Jump to content

Recommended Posts

Posted
We turned down Cabaye, let's hope the black box got that one right.

 

You don't need the black box to see he's a very good player.

 

And you don't need the black box to know that his wages coupled with his age would be a commitment that Saints don't really like to make. And it appears a lot of clubs around the world who are better than Crystal Palace think the same.

Posted
I must admit we are pretty slow at bringing in players, Certainly need another midfielder and it has to be the right price for the club blah blah....!!!

So many of the middle range clubs are buying some cracking players these days and I often think why did we not go for them.

 

Toons, Palace, Stoke and Sunderland to name a few.

 

Signing players is one thing, putting a squad together that can do what you want and can play together is another. Look at Manchester City. They bring in players at the drop of a hat yet their success rate isn't commensurate to the money they have spent on their squads. Be patient. Better to get the right player in than to sign someone for the sake of it.

Posted
Signing players is one thing, putting a squad together that can do what you want and can play together is another. Look at Manchester City. They bring in players at the drop of a hat yet their success rate isn't commensurate to the money they have spent on their squads. Be patient. Better to get the right player in than to sign someone for the sake of it.

 

it kinda is. last 5 years they have won many things

Posted

They aren't the force they aimed to be either in Europe or in the Premiership - especially Europe. If I had spent that kind of money I would expect the kind of dominance shown by Manchester United or Liverpool when they were in their peek. Both kicked on at a higher level, something City have failed to do.

Posted
I must admit we are pretty slow at bringing in players, Certainly need another midfielder and it has to be the right price for the club blah blah....!!!

So many of the middle range clubs are buying some cracking players these days and I often think why did we not go for them.

 

Toons, Palace, Stoke and Sunderland to name a few.

LOL. Dry your bed. Let's see how we do this season compared to those galactico packed mega clubs, shall we?

Posted
They aren't the force they aimed to be either in Europe or in the Premiership - especially Europe. If I had spent that kind of money I would expect the kind of dominance shown by Manchester United or Liverpool when they were in their peek. Both kicked on at a higher level, something City have failed to do.

 

but they have been successful. the more teams spend, the more successful they are

Posted
No. The better players you have' date=' the more successful you are. Not the more you spend.[/quote']

 

is it by luck that madrid, barca, united, PSG, Chelsea do the best in their leagues and in europe...?

Posted (edited)

I am not saying they haven't been successful, but given the plan was to dominate Europe they clearly haven't been as successful as Liverpool and Manchester United have been. Player for player they have spent an awful lot more on trying to buy success than either of those two teams. The last time they did anything in Europe was 1970. They are hardly streets ahead of the main premiership contenders either.

Edited by sadoldgit
Posted
I am not saying they haven't been successful, but given the plan was to dominate Europe they clearly haven't been as successful as Liverpool and Manchester United have been. Player for player they have spent an awful lot more on trying to buy success than either of those two teams.

 

not yet. but they are a hell of a lot closer than say, saints...or stoke, or spurs, or swansea

 

maybe, that is just luck

Posted
and paid top £$£$£$£ for most them

 

Yes, but you didn't say the best players cost the most and the best clubs can only afford the best players.

 

You said that the more teams spend the more successful they are. And we know that isn't true.

Posted
I must admit we are pretty slow at bringing in players

Pretty slow at bringing in the 6 players so far aren't we. Hopefully you were joking. Over 3 weeks until the transfer window closes, we know we still want 2 but thats not anything to do with being slow.

Posted
Yes, but you didn't say the best players cost the most and the best clubs can only afford the best players.

 

You said that the more teams spend the more successful they are. And we know that isn't true.

 

generally, it is.

city are more successful than us, we are more successful than MK Dons

Posted
generally, it is.

city are more successful than us, we are more successful than MK Dons

 

So how come Cardiff got relegated a few years ago despite spending £60m+

 

How come QPR have gone down twice after spending more than most teams in the bottom half of the table?

