Jump to content

Saints vs. Newcastle Thread

Dark Munster

By Dark Munster
in The Saints

 Share

Recommended Posts

washsaint

washsaint

Posted
Posted

couldnt give a monkeys about tomorrows game. Puel was treated terribly and we now have a totally clueless manager in charge who has made us much, much worse than last season. Last season we had Puel coaching the younger home grown players and seeing them improve was a high spot.

 

Pellegrino has done nothing to convince me he can coach these players to become better - he certainly is not giving them a chance. Yet that piece of s**t Redmond and Tadic are no doubt nailed on to start tomorrow.

 

Enjoy the crabfest tomorrow.

Lighthouse

Lighthouse

Posted
Posted
couldnt give a monkeys about tomorrows game. Puel was treated terribly and we now have a totally clueless manager in charge who has made us much, much worse than last season. Last season we had Puel coaching the younger home grown players and seeing them improve was a high spot.

 

That's a pretty rose tinted view on things. Puel wasn't treated terribly, he was sacked (with a meaty payoff no doubt) because the results and quality of football were generally poor. He took us from 3 points off 4th the previous year to 6 points above 17th. We went out of Europe and the FA Cup pathetically on top.

 

Sims and McQueen had some good moments last season but I don't think Puel should take any more credit than Redknapp deserves for Walcott.

Charlie Wayman

Charlie Wayman

Posted
Posted

 

It needed saying. One doubts that the club pay much heed to what fan forums say but when a national broadsheet takes a swipe somebody will take notice. In his interviews Pellegrino looked distinctly uncomfortable and hesitant, a sign perhaps that his recent meetings with the board have not been quite as friendly as they used to be a few weeks ago?

Suhari

Suhari

Posted
Posted
It needed saying. One doubts that the club pay much heed to what fan forums say but when a national broadsheet takes a swipe somebody will take notice. In his interviews Pellegrino looked distinctly uncomfortable and hesitant, a sign perhaps that his recent meetings with the board have not been quite as friendly as they used to be a few weeks ago?

 

Just read that.

 

Solid assessment. We are going backwards, yet there are some very poor teams this year.

 

We'll be alright. Not sure that's really The Southampton Way though.

Dangermouth

Dangermouth

Posted
Posted

Normally us against the Mags at SMS is a home banker. I'm a bit worried about this one though. I reckon it might be a Shelvey belter from yards out that does it too. Let's hope it's an attack-minded team that's put out.

Saint_Tony

Saint_Tony

Posted
Posted

Massive game. Today needs to be the day we start scoring again; if MP hasn't worked out Tadic and Redmond don't deserve to start then we have big problems. It's easy for is as fans to say he needs to change things up top as a solution but he really does.

 

Forster

Bertrand

VvD

Yoshi

Cedric

Rom

Lemina

Davis

Boufal

Austin

Gabbiadini

 

For me, that line up is our best chance for scoring/winning

 

 

 

Sent from my SM-G920F using Tapatalk

Saint Billy

Saint Billy

Posted
Posted

Hopefully the manager watched the Palace game against Chelsea, attacking football can win games!!.

 

If we have another display of tippy tappy keep ball without hardly crossing the halfway line I fekin give up, and Reed and co need to be shot at dawn for their recent manager appointments and general poor decision making.

 

For me today's game is pivotal.

benjii

benjii

Posted
Posted
Hopefully the manager watched the Palace game against Chelsea, attacking football can win games!!.

 

If we have another display of tippy tappy keep ball without hardly crossing the halfway line I fekin give up, and Reed and co need to be shot at dawn for their recent manager appointments and general poor decision making.

 

For me today's game is pivotal.

 

I can't remember a single game where we hardly crossed the half way line.

 

The problem is penetrating the opposition's box (ooh, er!) not a failure to attack in general.

doddisalegend

doddisalegend

Posted
Posted
Hopefully the manager watched the Palace game against Chelsea, attacking football can win games!!.

 

If we have another display of tippy tappy keep ball without hardly crossing the halfway line I fekin give up, and Reed and co need to be shot at dawn for their recent manager appointments and general poor decision making.

 

For me today's game is pivotal.

 

Despite us being crap that's not actually true we've had the 6th most shots in the league this season (and last season was the same) yet we have the worse shot conversion rate in the league (and not surprisingly we did last season to) the issue last season and this season is the lack of clinical finishing rather than this myth that we don't create anything.

5string

5string

Posted
Posted
Despite us being crap that's not actually true we've had the 6th most shots in the league this season (and last season was the same) yet we have the worse shot conversion rate in the league (and not surprisingly we did last season to) the issue last season and this season is the lack of clinical finishing rather than this myth that we don't create anything.

 

Stats which are borne out in the match day experience. How many 'shots' do we witness being lashed at uncontrollably and head for the underside of the main stand roof?

 

Surely a slight reduction in power to allow accuracy and control would provide a higher conversion rate?

HKsaint

HKsaint

Posted
Posted
Forster

Cedric VVD Hoedt Bertrand

Romeu Lemina

Long Boufal Tadic

Gabbiadini

 

Get at them,

 

Putting our only goal scorer on the bench is insane.

doddisalegend

doddisalegend

Posted
Posted
Stats which are borne out in the match day experience. How many 'shots' do we witness being lashed at uncontrollably and head for the underside of the main stand roof?

 

 

 

Surely a slight reduction in power to allow accuracy and control would provide a higher conversion rate?

