Jump to content

Gaston to Genoa (Loan)


Saint Garrett

Recommended Posts

Perhaps he'll go and score goals and return to us when he's playing well? He is still very young, and a damn good player when on form (despite what some overweight, balding expert sitting on his arse in the Austrian mountains thinks) so still lots of time to turn it around with Saints.

 

Shame if he does go off on loan, especially as now that there aren't any International matches until March (not gospel just quoting somebody else!!),

that has seen him jetting off around the globe for WC qualifiers every 2 weeks or so!!

 

A good chance to get himself sorted out and establish himself back into the squad. Lots of matches coming up next month where injuries and suspensions could kick in pretty fast.

 

Lets remember he didn't do the pre season warm up with us and due to injury and WC duty has barely had anytime to train with us week in week out. an uninterrupted run of training with us might get him up to speed.

 

Blue line, fresh start for me. If by Jan, still no improvement proceed with loan / sell, but it would be foolish to go ahead until we can geta replacement in.

Edited by ericofarabia
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Id look to sell not loan - get rid and invest in someone new/fit for purpose. Our squad looks thin and we will start to get injuries and suspensions very soon

 

Not at all surprised by this - saw him play alot for Bologna and during the delirium when he signed I was the quiet voice that said i didnt see him making it in the prem or longterm with us (took the normal stick for it, but hey ho)

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Id look to sell not loan - get rid and invest in someone new/fit for purpose. Our squad looks thin and we will start to get injuries and suspensions very soon

 

Not at all surprised by this - saw him play alot for Bologna and during the delirium when he signed I was the quiet voice that said i didnt see him making it in the prem or longterm with us (took the normal stick for it, but hey ho)

 

Let me guess you put a tenner on him going to Genoa....obviously

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Id look to sell not loan - get rid and invest in someone new/fit for purpose. Our squad looks thin and we will start to get injuries and suspensions very soon

 

Not at all surprised by this - saw him play alot for Bologna and during the delirium when he signed I was the quiet voice that said i didnt see him making it in the prem or longterm with us (took the normal stick for it, but hey ho)

 

Are you any good at picking winners at the track?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Id look to sell not loan - get rid and invest in someone new/fit for purpose. Our squad looks thin and we will start to get injuries and suspensions very soon

 

Not at all surprised by this - saw him play alot for Bologna and during the delirium when he signed I was the quiet voice that said i didnt see him making it in the prem or longterm with us (took the normal stick for it, but hey ho)

 

I think it's about time people started to listen to you a bit more pal, you've got an eye for a player and certainly have a great knowledge of the game which is usually dismisses as trolling by the flag waving keyboard tappers. Did you spot anyone at Celtic v Milan last night that would be worth us having a look at?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I think it's about time people started to listen to you a bit more pal, you've got an eye for a player and certainly have a great knowledge of the game which is usually dismisses as trolling by the flag waving keyboard tappers. Did you spot anyone at Celtic v Milan last night that would be worth us having a look at?

 

Thank you mate - this forum can sometimes be cruel, its like being the clever/attractive kid at school & everyone picks on him because they are jealous that he is clever and good with the ladies! Jealousy is ugly and ruins alot of good threads imho

 

No massive stand outs from last night - unless we can transfer some passionate Celtic support to SMS? What a great atmosphere!!

 

Player wise Cristián Zapata looked very good at CB - I saw him play alot for Villarreal and Udinese before he joined ACM and this boy has talent! I had mentioned him on the HCDAJFU thread a few times, but he joined ACM for £5m in July so missed out. Him and Lovren would be superb together

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Thank you mate - this forum can sometimes be cruel, its like being the clever/attractive kid at school & everyone picks on him because they are jealous that he is clever and good with the ladies! Jealousy is ugly and ruins alot of good threads imho

 

would you know what it feels like being the clever/attractive kid, I was told you and Rebecca Adlington were twins
Link to comment
Share on other sites

A real shame when he moves on in my opinion as he has shown in glimpses that he is an excellent technical player (eg. great tekkers for his League Cup this season) and can really make an impact in games - Aston Villa and Newcastle home games spring to mind from last year.

 

unfortunately, he just hasn't done it enough to date and with MP's style now clearly imprinted on the team, he doesn't seem to fit the bill either, unless he showed a real change in attitude towards the work he does when we haven't got the ball.

 

Disappointing as he was such a marquee signing for us that I couldn't really believe we had pulled off at the time - probably shouldn't underestimate that impact in terms of paving the way for the likes of Lovren, Wanyama and Osvaldo this year.

 

If he goes, we definitely need to replace him - in contrast to MP's recent chat about not getting involved in the January transfer window

Link to comment
Share on other sites

As I have mentioned a number of times, Moussa Dembele should be the type of player we are looking to bring in. Spurs aren't using him regularly so a cheeky bid would be good.

