Saint-Armstrong Posted 23 April, 2013 Share Posted 23 April, 2013 Simple really, what would be your North XI and South XI - and who do you think would win? ONE RULE: Maximum of 2 players from each club in your selected XI. Teams are categorised as follows... NORTH Aston Villa Everton Liverpool Manchester City Manchester United Newcastle United Stoke City Sunderland West Bromwich Albion Wigan Athletic SOUTH Arsenal Chelsea Fulham Norwich City Queens Park Rangers Reading Southampton Swansea City Tottenham Hotspur West Ham United Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
The Kraken Posted 23 April, 2013 Share Posted 23 April, 2013 The south's team is essentially Chelsea plus Gareth Bale. Edit: Didn't read the rules Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
kpturner Posted 23 April, 2013 Share Posted 23 April, 2013 Norwich is further north than Aston Villa - HTH Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Saint-Armstrong Posted 23 April, 2013 Author Share Posted 23 April, 2013 Norwich is further north than Aston Villa - HTH I know, but then I'd end up splitting the Midlands side and that would be a ballache as I am too lazy to judge who is where. So Norwich can remain southern for this. Good job I never took Geography as a qualification. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
studentsaint Posted 23 April, 2013 Share Posted 23 April, 2013 De gea, zabaletta, jagielka, mcCauly, Baines, cabeye, toure, coutinho, benteke Suarez, van persie Schwarzer, ivanovic, Williams, vertonghen, Shaw, schneiderlin, Diame, bale, mata, cazorla, michu North wins. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
The Kraken Posted 23 April, 2013 Share Posted 23 April, 2013 (edited) Ben Foster Glenn Johnson - Phil Jagielka - Vincent Kompany - Leighton Baines Hatem ben Arfa - Yaya Toure - Yohan Cabaye Wayne Rooney Robin van Persie - Luis Suarez Michel Vorm NateDog Clyne - Brede Haangeland - Jan Vertonghen - Ashley Cole Jack Wilshere - Morgan Schneiderlin Juan Mata - Santi Cazorla - Gareth Bale Michu Edited 23 April, 2013 by The Kraken Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Turkish Posted 23 April, 2013 Share Posted 23 April, 2013 North team Krul Baines kompany Vidic Johnson Ben Arfa Toure Fellani Van Persie Benteke Suarez South Caser Walker Williams Haagaland Cole Cazorla Hazard Bale Remy Michu Lambert Both 4-3-3. The North would win easily. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
dubai_phil Posted 23 April, 2013 Share Posted 23 April, 2013 FFS how can you NOT have Guly & Fox in the Southern Teams Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Saint Matty 76 Posted 23 April, 2013 Share Posted 23 April, 2013 Can't really argue with the South team from above. Mignolet G Johnson - Kompany - Vidic - Baines Ben Arfa - Cabaye - Yaya Toure - A Johnson Suarez - van Persie Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
whelk Posted 24 April, 2013 Share Posted 24 April, 2013 No one gone for Carrick yet many seem to rate Newcastle's (16th place) midfielders as better. Oh you football hipsters you! And Adam Johnson is a wind up right? One player from the runaway league winners? Surprised not to see Aguerrooooooo anywhere or Boruc or Hart or Natasic Anyway far easier to criticise than compile my own which seems too much effort Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Turkish Posted 24 April, 2013 Share Posted 24 April, 2013 No one gone for Carrick yet many seem to rate Newcastle's (16th place) midfielders as better. Oh you football hipsters you! And Adam Johnson is a wind up right? One player from the runaway league winners? Surprised not to see Aguerrooooooo anywhere or Boruc or Hart or Natasic Anyway far easier to criticise than compile my own which seems too much effort I initially chose Carrick but took him out as prefered Van Persie and Vidic from Man U, I'm a big Carrick fan but can only have two players from each team! Ben Arfa is a quality player fella! Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Wes Tender Posted 24 April, 2013 Share Posted 24 April, 2013 Norwich is further north than Aston Villa - HTH And therefore probably West Brom too. But I thought that the anywhere north of Watford was the North. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Matthew Le God Posted 24 April, 2013 Share Posted 24 April, 2013 (edited) Teams are categorised as follows... NORTH Aston Villa West Bromwich Albion SOUTH Norwich City Norwich is further north than both Aston Villa and West Brom. Edited 24 April, 2013 by Matthew Le God Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Turkish Posted 24 April, 2013 Share Posted 24 April, 2013 What a shame the usual pedantic *****s are ruining what could have been quite a decent thread. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Matthew Le God Posted 24 April, 2013 Share Posted 24 April, 2013 (edited) What a shame the usual pedantic *****s are ruining what could have been quite a decent thread. So if he did this we should just accept it, not question it and play along...? NORTH Aston Villa Everton Chelsea Liverpool Manchester United Fulham Norwich City Queens Park Rangers Reading West Ham United SOUTH Arsenal Southampton Swansea City Stoke City Sunderland Newcastle United Sunderland West Bromwich Albion Wigan Athletic Tottenham Hotspur Manchester City He had 2 team in the wrong category. What if it was 4, 6, 8? Would you just let him get that wrong and play along? How has pointing it out "ruined the thread"? Edited 24 April, 2013 by Matthew Le God Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
