Jump to content

Recommended Posts

Posted
  Horley CTFC Saint said:
I 'like' the comment "namesake seaside town" - bet that will go down well up the road :o

Thought it was very strange when I read it. There are 2 things wrong with referring to Southampton as a "seaside town". (1) It's not a town, (2) it's not by the sea side. Think those down the road will be laughing thinking of us being referred to as a seaside town. If you want a seaside town, think Boscombe.

Posted
  VectisSaint said:
Thought it was very strange when I read it. There are 2 things wrong with referring to Southampton as a "seaside town". (1) It's not a town, (2) it's not by the sea side. Think those down the road will be laughing thinking of us being referred to as a seaside town. If you want a seaside town, think Boscombe.

 

Could have sworn Southampton is by the sea

Posted
  Batman said:
Could have sworn Southampton is by the sea

 

No, it's a port-"town" at the top of an estuary which opens to the sea. The city itself isn't a "seaside" one.

Posted
  Pancake said:
No, it's a port-"town" at the top of an estuary which opens to the sea. The city itself isn't a "seaside" one.

 

So, by the sea then. Which is probably what they meant (clearly)

Posted
  Batman said:
Could have sworn Southampton is by the sea

Well, shows how wrong you can be, doesn't it. :rolleyes: The city is not by the sea.

If you want to be geographically accurate, Southampton Water is a drowned valley, or ria formed by the Rivers Test, Itchen and Hamble that flow into it.

Posted
  VectisSaint said:
Well, shows how wrong you can be, doesn't it. :rolleyes: The city is not by the sea.

If you want to be geographically accurate, Southampton Water is a drowned valley, or ria formed by the Rivers Test, Itchen and Hamble that flow into it.

 

It's an American report written by them, for them! The terminology may be strange to us but any seafaring town is probably close enough to a seaside town to Americans. Anyway, it's no less true of us, than say Sydney or San Francisco and we do have a beach (of sorts).

Posted
  eelpie said:
I remember going to Weston beach, and I expect to find it full of sunbathing Yanks after this article.

 

Used to be taken to Weston Shore as a toddler in the 1940s after a trip on the Floating Bridge

Posted
  buctootim said:
Its on the sea. The sea is the continuous body of water which covers the earth. First definition in most dictionaries.

The Saintsweb forum isn't renowend for accepting dictionary definitions....

Posted
  trousers said:
The Saintsweb forum isn't renowend for accepting dictionary definitions....

Southampton is the dictionary definition of a seaside town? Remind me to never go on holiday with you.

Posted
  Quote
Only on this forum could there be a serious discussion about whether Southampton is near the sea or not.

Only on this forum would English adults start pretending they'd never heard the expression "seaside town" before and then start making out that Southampton is one.

Posted
  ericb said:
That's probably because you chose to support a team based on a computer game

 

 

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

 

  hypochondriac said:
:lol: so true.

 

whereas you two went through a much more substantial and credible thought process - your parents decided to live there :mcinnes:

Posted
  ericb said:
That's probably because you chose to support a team based on a computer game

 

 

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

 

Thank you for reading my blog. By the way, did you check out the link in my post?

Posted
  buctootim said:
whereas you two went through a much more substantial and credible thought process - your parents decided to live there :mcinnes:

 

Well I've actually been to a game which I think should be a factor :lol:

Posted
  Danish Saint said:
Winner of the "How-far-off-the-original-topic-replies"-thread? :)

 

Thats a rash claim at too early a stage, given the intense competition for that title

Posted
  buctootim said:
whereas you two went through a much more substantial and credible thought process - your parents decided to live there :mcinnes:

 

I'm fourth generation Southampton so not just my parents.

 

But yeah supporting the team from where you're born is far more credible than choosing via a computer game thanks for pointing that out

 

 

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Posted
  Redslo said:
Thank you for reading my blog. By the way, did you check out the link in my post?

 

Correct me if I'm wrong but didn't I read in your blog that you are from that lovely seaside town, Los Angeles?

Posted

Southampton Water is an Estuary. An Estuary is a mix of fresh water from rivers and saline sea water. Hence the salinity in a estuary is not as great as that of the Sea.

 

It is correct to describe Southampton as "waterside" but not "sea side".

Posted
  Nolan said:
Southampton Water is an Estuary. An Estuary is a mix of fresh water from rivers and saline sea water. Hence the salinity in a estuary is not as great as that of the Sea.

 

It is correct to describe Southampton as "waterside" but not "sea side".

 

I would say 'seaport' rather than 'seaside', which has a rather sentimental meaning for the English invoking memories of buckets and spades, Punch and Judy, end-of-the-pier shows, that sort of thing.

Posted
  Nolan said:
Southampton Water is an Estuary. An Estuary is a mix of fresh water from rivers and saline sea water. Hence the salinity in a estuary is not as great as that of the Sea.

 

It is correct to describe Southampton as "waterside" but not "sea side".

 

Really? I must remember to refer to the Baltic Estuary in future

Posted
  buctootim said:
Really? I must remember to refer to the Baltic Estuary in future

 

or you could just call it a large Fjord.

Posted
  Picard said:
Correct me if I'm wrong but didn't I read in your blog that you are from that lovely seaside town, Los Angeles?

 

Accusing me of being from Los Angeles is worse than accusing you of being from Portsmouth. I am from San Francisco. (By the way, if you actually are from Portsmouth, I apologize. I am sorry you are from Portsmouth.)

Posted
  Redslo said:
Accusing me of being from Los Angeles is worse than accusing you of being from Portsmouth. I am from San Francisco. (By the way, if you actually are from Portsmouth, I apologize. I am sorry you are from Portsmouth.)

Aha another hick seaside town like Boscombe:lol:.

Actually, much like Southampton, not "by the sea" at all, but a major port city with a waterfront based on an estuary/drowned river valley/ria.

Posted
  Whitey Grandad said:
I would say 'seaport' rather than 'seaside', which has a rather sentimental meaning for the English invoking memories of buckets and spades, Punch and Judy, end-of-the-pier shows, that sort of thing.

 

Yeah Seaport. Its more about terminology than geography. Nobody would describe Liverpool, Cardiff, Bristol, Hull as seaside towns so why Southampton? Well, because it fits with the picture being portrayed in the article of some bunch of lightweights that have been propelled into the big boys club by Frau Liebherr.

Posted
  hypochondriac said:
Well I've actually been to a game which I think should be a factor :lol:

 

Fair play as you are obviously far younger than I had previously thought.

Posted
  VectisSaint said:
Aha another hick seaside town like Boscombe:lol:.

Actually, much like Southampton, not "by the sea" at all, but a major port city with a waterfront based on an estuary/drowned river valley/ria.

 

You are greatly understating San Francisco's seasideness.

 

https://www.google.com/maps/place/San+Francisco,+CA/@37.7577,-122.4376,12z/data=!3m1!4b1!4m2!3m1!1s0x80859a6d00690021:0x4a501367f076adff

 

Also, pretty cool how Liebherr has broken into that boys club, isn't it?

Posted

So for someone who works so tirelessly to provide sources and reasoning i had to have a laugh at the hilarity at your misinformed understanding having never been to Southampton. So here are some pictures to help.

 

Here is a seaside town called Exmouth, home of Jack Sparks. Note the sand.Exmouth_seafront_in_south_devon_arp.jpg

 

And here an overview of Southampton water, the city occupying the area between the confluence of the two rivers

 

https://m.flickr.com/photos/snapperz/5037015875/

Posted

What Redslo needs is a break.

 

He needs to experience a traditional British holiday at one of our lovely seaside towns like Middlesbrough or Hull.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...