Player ratings this season

[rickylambert]

How do you think they've preformed this season?

 

 

Gazza-7

Yoshida-4

Fonte-7

Clyne-8

Fox-6

Schniderlin-8

Cork-N/A

Gaston-7

Lallana-5

Punch-7

Lambert-7

Steve Davis-6

Hoovield-4

[Thedelldays]

Gazza - 5

yoshida - 5

Fonte - 5

Fox - 4

Clyne - 6

Morgan - 7

Ramirez - 7

Lallana - 5

Puncheon - 5

Lambert - 7

Davis - 6

Hooiveld - 2

Rodriguez - 6

Mayuka - 6

guly - 4

 

adkins - 5

[JackFrost]

Gazza - 6

yoshida - 6

Fonte - 7

Fox - 4

Clyne - 7

Morgan - 7

Ramirez - 6

Lallana - 4

Puncheon - 5

Lambert - 7

Davis - 5

Hooiveld - 1

Rodriguez - 6

Mayuka - 7

guly - 5

 

adkins - 4

[Roger]

How do you think they've preformed this season?

 

 

Gazza-7

Yoshida-4

Fonte-7

Clyne-8

Fox-6

Schniderlin-8

Cork-N/A

Gaston-7

Lallana-5

Punch-7

Lambert-7

Steve Davis-6

Hoovield-4

 

Steven Davis 2

[Jonnyboy]

Gazza - 5

yoshida - 5

Fonte - 5

Fox - 4

Clyne - 6

Morgan - 7

Ramirez - 7

Lallana - 5

Puncheon - 5

Lambert - 7

Davis - 6

Hooiveld - 2

Rodriguez - 6

Mayuka - 6

guly - 4

 

adkins - 5

 

Fonte has been better than Gazza or Yoshida

[Mr X]

How do you think they've preformed this season?

 

 

Gazza-7

Yoshida-4

Fonte-7

Clyne-8

Fox-6

Schniderlin-8

Cork-N/A

Gaston-7

Lallana-5

Punch-7

Lambert-7

Steve Davis-6

Hoovield-4

 

schneiderlin an eight! Think that's a bit generous, no one in our team is worthy of that if its based on the season so far and not individual games

[Glasgow_Saint]

Gazza - 6

yoshida - 5

Fonte - 5

Fox - 3

Clyne - 6

Morgan - 6

Ramirez - 7

Lallana - 5

Puncheon - 5

Lambert - 7

Davis - 5

Hooiveld - 2

Rodriguez - 5

Mayuka - 5

Guly - 0

 

adkins - 5

[Lighthouse]

Gazza - 6

Boruc - 5

K. Davis - 4

Clyne - 5

Yoshi - 5

Fonte - 5

Jos - 4

Fox - 4

Gaston - 7

Morgan - 7

Davis - 6

JWP - 6

Lallana - 6

Puncheon - 6

Lambert - 7

JRod - 5

Mayuka - 6

 

Can't say I've seen all that much of the rest to make a comment.

[sidthesquid]

I'll give it bit more detail

All 3 keepers - 5 max. None of them have really looked the part and maybe splashing the cash on Butland is the answer.

Clyne 7 - a really good prospect who will play for England before he is done, BUT still has some learning to do before that moment

Fox 6 - nowhere near as bad as many make out, but a borderline Prem player who gives his all. And his dead-ball delivery is sorely missed when he doesn't play

Fonte 7 - a big surprise plus this season, he has risen to Prem level and (mostly) cut out the silly errors

Yoshida 6 - unfairly blamed for the odd error, he has got better and better

Hooiveld 4 - poor old Jos, it has all been a bit of a 'mare for him

Schneiderlin 6 - looked twice the player with Cork beside him, generally he has done okay without setting the Prem alight

S Davis 5 - comfortable on the ball but too pedestrian, too lightweight, a bit of a disappointment

Lallana 7 (just) - on his day unplayable and works hard but hasn't quite got there yet

Puncheon 6 (just) - still not convinced he is Prem class, but at least has knuckled down to be a team player

Ramirez 6 - clearly has huge talent and potential, but his injury means we haven't quite seen it yet

Rodriguez 6 - have seen enough to think he will make it in the Prem, but like a few of the others it is a steep learning curve at the moment

Mayuka 6 - same comment as above

Lambert 7 (just) - could do with a goal, but still a handful at this level

Guly 4 - I wasn't convinced he was CCC quality, even less convinced he is Prem quality

JWP, Shaw, Reeves 5 - all have the talent, just have to show they have it mentally; the backbone of our future if we stay up....

 

Adkins 5 - one or two iffy substitutions/ tactical switches don't make a bad manager. Neither does the odd mental aberration by our defenders. I still believe he is one of the brightest young managers around and we would be mad to axe him

Overall a 5 - not all good, but by no means all bad. Fundamentally we have a very talented young team, but inexperience and bad luck have conspired to make it a tough start. I just hope people keep the faith.