trousers Posted 24 April, 2013 Share Posted 24 April, 2013 Why are people worrying about Villa, WBA and Norwich when none of their players would make either team anyway....? Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Wes Tender Posted 24 April, 2013 Share Posted 24 April, 2013 So if he did this we should just accept it, not question it and play along...? NORTH Aston Villa Everton Chelsea Liverpool Manchester United Fulham Norwich City Queens Park Rangers Reading West Ham United SOUTH Arsenal Southampton Swansea City Stoke City Sunderland Newcastle United Sunderland West Bromwich Albion Wigan Athletic Tottenham Hotspur Manchester City He had 2 team in the wrong category. What if it was 4, 6, 8? Would you just let him get that wrong and play along? How has pointing it out "ruined the thread"? The irony of Turkish declaring that some posters are ruining threads is delicious. And I agree with you, that it isn't pedantry to point out two errors which undermine the entire basis of the thread. If the thread title called for posters to nominate the eleven best Saints players of all time and the suggestions included George Best, would one be a pedant for pointing out that he never played for us? Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Griffo Posted 24 April, 2013 Share Posted 24 April, 2013 So if he did this we should just accept it, not question it and play along...? NORTH Aston Villa Everton Chelsea Liverpool Manchester United Fulham Norwich City Queens Park Rangers Reading West Ham United SOUTH Arsenal Southampton Swansea City Stoke City Sunderland Newcastle United Sunderland West Bromwich Albion Wigan Athletic Tottenham Hotspur Manchester City He had 2 team in the wrong category. What if it was 4, 6, 8? Would you just let him get that wrong and play along? How has pointing it out "ruined the thread"? What is wrong with you? Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Olallana Posted 24 April, 2013 Share Posted 24 April, 2013 North: De Gea Zabaleta, Shawcross, Jagielka, Baines Coutinho, Cabaye, Toure, Ben Arfa Benteke, v. Persie South Boruc Walker, Williams, Vermaelen, Shaw Hazard, Cazorla, Mata, Bale Michu, Remy Hmm, tougher than I thought, but a nice bit of fun. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Turkish Posted 24 April, 2013 Share Posted 24 April, 2013 The irony of Turkish declaring that some posters are ruining threads is delicious. And I agree with you, that it isn't pedantry to point out two errors which undermine the entire basis of the thread. If the thread title called for posters to nominate the eleven best Saints players of all time and the suggestions included George Best, would one be a pedant for pointing out that he never played for us? I'm surprised you haven't ripped up your Saintsweb login details in disgust Les. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Turkish Posted 24 April, 2013 Share Posted 24 April, 2013 (edited) So if he did this we should just accept it, not question it and play along...? NORTH Aston Villa Everton Chelsea Liverpool Manchester United Fulham Norwich City Queens Park Rangers Reading West Ham United SOUTH Arsenal Southampton Swansea City Stoke City Sunderland Newcastle United Sunderland West Bromwich Albion Wigan Athletic Tottenham Hotspur Manchester City He had 2 team in the wrong category. What if it was 4, 6, 8? Would you just let him get that wrong and play along? How has pointing it out "ruined the thread"? He didnt do that though did he you prat. I think too much of your life revolves around your computer Matthew. Either that or you have mental problems. Edited 24 April, 2013 by Turkish Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Nexstar Posted 24 April, 2013 Share Posted 24 April, 2013 So if he did this we should just accept it, not question it and play along...? NORTH Aston Villa Everton Chelsea Liverpool Manchester United Fulham Norwich City Queens Park Rangers Reading West Ham United SOUTH Arsenal Southampton Swansea City Stoke City Sunderland Newcastle United Sunderland West Bromwich Albion Wigan Athletic Tottenham Hotspur Manchester City He had 2 team in the wrong category. What if it was 4, 6, 8? Would you just let him get that wrong and play along? How has pointing it out "ruined the thread"? Oh for goodness sake, shut up. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Nexstar Posted 24 April, 2013 Share Posted 24 April, 2013 Ben Foster Glenn Johnson - Phil Jagielka - Vincent Kompany - Leighton Baines Hatem ben Arfa - Yaya Toure - Yohan Cabaye Wayne Rooney Robin van Persie - Luis Suarez Michel Vorm NateDog Clyne - Brede Haangeland - Jan Vertonghen - Ashley Cole Jack Wilshere - Morgan Schneiderlin Juan Mata - Santi Cazorla - Gareth Bale Michu Good choices. Would be tempted to have Sessegnon in there for the North and it's slim pickings for right-back! In terms of winning I think the lightweight southern midfield might get overrun a bit. 3-1 to the North. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