 

How come teams in the Championship with the biggest budgets routinely finish well below where they should and below teams with much smaller budgets?

 

Spending money does not mean you are more successful. It gives you a better chance in general, as the presumption is that it means you have better players - but we know it doesn't work like that.

 

Having the better players means you are more successful.

Posted
So how come Cardiff got relegated a few years ago despite spending £60m+

 

How come QPR have gone down twice after spending more than most teams in the bottom half of the table?

 

How come teams in the Championship with the biggest budgets routinely finish well below where they should and below teams with much smaller budgets?

 

Spending money does not mean you are more successful. It gives you a better chance in general, as the presumption is that it means you have better players - but we know it doesn't work like that.

 

Having the better players means you are more successful.

generally it is though. generally, the best teams spend more

there are of course, exceptions to the rule either way

Posted
is it by luck that madrid, barca, united, PSG, Chelsea do the best in their leagues and in europe...?

 

You haven't mentioned Manchester City in that list....

Posted
So how come Cardiff got relegated a few years ago despite spending £60m+

 

How come QPR have gone down twice after spending more than most teams in the bottom half of the table?

 

How come teams in the Championship with the biggest budgets routinely finish well below where they should and below teams with much smaller budgets?

 

Spending money does not mean you are more successful. It gives you a better chance in general, as the presumption is that it means you have better players - but we know it doesn't work like that.

 

Having the better players means you are more successful.

 

Totally agree. It is not how much you spend but who you spend it on.

Posted
Heard a reported comment on 5Live that Martinez said Everton will spend big between now and the close of the transfer window.

 

Won't help them if their manager is crap

 

 

Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk

Posted

@SimonPeach: Jose Fonte believes Virgil van Dijk would be a high-quality addition if #SaintsFC can coax the defender away from #Celtic

 

@SimonPeach: Fonte on Van Dijk: "I know he's a good player, obviously. He's a guy that we've been linked to, but he's not here yet" #SaintsFC #Celtic

 

@SimonPeach: Fonte: "If (Van Dijk) comes, he'll add quality to the team & even more competition at the back, so it will be interesting" #SaintsFC #Celtic

Posted
@SimonPeach: Jose Fonte believes Virgil van Dijk would be a high-quality addition if #SaintsFC can coax the defender away from #Celtic

 

@SimonPeach: Fonte on Van Dijk: "I know he's a good player, obviously. He's a guy that we've been linked to, but he's not here yet" #SaintsFC #Celtic

 

@SimonPeach: Fonte: "If (Van Dijk) comes, he'll add quality to the team & even more competition at the back, so it will be interesting" #SaintsFC #Celtic

 

Now we would be going ape**** if the captain of another club said that about one of our players.

Posted

Latest snippet I've heard, Celtic are trying to get a Scandinavian CB in so that Van Dijk can leave. We are after a loan signing plus a top midfielder with premiership experience.

Pinch of salt job from me.

Posted

@JongsmaJongsma: @SimonPeach In my humble opinion his potential is higher than that of Lovren and Alderweireld. Great on the ball, but good in duels too.

 

@JongsmaJongsma: @SimonPeach To clarify, he can operate 'on his own', doesn't need to be guided. Big difference with other two I think.

 

Jongsma is pretty knowledgeable so sounds good...

Posted
Latest snippet I've heard, Celtic are trying to get a Scandinavian CB in so that Van Dijk can leave. We are after a loan signing plus a top midfielder with premiership experience.

Pinch of salt job from me.

 

Any ideas on name for the midfielder?

Posted
@JongsmaJongsma: @SimonPeach In my humble opinion his potential is higher than that of Lovren and Alderweireld. Great on the ball, but good in duels too.

 

@JongsmaJongsma: @SimonPeach To clarify, he can operate 'on his own', doesn't need to be guided. Big difference with other two I think.

 

Jongsma is pretty knowledgeable so sounds good...

 

But he doesn't make it any cleaere that VVD will come to Saints, just that he's a good player.

