Jump to content

Player ratings this season


rickylambert
 Share

Recommended Posts

How do you think they've preformed this season?

 

 

Gazza-7

Yoshida-4

Fonte-7

Clyne-8

Fox-6

Schniderlin-8

Cork-N/A

Gaston-7

Lallana-5

Punch-7

Lambert-7

Steve Davis-6

Hoovield-4

 

schneiderlin an eight! Think that's a bit generous, no one in our team is worthy of that if its based on the season so far and not individual games

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I'll give it bit more detail

All 3 keepers - 5 max. None of them have really looked the part and maybe splashing the cash on Butland is the answer.

Clyne 7 - a really good prospect who will play for England before he is done, BUT still has some learning to do before that moment

Fox 6 - nowhere near as bad as many make out, but a borderline Prem player who gives his all. And his dead-ball delivery is sorely missed when he doesn't play

Fonte 7 - a big surprise plus this season, he has risen to Prem level and (mostly) cut out the silly errors

Yoshida 6 - unfairly blamed for the odd error, he has got better and better

Hooiveld 4 - poor old Jos, it has all been a bit of a 'mare for him

Schneiderlin 6 - looked twice the player with Cork beside him, generally he has done okay without setting the Prem alight

S Davis 5 - comfortable on the ball but too pedestrian, too lightweight, a bit of a disappointment

Lallana 7 (just) - on his day unplayable and works hard but hasn't quite got there yet

Puncheon 6 (just) - still not convinced he is Prem class, but at least has knuckled down to be a team player

Ramirez 6 - clearly has huge talent and potential, but his injury means we haven't quite seen it yet

Rodriguez 6 - have seen enough to think he will make it in the Prem, but like a few of the others it is a steep learning curve at the moment

Mayuka 6 - same comment as above

Lambert 7 (just) - could do with a goal, but still a handful at this level

Guly 4 - I wasn't convinced he was CCC quality, even less convinced he is Prem quality

JWP, Shaw, Reeves 5 - all have the talent, just have to show they have it mentally; the backbone of our future if we stay up....

 

Adkins 5 - one or two iffy substitutions/ tactical switches don't make a bad manager. Neither does the odd mental aberration by our defenders. I still believe he is one of the brightest young managers around and we would be mad to axe him

Overall a 5 - not all good, but by no means all bad. Fundamentally we have a very talented young team, but inexperience and bad luck have conspired to make it a tough start. I just hope people keep the faith.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
 Share

×
×
  • Create New...