Who would make more of a difference. Right now j rod or billy sharp?

[Mr X]

For me lending him out for the whole season is a joke exactly the kind of poacher and physical player we needed against westham. J rod is probably technically better? Thoughts ?

[alpine_saint]

You really are a naughty bunny.

[Saint Garrett]

J-Rod is better and contributes more. HTH.

[notnowcato]

J-rod is probably better in defence

[Mr X]

  Saint Garrett said:

J-Rod is better and contributes more. HTH.

 

He also knows where the net is more than billy

[Saint_clark]

Rodriguez. Sharp was great for us, but we have better.

[eurosaint]

Perhaps Tadanari Lee will prove to be better than either of them !

Hope he gets a chance soon !

[Mowgli]

J Rod is here and playing. Sharp is not. J Road makes more of a difference. Next question?

[Supersubpuckett]

sharp is too slow for the prem - we're keeping him warm for when we get relegated

[Mr X]

  Supersubpuckett said:

sharp is too slow for the prem - we're keeping him warm for when we get relegated

 

No slower than Ricky though

[Miltonroader07]

J Rod for me and hopefully s fit Tadanari Lee

[Doctoroncall]

  Mr X said:

No slower than Ricky though

 

SRL has better control and vision.

[Fitzhugh Fella]

Jay rod is a far superior all round player to Sharp

[DaveyR]

J-Rod and Lambert in a 4-4-2 for me

[kpturner]

Mr X's daily thread.....yawn.

[Genk]

Sharpy & Jay Rod will be excellent for us in the Championship next season.

[ottery st mary]

J Rod by a country mile....

 

Would like to see our 4 strikers...all up and running/fit

 

RIkee, Rod, Mayuka and Lee.

[madruss]

  Fitzhugh Fella said:

Jay rod is a far superior all round player to Sharp

 

This. Every day of the week.

[eelpie]

  Saint Garrett said:

J-Rod is better and contributes more. HTH.

 

But it is unlikely that goal poacher Billy Sharp would have missed so many chances in front of goal. HTH

[sfc4prem]

  eelpie said:

But it is unlikely that goal poacher Billy Sharp would have missed so many chances in front of goal. HTH

 

I think you overestimate his goal-poaching ability.

[S-Clarke]

Why do players turn into world baters when they are either injured, or not playing for us? He was a decent player for us, don't get me wrong, but the same goes for Harding/Hammond and now Sharp - they're not world beaters and they moved on for a reason.

 

It doesn't take a genius to see that Jay has much more to him in terms of an all round game, and I fail to see exactly what Sharp would have done on Saturday that Jay didn't. Can Sharp defend?