gio1saints

Except nobody is saying that. One poster has suggested both Rm and IJ have had weak cards to play. Fair point. @Trousers your ability to sit on the fence is almost legendary in here. I’m unsure I’ve ever heard a definitive opinion from you that was not couched in your recognisable style …. So you can imagine my surprise when I read that youve invented a secret sect of RM worshippers who wallow in SFC defeats and rush to post the equivalent of “ Ivan out” and “ Bring back russell” after each miserable result. Really! 😂

Playing without a centre forward against a weakened Burnley who everybody knew were more interested in getting promoted than winning this game was simply a bad management decision. Ivan decided on a false 9 approach before the match. Fair enough. But stupid imo. But he should have seen what the Burnley line up and formation was - and how ineffective we were against it - and adjusted saints team and tactics accordingly during the match. Instead it was just more of the meandering same and even when TP arrived we were so lost in our shit play we could not improve. That our team played like it was a friendly when we should have been bullying them from the start pisses me off . It’s the FA cup and we already going down. Fight! We sleepwalked to defeat. Yet again. I did not think that a Juric team could be so limp. But maybe he knew that this shows SR we need more meat in the team and he’s thrown our cup run to make a point for next seasons recruitment? Probably overthinking it but I prefer that than he could not see or know what to do about that shit show yesterday. It was embarrassing bad. On a par with the home to forest U formation loss in terms of tactical ineptitude.

Yup. This is about our level.

Yup true. I went to Eastleigh for the preseason ( infamously Adam Lallana injured himself in the warm up…a portent of his future availability..) and was reminded of that different vibe you mention. Even so, the Eastleigh want to be the next team to “ make it” into the big time. I will still pay to watch and retain my ST but I see little point for many today to bother with SFC. It’s become just a generic EPL/Championship football club on a Sisyphean mission ultimately ending in failure. What are the redeeming features? Are there any outstanding principles associated ( and valid) with Southampton FC anymore? I just completed one of the SFC questionnaires and I swear you could cut and paste any football team into the questions they are all so meaningless. It’s like let’s pretend we have a unique identity when in fact it’s obvious we do not. It’s all the same just different shirt colours.

Football has had its heart and soul eviscerated over the last three decades. Only the older supporters know what it was really like back in the day to go to watch your team play, home and away. Compared to the supporter experience today it’s chalk and cheese. Is it worse? Is it better? Some of it is certainly better - I don’t miss the violence, though it’s still there, I don’t miss being near crushed to death on open terraces either. But what I do miss is the hope that the matches Saints play actually mean something - not just more £££ to the latest round of club owners and media oligarchs milking the game dry of everything that was beautiful about it. Not having to pay £60 for a crappy nylon shirt when before anything in red & white & black stripes would do. You support a football team today you are basically a tool. Being used. And yet some of us cling onto the memories of what it was before. God knows what younger generations (under 30/40’s) see in this spectacle nowadays. Multi Millionaires chasing a ball in a ground owned by multi millionaires filmed by multi millionaires wearing shirts and equipment owned by multi millionaires. The only poor saps are those actually watching the damn @ game@. I’ve got my excuse cos I know what it used to be like but relatively new “Saints fans” Have you asked yourself what is it that you are actually supporting?

You can buy a four course meal ( chips, a sausage, more chips, nice snickers bar) with an alcopop from Poundland get a bus there and back and still get enough change out of that £5 in Preston to pay the leccie meter. It’s £10 to park your car within a mile of SMS…Cannot charge less than the St Mary’s freelance car parking entrepreneurs / dodgy peeps I reckon.

