HarvSFC Posted 1 July, 2020 Posted 1 July, 2020 I was reminiscing over the 2015-16 season the other day and noticed Forster was named Premier League Player of the Month in February. We of course also remember the Stekelenburg horror show from the following season, but it’s crazy how much worse Forster got.
Kenilworthy Posted 1 July, 2020 Posted 1 July, 2020 On 01/07/2020 at 16:30, HarvSFC said: I was reminiscing over the 2015-16 season the other day and noticed Forster was named Premier League Player of the Month in February. We of course also remember the Stekelenburg horror show from the following season, but it’s crazy how much worse Forster got. Expand Stekelenburg played for Saints in the 2015-16 season. He played 17 league games, kept 4 clean sheets and conceded 19. Maybe not brilliant. But far from a horror show.
Badger Posted 1 July, 2020 Posted 1 July, 2020 On 01/07/2020 at 17:56, Kenilworthy said: Stekelenburg played for Saints in the 2015-16 season. He played 17 league games, kept 4 clean sheets and conceded 19. Maybe not brilliant. But far from a horror show. Expand Steklenburg also had a good season under Koeman at Everton after he left Saints. Another GK that appeared to underperform with us.
The Odd Guy Posted 2 July, 2020 Posted 2 July, 2020 Is Forster eligable to play for us this season? If he is maybe Ralph will give him a few games and put him in the shop window, see if a PL club is tempted to buy our top earner. Celtic can't afford his wages even if we gave Forster to them for free and he won't take a significant wage cut even though it would guarantee him legendary status among the Cetic supporters. At £90,000 a week Forster can just sit it out and neither Celtic or Saints gets his services. I don't think he is bothered either way.
skintsaint Posted 2 July, 2020 Posted 2 July, 2020 On 02/07/2020 at 06:45, The Odd Guy said: Is Forster eligable to play for us this season? Expand He probably wasn't registered in our squad for the season unfortunately.
trousers Posted 2 July, 2020 Posted 2 July, 2020 (edited) On 01/07/2020 at 15:33, saint1977 said: Forster is a greedy git. I still resent the additional unwarranted contract extension as it stank it the time and still does now. Expand On 01/07/2020 at 15:46, Badger said: Can't blame him for accepting it, the anger should be reserved for the stupid bald twat who offered it to him. Step forward, Les Bunsen. Expand My memory is possibly playing tricks on me but wasn't there two factors in play around the time his contract was extended? Firstly, hadn't he been in good form leading up to the extension? Secondly, I seem to recall around that period that fans were often agitated at how long we typically waited to tie players down to a contract extension. I'm not saying the scale of the extension (both in terms of value and duration) wasn't taking things too far towards the opposite end of the scale, but I don't think the backdrop and context to the extension was as "what the f***?" as people are making out retrospectively? As I say, I could be mis-remembering events but there again.... (I guess digging out the forum thread at the time will be informative) Edited 2 July, 2020 by trousers
trousers Posted 2 July, 2020 Posted 2 July, 2020 (edited) I take it back... my memory was indeed rubbish....! It was a "WTF?" moment.... Edited 2 July, 2020 by trousers
Lord Duckhunter Posted 2 July, 2020 Posted 2 July, 2020 On 02/07/2020 at 07:11, skintsaint said: He probably wasn't registered in our squad for the season unfortunately. Expand Unfortunately?
skintsaint Posted 2 July, 2020 Posted 2 July, 2020 On 02/07/2020 at 10:10, Lord Duckhunter said: Unfortunately? Expand 😇
Markyruk Posted 3 July, 2020 Posted 3 July, 2020 Rumour going round that the Club are circulating that Gunn is available for transfer and that our 2 first choice keepers will be McCarthy and Forster.
woodsaint1 Posted 3 July, 2020 Posted 3 July, 2020 On 03/07/2020 at 17:35, Markyruk said: Rumour going round that the Club are circulating that Gunn is available for transfer and that our 2 first choice keepers will be McCarthy and Forster. Expand Hope not. I just cant see Forster reestablishing himself here. Yes hes done well at Celtic, but hes rarely troubled in that league and he seems buoyed there because hes a fan favourite. His confidence was shot at us and he just isnt that good a keeper for PL level. Gunn is young and can still prove himself. Bit harsh that some have pinned the 9-0 on him, he couldnt have done anything for most of the goals and had a shambolic defence in front of him
MarkSFC Posted 3 July, 2020 Posted 3 July, 2020 I'd be tempted to get rid of FF and AMc, get a new clear no.1 and a younger keeper, up and coming from the Championship perhaps, and send Gunn out on loan. Completely freshen up that department of the team. There will hopefully, likely be at least 1 if not 2 new CBs plus RB and even CM, so they'll need to gel as a unit anyway!!
