Jump to content

Saints vs Palace (EFL R3) - Build Up

Lighthouse

By Lighthouse
in The Saints

 Share

Recommended Posts

Lighthouse

Lighthouse

Posted
Posted

Another 3 days rest for this one. Like Christmas already.

 

I'd pretty much play the kids and a few fringe players. Something like:

 

McCarthy

 

Martina - Yoshi - Gardos? - Targett

 

Reed

JWP - Clasie

Isgrove

 

Long - Olomola

VivaElTri

VivaElTri

Posted
Posted
Another 3 days rest for this one. Like Christmas already.

 

I'd pretty much play the kids and a few fringe players. Something like:

 

McCarthy

 

Martina - Yoshi - Gardos? - Targett

 

Reed

JWP - Clasie

Isgrove

 

Long - Olomola

 

I think those who played vs Prague but didnt play today will get a start . So Rodriguez might play but I would love it if Olomola gets a chance

Globetrotter

Globetrotter

Posted
Posted

Think we'll see something like:

 

McCarthy

Martina Stephens Yoshida Targett

JWP Reed Clasie

Olomola Hesketh Isgrove

 

Subs: Forster, Fonte, McQueen, Hojberg, Davis, Long/Redmond, Austin/J-Rod

 

Adjust for diamond etc

 

Sent from my SM-G920F using Tapatalk

lickierambert

lickierambert

Posted
Posted
Think we'll see something like:

 

McCarthy

Martina Stephens Yoshida Targett

JWP Reed Clasie

Olomola Hesketh Isgrove

 

Subs: Forster, Fonte, McQueen, Hojberg, Davis, Long/Redmond, Austin/J-Rod

 

Adjust for diamond etc

 

Sent from my SM-G920F using Tapatalk

 

I think JWP would be the tallest of the front 6. No way are we going to be that weak

The9

The9

Posted
Posted

I think the presence of Reed and Isgrove on the bench today will be a hint towards Wednesday's side. I'm going but I'd much rather we picked the kids with a couple of fringe starters who need a game and won't be involved against West Ham.

 

So how about (back to 4-2-3-1 like the U23s have used a bit, as I can't really fit the players in any other way)...

 

-------------McCarthy-----------------

Martina--Yoshida--Stephens--Targett

----------Reed-------Clasie------------

-Ward-Prowse--Hesketh--Isgrove----

--------------Rodriguez----------------

 

Subs: Parkes(GK), Jones, McQueen, Sims, Davis, Johnson, Olomola

striker

striker

Posted
Posted
I think the presence of Reed and Isgrove on the bench today will be a hint towards Wednesday's side. I'm going but I'd much rather we picked the kids with a couple of fringe starters who need a game and won't be involved against West Ham.

 

So how about (back to 4-2-3-1 like the U23s have used a bit, as I can't really fit the players in any other way)...

 

-------------McCarthy-----------------

Martina--Yoshida--Stephens--Targett

----------Reed-------Clasie------------

-Ward-Prowse--Hesketh--Isgrove----

--------------Rodriguez----------------

 

Subs: Parkes(GK), Jones, McQueen, Sims, Davis, Johnson, Olomola

 

I like this. The only thing I may add is Long to see if we can get him going, plus he only played a half today.

The9

The9

Posted
Posted
What kind of team did palace field last time out?

v Blackpool, EFL Cup 2nd Round W 2-0

 

S Mandanda (G)

J Tomkins (D)

S Dann (D)

P N'Diaye Souare (D) - well he won't be playing...

M Kelly (D)

Y Cabaye (M)

A Townsend (M)

J McArthur (M)

J Mutch (M)

J Puncheon (M)

C Benteke (F)

 

Subs: J Speroni (G), E Fryers (D), W Zaha (M), Lee Chung-Yong (M), H Boateng (M), C Wickham (F), K Anderson (F)

whelk

whelk

Posted
Posted
I always want Saints to win but I won't lose any sleep if we don't win. The EFL Cup is the least important competition we're in.

 

CheckaTrade?

The9

The9

Posted
Posted
I like this. The only thing I may add is Long to see if we can get him going, plus he only played a half today.

 

The issue is trying not to wear out the striker rotation so we have fresh players for West Ham - I think Long's still ahead of Rodriguez, and Austin and Redmond will definitely be in the squad so 60+ mins for Rodriguez with Olomola and Sims to give attacking options.

 

Having just gone back through the thread it's not dissimilar to Globetrotter's team.

The9

The9

Posted
Posted
When is Boufal due back? Could he be in?

