Jump to content

Jan Signing who would you get?

ally_uk

By ally_uk
in The Saints

 Share

Recommended Posts

ally_uk

ally_uk

Posted
Posted

You have been given the go ahead to sign one player in January to strengthen the squad. This has to be a realistic signing no Bales, Ronaldo :p

who would you get it and why?

 

My choice: Sebastien Haller

 

Why?:

 

We were linked to him before, We need more firepower up top, Has a good goal goal scoring record. Would mean we don't have to rely on Austin.

 

 

Another Choice?:

 

Recall Sam G.

Lighthouse

Lighthouse

Posted
Posted

I think we're pretty good unless we pick up a long term injury at some point. The only signing I think we would get is a deal like Austin last year, where they are out of contract next summer and we can get a bargain.

doddisalegend

doddisalegend

Posted
Posted

Only place I think we are a little lacking is behind Romeu. We have Reed (who in fairness has been good in both cup games) but weather he is good enough if Romeu is out for a prolonged time I'm not so sure. So a decent holding midfielder....no idea who that I though.

derry

derry

Posted
Posted

Some big nasty bastard to play in midfield and get in amongst the opposition. We are far too nice. Chelsea got away with murder yesterday especially their no 3 Marcos Alonso? He needed clattering especially as the referee Mike Jones was letting everything go.

Heisenberg

Heisenberg

Posted
Posted
Some big nasty bastard to play in midfield and get in amongst the opposition. We are far too nice. Chelsea got away with murder yesterday especially their no 3 Marcos Alonso? He needed clattering especially as the referee Mike Jones was letting everything go.

 

YAYA T on loan :)

DT

DT

Posted
Posted
I would buy Defoe on a short term contract. He is a goal scorer has pace and would thrive on the chances on we create.

 

have been saying this for yonks. Realistic, and would score for fun.

Cartman

Cartman

Posted
Posted

Juanpi from Malaga (forward) and Franck Kessié from Atalanta (midfielder). Anything but big immobile lumps up top with Heskey's dribbling and Wanyama's passing ability but are supposedly good at "hold up play".

DT

DT

Posted
Posted
Defoe has a contract at Sunderland until 2019, he's unlikely to give that up for some short term deal.

 

oh yeah, forgot about contracts. they are WATERTIGHT

fish fingers

fish fingers

Posted
Posted
Juanpi from Malaga (forward) and Franck Kessié from Atalanta (midfielder). Anything but big immobile lumps up top with Heskey's dribbling and Wanyama's passing ability but are supposedly good at "hold up play".

 

He's been fairly useless for a couple of seasons now.

DT

DT

Posted
Posted
Ings or Berhino. Both doable. Both fit the bill.

 

Sunderland wouldn't sell Defoe, it would cause a riot on Wearside.

 

Lambert? LOL.

 

Sunderland might take JayRod in part exchange?.

SNSUN

SNSUN

Posted
Posted

It's clear we all think we need a striker as that's pretty much what everyone has mentioned. Berahino would have been decent on a cheapie as he's out of contract at the end of the season, and had natural goalscoring talent, but he's recently been found to be overweight, which shows a lack of professionalism and desire to play for WBA, and has done very little in 2 years anyway due to the beef he had with them. Perhaps worth a stab for an Austin-fee but no more.

 

Ings is a good shout if he's now fully fit. Personally I think we'll go for Haller, it seems we were linked with him at the tail end of the window and he's continued his goalscoring form this season. As for Defoe, he has a contract until he's 37 at Sunderland. If ,and probably when, they get relegated this season, that'll cost them a fortune. Maybe they'd be looking to sell on the cheap but I think he's not a Saints type signing.

 

Whoever we bring in they just need to put the ball in the net! We have depth elsewhere.

S-Clarke

S-Clarke

Posted
Posted

Why do people think a striker is the solution? If you don't move the ball quick enough and create clear openings, then it doesn't matter who is up front. That was the case yesterday, just a little too slow in the buildup and it allowed Chelsea to regroup and block the avenues - so the service was never really there for Austin.

