Jump to content

Morgan appeal won

Yorkshire Saint

By Yorkshire Saint
in The Saints

 Share

Recommended Posts

JRM

JRM

Posted
Posted

I said after the game that it should never have been a red card, the mk dons player made an advance towards schneiderlin, not the other way round, he was therefore just defending himself. There needs to be some common sense and this is good to hear.

JonnyLove

JonnyLove

Posted
Posted

What the hell is going on. not only do we have a great ownership team, a Great Management team and improving playing team. cup runs and good results all over the place. A Great feel good factor.

 

But to top it all off we are also wining appeals to the FA which lets face it would of lost and been hit with the whole squad being banned for 100 years before hand.

 

I don't think I want this season to end.

Toadhall Saint

Toadhall Saint

Posted
Posted
What the hell is going on. not only do we have a great ownership team, a Great Management team and improving playing team. cup runs and good results all over the place. A Great feel good factor.

 

But to top it all off we are also wining appeals to the FA which lets face it would of lost and been hit with the whole squad being banned for 100 years before hand.

 

I don't think I want this season to end.

 

LOL! Everyone loves a Saint!

sussexsaint

sussexsaint

Posted
Posted
What the hell is going on. not only do we have a great ownership team, a Great Management team and improving playing team. cup runs and good results all over the place. A Great feel good factor.

 

But to top it all off we are also wining appeals to the FA which lets face it would of lost and been hit with the whole squad being banned for 100 years before hand.

 

I don't think I want this season to end.

 

I was just going to write this, this is a fantastic season, I genuinely have not stopped smiling for months now :D

Matthew Le God

Matthew Le God

Posted
Posted
I wonder if NC said to the FA. "You know those 10 points you took from us and we said we would not appeal. Well it's time to call in a favour"

 

The Football League gave Saints -10 not the Football Association.

Red Alert

Red Alert

Posted
Posted
I wonder if NC said to the FA. "You know those 10 points you took from us and we said we would not appeal. Well it's time to call in a favour"

 

I would be gutted if he made that call and all we got was Morgan back two games quicker. ;)

SFC Forever

SFC Forever

Posted
Posted
The Football League gave Saints -10 not the Football Association.

 

The FA were told politely that pompeys books are due for another close inspection. Reminded them that Luton were hammered when such previous offences as mismanaging funds occured. Also asked if they were backing the pompey mismanagement.

Block 5

Block 5

Posted
Posted
You just know he will score the winning goal tomorow now!!

 

I have been waiting for him to score any goal (and I've had a few bets too) and so far nothing.... nada...zilch....zip.

iansums

iansums

Posted
Posted
This must meen we are a top 4 club! Got the FA in our back pocket already...

 

Does this mean if we are one-nil down we can get 'Pardew time'?;)

Saint J 77

Saint J 77

Posted
Posted
just the one game v ipswich served !

 

http://www.dailyecho.co.uk/sport/saints/

 

This is good news its little things like this that shows me things are starting turning about for the better for us. If this had happened last season it would not have been over turned, we probably would not have even appealed. Things are slowly turning in our favour. Could be a good sign for the Pompey match?

JonnyLove

JonnyLove

Posted
Posted
This must meen we are a top 4 club! Got the FA in our back pocket already...

 

Yes and when the rest of the prem implodes only

chelsea,

Man City,

QPR

Saints

Spuds

Villa

 

Will be considered for any perks / added time and rights to feild weekended teams and slate all competitions for being needless and crap (apart from the title and europe)

Matthew Le God

Matthew Le God

Posted
Posted
Yes and when the rest of the prem implodes only

chelsea,

Man City,

QPR

Saints

Spuds

Villa

 

Will be considered for any perks / added time and rights to feild weekended teams and slate all competitions for being needless and crap (apart from the title and europe)

 

:D

 

What makes you think QPR will have any success? Yes, they have rich owners, but they are idiots, sacked about 9 managers and haven't invested much.

krissyboy31

krissyboy31

Posted
Posted

Result!! I thought that the sending off was harsh but could see the referee (to the letter of the law) was correct! When I saw we appealed I honestly thought he might get an extra match added, didn't see the decision being rescinded coming, at all.