VectisSaint Posted 24 April, 2013 Share Posted 24 April, 2013 The irony of Turkish declaring that some posters are ruining threads is delicious. And I agree with you, that it isn't pedantry to point out two errors which undermine the entire basis of the thread. If the thread title called for posters to nominate the eleven best Saints players of all time and the suggestions included George Best, would one be a pedant for pointing out that he never played for us? Yes, because we would all have realised that it was a typo and he meant Leon Best, who of course would be contender for Saints Best XI. While I agree with you about Turkish, there is no hard and fast rule about what is considered north and south. Gloucester City play in the Conference North. There have always been such discrepancies, look back at the Third Division when it was split North/South. It was just a way of balancing the divisions out. Anyway its just a fun thread, there was no need for geographical accuracy. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Appy Posted 24 April, 2013 Share Posted 24 April, 2013 Good choices. Would be tempted to have Sessegnon in there for the North and it's slim pickings for right-back! In terms of winning I think the lightweight southern midfield might get overrun a bit. 3-1 to the North. Zabaleta? Very hard to leave out 2 other City players though I agree. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Turkish Posted 24 April, 2013 Share Posted 24 April, 2013 Yes, because we would all have realised that it was a typo and he meant Leon Best, who of course would be contender for Saints Best XI. While I agree with you about Turkish, there is no hard and fast rule about what is considered north and south. Gloucester City play in the Conference North. There have always been such discrepancies, look back at the Third Division when it was split North/South. It was just a way of balancing the divisions out. Anyway its just a fun thread, there was no need for geographical accuracy. Vectis, are you going to answer my question regarding Tanadari Lee? This is about the 5th time I've asked you too. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Turkish Posted 24 April, 2013 Share Posted 24 April, 2013 Zabaleta? Very hard to leave out 2 other City players though I agree. Phil Jones has played there, I suppose you could use him. Then you'd have to leave out Vidic, Van Persie, Rooney etc. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Nexstar Posted 24 April, 2013 Share Posted 24 April, 2013 Zabaleta? Very hard to leave out 2 other City players though I agree. Yeah I wouldn't change Kompany or Toure Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Wes Tender Posted 24 April, 2013 Share Posted 24 April, 2013 Yes, because we would all have realised that it was a typo and he meant Leon Best, who of course would be contender for Saints Best XI. While I agree with you about Turkish, there is no hard and fast rule about what is considered north and south. Gloucester City play in the Conference North. There have always been such discrepancies, look back at the Third Division when it was split North/South. It was just a way of balancing the divisions out. Anyway its just a fun thread, there was no need for geographical accuracy. Leon Best is certainly a contender for greatest own goal scored by a former Saints player. I don't think that he'll ever score a more accomplished header in his career. Shame it was such a significant one in such a a crucial match for us. Trousers: Why are people worrying about Villa, WBA and Norwich when none of their players would make either team anyway....? A couple of decent Belgians playing for two of those teams :- Lukaku and Benteke. Or does Lukaku count as a Chelsea player? Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
SW5 SAINT Posted 25 April, 2013 Share Posted 25 April, 2013 Simple really, what would be your North XI and South XI - and who do you think would win? ONE RULE: Maximum of 2 players from each club in your selected XI. Teams are categorised as follows... NORTH Aston Villa Everton Liverpool Manchester City Manchester United Newcastle United Stoke City Sunderland West Bromwich Albion Wigan Athletic SOUTH Arsenal Chelsea Fulham Norwich City Queens Park Rangers Reading Southampton Swansea City Tottenham Hotspur West Ham United No Portsmouth players..............Oh Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Evil Monkey Posted 25 April, 2013 Share Posted 25 April, 2013 Ruddy Clyne Luiz Verthongan Monreal Arteta Schneiderlin Mata Berbatov Bale Michu Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
ExSt Peter Saint Posted 25 April, 2013 Share Posted 25 April, 2013 Hart Zabaleta Collocini Shawcross Baines Cabaye Carrick Fellaini Suarez Lukaku RVP Cech Walker Haangeland Williams Shaw Wilshere Schneiderlin Cazorla Bale Hazard Michu Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now