Batman Posted 12 January, 2014 Posted 12 January, 2014 Man city 1-0 up at newcastle already cant see anyone else winning the league than them. Just so powerful all over the park newcastle, despite being on a very very good run are well within our sights
adrian lord Posted 12 January, 2014 Posted 12 January, 2014 Agree. Citeh in league of own with Chelsea next then Arse. Then the rest all the way down to us, headed by the 'pool.
Saint Garrett Posted 12 January, 2014 Posted 12 January, 2014 Yeah, I fully expect it'll be between City and Chelsea, said that at the start of the season. They seem to have sorted out their away form.
Saint Garrett Posted 12 January, 2014 Posted 12 January, 2014 What a goal from Tiote!! Edit: not given....definitely should be a goal that
Batman Posted 12 January, 2014 Author Posted 12 January, 2014 another howler this week what a shocker
adrian lord Posted 12 January, 2014 Posted 12 January, 2014 Shocking decision, the offside players were not interfering with play or sight lines. big club favoritism strikes again
adrian lord Posted 12 January, 2014 Posted 12 January, 2014 This season refereeing has plumbed new depths.
Batman Posted 12 January, 2014 Author Posted 12 January, 2014 This season refereeing has plumbed new depths. been saying for ages. every week there is an absolute howler still not seen another penalty given like we had against us v arsenal but that just now in newcastle was disgusting
Monk Posted 12 January, 2014 Posted 12 January, 2014 A horrific stay if true; It has been 13 months since an Englishman scored in the Premier League for Newcastle United.
Glasgow_Saint Posted 12 January, 2014 Posted 12 January, 2014 Yeah, I fully expect it'll be between City and Chelsea, said that at the start of the season. They seem to have sorted out their away form. Great insight mate Newcastle goal ruled out, not sure why!?
Olallana Posted 12 January, 2014 Posted 12 January, 2014 100% correct decision. Gouffran is involved in the play. If he doesn´t move ball hits him and dont end up in goal, therefore he IS involved in the situation.
thornhill_saints Posted 12 January, 2014 Posted 12 January, 2014 Terrible decision! If a player has to move out of the way of a ball once it's kicked - surely that's interfering with play????
SaintSteve Posted 12 January, 2014 Posted 12 January, 2014 100% correct decision. Gouffran is involved in the play. If he doesn´t move ball hits him and dont end up in goal, therefore he IS involved in the situation. That is not the Offside rule as it stands... its a clear goal. Otherwise we can claim that Aguerro goal against us should have been ruled out... Negredo had to move quickly to avoid it..
Olallana Posted 12 January, 2014 Posted 12 January, 2014 That is not the Offside rule as it stands... its a clear goal. Otherwise we can claim that Aguerro goal against us should have been ruled out... Negredo had to move quickly to avoid it.. Maybe the ref was wrong then rather than now. Richard Keys @richardajkeys 22m Mark Halsey says right call. 'Moving towards the ball or interfering with an opponent - off side'
Whitey Grandad Posted 12 January, 2014 Posted 12 January, 2014 If a player has to move out of the way of a ball once it's kicked - surely that's interfering with play???? Not at all, not impeding an opponent nor gaining an advantage. According to the modern version of the law the goal should have stood.
Whitey Grandad Posted 12 January, 2014 Posted 12 January, 2014 Maybe the ref was wrong then rather than now. Richard Keys @richardajkeys 22m Mark Halsey says right call. 'Moving towards the ball or interfering with an opponent - off side' Gouffran did neither, quite the opposite. To whom was Halsey referring?
Olallana Posted 12 January, 2014 Posted 12 January, 2014 Not at all, not impeding an opponent nor gaining an advantage. According to the modern version of the law the goal should have stood. So you dont think its an advantage that the ball ends up in net because of his movement? I think so honestly.
Whitey Grandad Posted 12 January, 2014 Posted 12 January, 2014 So you dont think its an advantage that the ball ends up in net because of his movement? I think so honestly. Gouffran got out of the way of the ball. If it had struck him then I would agree with you. In what way did his movement help the ball end up in the net? Hart wasn't distracted and had no chance of getting to the ball.
Olallana Posted 12 January, 2014 Posted 12 January, 2014 Gouffran got out of the way of the ball. If it had struck him then I would agree with you. In what way did his movement help the ball end up in the net? Hart wasn't distracted and had no chance of getting to the ball. IMO he gaines an advantage by moving out of the balls way. And thats why players in offside position cant let the ball go through their legs to an onside teammate and claim they didn´t play it. But it is a matter of opinions, agree about that. And the big problem is the rules that allows individual interpretations of it...
lifeintheslowlane Posted 12 January, 2014 Posted 12 January, 2014 Wow did he try to make up for his howler. How Cabaye stayed on the pitch I don't know...a booking followed by and other two bookable offenses in quick succession and got away with a stern finger wagging. The late challenge on Nasri was worth a sending off...all in all a stunningly inept refereeing performance.
