tomf05 Posted 8 April, 2013 Posted 8 April, 2013 Before you all raise me to the ground I am delighted with our recent playing style, results and above all position in the table! However with terrible results against Newcastle and QPR at the start of Pochs reign is it too quick to assume our season safe and the new manager as a saviour who can do no wrong? I am amazed by the progression of Jrod but would this have happened anyway? I agree there has been more comsistancy in team selection and I agree overall we have played very well but I still think West Ham, who we came up with, should still be a real test as I still find myself nervous with a 1 nil lead for 60 mins! Or even the last 20! I sound very negative but i just feel many jumping to conclusions about how Cortese was right, and that Adkins could never do it haven't really considered everything? Most of all COYR and wouldn't top ten be a beautiful thing
Saint Charlie Posted 8 April, 2013 Posted 8 April, 2013 He deserves praise, simple as. We are a better team than before he arrived so it was a good choice. He will make mistakes etc but NC made an astute decision IMO.
CB Fry Posted 8 April, 2013 Posted 8 April, 2013 Frankly, this is not MP's team. This time next year. Then we'll know. Nailed on top six, I guess.
tomf05 Posted 8 April, 2013 Author Posted 8 April, 2013 This is where I'm not sure we were pretty impressively unbeaten before Adkins left and always looked our best pressing high and shaky when we sat back! I think he has done incredibly well to adapt to a new role in a new league and country but with those losses is it any different really!
tomf05 Posted 8 April, 2013 Author Posted 8 April, 2013 Frankly, this is not MP's team. This time next year. Then we'll know. Nailed on top six, I guess. I agree.... And that would be awesome
Glasgow_Saint Posted 8 April, 2013 Posted 8 April, 2013 Looks like Nigels team will finish in 10th-14th place this season..... If Tino can do better next season (with his team) then we can praise him or sure
Saint Garrett Posted 8 April, 2013 Posted 8 April, 2013 We're better than under Adkins. Can't argue with that. I really want us to beat those tossers on Saturday though and cement our place as the top promoted team at least.
Dig Dig Posted 8 April, 2013 Posted 8 April, 2013 So it's definitely not Pardews team anymore? That only took over 3 years then so I guess we can judge it in approx 3 years time so we can discuss MP on his own merits.
Miltonroader07 Posted 8 April, 2013 Posted 8 April, 2013 Frankly, this is not MP's team. This time next year. Then we'll know. Nailed on top six, I guess. I disagree, may be the same players but the Team and the way the Team play is very different
Saint Charlie Posted 8 April, 2013 Posted 8 April, 2013 I disagree, may be the same players but the Team and the way the Team play is very different Agree. He has changed what we do quite significantly in a short time. The pressing is one visible change but the increase in confidence and belief is huge and IMO not something NA could have instilled as MP has done. Listen to NA now...he was talking after the game about being upset because Reading have "a winning mentality". Do they really? 7 defeats in a row suggests otherwise. Pochettino is just a more authentic character IMO and you can see why the players would respond to him. As I said last week someone who has been on the coaching pitch during both regimes said they loved Nigel and he was a good coach but the sessions under MP are just better allround and the players have really connected with him. Kelvin's recent comments suggest this is the case. If Im correct, under NA we hadnt beaten anyone above us in the league apart from Newcastle at home.
Olallana Posted 8 April, 2013 Posted 8 April, 2013 NA´s (and committees) squad. But MP´s team and setup.
Miltonroader07 Posted 8 April, 2013 Posted 8 April, 2013 Agree. He has changed what we do quite significantly in a short time. The pressing is one visible change but the increase in confidence and belief is huge and IMO not something NA could have instilled as MP has done. Listen to NA now...he was talking after the game about being upset because Reading have "a winning mentality". Do they really? 7 defeats in a row suggests otherwise. Pochettino is just a more authentic character IMO and you can see why the players would respond to him. As I said last week someone who has been on the coaching pitch during both regimes said they loved Nigel and he was a good coach but the sessions under MP are just better allround and the players have really connected with him. Kelvin's recent comments suggest this is the case. If Im correct, under NA we hadnt beaten anyone above us in the league apart from Newcastle at home. Good shout!!!
ART Posted 8 April, 2013 Posted 8 April, 2013 Nigel's greatness is seen now that he is no longer at the club, yet, they are his players whom Pochettino has taken and got them performing with greater belief and confidence. However, we shall not know how good Pochettino is, until he brings in his own players and maintains the good results. In management, a manager's real ability is often not seen in his presence, but in his absence when his team are led by another. Were Nigel not such a good manager, Pochettino wouldn't have had such a easy transition, would have had to bring in other players to make improvements. Let's wait till next season to assess Pochettino's success or otherwise.
VectisSaint Posted 8 April, 2013 Posted 8 April, 2013 Before you all raise me to the ground I am delighted with our recent playing style, results and above all position in the table! However with terrible results against Newcastle and QPR at the start of Pochs reign is it too quick to assume our season safe and the new manager as a saviour who can do no wrong?I am amazed by the progression of Jrod but would this have happened anyway? I agree there has been more comsistancy in team selection and I agree overall we have played very well but I still think West Ham, who we came up with, should still be a real test as I still find myself nervous with a 1 nil lead for 60 mins! Or even the last 20! I sound very negative but i just feel many jumping to conclusions about how Cortese was right, and that Adkins could never do it haven't really considered everything? Most of all COYR and wouldn't top ten be a beautiful thingHow was Newcastle away a terrible result? Most people on here expected us to lose to them, in the end we were a bit unlucky. Transformation of JRod (playing him down the middle) and Steve Davis is down fairly and squarely to the Sheriff in my opinion. We had awful games under NA just like QPR, not sure I even see that now as a terrible result, just something that was bound to happen with Saggy Chops in charge.Not dissing NA by any means, but the difference since MP arrived is clear for all to see.
UpweySaint Posted 8 April, 2013 Posted 8 April, 2013 I think it is fair to praise him, we've done well and the players seem happy under him. But we cannot seriously evaluate him until maybe the end of the calendar year. His players, his pre season, his tactics ... if we progress, well done great, if not ... im sure we'l all have our opinions about where to place the blame
kpturner Posted 8 April, 2013 Posted 8 April, 2013 Before you all raise me to the ground....it is "raze" not "raise"! Carry on.....
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now