 

He was "a month away" a week ago. With a two week break after Leicester on Oct 2nd, he should be back for Burnley on Oct 16th, I can't see us casually popping him in for a debut at the San Siro the Thursday after as it might not be too good for squad morale. Unless of course he's bloody amazing in training, players have a habit of lumping it when the inevitable is staring them in the face. But I'd guess at Burnley.

sammysaint

sammysaint

Posted
Posted

Jay Rod should be fit for Wes so I think this game is ideal for him to regain the fitness he has lost the last few days and just as he was starting to look sharp again with his movement off the ball.

 

McCarthy

Targett Yosh Stephens Martina.

Reed JWP

Isgrove Sims

Jay Rod Long

 

Sims and Jay Rod can rotate every 20/25 from LW to upfront as I have noticed Puel rotate Tadic Jay Rod Long and Redmond at times during the games especially agaist Sunderland and the Europa league.

SNSUN

SNSUN

Posted
Posted
v Blackpool, EFL Cup 2nd Round W 2-0

 

S Mandanda (G)

J Tomkins (D)

S Dann (D)

P N'Diaye Souare (D) - well he won't be playing...

M Kelly (D)

Y Cabaye (M)

A Townsend (M)

J McArthur (M)

J Mutch (M)

J Puncheon (M)

C Benteke (F)

 

Subs: J Speroni (G), E Fryers (D), W Zaha (M), Lee Chung-Yong (M), H Boateng (M), C Wickham (F), K Anderson (F)

 

Strong team for Palace. I can't see us putting out a team anywhere near as strong.

 

McCarthy

Martina

Fonte

Yoshida

Targett

JWP

Clasie

Reed

Isgrove

Hesketh/JRod

Austin

 

I reckon, with youth on the bench. Though I'd be tempted to play Long to see if he can't regain some confidence.

The9

The9

Posted
Posted (edited)
I'd be tempted to play Long to see if he can't regain some confidence.

 

Not a bad shout either.

 

Palace's team today was

Steve Mandanda (G) 30

Joel Ward (D) 2

(45) James Tomkins (D) 5

Scott Dann (D) 6

Martin Kelly (D) 34

(85) Andros Townsend (M) 10

Wilfried Zaha (M) 11

(78 ) Joe Ledley (M) 16

James McArthur (M) 18 60

Jason Puncheon (M) 42 77

Christian Benteke (F) 17 71

 

Only Ward, Cabaye, Zaha and Ledley different from their League Cup team against Blackpool.

Edited by The9
SuperSAINT

SuperSAINT

Posted
Posted
v Blackpool, EFL Cup 2nd Round W 2-0

 

S Mandanda (G)

J Tomkins (D)

S Dann (D)

P N'Diaye Souare (D) - well he won't be playing...

M Kelly (D)

Y Cabaye (M)

A Townsend (M)

J McArthur (M)

J Mutch (M)

J Puncheon (M)

C Benteke (F)

 

Subs: J Speroni (G), E Fryers (D), W Zaha (M), Lee Chung-Yong (M), H Boateng (M), C Wickham (F), K Anderson (F)

 

Thanks. Surprisingly strong team from them.

Saint in NZ

Saint in NZ

Posted
Posted
v Blackpool, EFL Cup 2nd Round W 2-0

 

S Mandanda (G)

J Tomkins (D)

S Dann (D)

P N'Diaye Souare (D) - well he won't be playing...

M Kelly (D)

Y Cabaye (M)

A Townsend (M)

J McArthur (M)

J Mutch (M)

J Puncheon (M)

C Benteke (F)

 

Subs: J Speroni (G), E Fryers (D), W Zaha (M), Lee Chung-Yong (M), H Boateng (M), C Wickham (F), K Anderson (F)

 

If posters on here get their way and Palace field a side similar to the above, it sounds like we don't want to go any further in this Cup. That'll put a smile on Alan Pardew's face.

Mowgli

Mowgli

Posted
Posted
If posters on here get their way and Palace field a side similar to the above, it sounds like we don't want to go any further in this Cup. That'll put a smile on Alan Pardew's face.

 

And have the same people bemoaning about blowing a real chance at silverware.

 

Forster

Martina Yoshida VVD Targett

Clasie Højbjerg JWP Reed

Long Austin

 

Long needs to find his shooting boots

 

Spot on!

Lighthouse

Lighthouse

Posted
  • Author
Posted
And have the same people bemoaning about blowing a real chance at silverware.

 

 

 

Spot on!