Simon3737 Posted 4 July, 2020 Posted 4 July, 2020 On 03/07/2020 at 17:35, Markyruk said: Rumour going round that the Club are circulating that Gunn is available for transfer and that our 2 first choice keepers will be McCarthy and Forster. Expand I’m sure that’s just tactics to inflate Forster’s sale price. Ralph clearly favours younger players. I can’t see him being happy having our 1st and 2nd choice goalkeepers over 30.
Charlie Wayman Posted 4 July, 2020 Posted 4 July, 2020 On 01/07/2020 at 15:33, saint1977 said: Forster is a greedy git. I still resent the additional unwarranted contract extension as it stank it the time and still does now. Expand Silly remark.
SuperSAINT Posted 6 July, 2020 Posted 6 July, 2020 (edited) Deal was agreed between clubs. https://www.dailyrecord.co.uk/sport/football/football-transfer-news/fraser-forster-celtic-transfer-latest-22308335 Edited 6 July, 2020 by SuperSAINT
the saint in winchester Posted 6 July, 2020 Posted 6 July, 2020 Insert Loan Loan deal was agreed between the clubs. Forster is the one hanging out for a perm deal, according to that. Then he'll need to revise his wage expectation. Or Celtic will have to shop elsewhere, within their budget.
SuperSAINT Posted 6 July, 2020 Posted 6 July, 2020 On 06/07/2020 at 11:02, the saint in winchester said: Insert Loan Loan deal was agreed between the clubs. Forster is the one hanging out for a perm deal, according to that. Then he'll need to revise his wage expectation. Or Celtic will have to shop elsewhere, within their budget. Expand He won’t get a better chance of a permanent move after that last loan spell. Whether anyone wants to stump up the cash is another question.
Dusic Posted 8 July, 2020 Posted 8 July, 2020 I don't really see how Forster moves to Celtic any way other than on loan. No way they will get near his wages and no way he will walk away from his contract at Saints, and why should he - Reed was stupid enough to offer it. So its seems odd that the breakdown in talks was supposedly Forster not agreeing to the move because he wants it to be a permanent one. Maybe he feels like he wants another crack at the PL...and all the talk after RH came in was that in training he was the best keeper.
Baird of the land Posted 8 July, 2020 Posted 8 July, 2020 On 03/07/2020 at 17:35, Markyruk said: Rumour going round that the Club are circulating that Gunn is available for transfer and that our 2 first choice keepers will be McCarthy and Forster. Expand Maybe we can get a newly promoted team like Leeds to buy Gunn.
SuperSAINT Posted 17 July, 2020 Posted 17 July, 2020 https://www.dailyrecord.co.uk/sport/football/football-transfer-news/neil-lennon-admits-fraser-foster-22373962
Saint_clark Posted 17 July, 2020 Posted 17 July, 2020 “It’s kind of bizarre the way it’s panned out. The impression we got at the end was that he wanted to stay at Southampton and fight for his place, which, again, is the player’s prerogative" He can obviously sense a chance for himself to make amends with McCarthy and Gunn being less than impressive. If Forster came out for crosses he would instantly be twice the keeper we know him to be, with his height and build he should be dominating the box to the extent we almost never concede a headed goal.
skintsaint Posted 18 July, 2020 Posted 18 July, 2020 FF will end up on the bench of a CL club I reckon.
The Curse of St Mary's Posted 20 July, 2020 Posted 20 July, 2020 Interesting piece in The Athletic comparing McCarthy , Gunn and Forster. Subscribers can access - https://theathletic.com/1926950/2020/07/20/mccarthy-gunn-and-a-6ft-7in-elephant-in-the-room-southampton-keepers-analysed?source=user-shared-article Basically saying McCarthy good with hands and commanding on crosses but less effective with the ball. Gunn good with ball but shot save percentage one of the poorest in league. Forster had technique issue before being dropped. Taking off from wrong leg and too tall when one on one leaving big gaps inside legs and outside.
S-Clarke Posted 20 July, 2020 Posted 20 July, 2020 On 20/07/2020 at 12:31, LeG said: McCarthy kicked the ball into touch about 5000 times on sunday. It was ridiculous. No idea about Gunn really. Club expected him to be no.1 but seems pretty average. Fraser Forster...no. We need a new signing to be a clear no.1 with McCarthy as back up. Expand Do you know if the club are actively looking at goal keeping options? There has been talk that Fraser is coming back and is going to fight for his place here.
the saint in winchester Posted 23 July, 2020 Posted 23 July, 2020 From who, LeG, from who? Celtic can't pay? Leeds won't pay?
