Jump to content

Team v Charlton?

NickG

By NickG
in The Saints

 Share

Recommended Posts

Saint_Jonny

Saint_Jonny

Posted
Posted

Like the look of the team above (second post) seeing as Lallana hasn't been crap enough to lose his place in the side. Only change I would make is Morgan for James, hes been quality thus far. Saying that Morgan has been quality coming off the bench so I could be wrong.

saintstr1

saintstr1

Posted
Posted

I think it is now time to maybe play a bit more adventurous , Especially with the players we have and so I would like to see us playing a 4-3-3 or a flexible 4-4-2.

 

Davis

 

Thomas. Jaidi. Trotman. Harding

 

Waigo. James. Hammond. Holmes

 

Saga. Lambert

 

Subs:- Bialkowski , Perry , Lallana , Schniederlin , Mellis , Mills, Patterson

J Bizzle

J Bizzle

Posted
Posted

I would personally go for a 4-3-3

 

-----------------------------Davis

 

Thomas---------------Trotman-----Jaidi-----------------Harding

 

-----------------------------James

-------------------Hammond-----Schneiderlin

 

Waigo-------------------------------------------------------Mills

---------------------------Lambert

 

 

Will probs see a 4-4-2

 

Davis

Thomas Trotman Jaidi Harding

Lallana Hammond Schneiderlin Mills

Waigo Lambert.

Bailey

Bailey

Posted
Posted

Got to be this . . .

 

Davis

 

Thomas - Jaidi - Trotman - Harding

 

Waigo - Hammond - Schneiderlin - Mills

 

Lallana - Lambert

 

Subs: Bialkowski, Perry, Wotton, Holmes, Thomson, Mellis, Paterson

red&white56

red&white56

Posted
Posted
I predict some jaw dropping astonishing moments from Mr Wiago. I cannot predict whether or not they will be for good reasons or bad reasons though ;-)

 

I can't go but i hope the You Tube generation will do their bit and record some great Wiago moments for me to check out on Sunday! I'm especially looing forward to his first goal !

Rebel

Rebel

Posted
Posted

Its got to be:

 

 

 

Davis

 

Thomas Jaidi Trotman Harding

 

Waigo Morgan Hammond Lallana

 

Lambert Saga

 

 

gives us a strong solid defence with Harding giving us some width going forward on the left and Waigo on the right

 

the best we've played so far this season was against Brum City for the first 70 mins and a lot of that was down to the interplay on the left going fowards between Harding, Lallana, Lambert and Saga

 

Thomas was solid at right back against Colchester and got forward quite a bit as well - now if he can do that again and feed Waigo the ball with time and space to run at the oppo we should look good on the right as well

 

Morgan as playmaker looking for Waigo in space on the right and Lallana on the left and/or Lambert dropping off Saga on the edge of the box(Morgan stood out in his brief cameo against Colchester - its time to give him a start)

 

Saga leading the line and looking for the flick-ons and one-twos with Lambert

 

Hammond as the box-to-box midfielder - being our extra man in their box!

 

Lallana needs to be encouraged to run at the oppo defence as when he does he causes chaos and space for Saga and Lambert

 

I'm hoping Waigo will give us some pace on the break and be a cross between a right winger and a third striker for us!!

shurlock

shurlock

Posted
Posted

Without stating the obvious, would be good to pick up a team that also attempts to neutralise Charlton's strengths (after all we are going to their place). They like to get the ball wide where they have pace to burn. Maybe we need a greater screen in midfield (so Schneiderlin misses out?) or Waigo plays on right wing rather than down the middle to track back with his pace (an added bonus that he's had experience of playing RB in the past). I do fear that if we just try and set our most attacking stall out as most posts are doing, we'll actually see very little of the ball and might have another Huddersfield on our hands.

eharty9

eharty9

Posted
Posted

-----------------Davis--------------------

 

thomas------jaidi------trotman-------harding

 

---------------scneiderlin------------------

 

------hammond-----------james-----------

 

waigo-------------------------------mills/holmes

 

------------Lambert------------------

Andy_Porter

Andy_Porter

Posted
Posted

I think a 4-5-1 is the way forward against Charlton, not sure which three from Lallana, Hammond, Schneiderlin, James and Gillett should play in the middle though. Really suprised Gillett hasn't been mentioned once in this thread, at the start of the season he would have been in 90% of teams. I'd still like to see him play ahead of James, especially if we're playing with five in midfield.

