Jump to content

Artur Boruc


niemi14

Recommended Posts

As a goalkeeper myself and coach, in my opinion we have one of the best goalkeepers in the Premier League and feel it is no coincidence we have kept 4 clean sheets in 6 games. After a shaky start, he looks solid, commands his area and has a calming presence on the defence. I'd put him right up there with Niemi!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Spot on. He just never looks fazed or nervous, confident to receive the ball a his feet even when under pressure. I think him and Lovren, who never stops talking to those around him have really steadied the ship which has meant that we can pick up 3 points when were not firing on all cylinders up top where as last season we would have to score 2 or 3 due to our defensive frailties.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

and to think people, including Adkins, thought PG was a better option than him....

 

When Boruc was 2 stone overweight and had zero match sharpness Adkins wasn't far wrong.

 

Adkins gambled on KD being good enough for the PL as a reward for his service to the club, it unfortunately became clear rather quickly that he shouldn't be anywhere near the first-team in this league. We were left with a rookie that wasn't good enough and a completely out-of-form, overweight Boruc.

 

Boruc was no better than KD or PG in bhis early days here but fortunately Adkins and co. managed to get him in shape and match sharp on the training ground, and we've never looked back since.

 

That said we could do with a stronger back-up GK unless Cropper or PG make serious progress in the next few years

Link to comment
Share on other sites

When Boruc was 2 stone overweight and had zero match sharpness Adkins wasn't far wrong.

 

Adkins gambled on KD being good enough for the PL as a reward for his service to the club, it unfortunately became clear rather quickly that he shouldn't be anywhere near the first-team in this league. We were left with a rookie that wasn't good enough and a completely out-of-form, overweight Boruc.

 

Boruc was no better than KD or PG in bhis early days here but fortunately Adkins and co. managed to get him in shape and match sharp on the training ground, and we've never looked back since.

 

That said we could do with a stronger back-up GK unless Cropper or PG make serious progress in the next few years

prettyunfair on KD, he was behind a new defence and we were not solid. I agreed that we needed a change but when KD was called upon in the second half when Boruc was injured KD made a match winning save to keep us in front. I am very happy with Boruc but KD does not deserve disrespect
Link to comment
Share on other sites

prettyunfair on KD, he was behind a new defence and we were not solid. I agreed that we needed a change but when KD was called upon in the second half when Boruc was injured KD made a match winning save to keep us in front. I am very happy with Boruc but KD does not deserve disrespect

 

Well said. KD has been a great servant for the club and will always do his duty when called upon. Even now i`m happy to have him as number 2. People forget that he could have gone to the pre when the **** hit the fan and yet he stayed loyal. The man is a true saint and I would almost have him at the top of this page tbh... Disrespecting him is totally unfair!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Not that ago , most of the helmets on here were saying how bad he was and would cost us points... with only a few sticking their necks out to say he's probably one of the best GK's we've had in recent history.

 

Interesting how views change....or start.

 

After his first couple of appearances there was not a single person who said he was probably one of our best GKs.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Not that ago , most of the helmets on here were saying how bad he was and would cost us points... with only a few sticking their necks out to say he's probably one of the best GK's we've had in recent history.

 

Interesting how views change....or start.

Can't remember there being too much moaning about Boruc at all.
Link to comment
Share on other sites

After his first couple of appearances there was not a single person who said he was probably one of our best GKs.

 

I agree he did not have a good start...and yes it was probably a couple of games..but most of the negative comments 'likely' appeared from people who don't know football outside of the city and hadn't heard of him.

Quite frankly, I couldn't believe he signed for us ...bloody international regular, champions league GK who was first choice for Fiorentina and Celtic before that entering his peak years at 31 years old, 6'4 commanding presence.. ....but most seemed to be written off after 180 minutes of first team football after missing an entire pre season.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

 

Boruc was no better than KD or PG in bhis early days here but fortunately Adkins and co. managed to get him in shape and match sharp on the training ground, and we've never looked back since.

 

That said we could do with a stronger back-up GK unless Cropper or PG make serious progress in the next few years

 

 

I've noted that a many Prem. sides have at least two international goalies on their staff.

 

Like many on here, I am very impressed with Boruc's progress, although KD might be OK for a one.off sub. He's no candidate in the longer term, (though his contract is well-earned for his previous service.)

 

It might be that " a bit of competition " could keep Boruc on his toes, but holding his current form .....I don't to see that as a problem at the moment.

 

However, we do need experienced back-up, (in case of serious injury)... and I can't think of one in the UK...or ?

 

Gazzaniga was Adkins' gamble, and it didn't come off and neither he or KD are good enough in the long term.

 

Cody Cropper is slowly making his way into the USA sqaud, but is still a long way off serious consideration, and couple of heavy defeats this season, when standing for the U21's doesn't inspire confidence.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

which teams do?