 

Real shame about Gaston, but obviously Mopo doesn't rate him. I have no doubt if Nige was still here that he'd be playing, but we also wouldn't be anywhere near where we are in the League.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Disappointing as he was such a marquee signing for us that I couldn't really believe we had pulled off at the time - probably shouldn't underestimate that impact in terms of paving the way for the likes of Lovren, Wanyama and Osvaldo this year.

 

That's a really good point.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

If he goes, we definitely need to replace him - in contrast to MP's recent chat about not getting involved in the January transfer window

Why do we need to replace him if he goes? He does not fit the system so he (and his ilk, i.e a #10) are surplus to requirements. We do not need a replacement for him. It could be argued according to the article that Osvaldo is his replacement. If you mean we need another player in the squad then I assume that will be covered by a youngster. hence why Poch has said we will not be delving into the market in January.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Not sure if posted elsewhere...

 

http://web.orange.co.uk

22 November 2013, 9:46

 

Ramirez staying - Pochettino

 

Mauricio Pochettino insists Gaston Ramirez will not be leaving Southampton in January and has warned him to "work hard to be part of the team".

The Uruguayan has yet to justify his £12million price tag after arriving from Bologna in the summer of 2012 and reports suggest he is growing unsettled at St Mary's.

Ramirez's representative has previously suggested the player did not like Pochettino and this week suggested Inter Milan were interested in the attacking midfielder - talk the Saints boss played down ahead of Saturday's trip to Arsenal.

 

"Gaston knows perfectly what I think and I know what he thinks," he said. "That's a private matter between us. He is fully obliged to fulfil his contract.

"That's all he has to do as a Southampton player. He has to work in order to fulfil that contract and be part of the team."

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

To me that's not a positive statement on Ramirez at all.

 

Yeah, when that came out during the press conference last week, I was more convinced Gaston won't last much longer here. Nothing in that statement suggests MP thinks he has much of a part to play here or even that they like each other.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Sell him or make him sit on the bench no loans thanks !

 

Time to get rid, a complete and utter waste of money.

 

No matter how hard people try and justify his ability, still harking back to 2 performances against poor Newcastle and villa peformances, he has been a complete and utter wash out. He's going to become the new Antonio or Billy Sharpe getting better and better in peoples minds the less he plays. If he goes on loan, we'll get the predictable calls for him to return, as if he's some sort of messiah. The bloke struggled when he came, struggled to get in the side and is now even struggling to make the match day squad. It used to be his age, then he was new to English football, then Nigel didn't know how to use him , now mp "doesn't like him", he's travelling a lot for world cup qualification games,he doesn't suit our system. Perhaps we should run a sweepstake on what the next excuse will be. People should take off the rose coloured glasses and accept he's not very good and that's why he can't get a game. Lets get rid,get as much money as the mugs are wiling to pay and move on.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Time to get rid, a complete and utter waste of money.

 

No matter how hard people try and justify his ability, still harking back to 2 performances against poor Newcastle and villa peformances, he has been a complete and utter wash out. He's going to become the new Antonio or Billy Sharpe getting better and better in peoples minds the less he plays. If he goes on loan, we'll get the predictable calls for him to return, as if he's some sort of messiah. The bloke struggled when he came, struggled to get in the side and is now even struggling to make the match day squad. It used to be his age, then he was new to English football, then Nigel didn't know how to use him , now mp "doesn't like him", he's travelling a lot for world cup qualification games,he doesn't suit our system. Perhaps we should run a sweepstake on what the next excuse will be. People should take off the rose coloured glasses and accept he's not very good and that's why he can't get a game. Lets get rid,get as much money as the mugs are wiling to pay and move on.

 

Can I be the first to say Lord Duckhunter - an excellent post and along with the long article the thread linked to

On the first post and very accurate appraisal of the situation....

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Time to get rid, a complete and utter waste of money.

 

Selling him BEFORE the World Cup would be even more of a waste of money. Get him showcased first, then flog him. Assuming he hasn't turned into an excellent, hard-working presser by then of course.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Selling him BEFORE the World Cup would be even more of a waste of money. Get him showcased first, then flog him. Assuming he hasn't turned into an excellent, hard-working presser by then of course.

 

Do you really believe that he's going to play like a drain for 2 seasons and then light up the world cup? It does happen occasionally, but from what I've read he's flattered to deceive whilst playing internationals. I would say sell before clubs see him in brazil , and realise he's really not that good.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I am justified on judging him on what I have seen and my judgement is that he is crap,lazy,lethargic and a waste of money......a bit like a bad berbatov.

Why the hell do we spend good money on players that have to travel thousands of miles each year to be available for their national sides is beyond me,you could justify it if he was doing the business for us like Suarez does for Liverpool but he isn't,he spends most of his time sitting in the stands,on the bench or in an aeroplane seat.

Good luck to the buying club.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I am justified on judging him on what I have seen and my judgement is that he is crap,lazy,lethargic and a waste of money......a bit like a bad berbatov.