Goodness knows what ABK has to do to get a start. All I can think of he is going to play v Burnley by which time it’s too late. Or maybe he is going to play for rest of season. We know Jack Stephens limitations but he got on the pitch no problem for Ivan yet ABK must feel like Johnny no mates. A wealthy Johnny no mates I might add getting paid a shedload of money each week NOT to play. And that grates. Trying to sell a player who reputedly has a shocking attitude is twice as hard when he does not even play reserve team. If he cannot get on when all our CB’s are crocked it really does not look good. Getting a valuation on him is like pick a number time. Is it his potential? What he did three years ago? Can we really believe he is so bad neither RM nor Ivan will touch him yet he is still sellable ? Only the most desperate will even try to do it. If he was at a French Club I’ve no doubt Saints would be signing him at 22.59 tonite though! We cannot even give him away it seems. Wotchagonnado ???

It's a nuanced point but I think you've hit the nail on the head. Given that some/ too many of the players are showing themselves not up to EPL standard in either RM or IJ style it seems obvious that the best time to start building a team of players who may be able to both get us out the Championship AND compete at EPL is not next season, but frankly, now. Having to ditch all our currently EPL players then recruit a whole squad of new players just to get out the Championship, and then ditch 90% of those as well as they will ( on current evidence) be unlikely to be competitive in the EPL is a horrific prospect. Makes what Forest did look reasonable. Basically do not bother getting any players name on your new shirt cos there's hardly any chance they will be with us more than a season if we go up. This can be moderated a little if we start the clear out now and only replace with players that (a) will be able to do what they told to get us out the Championship and (b) have got the potential to compete at EPL level. Agents are rubbing their hands at SFC.....gone are the days you could recite a team from such and such a season...

Saints transition in style is obviously a work in progress but I sense Juric feels it will be ultimately more winning than losing - certainly at Championship level next season. Hence his ongoing optimism about his own and Saints future. In retrospect, the intense scrutiny the EPL handed us and the extreme dogma of RM’s style rules meant Saints had to play the perfect game for 100minutes+ to win a match - or lose - and often lose badly. Many here predicted the collapse but others, myself included, applauded the idealism - especially in such a corrupt closed shop arena as professional football. Under Juric we can now seemingly win and compete without having to look great in doing so. Before we could ONLY win or compete if we looked like peak Barcelona or Man City. It gave us some beautiful team goals and moves - but the intense high players and Manager got when it went right now looks akin to a heroin addict chasing after that sensation they got from their very first fix. It was 99% a suicide mission. I can totally understand why footballers and the Manager and the club would want to play that way though. I can also see why supporters like myself respected the idealism and absolutism. It makes our players our team our club look like football Gods when it works. Playing the beautiful game beautifully must be the ultimate feeling for a pro- even for amateurs. Juric style is more like just old fashioned hard work. It’s not a mission it’s not a cause it’s just roll up your sleeves and be a professional footballer not a demigod. And it’s been effective for years with many teams. Not ground breaking with the quality of players we have at present but Juric should be good enough to get us straight back up next year if he gets the players he wants after the expected end of season fire sale. Im pleased for Ivan and I’m intrigued by the Burnley match now. Big clue as to how we will do next year coming up!

Main reason I’m going is to exactly evaluate that. Swansea was a clue but Burnley even better. If we can match and or outplay Burnley ( assuming they put out a decent side) it should be a reasonably good indicator of our prospects for next season. I currently expect us to outplay them and win albeit I also expect Burnley to play their reserve team so the result may be not quite as relevant.

To all those thinking we should “ keep” players who are proven anonymous / rubbish at EPL level for another season just in case they are world beaters at championship level maybe consider the implications. This means, should they actually perform as hoped, that in a years time, and SR learn the lesson, that we need dump ALL of them in order to get players who CAN actually perform at EPL level. Strikes me that if Saints want me to renew my ST then watching the dead men walking of our first team trying to get promotion does not sound all that vfm to me nor all that fun nor is it contributing to future proofing us for the EPL. Sadly, Nottingham Forest are the template for how to game the system atm. If you trying to build a team to compete in the EPL but they have to get out the Championship first then the thinking seems to be that you need virtually two different teams altogether. Soend all season getting behind a team and a manager, with a mission, and then, when you fulfil the mission, sack them all off, appoint a David Moyes type and sell all the players to be replaced by Giorgio Scorragoal, Bernard Assistmachine and Angelo Maimforwards. The gap is ever widening. IF we go up next season expect at least 75% departures and same incoming to our squad. It’s effing crazy almost impossible to work out who or how or what in the context.

