Jump to content

Recommended Posts

Posted

May be a bit early but thought it might be interesting to guess whether we'll go with a full strength team or not. If you consider that we could make 10 changes from Tuesday and still put out

 

-------------Bart----------------

Richardson Jaidi Martin Dickson

Puncheon Schneiderlin Wotton :cry: Holmes

------ Guly --- Bignall ------------

 

Doesn't look too bad, does it?

 

 

BTW, really looking forward to their fans' rendition of "When the Shrews go marching in" :lol:

Posted (edited)

If Bignall does not get permission to play, a possible debut could be on the cards for Doble, or NA may revert back to a Lambert/Guly combo IMO....

I don't think you're far off though - could be that all the subs from Tuesday may start on Saturday...

Edited by markr27
Posted

I think we should start with....

 

Bart

 

Richardon

Fonte

Jaidi

Dickson

 

Puncheon

Morgan

Hammond

Holmes

 

Guly

Lambert

 

 

with making an show from the bench...

 

Martin

Bignall

lallana or chamberlin

Posted
If Bignall does not get permission to play, a possible debut could be on the cards for Doble, or NA may revert back to a Lambert/Guly combo IMO....

I don't think you're far off though - could be that all the subs from Tuesday may start on Saturday...

 

I'd certainly keep Oxo and Lallana on the bench. The Wotton bit was tongue in cheek - probably will be Morgan and Hammond since if Chaplow is here he may not get permission. But I think Dickson, Jaidi, Martin, Bart in particular are too good to be just playing reserve, sorry "development" games and they should be able to do a job.

 

I dread thinking that we won't win easily. Shrewsbury is my local team and I work with far too many people waiting to gloat on Monday if we slip up.

Posted

Chaplow will probably play if he has no future at Preston and he's still here on Saturday. I think it'll be a Fonte/Jaidi combo at the back, with the former wearing the captain's armband.

Posted

Saints for the first round of the JPT put out the strongest side maybe bar Jaidi/Martin.

 

The FA Cup is a more prestigious competition, with more prize money and potential future earnings at stake. I doubt there will be wholesale changes to the team against a team flying high only one league below.

Posted
Saints for the first round of the JPT put out the strongest side maybe bar Jaidi/Martin.

 

The FA Cup is a more prestigious competition, with more prize money and potential future earnings at stake. I doubt there will be wholesale changes to the team against a team flying high only one league below.

 

You might be right but I would still pick a team without Lallana, Fonte, Davis, Harding, Hammond, Chaplow, Lambert and Barnard for this one. It is completely pointless. We have no hope of winning the FA Cup and no need for further ticket money from getting a "glamour" draw. I would like us to win the game as winning is fun and the cup is fun but this is a valuable opportunity to give some players a run-out against a decentish team.

Posted

Pardew's theory was that we put out the strongest team in all competitions and try to get as far as possible. This certainly worked last season with a nice FA Cup run and the JPT win. This season however our priority is certainly only the league. Adkins recognises this and doesn't need a cup run to lift spirits, as we did last season.

 

However, regardless of who starts we should not have a problem turning Shrewsbury over. Even though they are performing well in L2, so are we in L1 and we would be comfortable in the Championship with this team.

Posted

I think the team will be similar to tuesday. A good time to continue the present momentum. I don't agree benji that its pointless. There is still much for this team to learn.

Posted

I'm not arguing that Shrewsbury are a pushover or that we don't want to win. My point is that we really do now have a strong squad and most of the "reserve" players should be able to deliver against any League 1/2 opposition and need serious match practice. They'll also know it's a chance to impress and challenge for regular places and will maybe even encourage the others.

Posted
I'm not arguing that Shrewsbury are a pushover or that we don't want to win. My point is that we really do now have a strong squad and most of the "reserve" players should be able to deliver against any League 1/2 opposition and need serious match practice. They'll also know it's a chance to impress and challenge for regular places and will maybe even encourage the others.

 

Exactly.

 

I would be surprised if the team below was not capable of beating Shrewsbury at home, if it performs properly:

 

------------------------Bart---------------------

 

Richardson--------Jaidi---Martin (is he fit?)-----Dickson

 

Chamberlain-----Wotton-----Schneiderlin-------Holmes

 

---------------------Guly------------------------

 

---------------Bignall / Doble----------------------

Posted

Bart

 

FR - Jaidi - Martin - Dickson

 

Puncheon - Morgan - Guly - Holmes

 

Lambert - Bignall/Doble

 

 

 

Think this game could be a good confidence builder for Lambert and Puncheon if they can pull out a performance.

Posted

Bialkowski

Richardson Martin Jaidi Dickson

Chambelain Wotton Schneiderlin Holmes

Guly Doble

 

Subs

Forecast

Seabourne

Hammond

Mcnish

Puncheon

Chaplow

Lambert

Posted
I don't see why people want wholesale changes. Carlisle is 7 days later which is plenty of time. I'd rather Saints put a strong side out and won on Saturday than rest players.

 

I agree we need to keep on winning and playing with a settled team

Posted
I don't see why people want wholesale changes. Carlisle is 7 days later which is plenty of time. I'd rather Saints put a strong side out and won on Saturday than rest players.

 

Its all about envolving the squad and getting them used to how NA wants them to play, also gives them a chance to stake a claim for a starting place.

Posted
Its all about envolving the squad and getting them used to how NA wants them to play, also gives them a chance to stake a claim for a starting place.

 

I'd prefer one or two changes and a victory, rather than 8 or 9 changes and a defeat to a good team from the league below.

Posted
I'd prefer one or two changes and a victory, rather than 8 or 9 changes and a defeat to a good team from the league below.