SuperSAINT Posted 23 July, 2020 Posted 23 July, 2020 On 23/07/2020 at 10:50, the saint in winchester said: From who, LeG, from who? Celtic can't pay? Leeds won't pay? Expand Assuming they want him, Leeds could probably afford him now.
a1ex2001 Posted 27 July, 2020 Posted 27 July, 2020 We should just loan/sell him to Celtic and subsidise his wages best for both the player and the club get as much of the cost off our books as possible and chalk it up to experience. It's a shame as initially for us he looked really good, was playing for England and probably earned his contract extension even if his form had started to tail off at that point.
Saint Garrett Posted 27 July, 2020 Posted 27 July, 2020 On 27/07/2020 at 08:56, a1ex2001 said: We should just loan/sell him to Celtic and subsidise his wages best for both the player and the club get as much of the cost off our books as possible and chalk it up to experience. It's a shame as initially for us he looked really good, was playing for England and probably earned his contract extension even if his form had started to tail off at that point. Expand He's stock is at the highest it's been for years, we should absolutely be trying to sell him now when we don't need him. If we could get his wages off the books and bring in £5-10M, we absolutely should.
Matthew Le God Posted 27 July, 2020 Posted 27 July, 2020 On 27/07/2020 at 08:56, a1ex2001 said: We should just loan/sell him to Celtic and subsidise his wages best for both the player and the club get as much of the cost off our books as possible and chalk it up to experience. It's a shame as initially for us he looked really good, was playing for England and probably earned his contract extension even if his form had started to tail off at that point. Expand Well he has seemingly regained his confidence and form, so isn''t it worth seeing if we can use him again? He isn't great with his feet, but we don't really play out from the back anymore in the same way.
Saint Garrett Posted 27 July, 2020 Posted 27 July, 2020 On 27/07/2020 at 09:11, Matthew Le God said: Well he has seemingly regained his confidence and form, so isn''t it worth seeing if we can use him again? He isn't great with his feet, but we don't really play out from the back anymore in the same way. Expand Hmm - we do. You're wrong.
Matthew Le God Posted 27 July, 2020 Posted 27 July, 2020 On 27/07/2020 at 09:20, Saint Garrett said: Hmm - we do. You're wrong. Expand You overlooked this part... "In the same way" Saints are now more willing to go longer and then counterpress with the opposition disorganised high up the pitch.
Saint Garrett Posted 27 July, 2020 Posted 27 July, 2020 On 27/07/2020 at 09:22, Matthew Le God said: You overlooked this part... "In the same way" Saints are now more willing to go longer and then counterpress with the opposition disorganised high up the pitch. Expand You're making the point that the keeper doesn't have to be good with his feet, IMO he absolutely does. Look at yesterday, pretty much all their chances came from us giving the ball to them from the keeper.
SuperSAINT Posted 29 July, 2020 Posted 29 July, 2020 We can soon draw a line in the Forster to Celtic move. https://www.thescottishsun.co.uk/sport/football/5863999/celtic-transfer-news-barkas-arrives-scotland-aek/ Set to sign Greek goalie for £4.5m instead.
Charlie Wayman Posted 29 July, 2020 Posted 29 July, 2020 Imagine if he was rehabilitated here displaced McCarthy and we ended up giving him another contract at even more money. 😬
VectisSaint Posted 29 July, 2020 Posted 29 July, 2020 On 27/07/2020 at 09:27, Saint Garrett said: You're making the point that the keeper doesn't have to be good with his feet, IMO he absolutely does. Look at yesterday, pretty much all their chances came from us giving the ball to them from the keeper. Expand Forster wasn't able to kick it long either, his kicks seemed always to go into touch, maybe a result of his early rugby playing. He is (or was) terrible with his feet, whether it is short or long. Not that Macca is that good either.
Saint Garrett Posted 29 July, 2020 Posted 29 July, 2020 On 29/07/2020 at 09:35, VectisSaint said: Forster wasn't able to kick it long either, his kicks seemed always to go into touch, maybe a result of his early rugby playing. He is (or was) terrible with his feet, whether it is short or long. Not that Macca is that good either. Expand Oh absolutely, all of our keepers are pretty terrible on the ground.
