Made in Southampton Posted 21 January, 2013 Posted 21 January, 2013 I've got to be honest I used to have a real dislike for him when he played for United but he is fast becoming one of the best pundits on the tele. His insight into the future of Southampton and relating it to the past that we had with the likes of the Shearers, Wallaces, MLT etc etc was spot on and shows that he has got a real knowledge of football. with everything that's been said about our club over the last few days I thought he'd talked the most sense.
Dazza82 Posted 21 January, 2013 Posted 21 January, 2013 Like him, think he will make a great manager one day
Fitzhugh Fella Posted 21 January, 2013 Posted 21 January, 2013 The only pundit worth listening to - was v complimentary about the Saints tonight.
Restark19 Posted 21 January, 2013 Posted 21 January, 2013 Very good pundit, clearly loves and knows a lot about the game.
Monk Posted 21 January, 2013 Posted 21 January, 2013 (edited) Had the pleasure of watching him coach with kids and with Wolves academy at St.George's Park. He is outstanding and has a fantastic eye. New bread of coach. Edited 21 January, 2013 by Monk
Dig Dig Posted 21 January, 2013 Posted 21 January, 2013 On Mondays he gets to the studio very early and spends all day researching the teams for MNF plus much more. He gets out what he puts in and shows the other joke pundits out there that you can't just rely on what you knew 15+ years ago.
Pat from Poole Posted 21 January, 2013 Posted 21 January, 2013 He was superb tonight. You can tell he really researches the sides. In a completely different league to the idiots on Match of the Day.
Jimmy_D Posted 21 January, 2013 Posted 21 January, 2013 (edited) He's turned out to be an annoyingly good pundit >_ Edited 22 January, 2013 by Jimmy_D
Matthew Le Tissier Posted 21 January, 2013 Posted 21 January, 2013 He's very good and talks a lot of sense unlike most. Funny thing is he used to get slated on here for talking utter ******. Can't buy that experience and he has learned from the best. 20 years apprenticeship from sir alex. Very switched on man. And will most deffiently make a great manager one day
NI Saint Posted 21 January, 2013 Posted 21 January, 2013 In a completely different league to the idiots on Match of the Day. I can't watch MOTD any longer as they all make me think of old men sat in a pub saying "In my day that was never a booking." Gary Neville is a very good commentator, knows his stuff on the teams he is commentating on, considering how long he played for United doesn't seem to be too biased towards them and he makes the other commentators look like amateurs.
Miltonroader07 Posted 21 January, 2013 Posted 21 January, 2013 I've got to be honest I used to have a real dislike for him when he played for United but he is fast becoming one of the best pundits on the tele. His insight into the future of Southampton and relating it to the past that we had with the likes of the Shearers, Wallaces, MLT etc etc was spot on and shows that he has got a real knowledge of football. with everything that's been said about our club over the last few days I thought he'd talked the most sense. Got to agree, not sure hs is management potential but an awesome number two
Colbury Posted 21 January, 2013 Posted 21 January, 2013 You can see why he was captain of Man United. Love hearing him talk football.
Torres Posted 22 January, 2013 Posted 22 January, 2013 England legend too. One of the few that ever seemed to appreciate the efforts of England fans to travel away and support the team.
dubai_phil Posted 22 January, 2013 Posted 22 January, 2013 We had to put up with Martin Tyler & Paul Walsh... Then Southgate and blur beer goggles in the studio. Tyler & Walsh did say "Adkins has left behind a Very Good Southampton Team here" But it was noisy in the pub so more just crowd noise coming over the telly - which DID sound REALLY good. Someone should post a clip of a Neville summary on Saints one day for us foreigners Please
lambtiss Posted 22 January, 2013 Posted 22 January, 2013 I can't watch MOTD any longer as they all make me think of old men sat in a pub saying "In my day that was never a booking." Gary Neville is a very good commentator, knows his stuff on the teams he is commentating on, considering how long he played for United doesn't seem to be too biased towards them and he makes the other commentators look like amateurs. This
theyin Posted 22 January, 2013 Posted 22 January, 2013 "fast becoming one of the best" ??? .... He IS the best. Period
CanadaSaint Posted 22 January, 2013 Posted 22 January, 2013 One of the things that most impresses me about him is the absence of the "snob factor" that besets so many of his peers - their almost fawning regard for the Big Four coupled with their patronizing, and often ignorant, comments about anyone else. Neville has a refreshing determination to "tell it like it is" - even if that involves disrespect for the respected and respect for the disrespected. On another point, though, it's pleasing to read the comments on match reports and see that other fans are starting to recognize that the Saints play some pretty decent football, and that we are not the relegation certainties they thought we were at the start of the season. Earning respect in the PL is a long road but, thanks largely to Adkins, we're making progress. Let's hope we can keep it up.
