Jump to content

Vincent Tan tells Malky Mackay to resign - or he'll be sacked


Saint-Armstrong

Recommended Posts

Followed by Yilmaz Vural (who?)

 

Just took a look at his management record...

 

1986–1988 Malatyaspor

1988–1989 Antalyaspor

1989 Samsunspor

1989–1990 Bursaspor

1990–1991 Karşıyaka S.K.

1991 Adanaspor

1991–1993 Bursaspor

1993–1994 Gaziantepspor

1995–1996 Eskişehirspor

1996–1997 Sarıyer

1997 Trabzonspor

1997–1998 Gençlerbirliği

1998–1999 Konyaspor

1999 Dardanelspor

1999–2000 Bursaspor

2000–2001 Denizlispor

2001 Diyarbakırspor

2003–2004 Adanaspor

2004 Çaykur Rizespor

2005 Ankaragücü

2005–2007 Antalyaspor

2008 Manisaspor

2008–2009 Kocaelispor

2009–2010 Kasımpaşa S.K.

2011 Konyaspor

2012 Sakaryaspor

2012–2013 Elazığspor

 

Stability then, yeah?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Just took a look at his management record...

 

1986–1988 Malatyaspor

1988–1989 Antalyaspor

1989 Samsunspor

1989–1990 Bursaspor

1990–1991 Karşıyaka S.K.

1991 Adanaspor

1991–1993 Bursaspor

1993–1994 Gaziantepspor

1995–1996 Eskişehirspor

1996–1997 Sarıyer

1997 Trabzonspor

1997–1998 Gençlerbirliği

1998–1999 Konyaspor

1999 Dardanelspor

1999–2000 Bursaspor

2000–2001 Denizlispor

2001 Diyarbakırspor

2003–2004 Adanaspor

2004 Çaykur Rizespor

2005 Ankaragücü

2005–2007 Antalyaspor

2008 Manisaspor

2008–2009 Kocaelispor

2009–2010 Kasımpaşa S.K.

2011 Konyaspor

2012 Sakaryaspor

2012–2013 Elazığspor

 

Stability then, yeah?

 

Oh please, please let this happen...

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Wasn't he a the left back around the golden period of Croatian footy with Suker, Boban etc?

Yep.

 

As mentioned above, once signed for Coventry from Real Betis but was then sold on to Real Madrid before he made an appearance - it seems as though Betis wouldn't deal with Madrid, so Madrid's solution was to basically use Coventry as a middle-man!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

While the vast majority of football fans recognise the lunacy of Vincent Tan it is probably true to acknowledge that there will be many managers out there who will fancy the position. Let's face it, get the job, put up with the gob, take the payout. It will hardly blemish your C.V. that you tried to work for a megalomaniac and failed!

 

The problem, for Cardiff fans, is that they are tied to the club, just like us, it's an emotion and a calling. They'll not walk away from it in vast numbers, just like Saints fans, they love the club.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Am I the only one that thinks the FA should take their fair share of blame for allowing the likes of Tan to pass the fit and proper person test?

Probably.

 

Firstly, it's not the FA's test, it's the Premier League and Football League (who each have their own, slightly different, tests).

 

Secondly, those tests are to ensure that the people attempting to buy football clubs are neither criminals (to prevent money laundering, etc) or proven incompetent when it comes to managing finances in football. They are not designed to subjectively decide whether an owner is a bit mental.

 

Wind the clock back a few years to when Tan bought Cardiff - they were on the verge of going bust. If the FAPP Test was subjective as you seem to suggest it should be, and Tan's takeover was blocked because the Football League thought he might be a bit of a mentalist, and as a result Cardiff went out of business, I think it's fair to say the FL would be taking a large share of the blame.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Probably.

 

Firstly, it's not the FA's test, it's the Premier League and Football League (who each have their own, slightly different, tests).

 

Secondly, those tests are to ensure that the people attempting to buy football clubs are neither criminals (to prevent money laundering, etc) or proven incompetent when it comes to managing finances in football. They are not designed to subjectively decide whether an owner is a bit mental.

