Jump to content

If Adkins is sacked ...


sotonjoe

Recommended Posts

All the talk about Adkins getting sacked !!! If i were Adkins i would walk. He has not had the backing of the CEO during the transfer window to get in the players HE wants, so why should he carry the can for Cortese?

 

Any proof for this, considering Adkins has said all summer that Cortese has been fantastic in giving him the backing he needed?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Any proof for this, considering Adkins has said all summer that Cortese has been fantastic in giving him the backing he needed?

 

Well Adkins has said people have been working very hard - not exactly the same thing. Either the money is not there, or it's been spent ill-advisedly in getting the players needed. I don't think it's Adkins fault - he said early on that they were looking at defensive positions - however perhaps Clyne and Yoshi were always the only targets.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

As much as people say it would be crazy to sack Nigel after a few games' date=' I think it is highly likely that the pressure will come to bear very quickly if we have a run of 2 or 3 more poor results. Football is tough and everybody wants results yesterday. A hell of a lot of money has been spent on the squad and NC will want a return on that I am sure.[/quote']

 

Ideally i'd like Nigel to be given time, but with the finances that have been invested and the massive finances at stake i think his job will be on the line. Cortese will do the deed if there are poor results in the next two games, i have no doubt in my mind about that. Lose or draw with Villa and i reckon the axe will be out of Cortese's draw ready to be sharpened, if we still have no win after the Everton game then i reckon it'll be curtains for Nigel. FWIW I think Nigel would get it right in the long term but there is just simply to much at stake for Cortese to wait and hope this happens, he will go for an impact manager, in other words a big name, whether or not that would be the answer, who knows?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

All the talk about Adkins getting sacked !!! If i were Adkins i would walk. He has not had the backing of the CEO during the transfer window to get in the players HE wants, so why should he carry the can for Cortese?

 

What a load of crap,how do you know this?

We have spent big money,it may be the case that we couldn't attract the players needed because of other factors.....my guess is that we are just not an attractive enough club with an unknown manager to attract the players needed.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Guest flickjax
What proves we are not ready yet.. That is the dumbest thing I have read on here

 

I said if we go down, i am still confident we will stay up. Learn to read.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I can't believe there are so many who would cut their noses off to spite their face.

I don't want Adkins to get the boot but staying in the prem is more important than anything,more important than Adkins keeping his job or redknapp getting the nod.

To sacrifice your premiership status just because you don't like redknapp is madness,i don't really give a monkeys who's the manager as long as we stay up,we have all had enough stress as supporters over the last few years to just throw all of the good work out of the window because of stubbornness and prejudice.

If Nigel is unable to turn it around then it's 'thanks for the good times,there's the door' I'm afraid,he is not bigger than the club and our premier league status......I would hate to look back at the end of the season after relegation and think to myself that we had a chance to do something about it and nothing was done.

I think some of you need to grow up and stop throwing your toys about when you don't get your own way.

Wether you or I like it or not,football today is all about the money and the prem is where the money is.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Any proof for this, considering Adkins has said all summer that Cortese has been fantastic in giving him the backing he needed?

 

Yes, but that was while the transfer window was still open. As I recall, it went from "we expect two more signings before the season starts", to a much watered down "everyone's working very hard behind the scenes" etc etc

 

The main thing I'd like clarified is .... WAS there any serious attempt to get a Top Class Goalkeeper ???

 

The mindset on this amazes me, I mean, what point is there in buying the most expensive bath with gold taps ...... if then you make do with a second hand plug

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Yes, but that was while the transfer window was still open. As I recall, it went from "we expect two more signings before the season starts", to a much watered down "everyone's working very hard behind the scenes" etc etc

 

The main thing I'd like clarified is .... WAS there any serious attempt to get a Top Class Goalkeeper ???

 

The mindset on this amazes me, I mean, what point is there in buying the most expensive bath with gold taps ...... if then you make do with a second hand plug

 

You end up having a shower...?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Those suggesting Arry as manager must have short memories. When he was here last time it was well known that the players just stood around on the training pitch waiting to be told what to do (e.g. practice set plays, fitness etc) and Arry spent all his time on the phone (either telephone banking for Rosie47 or calling Agents etc). The coaching of the players was NON EXISTENT.

Also can you see him working with Reed acting as DoF ? or "signing up" to the modern Sports Sciences that the Don insists on ? or bring Youth Team players into the 1st Team ? NO CHANCE.

