If you could pick one player from another team in the PL....

[ToreSF]

who would you take?

 

Think I would have gone for Kompany at City.

[itchen_dan]

Ashley Cole. Say no more.

[Lighthouse]

Can't argue with that. A decent 'keeper would be nice but there hasn't been a stand out performer for me yet. A decent LB, so either Cole or Clichy would be good.

[ozzmeister]

Leighton bains, younger than cole (I think), class LB, set piece specialist.

[Aura]

Vidic everyday of the week.

 

would be a total boss in our Defense.

[ToreSF]

  Aura said:

Vidic everyday of the week.

 

would be a total boss in our Defense.

 

Struggled a bit against us, didn't he?

[Whitey Grandad]

  ToreSF said:

Struggled a bit against us, didn't he?

 

But he wouldn't be playing against us.

[RobM]

  itchen_dan said:

Ashley Cole. Say no more.

 

Agreed.

[Dazza82]

Howard Webb from Man Utd! lol

 

I would say Cole too or Kolarov.

[Big_Bald_Si]

Kenwyne Jones for me.

[S-Clarke]

  Big_Bald_Si said:

Kenwyne Jones for me.

 

Really? Don't rate him at all these days. Neither do Stoke, or Sunderland fans.

 

Prob a championship sriker at best, CB's know all about him at this level now.

[Jack]

Leighton Baines. Will be a top class LB for years to come.

[Glasgow_Saint]

Gerrard

[trousers]

Simple. Paul Scholes.

[Big_Bald_Si]

  S-Clarke said:

Really? Don't rate him at all these days. Neither do Stoke, or Sunderland fans.

 

Prob a championship sriker at best, CB's know all about him at this level now.

 

Sarcasm clearly doesn't read well over forums

[pimpin4rizeal]

Yaya toure for me hes the complete midfielder would also make us more solid

[lordswoodsaints]

Leighton baines

[Cheese on Toast]

Ryan Tunnicliffe

[Turkish]

  pimpin4rizeal said:

Yaya toure for me hes the complete midfielder would also make us more solid

 

Yep, the type of player we missing.

[david in sweden]

John Terry(!)....he seems to be out of favour with almost everyone else.

 

I think he'd be... (fictionally-speaking)..... a good recruit for our back line.

 

....just be sure to keep him away from the WAGS.

[Avenue Saint]

Toure

[Huffton]

Gareth Bale.

Failing that, Rory Delap...

[Patrick Bateman]

Toss up between Kompany and Ashely Cole. Given how weak our left side is, I'd go for Cole. Hypothetical I know, but if only we could have him, or both - wow!

[Sour Mash]

  pimpin4rizeal said:

Yaya toure for me hes the complete midfielder would also make us more solid

Would be my choice by a country mile.

[doddisalegend]

 

Stupid hair ...but good player might be useful defending corners to

[max_saints]

  doddisalegend said:

 

Stupid hair ...but good player might be useful defending corners to

 

this.

 

skillful player and has the physique to impose himself and bully opposing defenders. plus he has cut out his disciplinary problems, very useful player to have

[Secret Site Agent]

Leighton baines for me.

[Appy]

Yaya Toure.

[Cheese on Toast]

Definitely Gary Caldwell

[S-Clarke]

In terms of a player that would immediately fix a shortcoming in our side, it has to be Baines. I still think Clyne is a bit of a square peg at left back, he can cover there - but he's primarily a right back.

[stu0x]

  pimpin4rizeal said:

yaya toure for me hes the complete midfielder would also make us more solid

qft

[tajjuk]

Yaya Toure for me as well, the complete 'boss a game, can do everything, take the game by the scruff of the neck' midfielder. Like Gerrard was for Liverpool about 4/5 years ago.

[Bucks Saint]

Santi Cazorla coz we are really short on attacking players

[saint_bert]

Malumbu (sp?) from WBA

 

Seriously underrated footballer this guy. Exactly what we need in the middle of the park too.

[Saint_Rick]

Jagielka

[Golac's Cunning Stunts]

Queue lots of abuse but John Terry please. Class above most central defenders out there.

[tajjuk]

  Quote

Queue lots of abuse but John Terry please. Class above most central defenders out there.

 

Would take John Terry the central defender every day of the week, pretty sure he would take a bullet if it helped prevent a goal.

 

John Terry the man however........................

[Golac's Cunning Stunts]

  tajjuk said:

Would take John Terry the central defender every day of the week, pretty sure he would take a bullet if it helped prevent a goal.

 

John Terry the man however........................

Agree completely. I was going on purely football ability. He was imperious for Chelsea v the arsenal on sat

[Window Cleaner]

Baines

[ottery st mary]

Gareth Bale for me...

 

If not available ..Dembele..

[GAS]

  ToreSF said:

who would you take?

 

Think I would have gone for Kompany at City.

Downing, a proper winger who gets lots of assists and great goals. Could also help out at left back. Weekends would be more cheerful with him in the team to moan about. Failing that Yaya Toure.

[Dr. Kucho]

Difficult choice between Baines, Kompany and Fellaini. Baines and Kompany for obvious reasons and the partnership Fellaini and Schneiderlin in midfield would be amazing.

[skintsaint]

Cech

[Saint86]

I am amazed no-one has said Joe Hart or similar tbh. Its like you think Kelvin and Gazza are good keepers?

[Window Cleaner]

  Saint86 said:

I am amazed no-one has said Joe Hart or similar tbh. Its like you think Kelvin and Gazza are good keepers?

 

 

Boruc is a good keeper, well in theory anyway. Don't doubt that he'll play on Sunday myself.

[This Charming Man]

100% Yaya Toure.

 

He's one of the most complete footballers I've ever seen. Strong, fast, imposing, can tackle, can score - he can do the lot.