Singapore Saint Posted 6 February, 2016 Posted 6 February, 2016 Absolute liability! Bet he's going to send another tweet saying he's sorry.
S4INT Posted 6 February, 2016 Posted 6 February, 2016 You're a moron. Come on you saints, we've got this
Wrensup Posted 6 February, 2016 Posted 6 February, 2016 Absolute liability! Bet he's going to send another tweet saying he's sorry. So worth a thread, them feels
simo Posted 6 February, 2016 Posted 6 February, 2016 You cracking on son, I'd rather pay them to jog on !
Window Cleaner Posted 6 February, 2016 Posted 6 February, 2016 5 match suspension will take him away for nearly half the rest of the season though...barring a successful appeal of course.
JxgrSaint Posted 6 February, 2016 Posted 6 February, 2016 5 match suspension will take him away for nearly half the rest of the season though...barring a successful appeal of course. Isn't a straight red 3 games?
Matthew Le God Posted 6 February, 2016 Posted 6 February, 2016 1) Wanyama commits foul 2) Clattenburg reaches to yellow card pocket 3) Clattenburg sees Payet rolling around 4) Wanyama gets red
JakkoUK Posted 6 February, 2016 Posted 6 February, 2016 Was a reckless challenge, but never a red. So can't be pointing too much of a finger at Victor, as he's been solid recently. It is Clattenburg you should be angry with. Bryam's challenge was just as bad and didn't get a red, so he was even non-consistent. Really dislike Clattenburg when he referees our matches, never seem to get anything.. apart from today of course! Which was an outstanding defensive performance.
Window Cleaner Posted 6 February, 2016 Posted 6 February, 2016 Isn't a straight red 3 games? Yes but not when you've already been sent off twice this season, this is his 3rd red card. cEach one gets you an extra match, last time it was 4 this time it should be 5.
austsaint Posted 6 February, 2016 Posted 6 February, 2016 Crazy thread. Vic played very well until the card, which should not have been red. He also provided the goal for Yoshida with a committed, deft touch from Mane's ball in.
supersonic Posted 6 February, 2016 Posted 6 February, 2016 Not a red card but Clattenberg should never have had a decision to make. Not the first time he's cost us (or nearly cost us) by committing a needless foul. All his hard work up to that point undone by a moment of stupidity.
tajjuk Posted 6 February, 2016 Posted 6 February, 2016 Bit of a silly tackle but is never in a million years a red, I doubtful that is even a yellow. From the side, one footed, doesn't jump in, is not over the ball. It was just late. I hope appeal.
mcjwills Posted 6 February, 2016 Posted 6 February, 2016 Think we should appeal the decision as a five match ban will be hard against us.
Dig Dig Posted 6 February, 2016 Posted 6 February, 2016 That was never a red. Yellow card offence, nothing more.
1960saint Posted 6 February, 2016 Posted 6 February, 2016 West Ham get a yellow for worse tackle Forster for England no 1
Saints foreva Posted 6 February, 2016 Posted 6 February, 2016 Hope his legs get snapped in half when he leaves. Let this club down for a 4th time this season. ****.
CHAPEL END CHARLIE Posted 6 February, 2016 Posted 6 February, 2016 Everytime I watch Mark Clattenberg in action, the decisions he makes and the way he conducts himself on the pitch, and I can help but think that here a is egotist who is seeking to be the centre of attention at all times and may even see himself as more important that the players are. Indeed, I wouldn't be the least surprised to learn that deep down he once wanted to be a top player himself but doubtless lacked the required talent. None of that would really matter very much if he were a brilliant at his job - but I'm far from convinced that he is. As for our Victor, the expression ''he needs to have a good hard look at himself'' comes to mind. So the purchase of some kind of mirror would seem to be in order then ...
simo Posted 6 February, 2016 Posted 6 February, 2016 He was hundreds of a seconds away from getting the ball imo , had Payet in his pocket up til then ! Romeu will cover aptly then Victor will have to catch the eye at the end of the season to get his big move ! Win win!
niceandfriendly Posted 6 February, 2016 Posted 6 February, 2016 Hope his legs get snapped in half when he leaves. Let this club down for a 4th time this season. ****. Players make fouls all the time. Cannot blame Wanyama for Clattenburg being an utter scumbag.