 

We've had a 'real chance of silverware' for decades and not won this competition. I think this year, with a European adventure to keep us amused, it should be taking a back seat. After all, the toughest team in the EL is probably Man Utd, whereas they aren't even in the top 4 teams in the EFL, IMO. We have a better chance at winning EL and should go for that.

 

Also, Austin isn't fit enough to play 3 games in a week yet. I'd save him for West Ham's colandrical defence at the weekend. McCarthy will need game time to stay sharp, should Forster be injured and was probably promised domestic cup games when he signed. I'd be astonished if he didn't play.

 

Personally think we'd be daft to risk Virgil at such an early stage of a low priority competition. I'm sure people will moan if we lose, doesn't mean we should listen to them.

captainchris

captainchris

Posted
Posted
Another 3 days rest for this one. Like Christmas already.

 

I'd pretty much play the kids and a few fringe players. Something like:

 

McCarthy

 

Martina - Yoshi - Gardos? - Targett

 

Reed

JWP - Clasie

Isgrove

 

Long - Olomola

I think Puel will mainly go with the team of the European game with a maybe a youngster in the melting pot. We need to give game time to the squad members who need to get match fit and stay sharp.

For the record Puel seems to understand the squad needs to play to a system that everyone works to. We are not blessed with lots of magnificent players and so the system is key.

Fair play to Puel, he is working well with what he has.....

Mowgli

Mowgli

Posted
Posted

Fair points. Would equally be happy to Fonte for VVD and JRod (if fit) for Austin or Long (Austin did not play the whole game Saturday). Overall I think we have enough depth to rotate and treat all competitions seriously. Otherwise, why bother entering?

Pass the Dutchie

Pass the Dutchie

Posted
Posted
And have the same people bemoaning about blowing a real chance at silverware.

 

Yet other people will bemoan us never giving the youngsters a chance while at the same time always wanting to play the strongest team. If not in this competition, when?

disconnect

disconnect

Posted
Posted

Palace will field a pretty strong team (they always do in the cups), and we'll likely pick a far weakened team. However, having Stephens, Yoshida and Targett might be giving McCarthy a very busy night, and we'll likely get smashed. That said, Yoshida had a good game against Prague - I just wouldnt trust them with the same continual passing along the back four as that game though without Virgil there.

Saint Garrett

Saint Garrett

Posted
Posted

--------------McCarthy--------------

Martina Stephens Yoshida Targett

-----------------Reed-----------------

--------Clasie----------JWP----------

----------------Hesketh--------------

Long-----------------------------JRod

 

Obviously if JRod isn't fit, then one of Austin/Redmond. Wouldn't mind seeing Sims play.

Saint_Ash

Saint_Ash

Posted
Posted

----------------------McCarthy------------------------

 

Martina------Fonte-------------Yoshi----------Targett

 

-------------Reed--------------Clasie------------------

 

------Isgrove---------Long--------------Davis--------

 

-------------------------JRod--------------------------

benjii

benjii

Posted
Posted

-----------------McCarthy-----------------

 

Martina-----Fonte----Yoshida---Targett

 

-------------------Reed--------------------

 

----------JWP--------------Classie--------

 

---Isgrove-------Jay Rod------------Long

---/Olumula

---/Hesketh

 

I think we should put out a pretty strong team. If Rodriguez is fit then he should play and 45 mins for Long won't hurt. I think we need to protect at least one of Fonte and Van Dijk. Ideally we would rest both but with Gardos injured that really depends on whether Stephens or Jones would be considered too weak to play a reasonably strong Palace team.

 

I think Davis, Romeu and Hojbjerg should be kept fresh so the midfield pretty much picks itself.

 

Would be nice to see a youth product or Isgrove start up front with a couple more on the bench.

Chris27687

Chris27687

Posted
Posted

Think it will be similar to the Sparta line up. Palace will bring a strong team - after last years FA Cup run the fans will be after another decent cup run and the LC is as good as any.

 

Would be good to have Hesketh/Olomola/Isgrove/Sims included in some capacity.

Cartman

Cartman

Posted
Posted

Pick the team that will start against West Ham and replace all of them, so a mix of first team players that need game time and a few kids filling in the blanks i think:

 

McCarthy

Martina Stephens Yoshida Targett

JWP Reed Clasie

Isgrove Rodriguez Long

 

Sims in for Jay if not fit.

ALWAYS_SFC

ALWAYS_SFC

Posted
Posted
We should have a forum expert pick the team and tactics, show Claude and Les how it's done!

 

Which one ? Too many to pick from

 

I vote for Kermitsaint, he's the cleverestest of them all :rolleyes:

Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.
 Share
Go to topic listing
×
×
  • Create New...