What actual evidence do you have to support any of this?
Why do you think we will be largely building from scratch? Is it because our board are not philanthropic (no evidence of this) so will therefore sell our best young talent ( despite our board saying the opposite) and pocket the money (not sure how we will build anything if that's the case)? If that's the case what evidence do you have other than gut feel?
How many of our young talent do you feel we will lose - just give me your gut feeling.
As to MP in what way is he inconsistent? Results? Attitude to players? What?
MP is non committal about his future? Is that because he wants to focus on the here and now or?
Basically what you are saying is that we are at a cross roads because erm well? I'm not sure really. You seem to base your SFC Armageddon on no evidence.
My only concern would be if we were to lose MP as the knock on effect would be that we could potentially lose some of our more influential players. Personally tho I think he will be here for a little while longer than his current contract.
Oh and I don't feel you are being negative just a little ott. I think we will be building as all good teams should do.