Pelle or Lukaku?

[FloridaMarlin]

So if Kowman came back and said: "Give us £10m and Pelle and you can have Lukaku" who would you have on tonight's evidence?

[Batman]

Lukaku is miles better. Jeez

[Saint Charlie]

Silly thread IMO. Lukaku anyday of the week. Just the same as if it were Benteke instead of Lukaku.

 

But that doesn't mean we should sell Pelle or that he isnt an excellent player.

[nta786]

Lukaku all day long.

Age, potential, resale value.

And tonight should not purely be a factor too

[Chris27687]

If Lukaku plays like that in the next couple of games they will be lucky to get £6.5m, let alone £65m.

 

The Belgium manager must be so ****ing bad to fail to get that group of players to do anything creative. All they had was trying to take speculative shots from 30 yards.

[the saint in winchester]

Lukaku plus £10M for Pelle, more like.

[silly point]

Does his goal mean an additional million or two?[emoji12]

 

 

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[SaintSteve]

Silly thread IMO. Lukaku anyday of the week. Just the same as if it were Benteke instead of Lukaku.

 

But that doesn't mean we should sell Pelle or that he isnt an excellent player.

 

Except that neither Lukaku nor Benteke have a football brain..whereas Pelle does and contributes far more to a team ethic.

[Saint Without a Halo]

Except that neither Lukaku nor Benteke have a football brain..whereas Pelle does and contributes far more to a team ethic.

 

Spot on

[Shance]

Lukaku is in a different league to Pelle. He'd fit well in our side as well but Everton want big money for him and he want's a big team.

[ashnats]

Pelle, all day long. The guy has got style. Lukaku, or benteke are just bruisers, they'll run past a player and score standard goals, with power. Benteke scored a cracking overhead once, but is mostly all about strength and power.

 

Pelle has scored some beautiful goals, some great assists, and those flicks come off one in 5, but when they do it's pure jizz.

 

Pelle is the easy choice for any football aficionado. You need special players like him to make your team unique.

[ADutchSaint]

Lukaku is in a different league to Pelle. He'd fit well in our side as well but Everton want big money for him and he want's a big team.

 

Good luck to Lukaku at a big team with his first touch. He's never going to make it in the top., he has the strength and pace but otherwise he lacks everything.

[ashnats]

Lukaku's goals this year (all of them - none of them that special):

 

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tD000ZY0IvI

 

Pelle (quality):

 

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xMm-RPHmkd0

[SaintBitterne]

Forum gold

[zurichboy]

You are quite right, watched the Italy game this evening. Pelle PL, Lukaku not even close.....

[Lets B Avenue]

I want us to keep Pelle, if only to fu ck Jamie off.

[ScepticalStan]

Guys. It's one match. Gash as Lukaku was tonight please close this tragedy of a thread.

[Smirking_Saint]

Except that neither Lukaku nor Benteke have a football brain..whereas Pelle does and contributes far more to a team ethic.

 

Not entirely sure you have a football brain either to be honest

[SaintStinger]

Lukaku all day long.

Age, potential, resale value.

And tonight should not purely be a factor too

 

Why do fans care about resale value?

[sadoldgit]

Lukaku is miles better. Jeez

 

 

Not on tonight's performance he isn't.

[Saint Charlie]

Not on tonight's performance he isn't.

Tonight Giaccherini played better than Hazard but nobody would buy him over EH.

 

Football exists beyond just one game and Lukaku is better than and worth far more than Pelle overall.

[Redslo]

Why do fans care about resale value?

 

Because it increases the chances that Southampton will be able to continue fielding a high quality team. But you are probably right. What are the chances that a club like Southampton would ever have financial difficulties?