derry Posted 10 January, 2013 Posted 10 January, 2013 Maybe if Boruc showed anything like the alleged Fiorentina performances at Southampton, there wouldn't be any criticism. At the moment he looks a mere shadow of the goalkeeper being put forward. Last year means nothing, he has to perform now, after all, as all his supporters keep saying, a class, experienced international goalkeeper, so that should be easy for him. Unfortunately he isn't living up to that reputation.
Barry Sanchez Posted 10 January, 2013 Posted 10 January, 2013 At the moment he looks a mere shadow Casting one hell of a shadow though.......................
tajjuk Posted 10 January, 2013 Posted 10 January, 2013 Maybe if Boruc showed anything like the alleged Fiorentina performances at Southampton, there wouldn't be any criticism. At the moment he looks a mere shadow of the goalkeeper being put forward. Last year means nothing, he has to perform now, after all, as all his supporters keep saying, a class, experienced international goalkeeper, so that should be easy for him. Unfortunately he isn't living up to that reputation. I don't think anyone diasgrees with this but he's had four games, two and then about two months before the next two. His class and experience means he should at least get a go to prove it and I don't think 4 games where unlike our other two keepers he has been largely blameless for the goals is a fair enough chance. The two he has had recently he had a wobbly start against Arsenal but then was pretty regulation aftert that and then he did his best pulled off a few saves against a very good Chelsea where the team as whole were poor. Some of the reactions on here you'd think he was single handledly responsible for our lowly position and was throwing the ball into our net every game. The descriptions, reactions and opinions in this thread are no where near proportional to his actual performances. I'm not epxecting miracles from him but it would be nice to have a game where the opposition doesn't get gifted a goal by with our GK or the defence or the ref. Thing is he won't get any credit even if he does well, Kelvin and Gazza have literally lost games for us this season yet people still want them back in. If Boruc concedes on Saturday I full expect some more 'rants' on here even if he has no chance of stopping the goals.
derry Posted 10 January, 2013 Posted 10 January, 2013 I don't think anyone diasgrees with this but he's had four games, two and then about two months before the next two. His class and experience means he should at least get a go to prove it and I don't think 4 games where unlike our other two keepers he has been largely blameless for the goals is a fair enough chance. The two he has had recently he had a wobbly start against Arsenal but then was pretty regulation aftert that and then he did his best pulled off a few saves against a very good Chelsea where the team as whole were poor. Some of the reactions on here you'd think he was single handledly responsible for our lowly position and was throwing the ball into our net every game. The descriptions, reactions and opinions in this thread are no where near proportional to his actual performances. I'm not epxecting miracles from him but it would be nice to have a game where the opposition doesn't get gifted a goal by with our GK or the defence or the ref. Thing is he won't get any credit even if he does well, Kelvin and Gazza have literally lost games for us this season yet people still want them back in. If Boruc concedes on Saturday I full expect some more 'rants' on here even if he has no chance of stopping the goals. Against WHU he was awful, the first goal was a cock up for a free kick cross that went in at the far post, the last goal was poor and his general performance was below par. Against Spurs he looked slow and immobile, before that he was poor for the U21s v MU. Against Arsenal he was ok ish and against Chelsea hardly made a save except for Ba's header that hit his foot. I want Gazzaniga back in because I think he is a better keeper than Boruc's current form. The two mistakes keep getting highlighted but he has let in less goals and we have taken more points per game with him in goal. When Boruc performs, fine keep him in. but his performances are a long way short of his reputation.
SaintNeil90 Posted 10 January, 2013 Posted 10 January, 2013 I dont understand Boruc. He should be exactly what we need but he looks nervous. I agree with others, prefer Gazza in goal.
