The exeter game seems to sum up Kelvin in a single game. Excellent shot stopper of "glory shots". As a keeper i love saving the ones full length dive a couple of foot off the ground as they look hard but are the easiest, you don't need to worry about holding the ball just get strong hands to it and parry it away. Looks magnificent but every decent goalie can do it. The true test of a goalie is holding the ones you need to hold, and getting to the edge/outside of your box to clear/gather the ones you need to. Remember as a goalie you are ALWAYS covering another players mistake.
Kelvin did the first thing really well at Exeter, he always has, however he spilled a very weakly struck shot that fortunately Fonte was there to clear, and the goal was 100% his fault. Thats not to say they wouldn't have scored if he had stayed in the right position, (edge of six yard box waiting for the striker to take a poor touch then charge) it was a one on one after all. By running out and missing the ball by at least 4 foot he made it an even easier task.
Bart is largely an unknown quality, we have seen some flashes of brilliance and a couple of mistakes. The main flaws he has is slight misjudgment of deep crosses and his kicking. Well Kelvins distribution is poor as well, he cant even kick from hand, the first thing you learn as a goalie. What bart does have is very good technique. An analysis pf his last game will show that he a) gathered through balls at the very edge of the area due to good judgment and good starting position. b) made the saves he would be expected to c) made one excellent save from the dipping nani shot that bounced in front of him. The hardest judgment call to make, Kelvin would have blocked that shot rather than gathered it.
I am not guaranteeing that Bart will be our next No 1 as we hopefully climb through the leagues, however Kelvins games is getting worse as he gets older, hes has made 3 or 4 key mistakes in the last month, as well as the ones that haven't been punished. He is definitely not going to cut it in the championship. Wouldn't it be more sensible to blood Bart and see if he will before we decide whether to go shopping for a new keeper or not?!