Saint Garrett Posted 22 January, 2013 Posted 22 January, 2013 GN is very very good. Like others say it's refreshing to see that he does proper research. I recorded MNF and just watched the saints build up, half time and the analysis at the end when I got in last night. Very interesting points and great to hear him praise a few of our English talents. Sounds like some of them aren't far from an England call up. Shaw/Clyne in particular.
isorry Posted 22 January, 2013 Posted 22 January, 2013 it was also good that he interrupted the question he was asked to slate Cortese for not mentioning/thanking Adkins in his programme notes. He does seem to have the right idea about how a football club should be run, and he chose the right time to give his opinion on the lack of class that has been shown without tarring the whole club with that brush
tajjuk Posted 22 January, 2013 Posted 22 January, 2013 Does his research and seems generally honest in his opinions, not afraid to interupt the presenter either.
adrian lord Posted 22 January, 2013 Posted 22 January, 2013 (edited) One of the things that most impresses me about him is the absence of the "snob factor" that besets so many of his peers - their almost fawning regard for the Big Four coupled with their patronizing, and often ignorant, comments about anyone else. Neville has a refreshing determination to "tell it like it is" - even if that involves disrespect for the respected and respect for the disrespected. Nail head. I notice that instead of wandering about the house aimlessly, drinking beer or wine, in the prematch and half time, I actually want to stick about and hear his analysis. Edited 22 January, 2013 by adrian lord
rooney Posted 22 January, 2013 Posted 22 January, 2013 It is great listening to him--so knowledgeable. I can understnd now why Roy wanted him in the England set up.
OldNick Posted 22 January, 2013 Posted 22 January, 2013 I put a thread up about hiom some months ago , he is superb. When it was announced i thought 'that was mad' butr he has showed real style and class
dinger Posted 22 January, 2013 Posted 22 January, 2013 On Mondays he gets to the studio very early and spends all day researching the teams for MNF plus much more. He gets out what he puts in and shows the other joke pundits out there that you can't just rely on what you knew 15+ years ago. This is the big thing, the research, the effort he puts in. He puts even the other Sky pundits to shame. Was watching a game the other weekend where they had a little feature on the 150th anniversary of the FA and wheeled out the original copy of the laws of the game. Then the presenter said something along the lines of, "and can you believe that there are still only 17 laws in football?", to which Jamie Redknapp expressed his absolute astonishment. Then 45 minutes later he's jabbering on about some penalty incident and keeps talking about 'the letter of the law'. WTF? What qualifies you to talk about the letter of the law when you so clearly haven't read them? How is it possible that pundits on national TV are able to say about goal-line officials, '"I don't know what it is they do", as if that is somehow a criticism of the officials/UEFA. Find out what they do and tell us! You're supposed to be the experts! Rant over. Breath now.
pingwing Posted 22 January, 2013 Posted 22 January, 2013 Seen bits of him and have generally been impressed, only thing I didn't like was him going on about his "work horse of a brother" when we walked into the pub after yesterdays game. Phil wasn't all that...
Window Cleaner Posted 22 January, 2013 Posted 22 January, 2013 Seen bits of him and have generally been impressed, only thing I didn't like was him going on about his "work horse of a brother" when we walked into the pub after yesterdays game. Phil wasn't all that... Phil Neville is a work horse, flair players don't last until they're 36, burnt out long before.
DT Posted 22 January, 2013 Posted 22 January, 2013 Agreed, he was excellent. Might be interesting to see if he as complimentary to Saints when not being asked questions by 'red and white' Ed...
Barry Sanchez Posted 22 January, 2013 Posted 22 January, 2013 Knows his stuff and is easily the best pundit on tv.
View From The Top Posted 22 January, 2013 Posted 22 January, 2013 (edited) I love the contempt he shows for saggy jr. Edited 22 January, 2013 by View From The Top
dinger Posted 22 January, 2013 Posted 22 January, 2013 Seen bits of him and have generally been impressed, only thing I didn't like was him going on about his "work horse of a brother" when we walked into the pub after yesterdays game. Phil wasn't all that... I think the work horse bit was with reference to his tackle.
St Matty Posted 22 January, 2013 Posted 22 January, 2013 I've got to be honest I used to have a real dislike for him when he played for United but he is fast becoming one of the best pundits on the tele. His insight into the future of Southampton and relating it to the past that we had with the likes of the Shearers, Wallaces, MLT etc etc was spot on and shows that he has got a real knowledge of football. with everything that's been said about our club over the last few days I thought he'd talked the most sense. Used to desopise him and refused to listen to him on Sky unitl a Liverpool supporting mate of mine who absolutely hates Man U saidf "he's good" and he is.