tajjuk Posted 10 January, 2013 Posted 10 January, 2013 Against WHU he was awful, the first goal was a cock up for a free kick cross that went in at the far post, the last goal was poor and his general performance was below par. Against Spurs he looked slow and immobile, before that he was poor for the U21s v MU. Against Arsenal he was ok ish and against Chelsea hardly made a save except for Ba's header that hit his foot. I want Gazzaniga back in because I think he is a better keeper than Boruc's current form. The two mistakes keep getting highlighted but he has let in less goals and we have taken more points per game with him in goal. When Boruc performs, fine keep him in. but his performances are a long way short of his reputation. The whole team were awful second half against West Ham, Fonte was mainly at fault for that freekick and there were cock ups from everyone, harsh to single him out. Against Spurs he looked fine to me, Bale's header was pinpoint and Clyne should have attacked the ball better and I thought he closed down Defoe well and made himself big but Defoe actually scuffed the finish and lucky to get it through (and Fonte should have cleared it but slipped) not to mention the woefull defending in the build up as Tottenham were given all the space. Against Arsenal he had two dodgy moments, and his long kicking was a bit wayward but his throws and short distribution were good and he was looking composed by the end. Against Chelsea I thought he did ok and you couldn't expect much more. I don't rate Gazzaniga at all, I think he has poor technique, especially his handling and that leads to his mistakes. He's made more than two mistakes but got away with them because the teams we played were poor, against QPR he was woeful and another day he would have costs us the game. He's also the one that has cost us the most dropped points against teams we couldn't afford to drop points to. IMO he'll be a league 1 keeper at best.
Zlavik Posted 12 January, 2013 Posted 12 January, 2013 I dont understand Boruc. He should be exactly what we need but he looks nervous. I agree with others, prefer Gazza in goal. And after today?
Stepgar Posted 12 January, 2013 Posted 12 January, 2013 Superb today, thats him our keep now surely Agreed, very brave towards the end there. deserved a bit of good fortune and a clean sheet. Well done fella.
S-Clarke Posted 12 January, 2013 Posted 12 January, 2013 His best game in a saints shirt, and he really hasnt' done much wrong in any of the games he played. People just getting too precious over that spurs incident.
RobM Posted 12 January, 2013 Posted 12 January, 2013 Agreed, a couple of dodgy moments where he should have held the ball but fumbled it, but by far the best performance from Boruc in a Saints shirt and those few moments were well outweighed by the fact he kept us in it today. Some really brave moments too, putting himself where he could get hurt.
Roger Posted 12 January, 2013 Posted 12 January, 2013 Different class today. Showed bravery. He's our best goalie. Pedigree says it all.
pap Posted 12 January, 2013 Posted 12 January, 2013 Love him. He's a nutter. Unpredictable. Think Benteke (sp) was unnerved by him. But damn, we rode our luck.
ottery st mary Posted 12 January, 2013 Posted 12 January, 2013 Well played Boruc.......great stuff.. By far our best GK and why he is first on the team sheet..
RobM Posted 12 January, 2013 Posted 12 January, 2013 His best game in a saints shirt, and he really hasnt' done much wrong in any of the games he played. People just getting too precious over that spurs incident. He has, he has been awful at times and looked like catching was impossible for him, but he has gotten better with every single game so far.
Smirking_Saint Posted 12 January, 2013 Posted 12 January, 2013 It's all gone a bit quiet Come on then you bell end Where are you ?
Restark19 Posted 12 January, 2013 Posted 12 January, 2013 Incredible performance today, if he keeps it up any chance of him being here next season?
Zlavik Posted 12 January, 2013 Posted 12 January, 2013 Incredible performance today, if he keeps it up any chance of him being here next season? If our fans would have treated him good, yes. We have treated him like **** and I wouldnt blame him if he left. If he leaves its our fans fault.
Dazza82 Posted 12 January, 2013 Posted 12 January, 2013 Brilliant today should get better and better now
Glasgow_Saint Posted 12 January, 2013 Posted 12 January, 2013 He's had one good game, lets not get carried away
Barry the Badger Posted 12 January, 2013 Posted 12 January, 2013 His best game in a saints shirt, and he really hasnt' done much wrong in any of the games he played. People just getting too precious over that spurs incident. I don't even think he was that, the whole reason the Spurs incident happened was because people were already on his back on his home debut.
Thedelldays Posted 12 January, 2013 Posted 12 January, 2013 that was the best keeper display for saints this season...by a country mile.... excellent display
austsaint Posted 12 January, 2013 Posted 12 January, 2013 Boruc's class and courage kept us in it second half. It almost looked like that Leeds game we nicked 1-0 for long periods.
Crab Lungs Posted 12 January, 2013 Posted 12 January, 2013 Superb display after being wobbly at home. Now, at home, we need to back him. Absolutely mountainous in more ways than one. BACK ARTUR "SAFE HANDS" BORUC
Nigel=God-Poyet=Sod Posted 12 January, 2013 Posted 12 January, 2013 Watching Boruc today actually made me feel confident we were going to hold out, he was confident, commanded the box, his handling was terrific and made a worldy save. Really chuffed for him because he hasn't the best of starts for us. I hope he can continue to improve for the rest of the season.
