Jump to content

Sam Gallagher - Joins Blackburn: Official

Sergei Gotsmanov

By Sergei Gotsmanov,
in The Saints

 Share

Recommended Posts

Lighthouse

Lighthouse

Posted
Posted
We've had people on here saying that Mane was shocking (when he first joined)

 

I don't remember it being when he first joined so much as that run up to Christmas when we were losing games and TBH Mané was awful; in that period he really did look like a more expensive Mayuka. Against Burnley and Sheff Utd I think he was especially bad, getting dragged off having made no impact at all.

 

Then on that Boxing day trip to Palace he suddenly turned it around and looked a decent player again.

Link to comment
Share on other sites
Saint86

Saint86

Posted
Posted
:lol: except he was

 

lol.

 

Funny that Arsenal fans took one look at him in the 2-1 cup game (one of his first matches for us) and said he was class and really dangerous.

 

A lot of numpties like you on here that write players off far to early.

 

JWP is another one that people will look like utter mugs over.

 

20 years old, 100 apps for a premier league team and captained his country at every level... but useless pile of steaming horse dung according to the world class scouts and managers on here. :mcinnes:

Link to comment
Share on other sites
Pastor Patrón

Pastor Patrón

Posted
Posted
lol.

 

Funny that Arsenal fans took one look at him in the 2-1 cup game (one of his first matches for us) and said he was class and really dangerous.

 

A lot of numpties like you on here that write players off far to early.

 

JWP is another one that people will look like utter mugs over.

 

20 years old, 100 apps for a premier league team and captained his country at every level... but useless pile of steaming horse dung according to the world class scouts and managers on here. :mcinnes:

 

Yes because Arsenal fans opinions on our players are certainly more valid and informed then our own. I was unaware JWP has captained the England senior side as well, or even got a call up, pretty sure that makes him the only English player under the age of 25 in the top two flights who hasn't at least got a cap.

Link to comment
Share on other sites
hypochondriac

hypochondriac

Posted
Posted
Yes because Arsenal fans opinions on our players are certainly more valid and informed then our own. I was unaware JWP has captained the England senior side as well, or even got a call up, pretty sure that makes him the only English player under the age of 25 in the top two flights who hasn't at least got a cap.

 

Well a load of saints fans disagree with you so I'm not sure why that makes your opinion any more valid.

Link to comment
Share on other sites
SFC Chris

SFC Chris

Posted
Posted
I don't remember it being when he first joined so much as that run up to Christmas when we were losing games and TBH Mané was awful; in that period he really did look like a more expensive Ali Dia. Against Burnley and Sheff Utd I think he was especially bad, getting dragged off having made no impact at all.

 

Fixed that for you.

Link to comment
Share on other sites
VectisSaint

VectisSaint

Posted
Posted
I dont think theres any argument (anyone else disagree ?) about that more the fact we judged him too early !

He was still shockingly awful in some games early on. Players can be shockingly awful and still turn out to be very good. Some can be shockingly awful and stay that way, some can be brilliant and turn out to be shockingly awful. Unfortunately there are a few rather dim posters on here who don't seem to be able to grasp such a concept and spout rubbish about a player being brilliant even when he was at some times shockingly awful.

Link to comment
Share on other sites
hypochondriac

hypochondriac

Posted
Posted
He was still shockingly awful in some games early on. Players can be shockingly awful and still turn out to be very good. Some can be shockingly awful and stay that way, some can be brilliant and turn out to be shockingly awful. Unfortunately there are a few rather dim posters on here who don't seem to be able to grasp such a concept and spout rubbish about a player being brilliant even when he was at some times shockingly awful.

 

It was obvious he was a decent buy IMO. Even in his poorer games he showed that he was a good player who would scare defenders.

Link to comment
Share on other sites
supersonic

supersonic

Posted
Posted

Getting back on point about Gallagher, he hasn't scored for them yet. Seems to be struggling a little according to the MK fan I know - thinks he may be carrying an injury. As others have pointed out, they've bought in another forward player which has dropped SG further down the pecking order. Will be interesting to see how he does between now and xmas.

Link to comment
Share on other sites
simo

simo

Posted
Posted
A bit frustrating when we send players out on loan to get games and experience and they end up sitting on the bench - but you cant blame the managers for not playing them if they aren't providing the goods.

 

Stephens hardly makes the bench at boro , makes you wonder what the point is !

Link to comment
Share on other sites
Lallana's Left Peg

Lallana's Left Peg

Posted
Posted
A bit frustrating when we send players out on loan to get games and experience and they end up sitting on the bench - but you cant blame the managers for not playing them if they aren't providing the goods.