Why the hell do we spend good money on players that have to travel thousands of miles each year to be available for their national sides is beyond me,you could justify it if he was doing the business for us like Suarez does for Liverpool but he isn't,he spends most of his time sitting in the stands,on the bench or in an aeroplane seat.

Good luck to the buying club.

 

He is far from crap and certainly not lazy.

 

It's such an easy thing to say about a #10 that they are "lazy", but if you have actually watched him you can see he isn't.

 

Yes, it's debatable whether he fits our system now, I'm starting to think there isn't a role for him in our style of play under MP. And yes, he hasn't delivered fully since he's been here, which is disappointing - as he is clearly a talented footballer, far from 'crap'.

 

Despite this, he still contributed a higher combined tally of goals and assists last season than Jason Puncheon (in less games), and matched that of Adam Lallana (again in less games).

 

I think he probably will move on sooner or later, and this move hasn't worked out for him as hoped, but this crap, lazy, lethargic stuff is just utter nonsense.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Based on what?

 

The only thing that's clear is he's not good enough for the Premier league. Mr Woo is clearly talented, but that doesn't make him a talented footballer.

 

Yeah, that Uruguay national team is awful.

 

I bet when he leaves he will go to a second tier team.

 

Funny how the teams he is apparently linked with are teams like Inter (awful), Fiorentina (awful) and Galatasary (awful).

 

Get that Jason Puncheon back from Palace!

Edited by KelvinsRightGlove
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Based on what?

 

The only thing that's clear is he's not good enough for the Premier league. Mr Woo is clearly talented, but that doesn't make him a talented footballer.

Oh dear... Ramirez has undoubted ability... certainly more than most in the EPL.. there must be something we do not know that is preventing him displaying his undoubted talent.. and its a real shame as he could have made our goals for much higher.. and this is our key problem this season

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Based on what?

 

The only thing that's clear is he's not good enough for the Premier league. Mr Woo is clearly talented, but that doesn't make him a talented footballer.

Can't believe that someone really does not understand that gaston is a talented footballer, must assume you are just a WUM. He may not fit into our system and may not have displayed some of the qualities that we would have liked, may not have sttled in England, may not have adapted to the PL and so on, but doubting his talent is just plain barmy.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Agustín Delgado was talented.

 

I couldn't give a flying **** whether he is wanted by Inter , Fiorentina or Galatasary, couldn't give a **** whether he plays for Uruguay ( James Milner plays for England) , all I'm interested in is whether he is any good playing for Southampton. And he quite clearly is not. It makes me laugh how we hear he cant fit into our system or cant play in England. People should stop making excuses for him because, we do play in England and have had 2 different Managers with different systems , yet still he doesn't perform.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Agustín Delgado was talented.

 

I couldn't give a flying **** whether he is wanted by Inter , Fiorentina or Galatasary, couldn't give a **** whether he plays for Uruguay ( James Milner plays for England) , all I'm interested in is whether he is any good playing for Southampton. And he quite clearly is not. It makes me laugh how we hear he cant fit into our system or cant play in England. People should stop making excuses for him because, we do play in England and have had 2 different Managers with different systems , yet still he doesn't perform.

 

You asked on what, I gave you some reasons, and now you couldn't give a flying f. Nice.

 

We should just stick to proper English players that run around a lot and contribute less. None of them Carlos Kickballs. BRING BACK PUNCHEON!!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

It really doesn't matter if any of us think Gaston is not a good enough player because Southampton Football Club clearly think he is, otherwise a) they wouldn't have bought him or b) they would have sold him in the summer.

It is therefore up to not just Gaston but also the coaching staff to realize the potential they think he has.

How long do you give a player in this situation with this price tag?

Some do not have much patience. I imagine some Spurs fans would have wanted rid of Gareth Bale when they were losing every time he played. It took him a while.

I reckon 2 seasons is probably enough. With the number of games coming up he will surely get some game time soon and who knows he may make the doubters eat their words.

If not I would sell in the summer. Lets hope Uruguay do well.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Agustín Delgado was talented.

 

I couldn't give a flying **** whether he is wanted by Inter , Fiorentina or Galatasary, couldn't give a **** whether he plays for Uruguay ( James Milner plays for England) , all I'm interested in is whether he is any good playing for Southampton. And he quite clearly is not. It makes me laugh how we hear he cant fit into our system or cant play in England. People should stop making excuses for him because, we do play in England and have had 2 different Managers with different systems , yet still he doesn't perform.

 

He did well under Adkins so that's not true.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

 

We should just stick to proper English players that run around a lot and contribute less. None of them Carlos Kickballs. BRING BACK PUNCHEON!!

 

We should stick to players that perform in the English league, whether they're English or not is irrelevant.

 

Had Harry Redknapp signed Gaston for QPR and he played for them like he played for us, would you be sticking up for him quite as much? I suggest that the majority opinion would be that old Arry had been mugged off, or had some sort of deal with his agent. I bet you cant find many neutrals who share the over inflated opinion of Gaston that some on here have.

 

Puncheon isn't good enough either, so I don't know what he's got to do with anything.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...