 

What Saints need at the moment is NOT a change in manager but :-

(a) the supporters to get behind Nigel and (b) IMO they need to bring in a Defensive Coach.

 

As I've said before, AP brought in Wally Downes after a few weeks here, he is now at west ham (3 clean sheets in 4 games) so is not available, but there are others who could come in part or full time to get us to defend as a "unit" and not as "individuals". For example (a) 3rd goal on Sat either the full back or cb should be covering the space as soon as a cb is pulled out. (b) one of the midfield players at the near post should have "stepped in the path" of Van-P so that his run was BLOCKED for manure' 3rd goal and then Jose would have had a clear header away © headers out of our pen area against Skates (Jose), Boro (Hoover), Man City (Foxy) etc SHOULD NOT go out to the D of the pen area but to the wings.

 

Prehaps wGS could come in 2 days a week to work with the defence, or what is Pendrey doing these days, or Joe Jordan or Tony Adams or the other Arsenal defender working for the BBC, or prehaps the Don knows of an Italian coach/defender etc.

There are a number of good coaches around who could do a job for us at the moment to sort out the "Sunday Morning Parks League Defending" that I am seeing at the moment.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

You've written that like one of those conspiracy theory books; You put forward a rumour and then use it as fact to support the next hypothesis. Clever if your joking. Otherwise.....

 

I didn't survive and successfully conduct business in China for 20 years without learning that things are not at all as straight forward as they seem. The recent conspiracy about the murder of British businessman wasn't as one off as it seemed. It was my ability to read beyond the surface that earned me the nickname of the Fox by Chinese colleagues and business opponents. Without this ability I would never have survived, and, especially in Shanghai, top businessmen from across the world have failed miserably, failing to be able to read a situation.

Even in Europe, the UK, our lives are interwoven by spring pulling and pay backs and favors. He, who thinks, that Obama or Cameron are the top men are naive. Behind the scenes they are controlled and manipulated.

 

Concerning my post, I have maintained right from the takeover, my belief Cortese was convinced of the Saints potential by someone. Throughout, others on here, will confirm I have suspected that being Rupert Lowe. At the same time I recall very well as the hopes of being saved, reached the level of hopeless, that Harry Redknapp issued a statement, that Saints were a tremendous investment, that he had recommended the Saints to a top investor. Almost, within days, Cortese and Liebherr, arrived on the scene. The scenario of Harry is just a supposition based on what I recall at the time. That Harry now is mentioned as being Cortese's chosen option to replace Nigel, lends possibility that it was indeed Harry who convinced Cortese to seek Markus Liebherr's investment.

 

What no longer exists amongst Saintsweb members is the respect and consideration of the opinions, hunches, thoughts of fellow member. I often throw thinking into a discussion to generate fresh input and opinions from others. I refrain nowadays from humor or being sarcastic as some younger know-it-all types have too fragile personalities to see the over seriousness or funny side of a situation.

 

Each full member is equal and has paid to participate in the discussion, yet too often, this is not allowed by bullies who try to restrict the opinions of others. If you don't agree with what is posted, ignore, say respectfully one doesn't agree, reply expressing constructively one's own thoughts.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

It would be the biggest division of the fanbase ever. I simply don't know how I could continue to support the team in the same manner if he were to become manager; I simply despise everything about the man. I couldn't imagine doing anything but booing him.

 

Then again; Chris Nichol used to get absolute pelters from the home fans on his pitchside walk at the start of the games, so its not totally unprecendented!

 

It's a shortlist of two, the names are Redknapp and Hoddle; what do you do?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I think anyone who seriously thinks NC would sack Adkins to bring in Redknapp is seriously deluded. He may sack Adkins (hope he doesn't) but no way on earth would he appoint that or any other dinosaur.

 

If he does sack Adkins it will be to bring in someone that fits his philosophy. If he is as ruthless as some suggest (and there is no evidence to say that he is, Pardew was a different kettle of fish) then he will already have someone lined up and it will almost certainly be a foreign (Italian) coach.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I think anyone who seriously thinks NC would sack Adkins to bring in Redknapp is seriously deluded. He may sack Adkins (hope he doesn't) but no way on earth would he appoint that or any other dinosaur.

 

If he does sack Adkins it will be to bring in someone that fits his philosophy. If he is as ruthless as some suggest (and there is no evidence to say that he is, Pardew was a different kettle of fish) then he will already have someone lined up and it will almost certainly be a foreign (Italian) coach.

