Jump to content

England v India


alpine_saint
 Share

Recommended Posts

FFS, nightwaatchmen NEVER work.

 

Why do England persist in using them ???

 

I've never understood the point of them either. Why, when batting gets really tricky, do you bring a bowler in to do it? I can understand you wouldn't want to lose another top order batsman in a hurry, but by bringing in a tail-ender you're inviting the loss of another wicket, at which point you'll have to bring in the top order anyway. I think it's a relic of the last century that'll fade away; with the rise of T20 it's getting harder to find genuine, patient, time-serving batsmen at the top of the order, let alone expecting blockers amongst the tail.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I've never understood the point of them either. Why, when batting gets really tricky, do you bring a bowler in to do it? I can understand you wouldn't want to lose another top order batsman in a hurry, but by bringing in a tail-ender you're inviting the loss of another wicket, at which point you'll have to bring in the top order anyway. I think it's a relic of the last century that'll fade away; with the rise of T20 it's getting harder to find genuine, patient, time-serving batsmen at the top of the order, let alone expecting blockers amongst the tail.

 

Who then also loses his wicket, meaning another top-order batsman.

 

Its f**king ridiculous. Almost as ridiculous as Englands inability to play spin.

 

Really surpsied that Pietersen didnt throw his wicket away. Has his exclusion from the T20 tournament somehow made him grow up ?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Would you have had Panesar in? I'm not a massive fan of his, but guess he's all we've got to fall back on in terms of a recognised 2nd spinner.

 

As he's been selected for the tour party and we are not exactly blessed with high class test standard spinners. Yes.

 

What the feck was Bresnan doing out there? Even if he gets a hundred tomorrow (and we may need it:scared: ) it was a daft selection.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

What England have missed recently is Paul Collingwood. Not so much for his place in the the batting line-up, although the frequency of middle order collapses has increased alarmingly without his obdurate stickability, but more for the way he kept the whole team honest. The hallmark of the ascendant England team of 2010-11 was how they were absolutely on it for every delivery, with bat or ball. They never let the opposition settle. I don't think they have that any more. Teams are allowed to get in their own groove, England are sloppy in the field and give up too easily.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

As he's been selected for the tour party and we are not exactly blessed with high class test standard spinners. Yes.

 

What the feck was Bresnan doing out there? Even if he gets a hundred tomorrow (and we may need it:scared: ) it was a daft selection.

Yep, would pretty much agree with that. We bat a long way down anyway, with the likes of Swann and Broad regularly contributing with runs regularly.
Link to comment
Share on other sites

What England have missed recently is Paul Collingwood. Not so much for his place in the the batting line-up, although the frequency of middle order collapses has increased alarmingly without his obdurate stickability, but more for the way he kept the whole team honest. The hallmark of the ascendant England team of 2010-11 was how they were absolutely on it for every delivery, with bat or ball. They never let the opposition settle. I don't think they have that any more. Teams are allowed to get in their own groove, England are sloppy in the field and give up too easily.
Definitely sloppier in the field of late, could well be due to the departure of Collingwood.
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Well this is a considerably better start to a test. And the reversal of that baffling decision to play Bresnan in preference to Monty pays big dividends straight away. This Pujara fella is awesome though, looks like a genuine star in the making. I wonder if any of the England top order can bat as carefully and as unflappably on this wicket? It's the sort of situation where you really want Cook to step up and dictate the tone and pace of the innings.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Well this is a considerably better start to a test. And the reversal of that baffling decision to play Bresnan in preference to Monty pays big dividends straight away. This Pujara fella is awesome though, looks like a genuine star in the making. I wonder if any of the England top order can bat as carefully and as unflappably on this wicket? It's the sort of situation where you really want Cook to step up and dictate the tone and pace of the innings.

 

Up to a point I agree and certainly the moronic decision to omit Monty has been reversed. India are still well on top after Anderson and Broad have criminally wasted the 2nd new ball. At least Jimmy bowled decently with the first one but I'd still like to see him bowling nearer 85mph. Broad has been terrible, he must be big mates with Cook and Flower to still be in the side. Even Cook gave him some foul looks after yet another slow-medium 77mph long hop got cut for 4. His batting has gone totally as well. Best to cruel to be kind and say he won't feature v NZ away/home and Ashes home, needs a full season with Notts to get the spite back in his bowling and some time at the crease. If he has a good summer, he could be considered for the Aussie Tour. Will be glad to see Finn fit again and Meaker get a few Tests to see if he is ready for the Aussies. Onions would do better than Broad or Bresnan.

 

Well done Monty and Swann (again). 300+ for India is a big score on that surface with our depleted batting line up and the surface really starting to turn. Pujara looks a superb prospect and Ashwin has batted well too, should love bowling on that pitch too.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 2 weeks later...
Cook :adore:

 

Another fantastic knock. There was never really any doubt in my mind that he would become one of the greats, but I think we can safely say he's now there. I maybe terribly old fashioned, but there's nothing I enjoy more in sport than watching Cook and Trott accumulate. They've got that perfect test approach of playing every delivery on its merits while retaining an awareness of the context of the match.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Keep batting. Refuse to finish early. Grind them into the dust.

 

Sit back and watch the infighting afterwards in India with a well deserved tinnie

 

This has it's merits but in the spirit of fair play ( Obviously I'm not a Skate) I would have liked to see the Indians have a go at a target. They would have gone for it as a 20/20 game and been out for 120.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

This has it's merits but in the spirit of fair play ( Obviously I'm not a Skate) I would have liked to see the Indians have a go at a target. They would have gone for it as a 20/20 game and been out for 120.

 

True, but as Simon Cowell said so eloquently on XFactor US last week. Strange things can happen (and it did on the results show)

Edited by dubai_phil
Link to comment
Share on other sites

This has it's merits but in the spirit of fair play ( Obviously I'm not a Skate) I would have liked to see the Indians have a go at a target. They would have gone for it as a 20/20 game and been out for 120.

 

I'm not sure it's got much to do with fair play. Misguided generosity, maybe. Why on earth would England have wanted to offer India a chance to win?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

:)

 

To be fair, he made a good point. And at least there was no claim that England had 'thrown the series away' this time...

 

No that's true, I did stay away from saying he predicted all doom and gloom, all his points were valid.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 3 weeks later...
  • 2 weeks later...

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
 Share

×
×
  • Create New...