Saints67 Posted 22 January, 2013 Posted 22 January, 2013 had me laughing when he was analysing the Spurs late equaliser when he was slating de Gea for only punching the ball out to Lennon. 'See the way Vidic is staring at de Gea Ed....it's not coz he fancies him"
OldNick Posted 22 January, 2013 Posted 22 January, 2013 had me laughing when he was analysing the Spurs late equaliser when he was slating de Gea for only punching the ball out to Lennon. 'See the way Vidic is staring at de Gea Ed....it's not coz he fancies him"He was even funnier a few weeks ago when he was talking about his brother, he said he's so boring its a risk to him if he has another piece of broccoli. it was on those lines anyway. it was a superb show, especially when he said about diving. He said he was sick of England being gracious losers etc
Saint Charlie Posted 22 January, 2013 Posted 22 January, 2013 The only pundit that botheres to find stuff out about lower Prem teams rather than just patronise them.
the stain Posted 22 January, 2013 Posted 22 January, 2013 My Aunt was being mugged once by a couple of bad lads when GN and his girlfriend past. GN stepped in and punched one of the criminals in the face and sent the other sprawling to the floor with a kick to the stomach. He was a proper hero. The only thing that ruined it was when he asked my aunt to join him and his girlfriend in a threesome. My aunt said she couldn't because she had just been shopping and had some frozen goods that needed to go in the freezer. He swore at her, called her ungrateful and walked off.
Under Weststand Posted 22 January, 2013 Posted 22 January, 2013 Hate him as a player, and feared that he'd be an awful pundit. How wrong was I he has been completely impartial very funny at times got a very analytical brain. And as said doesn't patronise the lower teams. Great going on about de gea poor punch.
View From The Top Posted 22 January, 2013 Posted 22 January, 2013 Thought his point he made on Sunday that Dempsey should have gone down, got the pen' & got the player sent off refreshingly honest. When Saggy Jnr looked aghast he made the simple point "it's about winning". Whilst I don't agree with him if was good to see an honest pundit. Souness is the only other one.
PaulSaint Posted 22 January, 2013 Posted 22 January, 2013 Has anybody alive or dead had so much praise on this forum as GN?
OldNick Posted 22 January, 2013 Posted 22 January, 2013 My Aunt was being mugged once by a couple of bad lads when GN and his girlfriend past. GN stepped in and punched one of the criminals in the face and sent the other sprawling to the floor with a kick to the stomach. He was a proper hero. The only thing that ruined it was when he asked my aunt to join him and his girlfriend in a threesome. My aunt said she couldn't because she had just been shopping and had some frozen goods that needed to go in the freezer. He swore at her, called her ungrateful and walked off.Are you trying to be Bearsy...sadly you are not
the stain Posted 22 January, 2013 Posted 22 January, 2013 Are you trying to be Bearsy...sadly you are not Nos, I ams nots. What a stranges things to says. Where's my mate tokes? Who are you trying to be Old*****?
Dig Dig Posted 22 January, 2013 Posted 22 January, 2013 (edited) ^ OldNick stuck one on the stain there and his comeback was poor. Keep going stain, you'll come back stronger than ever I predict. Edited 22 January, 2013 by Dig Dig
yamms_schmitz Posted 22 January, 2013 Posted 22 January, 2013 Best pundit out there by a country mile. I second that. Clearly a hard working professional.
saints_is_the_south Posted 22 January, 2013 Posted 22 January, 2013 "fast becoming one of the best" ??? .... He IS the best. Period +1. Would make a terrific manager but he's said before he has no interest in it.
martel Posted 23 January, 2013 Posted 23 January, 2013 I've got to be honest I used to have a real dislike for him when he played for United but he is fast becoming one of the best pundits on the tele. His insight into the future of Southampton and relating it to the past that we had with the likes of the Shearers, Wallaces, MLT etc etc was spot on and shows that he has got a real knowledge of football. with everything that's been said about our club over the last few days I thought he'd talked the most sense. I have to agree with that, since becoming a pundit he has always been on the nail.
Saint Garrett Posted 24 January, 2013 Posted 24 January, 2013 http://www.dailymail.co.uk/sport/football/article-2267346/Gary-Neville-hidden-agenda-Sky-Sports-claims-Richard-Keys.html Keys talking ********...
LVSaint Posted 24 January, 2013 Posted 24 January, 2013 He is good. I'll need to call him and tell him now I've got his mobile number.
SaintsAddict Posted 24 January, 2013 Posted 24 January, 2013 http://www.dailymail.co.uk/sport/football/article-2267346/Gary-Neville-hidden-agenda-Sky-Sports-claims-Richard-Keys.html Keys talking ********... "Listen, finger him". I don't think you can nail a goalkeeper in that way.' Keys clearly hasn't learnt from his mistakes at Sky........
Thedelldays Posted 24 January, 2013 Posted 24 January, 2013 Keyes is a muppet Sky football is a million miles better with chamberlain and Neville than Keyes and gray
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now