 

A couple of bookies must be seriously deluded.

 

http://www.oddschecker.com/football/football-specials/southampton-specials/next-permanent-manager

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Any proof for this, considering Adkins has said all summer that Cortese has been fantastic in giving him the backing he needed?

 

Docker doesn't need proof. Agenda driven posters just like to stir the pot occasionally. If I had to choose the person on this forum who would be least able to see into Adkins' mind to anticipate what he may or not do under different circumstances, Docker would be high up on my list.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Those suggesting Arry as manager must have short memories. When he was here last time it was well known that the players just stood around on the training pitch waiting to be told what to do (e.g. practice set plays, fitness etc) and Arry spent all his time on the phone (either telephone banking for Rosie47 or calling Agents etc). The coaching of the players was NON EXISTENT.

Also can you see him working with Reed acting as DoF ? or "signing up" to the modern Sports Sciences that the Don insists on ? or bring Youth Team players into the 1st Team ? NO CHANCE.

 

What Saints need at the moment is NOT a change in manager but :-

(a) the supporters to get behind Nigel and (b) IMO they need to bring in a Defensive Coach.

 

As I've said before, AP brought in Wally Downes after a few weeks here, he is now at west ham (3 clean sheets in 4 games) so is not available, but there are others who could come in part or full time to get us to defend as a "unit" and not as "individuals". For example (a) 3rd goal on Sat either the full back or cb should be covering the space as soon as a cb is pulled out. (b) one of the midfield players at the near post should have "stepped in the path" of Van-P so that his run was BLOCKED for manure' 3rd goal and then Jose would have had a clear header away © headers out of our pen area against Skates (Jose), Boro (Hoover), Man City (Foxy) etc SHOULD NOT go out to the D of the pen area but to the wings.

 

Prehaps wGS could come in 2 days a week to work with the defence, or what is Pendrey doing these days, or Joe Jordan or Tony Adams or the other Arsenal defender working for the BBC, or prehaps the Don knows of an Italian coach/defender etc.

There are a number of good coaches around who could do a job for us at the moment to sort out the "Sunday Morning Parks League Defending" that I am seeing at the moment.

 

Good post John, I've been advocating a new defensive coach with extensive PL experience to help Nigel, sacking Nigel is not the answer. My suggestion was Martin Keown but your other suggestions would be good. Wally Downes wouldn't be an option after AP's departure though. Jason Dood was always a good communicator away from home and his Bristolian accent could usually be heard! However, it would be a pity to disrupt his excellent work in the Academy. Is our goalkeeping support sufficient?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Adkins is a fantastic manager and replacing him adequately would require an intensive process like the one we undertook to get him here in the first place. We really would be ****ed if we had Dean Wikins in charge during the season!

 

Not being a yes man isn't the same as someone like Redknapp who has all his own ideas and would bring about chaos. A manager needs to be able to work with the chairman and DoF to get the best out of the club, not someone who throws his toys out of the pram if he doesn't get his own way.

 

Talk of getting rid of a fantastic manager after losing to the 3 best teams in the country is absolute nonsense and shows up the short termism that some fans see.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Adkins is a fantastic manager and replacing him adequately would require an intensive process like the one we undertook to get him here in the first place. We really would be ****ed if we had Dean Wikins in charge during the season!

 

Not being a yes man isn't the same as someone like Redknapp who has all his own ideas and would bring about chaos. A manager needs to be able to work with the chairman and DoF to get the best out of the club, not someone who throws his toys out of the pram if he doesn't get his own way.

 

Talk of getting rid of a fantastic manager after losing to the 3 best teams in the country is absolute nonsense and shows up the short termism that some fans see.

 

Big difference between being a fantastic championship manager and a fantastic premier league manager. Neil Warnock is a fantastic championship level manager, not in the premier league yet.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Talk of getting rid of a fantastic manager after losing to the 3 best teams in the country is absolute nonsense and shows up the short termism that some fans see.

 

Correct me if I'm wrong, but hardly any fans are calling for Adkins to get the chop. Plenty are speculating that the chairman will fire him though; two entirely different things.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I didn't survive and successfully conduct business in China for 20 years without learning that things are not at all as straight forward as they seem. The recent conspiracy about the murder of British businessman wasn't as one off as it seemed. It was my ability to read beyond the surface that earned me the nickname of the Fox by Chinese colleagues and business opponents. Without this ability I would never have survived, and, especially in Shanghai, top businessmen from across the world have failed miserably, failing to be able to read a situation.