Thedelldays Posted 12 January, 2013 Posted 12 January, 2013 None of this changes the fact that Boruc is garbage. All in good time . where are you now..?
Barry Sanchez Posted 12 January, 2013 Posted 12 January, 2013 I shall watch motd later and as ever give an even unbiased account of the match.
Window Cleaner Posted 12 January, 2013 Posted 12 January, 2013 where are you now..? making Kelv's tea, it's his Mum.
beatlesaint Posted 12 January, 2013 Posted 12 January, 2013 He's had one good game, lets not get carried away Why not, people on here have been getting carried away after he had one bad game when he hadn't played for God knows how long so wasn't exactly match sharp !!
S-Clarke Posted 12 January, 2013 Posted 12 January, 2013 where are you now..? He'll slide sideways, somewhere. He's been known to post crap on a few occasions.
the stain Posted 12 January, 2013 Posted 12 January, 2013 Am I the only one who saw him fumble their first shot and Yoshida had to kick the ball out of play?
Zlavik Posted 12 January, 2013 Posted 12 January, 2013 Am I the only one who saw him fumble their first shot and Yoshida had to kick the ball out of play? You mean when Yoshida TOUCHED the ball before so the direction changed before it got to Boruc? Look at the slow-mo replay and you'll see why that happned...
slickmick Posted 12 January, 2013 Posted 12 January, 2013 Got to say, I didn't think he had a performance like that in him. Hopefully he can build on that. He won us 3 points today.
Matthew Le Tissier Posted 12 January, 2013 Posted 12 January, 2013 I hear he had a good game! Sounded good on the radio. I'm as over the moon as you trust me! I don't want him to fail I just think he's a load of ****e I won't get to exited yet as Villa are a league one side. Fair play if he played well today though. He will have to do that alot more times to change my mind!
Thedelldays Posted 12 January, 2013 Posted 12 January, 2013 I hear he had a good game! Sounded good on the radio. I'm as over the moon as you trust me! I don't want him to fail I just think he's a load of ****e I won't get to exited yet as Villa are a league one side. Fair play if he played well today though. He will have to do that alot more times to change my mind! they really are not
derry Posted 12 January, 2013 Posted 12 January, 2013 I made him MOM for block, and a couple of decent saves, The one straight at him that came back out was dodgy and lost himself for the header that hit the bar. He played pretty well and this will do his confidence good. He should keep his place on this display.
Crab Lungs Posted 12 January, 2013 Posted 12 January, 2013 And fair play to MLT for coming online and ever-so-slightly reversing his stance. I think Boruc will prove why he's an excellent GK over the next few weeks.
Thedelldays Posted 12 January, 2013 Posted 12 January, 2013 thing is, will all be back to normal when we get tonked at the bridge....
Smirking_Saint Posted 12 January, 2013 Posted 12 January, 2013 thing is, will all be back to normal when we get tonked at the bridge.... Who tonked stoke today who are no mugs defensively
Badger Posted 12 January, 2013 Posted 12 January, 2013 He's had one good game, lets not get carried away Agree with you, it will take more than one good performance to convince me he's our saviour, or can be relied on week in week out.
Matthew Le Tissier Posted 12 January, 2013 Posted 12 January, 2013 Can't argue with a clean sheet. Same for the defenders. First step in a big ladder. Lets hope he keeps going up and doesn't fall. For the record to the Clark fella who said IDE be hiding. Far from it . I hope I turn out to be wrong! It wouldn't be the first time and won't be the last ! Time will tell, still very early days! Chelsea next.
dubai_phil Posted 12 January, 2013 Posted 12 January, 2013 Thought he had a good game today made a cracking save or 3 Gave him my motm vote Even Polish FMDP was singing his praises at the end instead of giving him abuse as normal Starting to look the part
Golac's Cunning Stunts Posted 12 January, 2013 Posted 12 January, 2013 I hear he had a good game! Sounded good on the radio. I'm as over the moon as you trust me! I don't want him to fail I just think he's a load of ****e I won't get to exited yet as Villa are a league one side. Fair play if he played well today though. He will have to do that alot more times to change my mind! You seem to like to exaggerate. Boruc is far from being a load of ****e. Villa are far from being a league 1 side.
ollysaints1 Posted 12 January, 2013 Posted 12 January, 2013 He did well but i think people may be jumping the gun a bit saying he was outstanding,he made 1 good save the rest was routine for an aspiring Premier league goalkeeper
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now