 

 

Davis is the worst culprit I'm a fan of his but my god his shooting is terrible.

5string

5string

Posted
Posted
Davis is the worst culprit I'm a fan of his but my god his shooting is terrible.

 

Interestingly, in the recent 200th appearance tribute video showing all his goals for us, every single one was low into the goal, and placed instead of blasted. Hmm...

 

I'm the same with Hoj - a fan of his attacking play and imagination (when he plays), but his shooting is/has always been awful.

John Boy Saint

John Boy Saint

Posted
Posted
Interestingly, in the recent 200th appearance tribute video showing all his goals for us, every single one was low into the goal, and placed instead of blasted. Hmm...

 

I'm the same with Hoj - a fan of his attacking play and imagination (when he plays), but his shooting is/has always been awful.

I think he is in the same boat as Boufal, trying a bit too hard in an effort to book a run in the team.

Saint Billy

Saint Billy

Posted
Posted
I can't remember a single game where we hardly crossed the half way line.

 

The problem is penetrating the opposition's box (ooh, er!) not a failure to attack in general.

 

Point taken about half way line, but as far as attacking is concerned I am not convinced, it all seems a bit half hearted with no real cut and thrust.

 

Again, for me, team selection and formation is all at sea and as I have said before, it's not unexpected as this managers previous indicates this is how he sets his team up. Ironically Reed brings him in to replace Puels dull football :mcinnes:

SFKA South Woodford

SFKA South Woodford

Posted
Posted
No away wins in the prem so far......until we play. If he doesn’t start Austin I give up.

 

Might as well give the shirt to one of the trees in St Mary's churchyard, it would be more mobile than Austin! He's the human equivalent of a super tanker

stknowle

stknowle

Posted
Posted
Davis is the worst culprit I'm a fan of his but my god his shooting is terrible.

 

Agreed but Tadic isn't far behind and neither is Redmond so far this season. 3 players demonstrably crap at shooting supporting Long who is, for a striker, demonstrably crap at scoring. If this is what we get today then it beggars belief.

Wade Garrett

Wade Garrett

Posted
Posted

a

Might as well give the shirt to one of the trees in St Mary's churchyard, it would be more mobile than Austin! He's the human equivalent of a super tanker

 

Doesn't have to be mobile to stick the ball in the onion bag mush.

Viking Saint

Viking Saint

Posted
Posted
Massive game. Today needs to be the day we start scoring again; if MP hasn't worked out Tadic and Redmond don't deserve to start then we have big problems. It's easy for is as fans to say he needs to change things up top as a solution but he really does.

 

Forster

Bertrand

VvD

Yoshi

Cedric

Rom

Lemina

Davis

Boufal

Austin

Gabbiadini

 

For me, that line up is our best chance for scoring/winning

 

 

 

Yep, same for me, with Hoj and Long on the bench. Would like to see McQueen back in the mix too

striker

striker

Posted
Posted (edited)
a

 

Might as well give the shirt to one of the trees in St Mary's churchyard, it would be more mobile than Austin! He's the human equivalent of a super tanker.

 

He's mobile enough to lead the team in scoring last season, and put in 18 a few years ago. Besides, where has all this great "pace" gotten us? We sure are flashy passing the ball quickly around midfield.

Edited by striker
mrfahaji

mrfahaji

Posted
Posted

I’m going to whinge if Long is CF and Redmond is playing. Can just about handle one or the other, especially if Long plays on the wing instead of Redmond, but putting out the same team will be a bit frustrating.

 

Waiting for the team in the car, then going to walk down. No matter what the team, come on Saints, we really need a result today.

ALWAYS_SFC

ALWAYS_SFC

Posted
Posted
So what’s your point, little fella, other than wanting attention and to spam this thread with complete shîte?

 

Quiet day for you is it? No one posting for you to be a clever d ick in reply.....

:p

Saint_clark

Saint_clark

Posted
Posted

Well at least he is trying something different, it's a step in the right direction. I hope this selection isn't just because Davis needs a rest from internationals and we'll go back to the usual line up even if we get a big win today...

mrfahaji

mrfahaji

Posted
Posted

Shall we just accept that Redmond is guaranteed to play no matter how he has played in previous games?

 

Bit of a strange one, putting a lot of faith in Romeu and Lemina to win the midfield battle.

Saint_clark

Saint_clark

Posted
Posted
Who’ll play up top out of Gabbi and Long?

 

Long will be the focal point, winning headers and running the channels, with Gabbi making runs from deep into the space Long creates looking for the lay off or the pass from Tadic/Redmond.

Saint_clark

Saint_clark

Posted
Posted
Shall we just accept that Redmond is guaranteed to play no matter how he has played in previous games?

 

Bit of a strange one, putting a lot of faith in Romeu and Lemina to win the midfield battle.

 

As we should, the two of them are more than capable of keeping control of midfield.

CB Fry

CB Fry

Posted
Posted

Well, it might work.

 

Newcastle home is usually a banker for us, no matter how dreadful our form is, so let's look forward to a straightforward procession to three points.

shurlock

shurlock

Posted
Posted
If the official formation graphic is genuine, that's an absolutely bizarre lineup.

 

Well he did try something similar in preseason with Austin in the position that Gabbi is occupying in this graphic. Gabbi is obviously a more natural finisher than Long, so in principle, he’d play up top unless he’s pushed much closer to Long.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
 Share
Go to topic listing
×
×
  • Create New...