Jump to content

Recommended Posts

Posted

 

It has been on the HCDAJFU thread since 5.30 this morning but probably warrants its own.

 

Plays central or wide, is pace one of his attributes?

Posted

my mate who's a chelsea fan told me he's seen him play a few times and said hes no doubt a future star, Fantastic ball Control and a deadly right foot!

 

signing him would be proper decent!

 

Nige sign him up!

Posted
Rodriguez and de Bruyne both priced at £7. Wonder who ends up getting the better deal.

 

At that price I would pay it out of my own pocket ;)

Posted
Surely they could loan him out to a team playing in Europe next season - probably even the CL if they send him to France, Germany or Holland...

 

I guess it depends if they want him to get Premier League experience. Would be great as our RM, but just can't see it happening.

Posted

Don't like having players in the squad who can't play against certain teams. If we take him on loan it should be on condition that he can play against Chelsea otherwise it distorts the competition.

Posted

Hmm. I'm obviously the only one not to get excited about this. What is the point in taking a loan (no matter how good) unless here is an option to buy?

 

I would much rather see a Jarvis or Phillips in that role knowing that they are going to stick around and actually have a vested interest in where we finish in the table.

Posted
Hmm. I'm obviously the only one not to get excited about this. What is the point in taking a loan (no matter how good) unless here is an option to buy?

 

I would much rather see a Jarvis or Phillips in that role knowing that they are going to stick around and actually have a vested interest in where we finish in the table.

 

Yes, because Sturridge did really badly for Bolton the season before last...

Posted

Come on guys - this ain't gonna happen. I mean which first choice starter would he displace? Surely not Hammond, Schneiderlin, Guly, Lallana, Cork or Chaplow? Surely none of those guys...? (;

Posted
Come on guys - this ain't gonna happen. I mean which first choice starter would he displace? Surely not Hammond, Schneiderlin, Guly, Lallana, Cork or Chaplow? Surely none of those guys...? (;

 

Butland

 

Clyne - Davies - Jos - Fox

 

De Bruyne - Morgan - Cork - Lallana

 

Lambert - Rodriguez

 

just dreaming....

Posted
Hmm. I'm obviously the only one not to get excited about this. What is the point in taking a loan (no matter how good) unless here is an option to buy?

 

I would much rather see a Jarvis or Phillips in that role knowing that they are going to stick around and actually have a vested interest in where we finish in the table.

 

Part of the loan deal is that they can't play against their parent club. Thats a Premier league rule not something agreed between clubs.

Posted
Hmm. I'm obviously the only one not to get excited about this. What is the point in taking a loan (no matter how good) unless here is an option to buy?

I would much rather see a Jarvis or Phillips in that role knowing that they are going to stick around and actually have a vested interest in where we finish in the table.

 

 

well I see your point, but eventually he may want to stay. It still takes a lot to get into the Chelsea side, let alone become a regular (see Jack Cork's case) - and he hasn't turned out too badly.

Posted

Just been chatting to a Belgium visitor who was raving about this guy before I even mentioned the fact he could be coming to us on loan. He reckons de Bruyne is Belgiums best player, better than Hazard.

Posted
Don't like having players in the squad who can't play against certain teams. If we take him on loan it should be on condition that he can play against Chelsea otherwise it distorts the competition.

 

So you'd say no if he can't play Chelsea? Sheesh!

Posted

He's far too good to even consider coming to us. Though I expect Chelsea would rather loan him out to a club like us than one challenging the top four. So who knows!

Posted

De Bruyne would be a really good loan if there's something to the rumour, would have taken Courtois off them for a season too but it appears he's been loaned out to Atletico Madrid for a second season.

Posted

A season long loan? That wouldn't be in line with the plans for the club. If there is an option to buy it will be a different story. Do you really think that NC would accept Saints as a farming club to Chelsea? Our Chairman appears to have much more self confidence and much bigger plans than most contributors on here.

 

If this turns out to be true in it's simple form I'll be very surprised and will have to re-assess what is going on at SMS.

