I don't think it was a bad window for us. These would be my observations:
Yes we lost mane and wanyama but we could have lost a lot more. (I accept that sounds negative but it's the reality based on the last few summers)
Not only did we keep some other key players we also tied them down to good contracts
These contracts would have been costly, a figure not represented in the "net spend" people talk about
Whilst I accept that it won't necessarily keep those players here it has probably brought our wage structure a little more in line with the rest of the premier league and may help in future signings
Hojberg definitely looks the real deal and could be a great signing as could boufal. McCarthy as back up is a great improvement on last year and had a keeper of his standard been available during forsters absence last year it could have made a big difference to the season outcome.
My biggest concern remains to be around where we will get goals from. We've lost our two best goal scorers from last season and the new formation doesn't suit Austin. Without a target up front I fear will be stuck with hopeful long distant shots like against Sunderland.
It's early days still for Puel and his philosophies are still bedding in.