The buy him and loan him back to saints story looks like a planted by agent(s) story to me. Just as likely to be Man Utd or Arsenal or a PSG ( yes he may surprise and go to a giant club - he does have a bit of the zidane- like body to hold the ball and fluidly move..) Spurs have got a bit more on their minds than buying a£50m teenager then not using him this season I’d say. Can imagine the uproar - Would be a not very spurs fan friendly move in current climate no matter how good everyone knows Dibling is. I personally think he is ultimately going to be on a playing quality and transfer fee par with a certain English player recently went to Madrid and was/is very successful. Put him in the RM team and he would shine imo. Which means £50m would look cheap. * * Dortmund paid Birmingham c £30m for Bellingham in 2020-21 Real Madrid paid £113m to them for him in 2023. Current transfermkt estimated value aged 21: £180m! Was Bellingham a better teenager than Tyler?

Leeds lost all their good players last year but are still top of the championship this year. We will lose all our good players at season end ( or this window!) but given the massive gap between EPL and Championship I’m still more than confident we will be good enough to be amongst the best six again next year - whatever style we play under whatever manager. Thats not the issue for me. I’m just so confused by it all. The BIG issue for me is that there’s no sure fire way of knowing who will or will not make it up a level. I thought THB would look a natural and look at least average at EPL - but he’s not been outstanding has he? James Bree looked terrible last year but Saturday his crossing was excellent and I thought he looked the part. I mean, wtf is going on? Downes looks shite but Manning is now a bright spark? Joe Aribo was a bench player but now he is a first name in MF? Sulemana is duff but is now not duff! Armstrong is a goalscorer now he’s a waste of space ? What’re alga’s TP been? Where the hell has our other centre forward gone- and Larios? What is Adam Lallana doing playing 4 minutes every week? I thought he was our genuine quality player? Tyler Dibling has to dribble past three players to give himself a chance to shoot. Wtf are the rest of the team doing watching him? Why not help him? How can Archer touch the ball only 6 times in a match - he makes invisible man look conspicuous. And what happened to Ryan Fraser? It’s all so very confusing and a mystery. Should make a good whodunnit.

Hollywood is full of men and women who were the prettiest / most handsome in their town. Encouraged by winning the local pageant they got on the bus hoping to become a star. Mostly they wait tables and wash cars and never make it. The players who got us promoted were amongst the best players of there position in the Championship. The prettiest and most handsome if you like to continue the analogy. But they found out there’s prettier and more handsome in Hollywood( the EPL). Martins style was super impressive and exotic for the locals in the championship - and ultimately did the trick - but one level up with these players who were 95% under average for epl quality ( at start of season I’d have only considered KWP as a better than average epl player) it clearly did not work. Now it seems clear that there must be a plan to get out the Championship next season- but it does not follow it needs be under Juric in this more aggressive front foot style. IF the players to get us up are very likely to be upgraded when we get promoted why is that not so for the Manager? Indeed, is there a specialist manager who could get us out the championship but might not be good enough for EPL? With the benefit of hindsight RM got us up but if he’d been sacked and replaced by a specialist epl manager ( like Moyes) who then chucked out the players he thought inadequate and reconstructed an epl surviving team using his experience - that would have worked better. I don’t know if juric is right for the championship or if indeed he truly is invested in the idea were we to get relegated. What I sense is that he will get paid more than he would virtually anywhere else by staying At Saints in championship ( considering his CV) and that might be the key factor. So I’d expect him to be leading us v Hull etc next year.

AA is mostly nailing it in the warm up shots. Got to put him on score anytime. I can see a penalty ….😄