 

They are a good team from a league below and im sure our squad will be more than good enough for them, with players playing to prove to the gaffer they deserve to get a run in the team

Posted

I don't want to see wholesale changes but I would like to see a few players rested. As great as it is to have a run in the cup and it would be good to get to Rd 3 and pull "a big team", promotion this year is paramount.

 

After Saturday we have 3 tough games where no less than 7 points should be the target. We have a good squad so some changes should not disrupt things too much and indeed mau well produce a really good performance as those currently out of the team may well force Adkins hand for Carlisle.

 

My starting XI would be;

 

Bart

FR. Jaidi. Martin. Dickson

 

OX. Chaplow. Morgan. Holmes

 

Lambert. Barnard

 

 

Impact Players

 

Davis

Seabourne

Lallana

Doble

Wotton

Guly

Punch

Posted

With Fonte off on his hols for the weekend and possible Davis too, keeping a winning team is not going to happen. In my OP I said tongue-in-cheek that we could make 10 changes, and that's not going to happen either. I expect something like

 

 

---------- Bart -----------------

 

Richardson Jaidi/Martin Seabourne Harding/Dickson

 

Puncheon Hammond Chaplow Dickson/Holmes

 

---- Guly ------- Lambert/Barnard

 

Subs: Lallana or Wotton if we want to give AL a rest, Schneiderlin, Oxlade-Chamberlain, Barnard/Lambert, Martin/Jaidi, GK (don't know who's available), Doble

Posted
Not for me, keep him in, get him some goals and much needed confidence.

 

Give Puncheon a rest - a very long one ! Can I suggest a week's break on a trawler at Iceland this should make him more focused cos God he needs to be!

Posted
Give Puncheon a rest - a very long one ! Can I suggest a week's break on a trawler at Iceland this should make him more focused cos God he needs to be!

 

I'd play him tomorrow too.

Posted

Don't Just take the 'Shrews' for granted. My nipper and I were there when they beat us 2 - 1 a few years back and we were a Prem Side! Trouble was the 'No Brain Oaf ' was in charge.Need I say more?

Posted

make as few changes as possible, it is always the best policy. The more players play together the better they willl become. Only rest players if they are carrying an injury, that would be my policy. Only exception I might concede is Bart for Davis.

Posted

my line up would be.

 

bart

 

frazer martin jaidi dickson

 

puncheon wotton chaplow holmes

 

guly doble

 

davis, seabourne,harding,hammond,oxo,barnard, tony garrod

 

this team should be more than good enough to do a professional job at home 2-0 win.

Posted
Don't Just take the 'Shrews' for granted. My nipper and I were there when they beat us 2 - 1 a few years back and we were a Prem Side! Trouble was the 'No Brain Oaf ' was in charge.Need I say more?

 

Nobody is taking them for granted, however a team consisting of Dickson, Holmes, Puncheon, Jaidi et. al. should beat them.

Posted

What if we field a reserve team and go 2-0 down????

 

I think you're way wide of the mark. Adders fancies the Cup so we will go in strength, resting only those who are knackered and maybe AC 'cos he "cramps up" whatever that means in my native Hampshire English. Richardson is only just back and needs the run, so too Seaborne and I wouldn't want to be the poor sodding coach who has to tell Dan Hard-ing that he's not included.

Posted
So, if we make it through and have the choice of a Premiership side or our blue neighbours, who would you want?

 

Need to win 2 games before that....

Posted

Fairly strong line up IMO.

 

Bart - Gives Davis a break, I don't have a shred of worry about Bart covering.

 

Frazer - Still needs match fitness

Martin - A welcome run out for him I would think, having been out for a while

Seaborne - To keep some familiarity in the back four.

Dickson - Gives Harding a break and Ryan can show what he can do.

 

The OC - undroppable after that performance on Tuesday. A chance to show his skills on the bigger stage. (Televisually-wise)

Chappers - if Preston let us play him, I'd keep him in.

Morgan - as he was dropped on Tuesday he should be fresh.

Puncheon - That's right, on the left, and it gives Lallana a break.

 

Guly - Skillz McGrillz

Lambert - Play him until he scores from open play, dammit!

 

subs: Davis, Harding, Jaidi, Hammond, Lallana, Barnard, Wotton.

 

Big win IMO, I know it's the FA cup and upsets happen but I really can't see it.

Posted
Away to Pompey would be my choice.

 

In God's name, why? Cheats FC currently have a stronger team, thanks to paying wages for players they can't afford. Wait until they implode next year, then we can give them a jolly good rogering.

Posted
I don't see why people want wholesale changes. Carlisle is 7 days later which is plenty of time. I'd rather Saints put a strong side out and won on Saturday than rest players.

 

Yes, but what if our strong players pick up injuries or suspensions? I agree Saints shouldn't send out a reserve team, but a few players rested wouldn't hurt.

 

One thing seems unanimous though: Bart must play. :)

Posted
Give Lambert a rest.

I disagree,he needs to play.

He is seriously lacking spark, and has done so for sometime now,this game could give the opportunity to net from open play and he needs to regain that form.

Posted

Difficult decisions today, sit upstairs with a broken A/C system listening to the Under Perform Group's SaintsPlayer dropping in and out.

 

Or sit downstairs where the A/C is fine and watch the Egg chasers in HD

 

hmmmmmmmmm

Posted
Difficult decisions today, sit upstairs with a broken A/C system listening to the Under Perform Group's SaintsPlayer dropping in and out.

 

Or sit downstairs where the A/C is fine and watch the Egg chasers in HD

 

hmmmmmmmmm

 

 

Move your computer downstairs! Nothings that bad that you have to watch egg chasing over listening to Saints, however bad the feed!!

Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.
×
×
  • Create New...