Olallana Posted 12 January, 2014 Posted 12 January, 2014 Skrtel pulling down opponents when defending corners and not penalised......that´s a new....
Olallana Posted 12 January, 2014 Posted 12 January, 2014 Wow, that Crouch goal was Stokes first headed goal this season.... http://www.transfermarkt.co.uk/en/premier-league/torverteilung/wettbewerb_GB1.html
Dr Who? Posted 12 January, 2014 Posted 12 January, 2014 Looks like we could make that 8th or 9th slot our own.
Dr Who? Posted 12 January, 2014 Posted 12 January, 2014 I went for Chelsea at the start of the season so I will stick with them. Chelsea Derby Co Brentford S****horpe Luton Want it to be Arsenal Derby co Brentford Southend Cambridge
Badger Posted 12 January, 2014 Posted 12 January, 2014 Great OG. Jos has a rival for goal of the season ?
trousers Posted 12 January, 2014 Posted 12 January, 2014 (edited) Penalty to Liverpool. Looks a soft one. Gerrard scores.2-3 Edited 12 January, 2014 by trousers
trousers Posted 12 January, 2014 Posted 12 January, 2014 It looked worse than it was from the referee's angle of view
Sour Mash Posted 12 January, 2014 Posted 12 January, 2014 Gouffran got out of the way of the ball. If it had struck him then I would agree with you. In what way did his movement help the ball end up in the net? Hart wasn't distracted and had no chance of getting to the ball. Hart could well have assumed Gouffran was going to touch it and therefore Hart didn't dive for it. Who knows in less than a split second?
Glasgow_Saint Posted 12 January, 2014 Posted 12 January, 2014 We are due a few bad decisions from refs imho Im a believer that things even out over a season and as it stands we are 4-5 decisions up
trousers Posted 12 January, 2014 Posted 12 January, 2014 We are due a few bad decisions from refs imho Im a believer that things even out over a season and as it stands we are 4-5 decisions up You got a breakdown of those stats me ol' mucker? Much obliged
Whitey Grandad Posted 12 January, 2014 Posted 12 January, 2014 Hart could well have assumed Gouffran was going to touch it and therefore Hart didn't dive for it. Who knows in less than a split second? We shall never know, of course. Hart doesn't make anything of it at the time. The guidance from FIFA is: “interfering with an opponent” means preventing an opponent from playing or being able to play the ball by clearly obstructing the opponent’s line of vision or movements or making a gesture or movement which, in the opinion of the referee, deceives or distracts an opponent. It must have been the referee's decision although why we needed to go to his assistant I don't know.
Whitey Grandad Posted 12 January, 2014 Posted 12 January, 2014 Another utterly terrible decision Yeah, Sterling's looking at the ref before he even hits the ground. Very poor decision.
Dr Who? Posted 12 January, 2014 Posted 12 January, 2014 We are due a few bad decisions from refs imho Im a believer that things even out over a season and as it stands we are 4-5 decisions up Really?
Micky Posted 12 January, 2014 Posted 12 January, 2014 We are due a few bad decisions from refs imho Im a believer that things even out over a season and as it stands we are 4-5 decisions up Are you a professional turdtalker? Do you get paid to talk total dogshyte daily? Sent from my HTC One S using Tapatalk
Glasgow_Saint Posted 12 January, 2014 Posted 12 January, 2014 Really? Foul on the Burnley keeper before our 3rd Foul on WBA player in build up to our goal yesterday Think we have largely been lucky with decisions this season and seem to win majority of the 50/50's..... Good job too. Look at the stink after the Everton 'handball'
benjii Posted 12 January, 2014 Posted 12 January, 2014 Are you a professional turdtalker? Do you get paid to talk total dogshyte daily? Sent from my HTC One S using Tapatalk More tragically than that, it's just a hobby. What an idiot!
Olallana Posted 12 January, 2014 Posted 12 January, 2014 Foul on the Burnley keeper before our 3rd Foul on WBA player in build up to our goal yesterday Think we have largely been lucky with decisions this season and seem to win majority of the 50/50's..... Good job too. Look at the stink after the Everton 'handball' Yes those 2 evens out everything... All the wrestling John O´Shea was allowed to do. The blatant handball against Norwich. (And dont say anything about Norwichs penalty in the last seconds cause if the first one is given that never happens cause it only happened because we were desperately chasing in the final minutes) The offside for Man Uniteds goal. The handball (not 'handball', just simply handball) at Everton. And that´s just a few of those we can discuss.... Btw, which player fouled which yesterday in the run up for our goal? Something 5 minutes before the actual goal?
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now