SuperMikey

SuperMikey

Posted
Posted

Brilliant news, feel a lot more confident about the upcoming games now with him back in the side. Wotton and James didn't really work that well on Saturday. James and Schneiderlin tomorrow please Pardew.

Gaucho

Gaucho

Posted
Posted
Strange this because there was a piece in the Echo last Thursday quoting Pardew saying the club would not appeal, especially as the 3 match ban could be extended to 4.

 

Did the club actually appeal though? - I read it as the FA decided to review it and came to the conclusion all on their own. Is that possible?

John B

John B

Posted
Posted
Did the club actually appeal though? - I read it as the FA decided to review it and came to the conclusion all on their own. Is that possible?

 

Not according to the Echo which could of course be wrong

Window Cleaner

Window Cleaner

Posted
Posted (edited)
The FA have upheld the red card but reduced the ban to one match

 

couldn't reduce it any more because he'd already served 1 match,they could have given him a get out of jail card for next time though I suppose.

More importantly he won't get fined so much (because cards sometimes have a financial kick in the arse as well) either by the FA or by the club.

Edited by Window Cleaner
Guest Dark Sotonic Mills

Guest Dark Sotonic Mills

Posted
Posted

From the FA site:

 

The latest cases heard by Regulatory Commissions and charges issued.

Monday 25 January 2010

 

Morgan Schneiderlin, Southampton FC

Milton Keynes Dons v Southampton

Johnstone's Paint Trophy, 20 January 2010

Dismissed for violent conduct

Claim made that the standard punishment is clearly excessive

 

Claim upheld, three-match suspension reduced to one-match

SNSUN

SNSUN

Posted
Posted

Good news. Until a new central midfielder comes in, we were looking a bit short in that area, although full credit to James and Wotton for Saturday.

VectisSaint

VectisSaint

Posted
Posted
I wonder if NC said to the FA. "You know those 10 points you took from us and we said we would not appeal. Well it's time to call in a favour"

Probably not because it was the Football League that docked us 10 points, and the Football Association who have rescinded the red card. You do realise there is a difference?

CHAPEL END CHARLIE

CHAPEL END CHARLIE

Posted
Posted
Probably not because it was the Football League that docked us 10 points, and the Football Association who have rescinded the red card. You do realise there is a difference?

 

Excellent point ! - pity it was first made 25 posts ago .

 

Do try to keep up old chap .

musesaint

musesaint

Posted
Posted
Am i the only one on here that thinks, although the reff was aweful, that when a player raises his hands to another players face/neck and makes contact its a red card? Money talks?

 

Needs to be looked at in context

 

Should have been either a yellow for BOTH players ...or if not a red for BOTH ...the fact that Morgan got the only red for the incident may have influenced the Appeal

 

But yes the ref was sh*ite

Saint_John

Saint_John

Posted
Posted
Beautiful!!

 

What a joke that ref was.......

 

On the night I thought he was completely rubbish as well.

 

However the last time he was in charge of a Saints game was Feb 2008, do you remember the pen 4 mins from time ?

http://www.saintsfc.co.uk/page/MatchReport/0,,10280~38703,00.html

 

(With just under four minutes on the clock, referee Jonathan Moss stunned everyone by suddenly stopping play to consult his assistant before pointing to the spot to give Southampton a penalty.

None of the Saints players had appealed, even the away fans tucked close behind that goal did not shout for it....)

 

 

Looking at his other games as well I have the feeling that he is one of those refs who "knows the final score in the first min", and we beat him the other night because he had the game down as a draw (IMO).

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
 Share
Go to topic listing
×
×
  • Create New...