SuperSAINT Posted 21 May, 2017 Posted 21 May, 2017 Been mulling this over for a while... When on form, one of our best players. Poor for large parts of the season. He supposedly wanted out last summer before signing a new contract... Has undoubtedly missed Pelle & Sadio. What would you do if we got a big offer for him?
S-Clarke Posted 21 May, 2017 Posted 21 May, 2017 Feels like he's being suffocated in this team, I wouldn't get rid of him. Better man management and a better central midfield and he'd be a lot more effective.
eurosaint Posted 21 May, 2017 Posted 21 May, 2017 Stay ! Has many limitations but still our most creative player !
Lighthouse Posted 21 May, 2017 Posted 21 May, 2017 Big offer - Sell, although I can't say he's done anywhere near enough to warrant that kind of interest Otherwise - Keep. He's a useful option to have. Inconsistent but on his day devastating. One of those who could be doing a lot better were it not for our dreadful style of play. If we can get him in and around Gabbi next season, with the right tactics, they will do well together.
Sidney Fudpucker the 3rd Posted 21 May, 2017 Posted 21 May, 2017 With a change of man management, I think he's still got something to offer.
adrian lord Posted 21 May, 2017 Posted 21 May, 2017 He will have a new lease of life without the dead hand of Puel managing him and the rest of the team. Keep. Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
James Posted 21 May, 2017 Posted 21 May, 2017 Definitely stay. We would have no chance of attracting a player of superior or even equivalent quality at the moment.
Saint Albert Posted 21 May, 2017 Posted 21 May, 2017 He's class when he can be arsed to play 100%. He seems to start the season strong and then fade into winter. I didn't like his grousing in the media this season about being subbed, nor did I like that his public complaining seemed to get him a result- he played the full 90 minutes for several games afterwards. I think that he's too good to let go unless we have someone with top-end skills waiting in the wings.
bazza Posted 21 May, 2017 Posted 21 May, 2017 Get rid. He's too inconsistent and not as good as he thinks he is. He does my nut in quite frankly.
James Posted 21 May, 2017 Posted 21 May, 2017 Get rid. He's too inconsistent and not as good as he thinks he is. He does my nut in quite frankly. Who would you replace him with?
Dusic Posted 21 May, 2017 Posted 21 May, 2017 Easy to say get rid but he is a semi reliable creator of chances, certainly our best. Would only sell if we had someone coming in who perhaps offered creativity in a different sort of style, but there are players we woulf benefit from selling far more: Clasie and Long to name two.
SuperSAINT Posted 21 May, 2017 Author Posted 21 May, 2017 Cheers of the answers so far. It's no coincidence that our main chance creator & assist-getter would have a bad season when we can't hit a barn door!
wild-saint Posted 21 May, 2017 Posted 21 May, 2017 Go, slows down the play and moans everytime he ****s up. typical west Ham playery
bazza Posted 21 May, 2017 Posted 21 May, 2017 Who would you replace him with? I'm sure with our scouting network and magical black box Les can identify an upgrade on Tadic. He's not exactly prolific in front of goal for a 'playmaker' and how many games this season has he actually dictated the play? The first team needs improving and that includes his position.
Harry_SFC Posted 21 May, 2017 Posted 21 May, 2017 If other teams are in for him and we get a decent offer I would sell him this summer
SuperSAINT Posted 21 May, 2017 Author Posted 21 May, 2017 I'm sure with our scouting network and magical black box Les can identify an upgrade on Tadic. He's not exactly prolific in front of goal for a 'playmaker' and how many games this season has he actually dictated the play? The first team needs improving and that includes his position. I wonder whether at 28, if a big bid of around £20-25m came in for him, we might accept.