Sheaf Saint Posted 6 February, 2016 Posted 6 February, 2016 If Clattenburg had made the correct decision and not allowed himself to be influenced by the whinging and play-acting from the WHU players, would we still have had this thread?
Shance Posted 6 February, 2016 Posted 6 February, 2016 He missed the ball by a fraction. He's a destroyer, there are risks that come with his style but we need his aggression. He was playing well until the red card. I criticized him when he was going through a rough patch but today Clattenburg failed him and allowed the west ham players to sway his mind.
Shance Posted 6 February, 2016 Posted 6 February, 2016 Hope his legs get snapped in half when he leaves. Let this club down for a 4th time this season. ****. What a really grown up thing to say. Go you.
notnowcato Posted 6 February, 2016 Posted 6 February, 2016 Not a red card but Clattenberg should never have had a decision to make. Not the first time he's cost us (or nearly cost us) by committing a needless foul. All his hard work up to that point undone by a moment of stupidity. It was only a foul. Never a red.
Saint Charlie Posted 6 February, 2016 Posted 6 February, 2016 Ridiculous thread. He was fantastic at Arsenal and United. Easily forgotten.
hasper57saint Posted 6 February, 2016 Posted 6 February, 2016 I don't point the finger at Vic.Clattenberg has history against us and is so full of his own importance he completely ignores the two possible Reds that WH should have received.There was no intent by Vic to get the player.Payet is almost as good an actor as Costa at Chelski.
Convict Colony Posted 6 February, 2016 Posted 6 February, 2016 Absolute liability! Bet he's going to send another tweet saying he's sorry. I lived in singapore for 4yrs and I am glad I never met a fan like you
rshephard3 Posted 6 February, 2016 Posted 6 February, 2016 Liability yes, sell at first half decent offer yes, Romeu better option yes.. but.. in what kind of world does Clattenberg live that he thinks it's fine to be influenced by Nobles reaction. In my opinion that's just as unforgivable as Victor lunging in (again!!)
ALWAYS_SFC Posted 6 February, 2016 Posted 6 February, 2016 That was never a red. Yellow card offence, nothing more. This
Huffton Posted 6 February, 2016 Posted 6 February, 2016 From where I was sat it looked a pretty awful tackle and I wasn't at all surprised when the red came out. That said Clattenburg is a knob, he thinks he is the centre of attention every time he refs and wants to put himself in the spotlight above the players.
ALWAYS_SFC Posted 6 February, 2016 Posted 6 February, 2016 Hope his legs get snapped in half when he leaves. Let this club down for a 4th time this season. ****. I wish you would snap all your fingers and we wouldn't have to read your over reactive garbage. Stupid, stupid thing to say from stupid poster
tobes8 Posted 6 February, 2016 Posted 6 February, 2016 I actually think he's played well recently. Today was never a yellow.
Special K Posted 6 February, 2016 Posted 6 February, 2016 Victor was having a bloody good game until he went a bit reckless. He's been pretty good this season but just need to work on his decision making. Rather he was here than elsewhere.
The9 Posted 6 February, 2016 Posted 6 February, 2016 Just glad Clattenburg was also crap when it came to giving the absolutely bolted on penalty against Yoshida for tripping the West Ham striker near the goal-line in the first half. And also didn't give the penalty for handball they appealed for late on, too. Didn't think it was a red, stupid tackle, probably a yellow, the rolling over and 3 West Ham players running up to him caused it as much as the tackle.
Deano6 Posted 6 February, 2016 Posted 6 February, 2016 1) Wanyama commits foul 2) Clattenburg reaches to yellow card pocket 3) Clattenburg sees Payet rolling around 4) Wanyama gets red They were playing up this narrative in the commentary too, but I noticed later in the game he booked Valencia and his yellow card was in his back pocket (bum) and not his breast pocket, so I think he just lost track of which upper pocket he put his red in (vs his notebook perhaps?). For the record, I thought it should have been a yellow.
Leicestersaint Posted 6 February, 2016 Posted 6 February, 2016 Clumsy but never a red card - absurd decision by Clattenberg (yet again).
Deano6 Posted 6 February, 2016 Posted 6 February, 2016 Just glad Clattenburg was also crap when it came to giving the absolutely bolted on penalty against Yoshida for tripping the West Ham striker near the goal-line in the first half. And also didn't give the penalty for handball they appealed for late on, too. Didn't think it was a red, stupid tackle, probably a yellow, the rolling over and 3 West Ham players running up to him caused it as much as the tackle. That wasn't a pen. For one thing their player took two more steps after Yoshida made contact with his foot and he clearly only went down once he was able to make the conscious decision to do so.
