I think most would take him back over Ivan Juric. I think had people known what a failure IJ was going to be they’d have preferred leaving him in place.
He gave us one of the most enjoyable seasons we’ve had for years. Play off trophy, a win at Wembley, triple beating of Leeds who were favourites for the title, unforgettable comebacks, dominant performances.
You can’t slate him, he did exceptionally well last season with those around him, the club and fanbase was united.
He’s ultimately failed due to two things:
1) His stubborn tactics on occasion, persisting with the same thing again and again and thinking it will change.
2) The summer window, lack of backing and lack of direction. He was naive to think the likes of Ryan Fraser and Alex McCarthy would be suitable for the Premier League, yet stood by them out of loyalty. No director of football meant he was largely ok to scatter gun his signings with no thoughts or seemingly a committee to bounce ideas off.
Since his Sky appearance he appears to have realised his mistakes. If he last learned to tinker and attack teams with pace rather than pass out from the back consistently.
I’d take him back now. But that ship has sailed, so whoever comes in next I hope it’s Spors decision, I hope that it’s a manager that wants to be here, I hope it is attacking football, and I hope it’s someone that will try and stick around longer than the previous footballing hierarchy (DoF, manager etc).