James Posted 21 May, 2017 Posted 21 May, 2017 I'm sure with our scouting network and magical black box Les can identify an upgrade on Tadic. He's not exactly prolific in front of goal for a 'playmaker' and how many games this season has he actually dictated the play? The first team needs improving and that includes his position. If you look at his stats since he came to the Prem he's in the top 5/6 assist makers in the league I think. I'm not sure I'd be quite so confident of the black box replacing a player who on his day is genuine top quality.
busylizzy Posted 21 May, 2017 Posted 21 May, 2017 Cheers of the answers so far. It's no coincidence that our main chance creator & assist-getter would have a bad season when we can't hit a barn door! I understand he is 3rd in the list of chances created in the Premier League. That is pretty special for a club like ours. Perhaps we all need to look for another explanation as to why he is so ineffective this season? Whilst I accept that the chances he has created may not have been taken, his overall play has been stunted by our negative approach (particularly at home where we haven't scored since it seems Derek Reeves retired - or does it just seem like that?)
SuperSAINT Posted 21 May, 2017 Author Posted 21 May, 2017 If you look at his stats since he came to the Prem he's in the top 5/6 assist makers in the league I think. I'm not sure I'd be quite so confident of the black box replacing a player who on his day is genuine top quality. There's an argument to be made that Paul Mitchell was a bigger miss than we thought.
Convict Colony Posted 21 May, 2017 Posted 21 May, 2017 Been mulling this over for a while... When on form, one of our best players. Poor for large parts of the season. He supposedly wanted out last summer before signing a new contract... Has undoubtedly missed Pelle & Sadio. What would you do if we got a big offer for him? Sell Put Boufal on right and get Ziyech in at no.10
LGTL Posted 21 May, 2017 Posted 21 May, 2017 I wonder whether at 28, if a big bid of around £20-25m came in for him, we might accept. £25m?! Jesus he'd go if an offer for half that came in I expect.
petts Posted 21 May, 2017 Posted 21 May, 2017 Lovely player, crates so much when in the mood, but hes not going to be happy sitting on the bench (and shouldn't be sat on our bench) , and that's where he needs to be if we're to get the best out of Boufal. Sent from my HTC 10 using Tapatalk
Bewildered Posted 21 May, 2017 Posted 21 May, 2017 His poor finishing and inconsistency will always mean we won't get a huge offer for him. A club in our position is his level.
Manuel Posted 21 May, 2017 Posted 21 May, 2017 Been mulling this over for a while... When on form, one of our best players. Poor for large parts of the season. He supposedly wanted out last summer before signing a new contract... Has undoubtedly missed Pelle & Sadio. What would you do if we got a big offer for him? Many of our players seem below average at the moment so I'm putting a lot of it down to style of play.
VectisSaint Posted 21 May, 2017 Posted 21 May, 2017 Go. Has become a total waste of space. He can take Sofia Annette with him as well.
shurlock Posted 21 May, 2017 Posted 21 May, 2017 Not Tadic's biggest fan -can be a flat track bully. Still he's proven himself in the PL and that's preferable to Les and wee Ross trying to be cute and clever in the transfer market.
bazza Posted 21 May, 2017 Posted 21 May, 2017 I understand he is 3rd in the list of chances created in the Premier League. That is pretty special for a club like ours. Perhaps we all need to look for another explanation as to why he is so ineffective this season? Whilst I accept that the chances he has created may not have been taken, his overall play has been stunted by our negative approach (particularly at home where we haven't scored since it seems Derek Reeves retired - or does it just seem like that?) I've never been a great fan of Tadic but you've got a point regarding tactics. He hasn't been helped in that respect this season. (I'd still sell him though.)
Pamplemousse Posted 21 May, 2017 Posted 21 May, 2017 First out this summer hopefully. I'd rather Tadic went than Puel.
James Posted 21 May, 2017 Posted 21 May, 2017 First out this summer hopefully. I'd rather Tadic went than Puel. Are you serious?!
S-Clarke Posted 21 May, 2017 Posted 21 May, 2017 First out this summer hopefully. I'd rather Tadic went than Puel. Don't be silly.