The9 Posted 6 February, 2016 Posted 6 February, 2016 That wasn't a pen. For one thing their player took two more steps after Yoshida made contact with his foot and he clearly only went down once he was able to make the conscious decision to do so. He tripped him in the box (ended up sliding off on all fours I think) when there was no reason to be anywhere near him as the ball was going off the pitch.
RedArmy Posted 6 February, 2016 Posted 6 February, 2016 Consistency is the key. Wanyama's first touch was poor, the ball was taken from him, he dived in two footed from behind and didn't get the ball, arguable a yellow but he gave Clattenburg a decision to make. It was stupid. However, Valencia's challenge was just as bad in the grand scheme of things. Clattenburg loves the attention and getting his face on tv. Another ref and a 3pm kick off and he might have got away with a yellow, but the point still stands, don't give the ref the opportunity to send you off!
angelman Posted 7 February, 2016 Posted 7 February, 2016 Just glad Clattenburg was also crap when it came to giving the absolutely bolted on penalty against Yoshida for tripping the West Ham striker near the goal-line in the first half. Wasn't that a case of either a penalty or a yellow card? Giving nothing was the worst decision of all.
westofshannonsaint Posted 7 February, 2016 Posted 7 February, 2016 Hope his legs get snapped in half when he leaves. Let this club down for a 4th time this season. ****. I don't know if that is sarcasm or if you are a troll (I don't really bother looking at usernames). But if it was neither, I have a few questions... - What if VW stays at saints until retirement? - What would you like to happen to Clattenberg? - At the start of the season did you think that VW would get more red/yellow cards than the average player?
Goatboy Posted 7 February, 2016 Posted 7 February, 2016 Hope his legs get snapped in half when he leaves. Let this club down for a 4th time this season. ****. You're a ****ing weirdo mate. Take a breath.
The9 Posted 7 February, 2016 Posted 7 February, 2016 Wasn't that a case of either a penalty or a yellow card? Giving nothing was the worst decision of all. It wasn't a dive, Yoshida clearly clipped him.
The9 Posted 7 February, 2016 Posted 7 February, 2016 Consistency is the key. Wanyama's first touch was poor, the ball was taken from him, he dived in two footed from behind and didn't get the ball, arguable a yellow but he gave Clattenburg a decision to make. It was stupid. However, Valencia's challenge was just as bad in the grand scheme of things. Clattenburg loves the attention and getting his face on tv. Another ref and a 3pm kick off and he might have got away with a yellow, but the point still stands, don't give the ref the opportunity to send you off! It was neither two-footed nor from behind, it was a sliding tackle across the player and with his right leg swinging (and missing) the ball. There was also a tackle from behind on a Saints player just as bad which may have been Valencia. And Bertrand did Byram a favour by staying on his feet after the studding onto the top of his foot with the ball nowhere.
PhilippineSaint Posted 7 February, 2016 Posted 7 February, 2016 Not a red card but Clattenberg should never have had a decision to make. Not the first time he's cost us (or nearly cost us) by committing a needless foul. All his hard work up to that point undone by a moment of stupidity. Yes but the moment of stupidity was Clattenbergs not Wanyama's. Wanyama went for the ball missing int by 1000's of an inch and took the player out. Clattenberg was indecisive and was swayed by the West Ham players.should be downgraded to a yellow card by the FA automatically.
shurlock Posted 7 February, 2016 Posted 7 February, 2016 Just glad Clattenburg was also crap when it came to giving the absolutely bolted on penalty against Yoshida for tripping the West Ham striker near the goal-line in the first half. And also didn't give the penalty for handball they appealed for late on, too. Didn't think it was a red, stupid tackle, probably a yellow, the rolling over and 3 West Ham players running up to him caused it as much as the tackle. Bolted on pen? Both Gary Monk and Jamie Redknapp in the Sky studio said it was never a pen. And as they pointed out with the benefit of the replays, Valencia initially planted his left foot into Yoshida that unbalanced him and caused the subsequent trip. Was there a shout for a pen? Perhaps. But that's a million miles from saying it was bolted on... But hey why listen to a couple of dispassionate ex-pros when we've got a complete numptie with a hard-on for a player offering his opinion?
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now