 

At least then we've got Saga and Paterson on the bench if we need to change the game and get a goal or two.

jam

jam

Posted
Posted 
                  Davis

Thomas     Jaidi       Trotman      Harding

Lallana    Scheiderlin   Hammond      Mills

           Waigo        Lambert

Subs:

Bart
Perry
James
Mellis
Paterson
Saganowski
Holmes

 

Like that but maybe swap James for Lallana. Better defensively and better crosses for the front two.

madruss

madruss

Posted
Posted
Got to be as MLG said.

 

Play Papa up front where he doesn't have to track back and can use his pace in the most dangerous areas.

 

I agree. This way he'll also be able to create space for Lambert, who had a difficult time of it against Colchester, mainly due to the fact that he was being double and sometimes tripled marked. With defenders being pulled all over the place by Waigo's (alleged) pace, Lambert will be more likely to get chances on goal

Clifford Nelson

Clifford Nelson

Posted
Posted 
                  Davis

Thomas     Jaidi       Trotman      Harding

Lallana    Scheiderlin   Hammond      Mills

           Waigo        Lambert

Subs:

Bart
Perry
James
Mellis
Paterson
Saganowski
Holmes

 

I can't see it in any other way. Lallana will be in the starting line up and AP will never take the risk of starting Papa on the wing without knowing how he plays. At home possibly, but never away. Then, of course, I'll prove to be dreadfully wrong.

NickG

NickG

Posted
  • Author
Posted
Got to be this . . .

 

Davis

 

Thomas - Jaidi - Trotman - Harding

 

Waigo - Hammond - Schneiderlin - Mills

 

Lallana - Lambert

 

Subs: Bialkowski, Perry, Wotton, Holmes, Thomson, Mellis, Paterson

 

dropping Saga from first 11 to not even on bench?

Northam Girls

Northam Girls

Posted
Posted
davis

thomas jaidi trotman harding

lallana james hammond holmes

waigo lambert

 

bart perry schneiderlin mellis mills saganowski paterson

 

Like this but would play Mills instead of Holmes in this one. Better defensively and can dovetail with Harding.

NickG

NickG

Posted
  • Author
Posted

Very sad but just gone through this to see the most popular team.

 

looking at each position to see who get the most votes for that position (rather than using the 11 players with most votes) the team is

 

back 5 - all agreed.

 

midfield - Papa Hammond Schniederlin Mills

 

forwards - Saga and Lambert.

 

Interesting bits for me;

 

no place for Lallana - had votes in several differnet positions. AP is big fan and sure will want to use him but where?

 

Everyone agreed on

Kelvin - no surprise

Thomas

 

Harding / Jaidi / Trottman / Hammond and Harding - all AP signings (and sure Murty would have been as well.

badgerx16

badgerx16

Posted
Posted

Not wanting to p1ss on anybody's parade, but we have spent the last 6 matches bemoaning the lack of pre-season & match practice in the squad, yet as far as I can see all the selections above include Jaidi & Waigo- just remind me how much first team action either has seen in the last 6 months ?

In my opinion Jaidi might well start, but how long will he last, and how sharp is he likely to be ? And I think Papa will be on the bench as an 'impact substitute'.

St Marco

St Marco

Posted
Posted

As i said in the last thread i would not put Morgan or Mills in simply because Morgan has overall been gash and since he has been taken out we look a better more compact side. A team that has let only 2 goals in. He is a good player, potential to be a great player but he is one of those players who will either be involved for about 20-30mins of a game or not be involved at all. James has done better then Morgan thus far and does his job well. Charlton are a team that will battle for midfield and we need likewise players in there.

If all fit then

 

 

---------------------Davis-----------------

 

Thomas------Jaidi--------Del Boy------Harding

 

Lallana -------Hammond---James------Holmes

 

--------------Papa Smurf----Lambert----------

 

Then if things are still solid and tight we have room to manouver. We can chase the game by then bringing on Mellis/Saga/Mills. Or if we need to go a little defensive we can then bring on Wotten/Perry. Or if we need a period where we want to get the ball up the front as quick as possible we can bring on Morgan with his passing.

This is a game where we have to remain solid and work hard from start to finish if we are to come away with anything. In other games against lesser sides then maybe start with him.