 

Wind the clock back a few years to when Tan bought Cardiff - they were on the verge of going bust. If the FAPP Test was subjective as you seem to suggest it should be, and Tan's takeover was blocked because the Football League thought he might be a bit of a mentalist, and as a result Cardiff went out of business, I think it's fair to say the FL would be taking a large share of the blame.

 

....and if a child maiming gun runner and bank robber can pass it then Tan will with flying colours

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Can you imagine Redknapp working for Tan? :lol:

 

He's got it pretty cushty at QPR, he has an owner who basically bows down to his every demand, regardless of how ridiculous it is and/or how much it costs.

 

Lennon would be my guess for Cardiff.

 

Well he hasnt done too bad cutting the wage bill and getting them into a championship title race.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Surely Cardiff fans will be defending Tan on the forums, they will be reminding everyone where the club was 4 years ago and without him they might not have a club to support. Mackay is just a department head and everything about the success the club has enjoyed is totally down to the chairman.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Surely Cardiff fans will be defending Tan on the forums, they will be reminding everyone where the club was 4 years ago and without him they might not have a club to support. Mackay is just a department head and everything about the success the club has enjoyed is totally down to the chairman.

 

:lol:

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Surely Cardiff fans will be defending Tan on the forums, they will be reminding everyone where the club was 4 years ago and without him they might not have a club to support. Mackay is just a department head and everything about the success the club has enjoyed is totally down to the chairman.

 

Showing lack of understanding the situation and how well we have done again young man ;)

 

I will explain the differences for you so you can be more cheery about how saints are doing and less cynical and miserable...

 

Tan came in (2010) Cardiff were 4th in championship. They were not in administration.

 

Year later he took them to....4th!

 

A year later down to 6th! (Not much success so far!)

 

A year later 1st

 

Half year later 15th in prem.

 

 

So in those 3 ½ season they have climbed 9 places.

 

When Cortese / Liebherr came in we were in administration.

 

We were 24th in league one.

A year later we were 5th

A year later we were 2nd in league 1

A year later we were 2nd in champ

A year later we were 14th in prem

½ year later we are 9th.

 

So each full year we have progressed more than Tan has in total. So don't think fans anywhere will see his success as in same league as our owners

 

Sent from my Nexus 4 using Tapatalk

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Showing lack of understanding the situation and how well we have done again young man ;)

 

I will explain the differences for you so you can be more cheery about how saints are doing and less cynical and miserable...

 

Tan came in (2010) Cardiff were 4th in championship. They were not in administration.

 

Year later he took them to....4th!

 

A year later down to 6th! (Not much success so far!)

 

A year later 1st

 

Half year later 15th in prem.

 

 

So in those 3 ½ season they have climbed 9 places.

 

When Cortese / Liebherr came in we were in administration.

 

We were 24th in Championship.

A year later we were 7th in league 1

A year later we were 2nd in league 1

A year later we were 2nd in champ

A year later we were 14th in prem

½ year later we are 9th.

 

So each full year we have progressed more than Tan has in total. So don't think fans anywhere will see his success as in same league as our owners

 

Sent from my Nexus 4 using Tapatalk

 

FTFY

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Showing lack of understanding the situation and how well we have done again young man ;)

 

I will explain the differences for you so you can be more cheery about how saints are doing and less cynical and miserable...

 

Tan came in (2010) Cardiff were 4th in championship. They were not in administration.

 

Year later he took them to....4th!

 

A year later down to 6th! (Not much success so far!)

 

A year later 1st

 

Half year later 15th in prem.

 

 

So in those 3 ½ season they have climbed 9 places.

 

When Cortese / Liebherr came in we were in administration.

 

We were 24th in league one.

A year later we were 5th

A year later we were 2nd in league 1

A year later we were 2nd in champ

A year later we were 14th in prem

½ year later we are 9th.