 

well I should think that; Arsenal, Tottenham, Chelsea, Aston Villa, West.Brom and Stoke certainly do.....and there may be more, but if you don't believe it, sorry I don't have the time to convince you.

 

(one might argue that De Gea is not a full Spanish international but he does have 27 U21 caps, but as Man.U's first choice keeper he surely has some international level experience (?) but Lindegaard has certainly played in goal for Denmark.)

 

The main point is that any team with pretentions to Euro football cannot rely on the form and fitness of only one keeper, no matter how good, and I'm sure it must be in MP's mind if he's considering that.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

well I should think that; Arsenal, Tottenham, Chelsea, Aston Villa, West.Brom and Stoke certainly do.....and there may be more, but if you don't believe it, sorry I don't have the time to convince you.

 

(one might argue that De Gea is not a full Spanish international but he does have 27 U21 caps, but as Man.U's first choice keeper he surely has some international level experience (?) but Lindegaard has certainly played in goal for Denmark.)

 

The main point is that any team with pretentions to Euro football cannot rely on the form and fitness of only one keeper, no matter how good, and I'm sure it must be in MP's mind if he's considering that.

spurs dont

arsenal dont

WBA?

villa?

 

erm, most teams dont

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I will explain my view on things.

 

Everton Gazza

http://www.caughtoffside.com/2012/09/29/video-everton-3-1-southampton-premier-league-highlights/

 

1st goal, fine he can't do anything.

2nd goal, what is he doing? He should go out and challange the player. Very bad positioning.

3rd goal, he shouldnt have moved so much to the left. Hard to say that he would have saved the 2nd

attempt even if he would have stayed though. And I'm not saying that Boruc would have either.

 

Fulham Gazza

http://theoriginalwinger.com/2012-10-07-video-southampton-vs-fulham-highlights-goals-premier-league

1st goal, Hooiveld. Gazza can't do anything there.

2nd goal, can't do anything about it.

 

West Ham Boruc

 

1st goal, hard to say really. Ball should never be allowed to bounce in that area and Boruc

was ready for a touch from someone.

2nd goal, defence should get there first. Had control over his goals position and would have saved it if it would have been on target.

3rd goal, penalty is never the goaltenders fault.

4th goal, what can he do?

 

Tottenham Boruc

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eToC-xY9_CY

 

First highlight, Boruc makes a nice save.

1st goal, Clyne makes an error and it is a nice header. What can he do?

2nd goal, Challenges the player and get beaten. Made the right choice. If Clyne would have ran all the way back it

might have been a whole other story.

 

WBA Gazza

http://www.jazayer.com/west-brom-2-0-southampton-all-highlights-and-goals/

 

1st goal, he can't do anything about that one.

2nd goal, he can't do anything about it.

 

 

Swansea Gazza

http://www.eplmatches.com/2012/11/10/southampton-vs-swansea-highlights/

 

Only goal, completely Gazzas fault.

 

QPR Gazza

http://www.fullhighlights.com/2012/11/qpr-1-3-southampton-highlights.html

 

Only goal, should have done better with it.

Looked nervous the whole game.

 

 

I can't say that Boruc has been great. What I will say is that he hasn't been bad in any of the games he's played.

Gazza has been bad against Everton, Swansea and QPR. I'd say that we give Boruc a shot.

Boruc is more composed and can command the defence, he did so against Tottenham when he ordered them to go

up so he could shoot the ball forward when we were pushing for an equalizer.

 

Boruc is an international goaltender and to choose a goaltender that really hasn't had a great game

over him is absurd. Especially when Boruc hasn't been bad in any game.

 

Ofc Gazza should be in the goal if he is the best goaltender, I however feel that he is not.

This is my view on the case, sorry for the long post.

 

This is what I said when people said that Gazza was better.

I have defended him from the start.

Too many people talk trash when they know nothing about football.

 

Btw, Gazza is useless and will never become a premier goaltender - and yes you can quote me on that later.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

spurs dont

arsenal dont

WBA?

villa?

 

erm, most teams dont

 

 

Do Tottenham still have Freidal (USA) and Lluvis (FRA).?...not totally sure about Gomes?.. (think he was capped by Brazil).

 

Arsenal until recently... still had (POLISH) Szeczeny and Fabianski (both understudies to Boruc), and Viviano who has been capped by ITALY.

 

West Brom. have Ben Foster (ENG) and Boaz Myhill (WALES)

 

Aston Villa have Guzan (USA) and Given (Rep. Ireland)

 

but do come back if you have some alternative stats. although I omitted mentioning; Man.City, Liverpool, Fulham and Hull who all have at least 2 goalkeepers who have been capped at international level.

 

 

However, the basic issue is : Only one top class goalie is not enough for a Prem.side.

Edited by david in sweden
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...