 

We'll score goals if we move the ball quicker, not sure why people want to reinvent the wheel after yesterday. We're not a bad side as it stands.

sad saints fan

sad saints fan

Posted
Posted
Only place I think we are a little lacking is behind Romeu. We have Reed (who in fairness has been good in both cup games) but weather he is good enough if Romeu is out for a prolonged time I'm not so sure. So a decent holding midfielder....no idea who that I though.

 

Harry Reed has just been injured in the u23 game at Derby and was subbed after 15mins

Turkish

Turkish

Posted
Posted
No idea, but I reckon they'd accept £10-£15m, perhaps plus Jay Rod

 

This is definitely something we should do. Maybe see if they'll throw in Cattermole if we offer them £8m?

DuncanRG

DuncanRG

Posted
Posted
Why do people think a striker is the solution? If you don't move the ball quick enough and create clear openings, then it doesn't matter who is up front. That was the case yesterday, just a little too slow in the buildup and it allowed Chelsea to regroup and block the avenues - so the service was never really there for Austin.

 

We'll score goals if we move the ball quicker, not sure why people want to reinvent the wheel after yesterday. We're not a bad side as it stands.

 

Not everyone is signing players to beat Chelsea - though I'll admit too many are. We're moving the ball as quickly as ever in most games but finishing has been a problem, as has movement in the box. Austin's had some great games but isn't fit enough to rely on, Long isn't clinical enough to rely on and Rodriguez has not had a good game since 2014. That's why I and many would sign a striker.

eelpie

eelpie

Posted
Posted
Why do people think a striker is the solution?

 

Because we are 13th on goals scored, with only seven teams having scored fewer? And a very high ratio of chances missed?

Cartman

Cartman

Posted
Posted
Good call. Koeman was after him for Everton during the summer for c£14m. No idea why it didn't go through.

 

Bad call, he's a talentless donkey. Only in the dutch league could he score as many as he does.

If Puel has his way we will play 433 with 3 Boufal type players up front, players like Haller have no place with us.

FriendlySaint

FriendlySaint

Posted
Posted

If I was going to spend money it would be at right back. We need a top class right back. I think it's the only position we don't have at least a decent player in. Martina and Cedric are quite average (not bad, but need improved on) in my opinion. Top right and left backs are like gold dust though (ones that are good going forward and at defending) and I really don't know which one I would bid for. I would be looking for an improvement at left and right back going forward to be honest if I could plus central midfield.

 

In an ideal world it's at least the new right back plus a top quality central midfielder that can run the game and passes forward more and quicker than our current players. Our current team isn't bad though and showing a lot of potential

SNSUN

SNSUN

Posted
Posted
If I was going to spend money it would be at right back. We need a top class right back. I think it's the only position we don't have at least a decent player in. Martina and Cedric are quite average (not bad, but need improved on) in my opinion. Top right and left backs are like gold dust though (ones that are good going forward and at defending) and I really don't know which one I would bid for. I would be looking for an improvement at left and right back going forward to be honest if I could plus central midfield.

 

In an ideal world it's at least the new right back plus a top quality central midfielder that can run the game and passes forward more and quicker than our current players. Our current team isn't bad though and showing a lot of potential

 

Left back is the position we're probably strongest in I believe A fit Bertrand is one of the best left backs in the league, and he's only just turned 27. If there's a position we currently don't need anyone in IMO it's left back. I agree that right back can be improved upon, but I reckon Cedric will get better - he showed flashes of improvement before he got injured.

 

Aside from a striker (which I personally think we need as the 3 senior strikers we have can't 100% be relied on to be fit (Austin/JRod) nor score many (Long/Redmond)) the 2 other positions I'd be looking at to strengthen would be defensive midfield (we'd miss Romeu if he got injured) and long term a Fonte replacement.)

HKsaint

HKsaint

Posted
Posted

I think the performance of Claise and Davis (recently) is not up to the expected quality and has costed us. Therefore, we need at least one holding midfielder who can run and make a clinical passing to Austin. Loan deal for Morgan is good but seems unlikely.

Heisenberg

Heisenberg

Posted
Posted

We are a level 4 club and seem more than happy to bend over when a level 1-3 wants/needs our players

 

We should be looking to take the best players from level 5-6 clubs (AFCB, Norwich, Brighton) or simply continue buying relative unknowns from overseas (France needs tapping more)

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
 Share
Go to topic listing
×
×
  • Create New...