 

I think Les Reed said we structure the deals in such a way that the more the player on loan plays the less the club he is at pay for him. Stephens is at a good club and will have a tough time getting in that Middlesbrough team unless there are injuries. Gallagher needs to refine his craft - he is a big lad with a lot of upside but his general touch isn't great and that will really impact the degree he can influence a game. Turnbull plays all the time at Swindon but they appear to be crap this season.

 

I'd expect several more from the U21's to go out on loan soon as well as they aren't getting too much from U21 football even if they are playing all the time.

Link to comment
Share on other sites
Saint in Paradise

Saint in Paradise

Posted
Posted
I think Les Reed said we structure the deals in such a way that the more the player on loan plays the less the club he is at pay for him. Stephens is at a good club and will have a tough time getting in that Middlesbrough team unless there are injuries. Gallagher needs to refine his craft - he is a big lad with a lot of upside but his general touch isn't great and that will really impact the degree he can influence a game. Turnbull plays all the time at Swindon but they appear to be crap this season.

 

I'd expect several more from the U21's to go out on loan soon as well as they aren't getting too much from U21 football even if they are playing all the time.

 

 

Now bringing this up at next weeks forum would make a lot more sense than someone moaning about beer or pies.

Link to comment
Share on other sites
Fitzhugh Fella

Fitzhugh Fella

Posted
Posted
I think Les Reed said we structure the deals in such a way that the more the player on loan plays the less the club he is at pay for him. Stephens is at a good club and will have a tough time getting in that Middlesbrough team unless there are injuries. Gallagher needs to refine his craft - he is a big lad with a lot of upside but his general touch isn't great and that will really impact the degree he can influence a game. Turnbull plays all the time at Swindon but they appear to be crap this season.

 

I'd expect several more from the U21's to go out on loan soon as well as they aren't getting too much from U21 football even if they are playing all the time.

 

 

Saints charge a club a sum of money when they loan a player out and then the club doing the loaning get a bit back from Saints every time the player makes an appearance.

Link to comment
Share on other sites
once_bitterne

once_bitterne

Posted
Posted

We've not done well targeting the clubs to loan players too. Gallagher is nowhere near Championship level so it's pointless sending him to MK he should be at a L1 or even L2 club. Likewise, Stevens is not up to a top promotion chasing Championship team he should have either gone back to L1 or to a mid-table level Championship team.

Link to comment
Share on other sites
SuperSAINT

SuperSAINT

Posted
Posted
We've not done well targeting the clubs to loan players too. Gallagher is nowhere near Championship level so it's pointless sending him to MK he should be at a L1 or even L2 club. Likewise, Stevens is not up to a top promotion chasing Championship team he should have either gone back to L1 or to a mid-table level Championship team.

 

I certainly feel Jack would have been better off playing every game for Swindon in league 1 rather than just playing 26 mins in the championship.

Link to comment
Share on other sites
  • 4 weeks later...
The9

The9

Posted
Posted (edited)
......it has to be said that many players who are fouled (or who do dive) make a better job of " falling " that Mane does. Chelsea game was a prime example

 

Even though he is (genuinely) fouled quite a lot - every time he goes down.... it looks a bit theatrical......

 

Mane's problem is that he IS pretty lightweight and tends to fall like he's been hit by a ton of bricks as a result. It's also easy to be made to fall over and go sprawling when you're flat out running too.

Edited by The9
Link to comment
Share on other sites
david in sweden

david in sweden

Posted
Posted

as this is Sam Gallagher's thread..back to the subject......

 

whatever else happens...

....if the MK Dons manager doesn't rate him - they shouldn't keep him, (although looking at their league position he could do worse than give Sam a run of games)

 

We should get him back (if poss.) and organise another loan out...(if legal). The lad needs games and really should be out of the U21 squad now - if he is to succeed.

Link to comment
Share on other sites
The9

The9

Posted
Posted

Nothing about "mutual agreement to cancel" season long loans ("Temporary Transfers") in the Prem Handbook [page 200], in fact it specifies a minimum term for it:

 

A “Temporary Transfer” shall mean the transfer of a contract registration effected in

accordance with Rules V.6 to V.10.

V.6. Subject to the conditions set out below, a Temporary Transfer shall be permitted:

V.6.1. between Clubs; and

V.6.2. between a Club and a club in membership of the Football League, the Football

Conference, the Northern Premier League, the Isthmian League and the Southern

League.