Cartman Posted 21 May, 2017 Posted 21 May, 2017 Sell. One of the biggest culprits when it comes to us not being able to hit a barn door yet gets away with it to some extent and for some reason he is seen as a midfielder rather than a forward who is often playing higher up the pitch than anyone else in the team. 2 goals from open play in 3107 minutes is a pathetic return for a player in his position. And is turning 29 this year. Tadic, Long, Rodriguez and Forster should be at top of the sale list.
Dellman Posted 21 May, 2017 Posted 21 May, 2017 He spends the whole time complaining, often to his own team mates, doesn't do anything for the team spirit we used to have but haven't got now.
Gorgiesaint Posted 21 May, 2017 Posted 21 May, 2017 Keep. Seemed to have built a good relationship with Gabbi, until Puel decided to mix things up a bit and play JRod and Long. Would be interested to see how he gets on with another manager actually providing some motivation.
Causer Posted 21 May, 2017 Posted 21 May, 2017 Stay as infuriating as he has been for large parts of season, he has still been creating more chances than anyone else in the squad. If our strikers had been even vaguely competent this season, he wouldn't be getting half the stick he gets. He is always brave enough to try the tough pass or take a player on that settle for the easy 5 yard square ball and we don't have anyone else like that in the squad.
Saint_clark Posted 21 May, 2017 Posted 21 May, 2017 Feels like a long, long time ago but the best i've ever seen him was at the start of this season after making the decision to stay and signing a new contract. Pity things never progressed. In a season where everyone offensive was disappointing in one way or another, he still got 7 assists and I would wager is right up there in the key chances created statistic. Keep him.
Chris27687 Posted 21 May, 2017 Posted 21 May, 2017 getting rid would be unbelieveably stupid, technically and by asssits he is worth a ****ing bundle. So unless someone is going to drop -£25m - £35m on him, he should not be leaving.
Causer Posted 21 May, 2017 Posted 21 May, 2017 Sell Put Boufal on right and get Ziyech in at no.10 add on the left, sign another defensive midfielder to play on Romeu and we have a bloody good midfield.
Causer Posted 21 May, 2017 Posted 21 May, 2017 add on the left, sign another defensive midfielder to play on Romeu and we have a bloody good midfield. Oops, posted too soon, add Tadic on left instead of Redmond sign another defensive midfielder to play on Romeu and we have a bloody good midfield
GGalpin Posted 21 May, 2017 Posted 21 May, 2017 If we want more goals, getting rid of our most creative player is basically shooting ourselves straight in the foot. Keep him and get faster players around him.
Whitey Grandad Posted 21 May, 2017 Posted 21 May, 2017 A good player with the right tactics and motivation. I'll leave the decision to the new manager.
Fitzhugh Fella Posted 21 May, 2017 Posted 21 May, 2017 I'll make no comment except to say that slowly I am being proved right.
Scoobysaint Posted 21 May, 2017 Posted 21 May, 2017 Go. Promises much but delivers very little. Too slow, too delicate, too frustrating.
Lighthouse Posted 21 May, 2017 Posted 21 May, 2017 Bin him off. Play Sims instead. Everton aside, Sims has done nowhere near enough to warrant a place in the team yet. If he is starting next season, we really are in trouble.
doddisalegend Posted 21 May, 2017 Posted 21 May, 2017 He is slow he needs pace around him so playing him with Austin and JWP really doesn't pay. I thought he would link up well with Gabbi but they don't seem to have clicked much at all. What really frustrates me is how ****ing bad he is at shooting.
John Boy Saint Posted 21 May, 2017 Posted 21 May, 2017 Don't let the door bang on his backside on the way out. Said for a long time he flatters to deceive, shows odd flashes of brilliance, but overall not as good as he thinks he is, when he loses the ball for the umpteenth time in a game he blames everyone else in pointing distance.
DT Posted 21 May, 2017 Posted 21 May, 2017 One of the most frustrating players. Clearly has ability but no application. And when he needs to deliver, he disappears. Will obviously score against us for another club Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now