Another fence sitter here, although obviously not to the same level as Trousers who I swear probably has splinters in a painful place.:-) But I do try and give people a chance and don't make snap judgements. It's good to see Dobbin, for example, working his way to form, and most fans give additional points for effort.
With Broja he did seem to have the attributes even if he came from Slough (Maidenhead United chant from around 1972 "We hate Slough and Slough Town, Slough Town we hate you.."), but there injuries seemed to have had large impact. My worries about the return of JWP I didn't voice as they weren't strong, and I could see he was no Walcott or Romeu. As for Tonda, I wonder if he wasn't always going to be the replacement, just not as early as expected? Eustace though? Rash!;-)
For other views you don't really have to be an expert. BBD a footballer?? Lavia a real shame to lose. But then there are the pleasant surprises like the Who? brothers, Larin and Schlotterbeck.