Even in Europe, the UK, our lives are interwoven by spring pulling and pay backs and favors. He, who thinks, that Obama or Cameron are the top men are naive. Behind the scenes they are controlled and manipulated.

 

Concerning my post, I have maintained right from the takeover, my belief Cortese was convinced of the Saints potential by someone. Throughout, others on here, will confirm I have suspected that being Rupert Lowe. At the same time I recall very well as the hopes of being saved, reached the level of hopeless, that Harry Redknapp issued a statement, that Saints were a tremendous investment, that he had recommended the Saints to a top investor. Almost, within days, Cortese and Liebherr, arrived on the scene. The scenario of Harry is just a supposition based on what I recall at the time. That Harry now is mentioned as being Cortese's chosen option to replace Nigel, lends possibility that it was indeed Harry who convinced Cortese to seek Markus Liebherr's investment.

 

What no longer exists amongst Saintsweb members is the respect and consideration of the opinions, hunches, thoughts of fellow member. I often throw thinking into a discussion to generate fresh input and opinions from others. I refrain nowadays from humor or being sarcastic as some younger know-it-all types have too fragile personalities to see the over seriousness or funny side of a situation.

 

Each full member is equal and has paid to participate in the discussion, yet too often, this is not allowed by bullies who try to restrict the opinions of others. If you don't agree with what is posted, ignore, say respectfully one doesn't agree, reply expressing constructively one's own thoughts.

 

is this for real....?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

It's a shortlist of two, the names are Redknapp and Hoddle; what do you do?

 

I think the water is well under the bridge in respect of Hoddle. He would be a top appointment. he has the experience, the desire and the ability.

 

What the difference between all the promoted side this year, yeah, West Ham, and they have a manager who has more PL experience of most that are there now, what does that tell you.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I think the water is well under the bridge in respect of Hoddle. He would be a top appointment. he has the experience, the desire and the ability.

 

What the difference between all the promoted side this year, yeah, West Ham, and they have a manager who has more PL experience of most that are there now, what does that tell you.

 

I find it hilarious how many people slate Sam Allerdyce on here yet he's got a very good record. Took Bolton to top half finishes, and had Newcastle and Blackburn in midtable when he was sacked, both went down the following season. He maybe a knob as a bloke but he knows how to make teams competitve at this level.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

There is clearly some tension there and these rumours that all is not well dont come from no where. Someone has said it feels like it did in Pardews final weeks.

 

Maybe they come from the same places/people who claim that the club is up for sale, has no money and are not being supported by the owners?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I know that, and you know that

 

But does Cortese know and accept that ??

 

He is a Businessman, a SUCCESSFUL Businessman, and has posted his colors to the mast about European Competition for Saints

 

Now, he's not on about in a few season's time, he wants it NOW

 

I'd like to think that Adkins will be given say four matches with the NEW aquisitions to get a winning run going, but I have my doubts.

 

(Especially with, IMHO, our shaky defence, and an even shakier GK when under Prem Pressure )

 

We are three years into his five year plan, I would have thought he was happy to wait until then, as long as the plan is in place and progressing. As a business man he does understand that you have to speculate to accumilate, and with us two year early to the prem, we can't get instant success unless you buy the whole first team of Man City and Chelsea.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I find it hilarious how many people slate Sam Allerdyce on here yet he's got a very good record. Took Bolton to top half finishes, and had Newcastle and Blackburn in midtable when he was sacked, both went down the following season. He maybe a knob as a bloke but he knows how to make teams competitve at this level.

I might not have worded it well, i am being serious in tha fact that West Ham have an experienced manager, Reading and us do not, and so far, it shows.

It was funny last season when everyone on here went overboard with him, but I think like you, the bloke has done a lot at all (Geordies excepted, though he was only there for 5 mins!) with all the clubs he has been at, he might be a fat t wat that hoofes the ball, but he sitting better than Adkins at the mo.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I might not have worded it well, i am being serious in tha fact that West Ham have an experienced manager, Reading and us do not, and so far, it shows.

It was funny last season when everyone on here went overboard with him, but I think like you, the bloke has done a lot at all (Geordies excepted, though he was only there for 5 mins!) with all the clubs he has been at, he might be a fat t wat that hoofes the ball, but he sitting better than Adkins at the mo.

