the width of the penalty area and force City into wide areas to cross the ball into the box where the probability of us being able to defend it competently were far greater than if we let them thread passes through us.

Given the way we've defended in recent years, that seems counterintuitive because we've been shit at defending crosses, but City are a completely different team to anyone else we face in the PL. They don't have much height, their attacking ability is based around supreme technical ability and pace, and the ability to marry the two together in tight spaces. Pep taking Sterling and Mahrez off in the second half actually played into our hands in the end, IMO, as De Bruyne and Foden want to operate in the central areas of the pitch, and we had loads of defensive coverage there.

Their biggest chances came from wide areas in the first half (Mahrez shot saved by McCarthy, Silva header from a cross - now that would have been embarrassing, to let him outjump our defence - and Sterling's subsequent shot wide), it was only really Silva's chance early in the second half which was created as a direct result of an incredible first touch that would have beaten most defenders in the world that came as a result of them threading the eye of the needle through the middle of us.

Link to comment
Share on other sites
Teddeer

Teddeer

Posted
Posted

What made the game so intriguing was that City obviously dominated possession yet I always felt we looked dangerous on the break and capable of scoring a second. Ok, we didn't have loads of clear cut chances but there were a few times when we almost won back the ball high up or else just failed to pick out a decent pass to set up an opportunity. Redmond could have done better on a couple of occasions, we know Ings is capable of converting chances like the one KWP provided, I thought Adams could have reached the dodgy back-pass and Armstrong probably should have slotted his chance. We did ride our luck but I think we were overdue a break against City.

Link to comment
Share on other sites
BallBoy

BallBoy

Posted
Posted

I feel very smug this morning. This one ticked all the boxes to make me happy:

1) Che's first goal. And a beauty.

2) Beating the multi million pound City.

3) Safety guaranteed.

4) Live on prime time TV for all to see.

5) Great performances from every player.

6) Highly encouraging displays from KWP and Che Adams.

I will bask in this for a few more days.  

Link to comment
Share on other sites
Saint Keef

Saint Keef

Posted
Posted

A very smug and satisfied feeling today........mates who are non Saints fans have called & emailed me saying they were actually cheering Saints as they watched it, something they've never done before. One mate, a Spurs fan (I know....he can't help it) said he punched the air and cheered at the final whistle. Don't worry, I won't reciprocate if they beat Everton tonight, although a couple of Everton injuries to key players tonight and I might raise a discreet smile.

Link to comment
Share on other sites
S-Clarke

S-Clarke

Posted
Posted

Yeah, people are saying to me that they were on the edge of their seats in the last few mins - one of them doesn't even really follow football, others aren't fans of Southampton.

I think we got ourselves a big neutral fan base after yesterday! We've certainly been one of the best teams to watch since the return, IMO.

Link to comment
Share on other sites
Batman

Batman

Posted
Posted
2 minutes ago, S-Clarke said:

Yeah, people are saying to me that they were on the edge of their seats in the last few mins - one of them doesn't even really follow football, others aren't fans of Southampton.

I think we got ourselves a big neutral fan base after yesterday! We've certainly been one of the best teams to watch since the return, IMO.

People I knew were whatsapp'ing in the groups I am in, praying we held out...

come one, who else thought that KdB freekick on 95 mins was going in?

That was an incredible defensive display....

Link to comment
Share on other sites
S-Clarke

S-Clarke

Posted
Posted
11 minutes ago, Batman said:

People I knew were whatsapp'ing in the groups I am in, praying we held out...

come one, who else thought that KdB freekick on 95 mins was going in?

That was an incredible defensive display....

I wasn't as worried as I thought I'd be, it was one of those nights. I thought it was a bit too close if I'm honest, maybe 5-10 yards further out and it could have been different. 

It really was reminiscent of Leeds away in the Champ, but this was against one of the best tika-taka teams in the world.

Link to comment
Share on other sites
fez

fez

Posted
Posted
30 minutes ago, S-Clarke said:

I wasn't as worried as I thought I'd be, it was one of those nights. I thought it was a bit too close if I'm honest, maybe 5-10 yards further out and it could have been different. 

It really was reminiscent of Leeds away in the Champ, but this was against one of the best tika-taka teams in the world.

JWP would have put it in from there

Link to comment
Share on other sites
bpsaint

bpsaint

Posted
Posted

There was a thread on this forum before the swap over entitled “How ready will we be for the restart” or something to that effect. Very ready is the answer to the question! 9 points from a possible 12 is definitely a better return than I expected, and with a bit of shrewdness in the window and a short wait until the new season maybe we can finally have a season where relegation doesn’t even look remotely possible for us.

Link to comment
Share on other sites
vectraman

vectraman

Posted
Posted

We were absolutely brilliant last night. Defended like our lives depended on it, rode our luck (against City you’ll have to) and played on the break brilliantly.

Every single player put 100% effort in. Fantastic. I thought Stephens was superb, showed he can do it!

Now we need to play like the away team at home all the time!

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
 Share
Go to topic listing
×
×
  • Create New...