Saint Mikey Posted 29 July, 2020 Posted 29 July, 2020 On 29/07/2020 at 10:24, Saint Garrett said: Oh absolutely, all of our keepers are pretty terrible on the ground. Expand Best keeper we've had in recent times for distribution was Gazzaniga, who was also a decent shot-stopper. Really lacked the presence in the area though and very prone to mistakes/lapses in confidence.
igsey Posted 30 July, 2020 Posted 30 July, 2020 Joe Hart being linked with Celtic, if that happens then we're definitely stuck with Forster.
Matthew Le God Posted 30 July, 2020 Posted 30 July, 2020 (edited) On 30/07/2020 at 08:46, igsey said: Joe Hart being linked with Celtic, if that happens then we're definitely stuck with Forster. Expand Celtic are spending £4.5m on goalkeeper Vasilis Barkas from AEK Athens. He flew into Scotland yesterday. Neil Lennon has already said that Forster's intention is to win his place back at Saints, so it isn't a surprise Celtic are signing the Greek international keeper. “We’re disappointed with the Fraser issue. It’s kind of bizarre the way it’s panned out. The impression we got was that he wanted to stay at Southampton and fight for his place, which is the player’s prerogative. But we had been led to believe something else.” - Neil Lennon Edited 30 July, 2020 by Matthew Le God
SKD Posted 30 July, 2020 Posted 30 July, 2020 On 30/07/2020 at 08:55, Matthew Le God said: Celtic are spending £4.5m on goalkeeper Vasilis Barkas from AEK Athens. He flew into Scotland yesterday. Neil Lennon has already said that Forster's intention is to win his place back at Saints, so it isn't a surprise Celtic are signing the Greek international keeper. “We’re disappointed with the Fraser issue. It’s kind of bizarre the way it’s panned out. The impression we got was that he wanted to stay at Southampton and fight for his place, which is the player’s prerogative. But we had been led to believe something else.” - Neil Lennon Expand More likely that he just didn’t fancy a pay cut.
Whitey Grandad Posted 30 July, 2020 Posted 30 July, 2020 On 30/07/2020 at 08:55, Matthew Le God said: Celtic are spending £4.5m on goalkeeper Vasilis Barkas from AEK Athens. He flew into Scotland yesterday. Neil Lennon has already said that Forster's intention is to win his place back at Saints, so it isn't a surprise Celtic are signing the Greek international keeper. “We’re disappointed with the Fraser issue. It’s kind of bizarre the way it’s panned out. The impression we got was that he wanted to stay at Southampton and fight for his place, which is the player’s prerogative. But we had been led to believe something else.” - Neil Lennon Expand Something not quite right here. ”The impression we got” followed by “we had been led to believe something else”
S-Clarke Posted 30 July, 2020 Posted 30 July, 2020 On 30/07/2020 at 09:39, Whitey Grandad said: Something not quite right here. ”The impression we got” followed by “we had been led to believe something else” Expand Chelsea were sniffing as well at the time, not sure if they still are. Their priority at the mo seems to be a new number 1 and Forster is certainly not going to be that!
Matthew Le God Posted 30 July, 2020 Posted 30 July, 2020 We knew it already, but Celtic is a no go with them spending £4.5m on a new keeper...
Fabrice29 Posted 30 July, 2020 Posted 30 July, 2020 On 30/07/2020 at 13:01, Matthew Le God said: We knew it already, but Celtic is a no go with them spending £4.5m on a new keeper... Expand As per your post earlier in this thread and before that someone else pointing it out also. Poor posting.
Matthew Le God Posted 30 July, 2020 Posted 30 July, 2020 On 30/07/2020 at 19:05, Fabrice29 said: As per your post earlier in this thread and before that someone else pointing it out also. Poor posting. Expand It wasn't confirmed until today
Fabrice29 Posted 30 July, 2020 Posted 30 July, 2020 On 30/07/2020 at 19:44, Matthew Le God said: It wasn't confirmed until today Expand But as you said, we all knew it. Poor.
austsaint Posted 31 July, 2020 Posted 31 July, 2020 I can't believe the Club is going to be lumbered with Forster - that stinking contract extension FF has at SFC seems to be the attraction for him to "fight for his place". So many crap performances from him, and the prospect of him returning is truly abject.
Matthew Le God Posted 31 July, 2020 Posted 31 July, 2020 (edited) On 31/07/2020 at 09:26, austsaint said: I can't believe the Club is going to be lumbered with Forster - that stinking contract extension FF has at SFC seems to be the attraction for him to "fight for his place". So many crap performances from him, and the prospect of him returning is truly abject. Expand Does his return to form and confidence after a very positive loan spell not make it any better? Edited 31 July, 2020 by Matthew Le God
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now