Jump to content

Saints Transfers Thread - Deadline Day

Saint Charlie

By Saint Charlie
in The Saints

 Share

Recommended Posts

Saint_Tony

Saint_Tony

Posted
Posted

Clasie's never really got going. Wouldn't be bothered if he left, but then I doubt we'd have a replacement. I would still like to see 2 more signings, but can't see it happening.

 

Sent from my D5803 using Tapatalk

Dalek2003

Dalek2003

Posted
Posted

Back to the topic of new signings.

 

If we don't get a few more key players in, who have obvious pedigree and track record then all I can say id the Board are 'playing with fire'. Hope they are right in thinking we can stay up with the current squad. Risky but very profitable if we finish between 17th and 14th.

Heisenberg

Heisenberg

Posted
Posted
Back to the topic of new signings.

 

If we don't get a few more key players in, who have obvious pedigree and track record then all I can say id the Board are 'playing with fire'. Hope they are right in thinking we can stay up with the current squad. Risky but very profitable if we finish between 17th and 14th.

 

Perhaps Reed is busy looking at his and the clubs bank balance? :poundit:

Saint86

Saint86

Posted
Posted
I like Romeu. I think he has the potential to be a very good player. He's intelligent and, despite making some rash challenges, has been rewarded with a starting spot so, in a sense, has justified the faith of Puel et al.

 

However, I don't believe that he will be given the chance to shine this year owing to the formation change - as the sole DM in front of the back four, he does not have a like-minded partner to rely upon. The Diamond formation is more attacking, and will leave Romeu a lot more exposed. It is my opinion that he will do just as well as Wanyama would do in the same position (that is, not as well as he would with a partner).

 

With regards to incoming transfers, my point is that, on the basis of the above, I don't think buying a new DM will help the defence to a degree substantial enough to garner necessary funding. Romeu will be doing a sufficient enough job as is. Whether the formation change is a good thing or not is another debate altogether (although my opinion is that, as of yet, it is an unconvincing switch - not least of all because the majority of players have been using the old system for two or more years, but also because I believe we are leaving the full-backs too exposed).

 

If we really must invest funds into a new player (all the evidence suggests that we may bring in one more player at best), then I think it is likely that we'll bring in a young player who is flexible in playing across the attacking line. Such a player would prove a good investment for the future, and could provide immediate support in reinforcement on the pitch.

 

Romeu is poor defensively. Gets done regularly and gives the ball away to easily when in defensive positions (in that case very similar to wanyama). What Romeu, Clasie and apparently PEH are all good at is striding forward, riding challenges and piging good passes about going forward.

 

Thats great for attacking.... but we're gonna leak like a sieve due to play coming straight through the middle... and we'er open on the flanks because of how narrow we set up. Hope we score more :)

Heisenberg

Heisenberg

Posted
Posted
Romeu is poor defensively. Gets done regularly and gives the ball away to easily when in defensive positions (in that case very similar to wanyama). What Romeu, Clasie and apparently PEH are all good at is striding forward, riding challenges and piging good passes about going forward.

 

Thats great for attacking.... but we're gonna leak like a sieve due to play coming straight through the middle... and we'er open on the flanks because of how narrow we set up. Hope we score more :)

 

Romeu is not yet the finished article that's obvious but he needs a run in the side and some of Puels magic.

 

If anyone can make Romeu top drawer it's Puel IMHO. Look at what he did with Thierry Henry, Ben Arfa and Vincent Koziello

wild-saint

wild-saint

Posted
Posted
Romeu is not yet the finished article that's obvious but he needs a run in the side and some of Puels magic.

 

If anyone can make Romeu top drawer it's Puel IMHO. Look at what he did with Thierry Henry, Ben Arfa and Vincent Koziello

 

That's a really good point. Lets hope he is able to improve the whole squad particularly the younger players

Dalek2003

Dalek2003

Posted
Posted
Perhaps Reed is busy looking at his and the clubs bank balance? :poundit:

 

I am not suggesting foulplay. Not at all. However, I am suggesting that the best way to maximise profits is to spend as little as possible if you are confident that you can stay up, even if that means 17th.

 

It seems that running a tight ship is the priority of the board and who can blame after we nearly went bankrupt a few years ago.

 

Under this policy we could easily cope with relegation and a good chance of coming back up.

 

I call this a 'sustainable' programme which after all was the model we were all told the club would follow.

ally_uk

ally_uk

Posted
Posted

Have we put a bid in for Boufal? I have had time to think and believe the way we do business is smart. Sure we could go out tommorow and sign three Carlos kick a balls for millions. But that just isn't the way we do things. I think Redmond and Hojbjerg are fantastic signings.

 

As for bringing in players I would go for Idrissa Gueye and Will Hughes both young and fit the mould. Then spend extra on Bas Dost.

mrfahaji

mrfahaji

Posted
Posted
Have we put a bid in for Boufal? I have had time to think and believe the way we do business is smart. Sure we could go out tommorow and sign three Carlos kick a balls for millions. But that just isn't the way we do things. I think Redmond and Hojbjerg are fantastic signings.