 

So each full year we have progressed more than Tan has in total. So don't think fans anywhere will see his success as in same league as our owners

 

Sent from my Nexus 4 using Tapatalk

 

also when cortese ruthlessly fired both pards and adkins, he didnt play games first but just pulled the trigger. the second time around he learnt from his mistake of leaving us in limbo whilst securing his next manager.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Our Tan was the pioneer and currently the only case study of "them Orientals love a red kit, they do. All forward thinking clubs are changing to all red to make untold millions all over Oriental-land. I mean, look at Cardiff"

 

Tan was the forum sweetheart only a few months ago as a groundbreaking red kit pioneer. I am disappointed this hero-worship hasn't translated into more support from the forum visionaries. How quickly you turn.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Ah the old look where we are now routine has appeared,

 

4 Years ago

League 1

- 10

Oldham away

Colchester away

Ryan Dickson

Our journey

Markus

Academy

4th highest spenders in Europe

Champions League football in 5 years

Never been relegated under Cortese

For Markus

Liebherr family

Iron will

Lego head

 

 

All in there now.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Ah the old look where we are now routine has appeared,

 

4 Years ago

League 1

- 10

Oldham away

Colchester away

Ryan Dickson

Our journey

Markus

Academy

4th highest spenders in Europe

Champions League football in 5 years

Never been relegated under Cortese

For Markus

Liebherr family

Iron will

Lego head

 

 

All in there now.

 

Would you prefer it if Lowe was still in charge????

 

Dutch duo

£90,000

Catering

Rapid turnover of managers

4th in Premier League on Christmas day

Hollow day out at Wembley in pointless cup

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Would you prefer it if Lowe was still in charge????

 

Dutch duo

£90,000

Catering

Rapid turnover of managers

4th in Premier League on Christmas day

Hollow day out at Wembley in pointless cup

 

Of course not, clappers use it as deflector shield against anything perceived negative.

 

We play poorly - We were playing Plymouth 4 years ago

We sign someone crap - Back to back promotions

We play Danny Fox - Look how far we have come

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Tan was the forum sweetheart only a few months ago as a groundbreaking red kit pioneer. I am disappointed this hero-worship hasn't translated into more support from the forum visionaries. How quickly you turn.

 

Name names. Who were these "forum visionairies" ??

Link to comment
Share on other sites

also when cortese ruthlessly fired both pards and adkins, he didnt play games first but just pulled the trigger. the second time around he learnt from his mistake of leaving us in limbo whilst securing his next manager.

 

Also, Cortese doesn't try to model himself on Mr Chow from the hangover ... Mother f*ckers ...

Link to comment
Share on other sites

also when cortese ruthlessly fired both pards and adkins, he didnt play games first but just pulled the trigger. the second time around he learnt from his mistake of leaving us in limbo whilst securing his next manager.

 

Well that isn't true. Its one of the worst kept secrets in SFC history that both Pardew and Adkins were dead men walking long before they were fired.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Showing lack of understanding the situation and how well we have done again young man ;)

 

I will explain the differences for you so you can be more cheery about how saints are doing and less cynical and miserable...

 

Tan came in (2010) Cardiff were 4th in championship. They were not in administration.

 

Year later he took them to....4th!

 

A year later down to 6th! (Not much success so far!)

 

A year later 1st

 

Half year later 15th in prem.

 

 

So in those 3 ½ season they have climbed 9 places.

 

When Cortese / Liebherr came in we were in administration.

 

We were 24th in league one.

A year later we were 5th

A year later we were 2nd in league 1

A year later we were 2nd in champ

A year later we were 14th in prem

½ year later we are 9th.

 

So each full year we have progressed more than Tan has in total. So don't think fans anywhere will see his success as in same league as our owners

 

Sent from my Nexus 4 using Tapatalk

 

They also have a league title to their name, one better than Nicola '2nd place' Cortese

The all red kit to appeal the zillions of people china

Spent more than us this summer - ambition and resources

Expanding their stadium - when is the one we so desperately need going to happen? More hot air from 2nd place

Climbed 9 places out of an available 24 and doing better than we were at the same stage in our first season back in top flight

Keeps the fans updated with what is going on

Let's not make out promotion from league one is a massive achievement from a chairman or back to back promotions for that matter, even Delia Smith managed that, she's achieved more than second place without the backing of billionaires!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Would you prefer it if Lowe was still in charge????

