Gemmel Posted 6 April, 2011 Posted 6 April, 2011 Ok, shamelessly stolen from the the huddersfield forum, but intresting to see what they think of our players, notably, Kelvin, Fonte, Lallana and Lambert. http://downatthemac.proboards.com/index.cgi?board=general&action=display&thread=55823 Don't really know enough about other teams players to comment on who should be in it, but intrested to see who you all come up with. Oh and you don't have a choice Lallana's in
Bristol_Benji Posted 6 April, 2011 Posted 6 April, 2011 lol at the distinct lack of Chamberlain mentioned by anyone on that thread! Personally I'd definately have Lallana ahead of him, but would've thought he'd have made the subs benches on some of the choices!?
Nexstar Posted 6 April, 2011 Posted 6 April, 2011 Very surprised to see so many of their fans choose Kelvin as keeper of the season. Would definitely have Richard Lee, of Brentford, in that spot.
B Rabbit Posted 6 April, 2011 Posted 6 April, 2011 Very surprised to see so many of their fans choose Kelvin as keeper of the season. Would definitely have Richard Lee, of Brentford, in that spot. ...and on the same note...very few appreciating how ridiculously good lalallalalalana is. He is head and shoulders above anyone in our squad...and we should be automatic come the end of the season.
Gemmel Posted 7 April, 2011 Author Posted 7 April, 2011 ...and on the same note...very few appreciating how ridiculously good lalallalalalana is. He is head and shoulders above anyone in our squad...and we should be automatic come the end of the season. There are a few that recogise his talent, but I can't think of a game that he hasn't stood out (With the exception of the one when he came back from injury)
EBS1980 Posted 7 April, 2011 Posted 7 April, 2011 I guess it just shows so people only see their own team week in and week out, so aren't best positioned to judge other teams players. Fonte and Lallana should make it from Saints i'd imagine.
sambosa75 Posted 7 April, 2011 Posted 7 April, 2011 Cant imagine there being many better left backs than Dan Harding this season either.
corsacar saint Posted 7 April, 2011 Posted 7 April, 2011 How about Ryan Dickson to the above question.
Danish Saint Posted 7 April, 2011 Posted 7 April, 2011 I'll have a go at this: Davis Butterfield, Fonte, Jaidi, Harding Ox-C, Hammond, Schneiderlin, Lallana Lambert Barnard Subs: Bart, Seaborne, Dickson, Prado, Chaplow, Richardson, Forte.
saintrich Posted 7 April, 2011 Posted 7 April, 2011 Richard Lee - Brentford Inigo Calderon - Brighton Jose Fonte - Saints Gordon Greer - Brighton Craig Dawson - Rochdale Anthony Pilkington - Huddersfield George Boyd - Peterborough Gary Jones - Rochdale Adam Lallana - Saints Craig Mackail-Smith - Peterborough Glenn Murray - Brighton Subs Kelvin Davis - Saints Peter Clarke - Huddersfield Painter - Brighton Eliott Bennett - Brighton Marc Pugh - Bournemouth Rickie Lambert - Southampton BWP - Charlton/Plymouth
thesaint sfc Posted 7 April, 2011 Posted 7 April, 2011 Gotta be honest. I have very little knowledge of other teams players. When we were in the Prem I could name just about every player in every squad. In the Champ at least half of them. In L1 they're all a bit anonymous to me!
sammysaint Posted 7 April, 2011 Posted 7 April, 2011 Gotta be honest. I have very little knowledge of other teams players. When we were in the Prem I could name just about every player in every squad. In the Champ at least half of them. In L1 they're all a bit anonymous to me! Same but i know CMS,Boyd,Pilkington and Calderon are good players who could get in our side and also i coach a 9 year old Brentford fan who's certain Lee is better then Davis, with saintrich putting Lee in his team i would assume thats correct, every other position i would have saints players, ok Murrary and BWP would maybe start ahead of RL because they deserve to be in team of year but fact is RL is much better then them 2.
Kingsland Red Posted 7 April, 2011 Posted 7 April, 2011 Bizarre how often BWP appeared on the Udders thread.