 

As for bringing in players I would go for Idrissa Gueye and Will Hughes both young and fit the mould. Then spend extra on Bas Dost.

 

I doubt Everton would be keen on selling their new signing already...

Give it to Ron

Give it to Ron

Posted
Posted
Have we put a bid in for Boufal? I have had time to think and believe the way we do business is smart. Sure we could go out tommorow and sign three Carlos kick a balls for millions. But that just isn't the way we do things. I think Redmond and Hojbjerg are fantastic signings.

 

As for bringing in players I would go for Idrissa Gueye and Will Hughes both young and fit the mould. Then spend extra on Bas Dost.

I cant see Gueye leaving Everton after only 2 weeks

Pass the Dutchie

Pass the Dutchie

Posted
Posted
Don't know anything about Dost. Is he very different to Austin?

 

He's pretty strong and a fighter. Good in the air. A little bit more pace than Austin, I'd say. Not very technical, and will need good support from the sides.

ErwinK1961

ErwinK1961

Posted
Posted
More in the Pelle mould mate. He would be a steal at the price Wolfsburg will be willing to sell him for.

 

But would be wasted in our current formation, as would any target man type striker.

angelman

angelman

Posted
Posted (edited)

But we don't have a target man striker, unless you consider Austin to be that one. But you don't play off Austin as you played off Pelle. Options......

Edited by angelman
MarkSFC

MarkSFC

Posted
Posted
Boetius, Bas (Dost), Berahino and Boufal..............BOOM!

 

Sign 2 out of those 4 and I'd be happy preferably from the latter 3

 

First two....meh.......second two.....yes please!!!!!

pangy

pangy

Posted
Posted

I still think Promes would be a decent buy,can play left,right or through the middle, 24 so has a decent sell on value, 18 goals from 30 games last season with 5 assists

 

That would be a Mane replacement imo

van Hanegem

van Hanegem

Posted
Posted
He's pretty strong and a fighter. Good in the air. A little bit more pace than Austin, I'd say. Not very technical, and will need good support from the sides.

 

I agree, you need a player like Ziyech to deliver the crossballs for a player like Dost. It's really weird that Ziyech is still at Twente...

Batman

Batman

Posted
Posted
Boëtius is a former left winger from Feyenoord who mostly sits on the bench of FC Basel nowadays. IMO he's not fit for playing in the PL.

 

just weird how all of a sudden, he would be a good signing

ALWAYS_SFC

ALWAYS_SFC

Posted
Posted (edited)
If we do get a few in, they are more likely to be young promising League 1 and 2 players. We can develop them and then sell them on for a profit.

 

When was the last time we did that Glenn....

Edited by ALWAYS_SFC
OldNick

OldNick

Posted
Posted
Promes or Ziyech decent! But hey this isn't footy manager we will end up with Tom Ince
funny that, but Ince still has potential as well as the other young English midfielder Derby have, I forget his name
Chez

Chez

Posted
Posted
funny that, but Ince still has potential as well as the other young English midfielder Derby have, I forget his name

 

Will Hughes?

van Hanegem

van Hanegem

Posted
Posted
Could have said the same about Tadic

 

I rate Ziyech even higher than Tadic when it comes to creativity and creating chances. Maybe PL-clubs believe he's too fragile to play in the PL? It can't be the asking price (give or take 10 million pounds) as British clubs are loaded with money.

SuperSAINT

SuperSAINT

Posted
Posted
I rate Ziyech even higher than Tadic when it comes to creativity and creating chances. Maybe PL-clubs believe he's too fragile to play in the PL? It can't be the asking price (give or take 10 million pounds) as British clubs are loaded with money.

 

Yeah, it's very strange that he hasn't been picked up yet.

 

#ZiyechWatch

Dazza82

Dazza82

Posted
Posted

Been linked with a move for jean seri from nice, looks like we have been looking at him for a while last season

 

Could be the reason for Clasie out rumour

Chris27687

Chris27687

Posted
Posted
Is that the sum total of our ambition?

 

Yes. The club is not going to be bailed out by Kat if they **** it up - we are in a fairly unique position where we are a small club with an owner who is happy with the management to run the club. Take a look at other teams around us and owning the club is a status symbol for them and a key part of why they bought the respective clubs. I prefer having people who know how to do their jobs doing them rather than the dildo brothers at West Ham - for example.

 

It's when they come for Uncle Les, Ralph and Rogers that we will be ****ed!

saint77

saint77

Posted
Posted
Is anyone else feeling a bit underwhelmed at the present?

To think it was 50 years ago when we signed the greatest centre-forward the world has ever seen.

 

Yep as underwhelmed as I've been for years felt better in the div 1 days

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
 Share
Go to topic listing
×
×
  • Create New...