Posted
Latest snippet I've heard, Celtic are trying to get a Scandinavian CB in so that Van Dijk can leave. We are after a loan signing plus a top midfielder with premiership experience.

Pinch of salt job from me.

 

Given Celtics track record of turning good players into £10m ones (Wanyama & VVD for two) perhaps we should just look to find out the proposed replacement and hijack the bid. Cut out the middleman as it were.

Posted
Latest snippet I've heard, Celtic are trying to get a Scandinavian CB in so that Van Dijk can leave. We are after a loan signing plus a top midfielder with premiership experience.

Pinch of salt job from me.

 

Alex Song?

Posted
@SimonPeach: Jose Fonte believes Virgil van Dijk would be a high-quality addition if #SaintsFC can coax the defender away from #Celtic

 

@SimonPeach: Fonte on Van Dijk: "I know he's a good player, obviously. He's a guy that we've been linked to, but he's not here yet" #SaintsFC #Celtic

 

@SimonPeach: Fonte: "If (Van Dijk) comes, he'll add quality to the team & even more competition at the back, so it will be interesting" #SaintsFC #Celtic

LOL.

 

I look forward to some genius on here telling me how this is, like, completely different to anything Steven Gerrard or Brendan Rodgers did with regard to our players previously. Because Liverpool are all evil and stuff and what Fonte has done here is, you know, fine. Obviously fine.

Posted
LOL.

 

I look forward to some genius on here telling me how this is, like, completely different to anything Steven Gerrard or Brendan Rodgers did with regard to our players previously. Because Liverpool are all evil and stuff and what Fonte has done here is, you know, fine. Obviously fine.

 

 

If you can't beat them........

 

Personally, I dislike the way players get tapped up by other players, but its understandable. Likewise with agents, they're c*nts but that's their job. What I can't stomach is tapping up by the national coach. Hodgsons comments before the big exodus were disgraceful, and as it turned out, somewhat misleading; anyone here think well see Lambert in an England shirt again now he's played for a "big" club?

Posted
LOL.

 

I look forward to some genius on here telling me how this is, like, completely different to anything Steven Gerrard or Brendan Rodgers did with regard to our players previously. Because Liverpool are all evil and stuff and what Fonte has done here is, you know, fine. Obviously fine.

Makes me think this is an authorised statement and the deal is done. Not like Jose to speak so candidly about another teams player.

 

Sent from my Nexus 10 using Tapatalk

Posted
LOL.

 

I look forward to some genius on here telling me how this is, like, completely different to anything Steven Gerrard or Brendan Rodgers did with regard to our players previously. Because Liverpool are all evil and stuff and what Fonte has done here is, you know, fine. Obviously fine.

 

This is completely different to anything Steven Gerrard or Brendan Rodgers did with regard to our players previously. The SPL is a Mickey Mouse league whose players we can fully expect to want a move to a proper league. Moving from Saints to a team 2-3 places higher in the same league is a very different thing.

Posted

Any chance the deals done but we're waiting for Celtic to finish their CL qualifying? Wouldn't seem wise for us to put all our eggs in 1 basket only to lose out 4 days before the transfer window shuts. A lot of things seem to suggest this to be the case.

Posted
This is completely different to anything Steven Gerrard or Brendan Rodgers did with regard to our players previously. The SPL is a Mickey Mouse league whose players we can fully expect to want a move to a proper league. Moving from Saints to a team 2-3 places higher in the same league is a very different thing.

 

Not if you're Mickey Mouse it isn't. Don't see the difference myself.

Posted

What I don't get is all this "Celtic waiting till they've qualified for The CL Group Stage" then will sell him.

Surely they'd want to keep their best players and hope to get through to the next stage, or are they basically admitting they can't get any further than that and will just milk the cash cow

and get some extra dosh in from Van Dijk as well, regardless of whether they qualify or not.

Either way it leaves them with a small window of opportunity (as it does us if we don't get him) to get a replacement in before the transfer window closes.

 

All rather strange.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...