The9 Posted 7 April, 2011 Posted 7 April, 2011 Cant imagine there being many better left backs than Dan Harding this season either. Really ? I can imagine there must about 10 based on what I've seen of him.
benjii Posted 7 April, 2011 Posted 7 April, 2011 Really ? I can imagine there must about 10 based on what I've seen of him. Then you have a vivid imagination.
The Flying Finn Posted 7 April, 2011 Posted 7 April, 2011 Harding has been ****poor this season. Carlisle away being his highpoint
hypochondriac Posted 7 April, 2011 Posted 7 April, 2011 Harding has been ****poor this season. Carlisle away being his highpoint Utter utter rubbish.
Jeff Le Taxi Posted 7 April, 2011 Posted 7 April, 2011 Butterfield imo is the most under rated player in Saints history, along with Lee Barnard going by how this thread is going so far!
Al de Man Posted 7 April, 2011 Posted 7 April, 2011 Brighton. I think they've proven it takes a lot more than just filling a team with Galácticos to get the best end result.
Hopkins Posted 8 April, 2011 Posted 8 April, 2011 Bizarre how often BWP appeared on the Udders thread. Not that bizarre when you appreciate he's scored goals for fun this season. Don't know enough about too many individuals to really pick a team, especially in defence but I'd have Dawson from Rochdale in it. Fonte probably too. Must have a Brighton defender in it, so Greer maybe? Possibly even Calderon too I guess, but like I said my knowledge of League One defenders is toilet. Midfield would be Bennett, Lallana, Gary Jones and Boyd. Strike force would be CMS and BWP.
niceandfriendly Posted 8 April, 2011 Posted 8 April, 2011 Utter utter rubbish. It just goes to show how immense Harding was last season that after being just slightly less consistant this season some people think he's been "**** poor". He's just so solid defensively, and offers so much gonig forward with his overlapping runs with Lallana. Two brilliant first seasons for him, and free!
Crowds Posted 8 April, 2011 Posted 8 April, 2011 Smithies Calderon, Fonte, P Clarke, Dickson Boyd, lallana, pilkington Barnard, CMS, Murray Subs Davies Butterfield Oxo Lambert Joey gudjohnson
Chez Posted 8 April, 2011 Posted 8 April, 2011 There are a few that recogise his talent, but I can't think of a game that he hasn't stood out (With the exception of the one when he came back from injury) as I recall he (lallana) was crap away at Huddersfield - hence their fans not including him.
Chez Posted 8 April, 2011 Posted 8 April, 2011 My guess it will be: Davis Calderon Fonte Greer Harding Pilkington Boyd Jones Bennett Murray CMS
daren1977 Posted 8 April, 2011 Posted 8 April, 2011 I would have to go for Davis Calderon - Fonte - Greer - Dawson Pilks - Boyd - Oxo - Lallana CMS - Barnard
krissyboy31 Posted 8 April, 2011 Posted 8 April, 2011 Davis has been very hit and miss tbh. Richard Lee and Casper Ankergren have got to be ahead of him.
sammysaint Posted 8 April, 2011 Posted 8 April, 2011 Butterfield imo is the most under rated player in Saints history, along with Lee Barnard going by how this thread is going so far! I think there both very good players
FalkirkSaint Posted 8 April, 2011 Posted 8 April, 2011 Ankegren (Brighton) Calderon (Brighton) Fonte (Saints) Clarke (Huddersfield) Dawson (Rochdale) Bennett (Brighton) Pugh (Bournemouth) or Jones (Rochdale) Lallana (Saints) Mackail-Smith (Peterborough) Murray (Brighton) Pilkington (Huddersfield)
FalkirkSaint Posted 8 April, 2011 Posted 8 April, 2011 Dawson is a CB. Pretty sure they pick 4-4-2. True, but there's no stand out left-backs in this league. And I think Pilks, Lallana and Bennett all deserve to be in the team
Chez Posted 8 April, 2011 Posted 8 April, 2011 True, but there's no stand out left-backs in this league. And I think Pilks, Lallana and Bennett all deserve to be in the team you're not wrong about the left backs. Shame Dickson didn't get more games otherwise he might have been that man. When it comes to the voting I would imagine they have to pick a left back otherwise we'd end up with a team of 5 strikers and 6 attacking midfielders.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now