Minsk

Minsk

Posted
Posted
Without stating the obvious, would be good to pick up a team that also attempts to neutralise Charlton's strengths (after all we are going to their place). They like to get the ball wide where they have pace to burn. Maybe we need a greater screen in midfield (so Schneiderlin misses out?) or Waigo plays on right wing rather than down the middle to track back with his pace (an added bonus that he's had experience of playing RB in the past). I do fear that if we just try and set our most attacking stall out as most posts are doing, we'll actually see very little of the ball and might have another Huddersfield on our hands.

 

No sh!t Shurlock! (Sorry, couldn't resist that one.) Seriously though, well said. We are playing AWAY to the team TOP of the league with 6 WINS OUT OF 6. Part of the problem last season was us not bothering about who the oposition were or how they play. Let's not repeat that please.

 

My team would be:

 

--------------------------Davis-----------------------------

 

Thomas--------Jaidi--------------Trotman-----Harding

 

James--------Morgan------------Hammond-------Mills

 

-------------------Lallana----------------------------------

 

------------------------------Lambert----------------------

 

However, I expect it to be this:

 

--------------------------Davis-----------------------------

 

Thomas--------Jaidi--------------Trotman-----Harding

 

Lallana--------James------------Hammond-------Mills

 

-----------------Lambert----------Saga------------------

 

With, as a couple of others have said, Waigo coming off the bench for the last 30 mins or so.

Gordon Mockles

Gordon Mockles

Posted
Posted
-----------------Davis--------------------

 

thomas------jaidi------trotman-------harding

 

---------------scneiderlin------------------

 

------hammond-----------james-----------

 

waigo-------------------------------mills/holmes

 

------------Lambert------------------

 

Davis 32 6'1

Thomas 30 6'2

Jaidi 34 6'2

Trotman 22 6'2

Harding 25 6'0

Waigo 25 6'1

James 21 5'8

Hammond 26 6'0

Holmes 22 5'8

Saga 30 5'10

Lambert 27 6'2

 

I think you'll find Jaidi's Nearer 6' 4" (or 6' 3.5" if I remember right

?!)

chrisobee

chrisobee

Posted
Posted 
                  Davis

Thomas     Jaidi       Trotman      Harding

Lallana    Scheiderlin   Hammond      Mills

           Waigo        Lambert

Subs:

Bart
Perry
James
Mellis
Paterson
Saganowski
Holmes

 

Yep, I'd go with that exactly, Schniederlin has to play for me and Waigo up front and not on the right side of midfield. Could leave Thomas exposed if Papa goes a wandering as I think he might and I think that he needs a freer role anyway to be at his most effective though that is clearly based on very limited knowledge of him.

chrisobee

chrisobee

Posted
Posted
I think you'll find Jaidi's Nearer 6' 4" (or 6' 3.5" if I remember right

?!)

 

Any advance on 6'4 ! Says 6'2 on OS and 6'3.5 on Wikapedia. I'm inclined to favour the accuracy of the latter !

samoakley

samoakley

Posted
Posted

I think most people on here have named the squad we should play but i have a feeling that saga will be on bench because of being away with poland.

 

I wouldnt mind seeing holmes get at least 20 mins out on the wing and push for a starting place as hes a natural winger and lallana is better in the middle or off the striker.

The one thing i think will be defo is the back 5 being the following

Davis

Thomas

Jihadi

Perry

Harding

iansums

iansums

Posted
Posted

Davis

 

Thomas Jaidi Trotman Harding

 

Papa Morgan Hammond Holmes/Mills

 

Saga/Lallana Lambert

 

When I chose the above the only two positions I had to think hard about were LM and RA. I do wonder whether Lallana's best position is in the hole ala Rooney, especially having Papa out wide. God I hope Papa lives up to the hype.

SNSUN

SNSUN

Posted
Posted

Chuffing looking forward to this one now!

 

Davis

 

Thomas Jaidi Trotman Harding

 

Waigo James Hammond Mills

 

Lallana

 

Lambert

 

(although I still think Lallana will be left in at left midfield and Saga played up front. There's also the dillema of who to play alongside Hammond, could it be James, Mellis, Morgan, Wotton, Gillett, or even Lallana? One of a managers greatest and worst decisions is when he's blessed with a full squad. James for me gets the nod, just ahead of Mellis, but I wouldn't be suprised to see any of them in there...)

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
 Share
Go to topic listing
×
×
  • Create New...