V.7. The conditions referred to in Rule V.6 are:

V.7.1. a Temporary Transfer to a Club may not take place in the Transfer Window in

which the Transferor Club acquired the Player’s registration;

V.7.2. during the period of the Temporary Transfer of his contract registration a Player

shall not play against the Transferor Club;

V.7.3. if during the period of a Temporary Transfer the Player’s registration is transferred

permanently from the Transferor Club to the Transferee Club, the two Clubs may

agree in writing (to be copied to the League) that the Player shall not play against

the Transferor Club for the remainder of the Season;

V.7.4. subject to any conditions imposed by the Board in the exercise of its discretion

under Rule V.4.2, the minimum period of a Temporary Transfer shall be the period

between 2 consecutive Transfer Windows and the period of a Temporary Transfer

shall not extend beyond 30th June next after it was entered into;

PREMIER L LEAGUE RULES: SECTION AV

201

SECTION V: PLAYERS – TRANSFERS OF REGISTRATIONS

V.7.5. the maximum number of Temporary Transfers to any one Club registrable in the

same Season shall be 4 and in no circumstances shall more than 1 be from the

same Transferor Club at any one time save there shall be excluded from these

numbers any Temporary Transfer of the kind described in V.7.6.1 or V.7.6.2;

V.7.6. not more than 2 Temporary Transfers shall be registered by a Club at the same

time except that there shall be excluded from that number:

V.7.6.1. any Temporary Transfer which become permanent; and

V.7.6.2. the Temporary Transfer of a goalkeeper which in its absolute discretion

the Board may allow in circumstances it considers to be exceptional;

V.7.7. a Club may transfer the registration of no more than one of its goalkeepers by way

of temporary Transfer to another Club each Season, subject to any further

Temporary Transfer of one of its goalkeepers pursuant to Rule V.7.6.2;

V.7.8. any other conditions agreed between the Transferor Club and the Transferee Club

or, in the exercise of its discretion, imposed by the Board.

Link to comment
Share on other sites
The9

The9

Posted
Posted

FWIW Rule 4.2 doesn't pertain to cancelling a loan either, only additional restrictions on an initial loan.

 

V.4. Outside a Transfer Window the Board in its absolute discretion may:

V.4.1. refuse an application; or

V.4.2. grant an application and, if thought fit, impose conditions by which the Club

making the application and the player shall be bound

Link to comment
Share on other sites
david in sweden

david in sweden

Posted
Posted
Nothing about "mutual agreement to cancel" season long loans ("Temporary Transfers") in the Prem Handbook [page 200], in fact it specifies a minimum term for it:

 

A “Temporary Transfer” shall mean the transfer of a contract registration effected in

accordance with Rules V.6 to V.10.

V.6. Subject to the conditions set out below, a Temporary Transfer shall be permitted:

V.6.1. between Clubs; and

V.6.2. between a Club and a club in membership of the Football League, the Football

Conference, the Northern Premier League, the Isthmian League and the Southern

League.

V.7. The conditions referred to in Rule V.6 are:

V.7.1. a Temporary Transfer to a Club may not take place in the Transfer Window in

which the Transferor Club acquired the Player’s registration;

V.7.2. during the period of the Temporary Transfer of his contract registration a Player

shall not play against the Transferor Club;

V.7.3. if during the period of a Temporary Transfer the Player’s registration is transferred

permanently from the Transferor Club to the Transferee Club, the two Clubs may

agree in writing (to be copied to the League) that the Player shall not play against

the Transferor Club for the remainder of the Season;

V.7.4. subject to any conditions imposed by the Board in the exercise of its discretion

under Rule V.4.2, the minimum period of a Temporary Transfer shall be the period

between 2 consecutive Transfer Windows and the period of a Temporary Transfer

shall not extend beyond 30th June next after it was entered into;

PREMIER L LEAGUE RULES: SECTION AV

201

SECTION V: PLAYERS – TRANSFERS OF REGISTRATIONS

V.7.5. the maximum number of Temporary Transfers to any one Club registrable in the

same Season shall be 4 and in no circumstances shall more than 1 be from the

same Transferor Club at any one time save there shall be excluded from these

numbers any Temporary Transfer of the kind described in V.7.6.1 or V.7.6.2;

V.7.6. not more than 2 Temporary Transfers shall be registered by a Club at the same

time except that there shall be excluded from that number:

V.7.6.1. any Temporary Transfer which become permanent; and

V.7.6.2. the Temporary Transfer of a goalkeeper which in its absolute discretion

the Board may allow in circumstances it considers to be exceptional;

V.7.7. a Club may transfer the registration of no more than one of its goalkeepers by way

of temporary Transfer to another Club each Season, subject to any further

Temporary Transfer of one of its goalkeepers pursuant to Rule V.7.6.2;

V.7.8. any other conditions agreed between the Transferor Club and the Transferee Club

or, in the exercise of its discretion, imposed by the Board.

 

very impressive data " 9 "........so is that ....a YES or a NO ?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
 Share
Go to topic listing
×
×
  • Create New...