 

It wasnt aimed at you. I knew what you meant.More of the clowns who claim he doesn't have a clue and is a crap manager when his record is pretty decent and has been over about 15 years.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Those suggesting Arry as manager must have short memories. When he was here last time it was well known that the players just stood around on the training pitch waiting to be told what to do (e.g. practice set plays, fitness etc) and Arry spent all his time on the phone (either telephone banking for Rosie47 or calling Agents etc). The coaching of the players was NON EXISTENT.

Also can you see him working with Reed acting as DoF ? or "signing up" to the modern Sports Sciences that the Don insists on ? or bring Youth Team players into the 1st Team ? NO CHANCE.

 

What Saints need at the moment is NOT a change in manager but :-

(a) the supporters to get behind Nigel and (b) IMO they need to bring in a Defensive Coach.

 

As I've said before, AP brought in Wally Downes after a few weeks here, he is now at west ham (3 clean sheets in 4 games) so is not available, but there are others who could come in part or full time to get us to defend as a "unit" and not as "individuals". For example (a) 3rd goal on Sat either the full back or cb should be covering the space as soon as a cb is pulled out. (b) one of the midfield players at the near post should have "stepped in the path" of Van-P so that his run was BLOCKED for manure' 3rd goal and then Jose would have had a clear header away © headers out of our pen area against Skates (Jose), Boro (Hoover), Man City (Foxy) etc SHOULD NOT go out to the D of the pen area but to the wings.

 

Prehaps wGS could come in 2 days a week to work with the defence, or what is Pendrey doing these days, or Joe Jordan or Tony Adams or the other Arsenal defender working for the BBC, or prehaps the Don knows of an Italian coach/defender etc.

There are a number of good coaches around who could do a job for us at the moment to sort out the "Sunday Morning Parks League Defending" that I am seeing at the moment.

 

 

I like this idea, you only have to look at the improved shape and structure of the Arsenal defence since Steve Bould came in to see that this could help.

 

If a great and experienced manager like Wenger can delegate this sort of role then there is no reason for Adkins to be resistant to this.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

It wasnt aimed at you. I knew what you meant.More of the clowns who claim he doesn't have a clue and is a crap manager when his record is pretty decent and has been over about 15 years.

 

Really that adds to the argument that there is a difference between a good champ manager and a good PL manager. Big Sam really seemed to struggle with the championship last season (considering the resources he had) yet has always done well enough in the PL. Like you pointed out Warnock has been a great champ mananger looked totally out of his depth in the PL.

 

Lets hope Nigel can learn quick like Lambert at Norwich last season or he may end up following Warnock back to the championship instead.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I can't believe there are so many who would cut their noses off to spite their face.

I don't want Adkins to get the boot but staying in the prem is more important than anything,more important than Adkins keeping his job or redknapp getting the nod.

To sacrifice your premiership status just because you don't like redknapp is madness,i don't really give a monkeys who's the manager as long as we stay up,we have all had enough stress as supporters over the last few years to just throw all of the good work out of the window because of stubbornness and prejudice.

If Nigel is unable to turn it around then it's 'thanks for the good times,there's the door' I'm afraid,he is not bigger than the club and our premier league status......I would hate to look back at the end of the season after relegation and think to myself that we had a chance to do something about it and nothing was done.

I think some of you need to grow up and stop throwing your toys about when you don't get your own way.

Wether you or I like it or not,football today is all about the money and the prem is where the money is.

 

At last!! the rose tinted glasses are falling off, Keeping faith with Adkins who lets face it had by far the best team in both your promotion years (and he almost managed to fux it up) could cost you the best part of 70 mill, Next seasons Prem moneys up by 40% Two more bad results and you will be up to your necks in the worst league in the world to play catch up, admittedly you have had a shyt call with your fist 4 fixtures, Allot of peeps saying (thats 3 of the top 4 out of the way) there are at least 10 sides who could easily be top six who will have marked all the new boys down as 6 pointers, You need to get experience and know how to survive in this league n quick

Link to comment
Share on other sites

The more i think about this the more i think the Redknapp thing may come true. I know many of you hate the thought of it but of all the available candidates his name jumps out at me as the sort of appointment Cortese may go for. If not Redknapp then I wouldn't rule out an appointment connected with Italy neither.....just a hunch.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...