Best saints goalies since 1986?

[Roger]

I started going everyweek then. My order would be:

1. Shilton

2. Niemi

3. Flowers

4. Jones

5. Brucie

 

Any thoughts. Havent included kelv as he wasnt in premier league.

Edited 21 February, 2011 by Roger

[eastleighhalo]

I would put paul jones above brucie and beasant personally

[Plonko]

I'd put Tommy Forecast above Beasant.

[Gemmel]

Shilton

Nemi

Flowers

Robsinson

Budgie

[Dimond Geezer]

If we are taking just their time at Saints into consideration:

 

Shilts

Flowers

Niemi

Jones

Budgie

Beasant

 

 

If we are talking about their entire careers:

Shilts

Brucie

Flowers

Niemi

Woods

Beasant

[chrisobee]

Shilton is our best goalkeeper ever, Niemi would be 2nd choice for me. I liked Grobellar even though he gave us some really hair raising moments! Tim Flowers was very good, possibly underrated. Paul Jones was also very consistent.

[Rory]

Beasant's pinpoint pass to John Barnes in 1996 was spectacular.

[fish fingers]

1. Ian Andrews

2. Neil Moss

3. Michael Stensgaard

4. Chris Woods

[St Columb Saint]

What no Eric Martin

[ecuk268]

I'd put Maik Taylor in there somewhere.

[Bucks Saint]

I'd put Maik Taylor in there somewhere.

 

Beat me to it. +1 defo

[Mr saint]

I bet someone will say Dexter Blackstock.

[anothersaintinsouthsea]

Dexter Blackstock

[Scudamore]

I bet someone will say Dexter Blackstock.

I'll give you 100/1 they don't...

[Deppo]

Kelvin Davis.

[Gemmel]

Kelvin Davis.

 

Deppo, will you please try harder? Davis is not in the top 5, so please rethink and come back with a proper answer and stop mucking around.

[Deppo]

Sorry, I meant Kevin Miller.

[Window Cleaner]

I've just noticed that Bob Charles isn't on the wiki list of past and present Saints players.Not that it's anything to do with this thread of course.Perhaps one of our wikiesxperts could rectify that. I'm sure Duncan could fill you in on him.

[Gemmel]

Sorry, I meant Kevin Miller.

 

Thank you

[SNSUN]

4. Chris Woods

 

Lol I could've done a better job. One of the rare times an injury to a player improved the side.

[MarkSFC]

Beasant's pinpoint pass to John Barnes in 1996 was spectacular.

 

yeah that was glorious!!

[MarkSFC]

No-one has ever come anywhere near Shilts.

 

In 1982 when he joined I was on a summer football course and we were on the pitch during a tour of The Dell when in ran two blokes. Quickly our coach realised who one of them was and mentioned that if you want an example of a true pro then look out there at Peter Shilton. He doesnt have to report back for pre-season for a week or two yet here he is training. Made quite an impression on a 13 year old!

[mitch01]

Niemi maintained the highest level of performance out of any player I have ever seen at SFC, then again I've only been a supporter for 10 years.

[paulwantsapint]

Never saw shilts or budgie

so

1 niemi

2 flowers

3 jones

4 taylor

5 beasent

[aintforever]

1. Shilts

2. Neimi

3. Flowers

4. Jones

5. Beasant

 

Was a tough choice between Beasant and Brucie for no5 but I gave it to Dodgy Dave for telling that joke to the entire away end at Alan Night's testimonial.

[Saint Stimp]

Anyone know if there's a video of Niemi hitting the bar vs Fulham about? Where Svensson heads in from the rebound?

[K,Billy's supersound]

Michael Stensgaard gotta be in with a shout, top 5 in anyones list i'm sure

[farawaysaint]

I'll give you 100/1 they don't...

 

Put me down for 100 quid please. Dexter Blackstock is our greatest goalie ever perfect record of clean sheets.