 

Dutch duo

£90,000

Catering

Rapid turnover of managers

4th in Premier League on Christmas day

Hollow day out at Wembley in pointless cup

 

Id have happily swapped the entire cup run and final for finishing 7th that season, that extra place would have helped us so much more as a club.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

They also have a league title to their name, one better than Nicola '2nd place' Cortese

The all red kit to appeal the zillions of people china

Spent more than us this summer - ambition and resources

Expanding their stadium - when is the one we so desperately need going to happen? More hot air from 2nd place

Climbed 9 places out of an available 24 and doing better than we were at the same stage in our first season back in top flight

Keeps the fans updated with what is going on

Let's not make out promotion from league one is a massive achievement from a chairman or back to back promotions for that matter, even Delia Smith managed that, she's achieved more than second place without the backing of billionaires!

 

If anyone ever doubted you enjoy moaning cynically and trolling....

 

Happy christmas

 

Sent from my Nexus 4 using Tapatalk

Link to comment
Share on other sites

If anyone ever doubted you enjoy moaning cynically and trolling....

 

Happy christmas

 

Sent from my Nexus 4 using Tapatalk

 

Why is it trolling to point out Cardiff chairmans achievements against our own? If I went on their forum I reckon now they backing tan and his plans not spend in January. now they are 15th one of their posters will be claiming their current squad is good enough for 6th anyway.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Just took a look at his management record...

 

1986–1988 Malatyaspor

1988–1989 Antalyaspor

1989 Samsunspor

1989–1990 Bursaspor

1990–1991 Karşıyaka S.K.

1991 Adanaspor

1991–1993 Bursaspor

1993–1994 Gaziantepspor

1995–1996 Eskişehirspor

1996–1997 Sarıyer

1997 Trabzonspor

1997–1998 Gençlerbirliği

1998–1999 Konyaspor

1999 Dardanelspor

1999–2000 Bursaspor

2000–2001 Denizlispor

2001 Diyarbakırspor

2003–2004 Adanaspor

2004 Çaykur Rizespor

2005 Ankaragücü

2005–2007 Antalyaspor

2008 Manisaspor

2008–2009 Kocaelispor

2009–2010 Kasımpaşa S.K.

2011 Konyaspor

2012 Sakaryaspor

2012–2013 Elazığspor

 

Stability then, yeah?

 

 

That would **** off the cardiff fans, they would have to be Cardiffspor to fit in.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Our Tan was the pioneer and currently the only case study of "them Orientals love a red kit, they do. All forward thinking clubs are changing to all red to make untold millions all over Oriental-land. I mean, look at Cardiff"

 

Tan was the forum sweetheart only a few months ago as a groundbreaking red kit pioneer. I am disappointed this hero-worship hasn't translated into more support from the forum visionaries. How quickly you turn.

The red kit is fine by me, I get tired of seeing people wearing red and white stripes and only when you get close seeing that they are Stoke, Sunderland or Exeter fans. If it is hard for me to tell it must be really difficult for fans abroad who are not so seeing the subtle differences.
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Well that isn't true. Its one of the worst kept secrets in SFC history that both Pardew and Adkins were dead men walking long before they were fired.

Without a doubt

If you listened to the post match interview with Adkins on Solent after the Coventry promotion game Adkins pretty much knew he was in the snipers sights as soon as the ref blew the final whistle: very strange to listen to at the time.

As mentioned before I have a friend who got invited to one of those Cortese dinners, and it was revealed there that Markus wanted Pardew out sooner than he was, but Nicola persuaded him against that. Pardew shot himself in the foot ultimately by being seen to take the teams foot off the gas after winning the JPT.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.
×
×
  • Create New...