Posted (edited)
A season long loan? That wouldn't be in line with the plans for the club. If there is an option to buy it will be a different story. Do you really think that NC would accept Saints as a farming club to Chelsea? Our Chairman appears to have much more self confidence and much bigger plans than most contributors on here.

 

If this turns out to be true in it's simple form I'll be very surprised and will have to re-assess what is going on at SMS.

 

An outstanding young player is available on loan, in a position which we are short. If there was a chance and we opted against it our scouts deserve to be sacked for not making the recommendation, it's a no-brainer.

 

Then next season, when we're hopefully a bit more established, we can go out and buy a right winger. If money can be saved this season then I'm all for it.

 

As much as I'm all for this 'Southampton way' and building our own team, you cannot turn up opportunities like this.

Edited by S-Clarke
Posted
A season long loan? That wouldn't be in line with the plans for the club. If there is an option to buy it will be a different story. Do you really think that NC would accept Saints as a farming club to Chelsea? Our Chairman appears to have much more self confidence and much bigger plans than most contributors on here.

 

If this turns out to be true in it's simple form I'll be very surprised and will have to re-assess what is going on at SMS.

 

Didn't Man Utd borrow Tevez? Before he signed or did he even sign?

Posted
As much as I'm all for this 'Southampton way' and building our own team, you cannot turn up opportunities like this.

 

I'm sure that NC will turn up opportunities like that, whilst a number of fans wouldn't. If we are going to be competitive in the PL it will be because we are doing things differently. One of the things we will need is to believe that we are up there to compete. If we get all weak at the knees about a good midfielder who sits in a big clubs , has no experience of playing PL football, but all the same is going to give us the benefit of his experience, then we need to ask ourselves questions both about the club's and our own confidence in the future. There is an echo of the exaggerated expectations of Iago Falque here.

Posted
Didn't Man Utd borrow Tevez? Before he signed or did he even sign?

 

Whoops, are we comparing Kevin de Bruyn with Carlos Tevez now? Apart from that I think there were plans for buying CT, although I must admit I don't follow them, so I don't know for sure.

Posted
I'm sure that NC will turn up opportunities like that, whilst a number of fans wouldn't. If we are going to be competitive in the PL it will be because we are doing things differently. One of the things we will need is to believe that we are up there to compete. If we get all weak at the knees about a good midfielder who sits in a big clubs , has no experience of playing PL football, but all the same is going to give us the benefit of his experience, then we need to ask ourselves questions both about the club's and our own confidence in the future. There is an echo of the exaggerated expectations of Iago Falque here.

 

It's all about small steps, and if we're going to turn into this mega club (Which i'm not even going to get into on here) then we'll need the occasional help from a current top 4 club, because they have much better players than we could attract oursevles. That's the whole point.

 

This isn't anything like Falque really, De Bruyne has been proven at international and CL level for a season already. He's top class and well beyond what we could current attract in terms of a full transfer.

Posted
Hmm. I'm obviously the only one not to get excited about this. What is the point in taking a loan (no matter how good) unless here is an option to buy?

 

I would much rather see a Jarvis or Phillips in that role knowing that they are going to stick around and actually have a vested interest in where we finish in the table.

 

I don't believe you need to worry too much, a good player but no where near the hype being thrown at him. When he signed for Chelsea in January, he was told he was staying in Belguim for the rest of the season, then being loaned else where for the following season, without even a sniff at the Chelsea first team. Magical right foot that likes to cut in from the left side (we'll have to play him alongside Lallana and forget about defending that side), Not so clever if shown down the line or starting on the right, but does have some very good close control. I can see him scoring a couple of wonder goals in the Premier, then just being shepherded into mediocrity there after. I am pretty sure Chelsea would love him to come to us, but I cannot see it making any sense at all unless it is with an option to buy. If we buy J Rod I see very little sense in a loan for Saints and goes directly against everything we are trying to do. What would make sense is having him as an option if the J Rod deal were to fall through.

Posted
If we buy J Rod I see very little sense in a loan for Saints and goes directly against everything we are trying to do. What would make sense is having him as an option if the J Rod deal were to fall through.

 

No it wouldn't at all, seeing as they're both totally different players who play in completely different positions.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...